Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2014 MLB Draft Thread

Featured Replies

Defense of Loria ridiculous? Not at all.

 

Here's what the FO faced. The slot value for the #2 pick is 6.8 mill. The Marlins had the largest budget cap of all 30 teams at 14.2 mill until they traded 1.46 mill off to PIT, leaving a 12.74 mill cap. HOU was then 1st at 13.4 mill. By comparison, BOS (ignoring compensatory, etc. picks) has a total cap of about 5 mill. 12.74 mill? Doesn't sound like Loria or anyone else is being "cheap."

 

Those caps were made because of cheap teams like the Marlins. Other teams were able to sign guys who demanded high bonuses that cheap teams like the Marlins would pass on. Back when picks were completely uncapped the Marlins still spent much less than most teams during the Loria era. Why do you think that was? I'm sure you will tap dance around the obvious reason.

 

Even if Loria spends the cap he has already cheaped out by shaving the original 14.2 number down to pay for Gregg. As you pointed out such a small amount should not even matter to a pro baseball team.

 

 

The Marlins can sign Kolek for more or less than 6.8 mill -- if more, it comes out of the hides of the picks in the next 9 rounds, unless the Marlins want to pay a penalty of 75% of any overage betwixt and between all of picks in the 1st 10 rounds. And you can't just refuse to sign anyone to avoid going over your cap.

 

I'm aware of how the draft cap works. Again if this was all part of a plan to maximize draft talent then they wouldn't have done the draft pick trade. That trade makes no sense in conjunction with a plan to maximize talent. Not so coincidentally it melds perfectly with a plan to save money by cheaping out.

 

I have no problem with Kolek and if nearly any other team picked him I would assume they liked him better than Rodon. I personally like him better than Rodon based on what I have read. But again given the history of this team the more likely scenario is saving money.

 

For example if the Red Sox heavily backload a contract for a player I just assume they have a legitamite reason for doing so but if the Marlins heavily backload a contract I assume they do so with the intent to trade the player before they have to pay the larger salaries since they have done so EVERY TIME. And again there they could maximize talent by paying a larger portion of the outgoing salaries so that they get a better haul of prospects. But guess which option they pick instead?

 

 

If we had taken Rodon as the #2, he still wanted 8 mill (7.9 mill is the #1 slot money) -- Boras is his agent. That's a potential 1.2 mill overage with a 75% penalty on any (total for all 10 rounds) overage -- could be up to 900K. And what's the penalty for ANY overage above 637K (5%)? LOSS OF NEXT YEAR'S 1ST ROUND PICK. Go 10% over (1.274 mill)? Lose next year's 1st AND 2nd round picks. No MLB team has ever done either. Can you imagine the outcry and gnashing of teeth, and perhaps calls for Loria's head on a platter if the Marlins were forced into doing that?

 

The FO obviously liked Kolek. A LOT. Every senior FO guy actually went to TX to watch him play and talk to him.

 

In the history of every FO I have never seen a FO not say that the guy they picked wasn't the guy they wanted. This is especially true for first round picks. And like I said if any other team did so I would assume they had Kolek rated higher.

 

And you're right there is such a big penalty for going over the cap that teams don't do that. So it would be especially egregious to trade away some of that cap for a crappy reliever just to save money correct? I'm more worried about the Marlins going significantly under the cap not over. I know that will never happen so the consequences are irrelevant. They could just pick under slot guys at their other picks. You know like they did anyway.

 

 

So, what would you rather do? Draft a guy who can probably be signed for slot money or maybe less (HOU signed their last two #1s for over 1 mill less than slot) or sign a guy who you ALREADY KNOW will cost you 1.2 mill MORE than slot and may screw up your ability to sign the rest of your picks (leaving only 4.7 mill instead of 5.9 mill for all of them) and possibly ALSO cost you a future pick or two?

 

The Astors went under slot so that they could spend more on later picks who would need over slot money. Do you think that will be the Marlins' strategy? I am extremely doubtful given their history and the picks they made. I would have no problem if we chose that strategy but its clear by our other picks that it wasn't.

 

In fact if we were using that strategy then the trade of #35 makes even less sense. If Loria just made a trade to save draft money it doesn't seem like his strategy is to maximize draft spending.

 

The Marlins would NEVER spend enough to trigger those penalties so I have no idea why you keep bringing them up. They were towards the bottom of spending in the uncapped years with no penalty. Now with financial penalties you think they will spend considerably more than other teams? Ha

 

I would rather they pick best player available with the #2 pick. Maybe that guy is Kolek. The problem is based on past transactions including the one just last week it seems like money is more important than talent.

 

The thing is if you pick an over slot guy you balance it out by taking under slot guys with your other picks OR you pick the underslot guy and balance it out by taking over slot guys later. The Marlins took the slot or under slot guy and then kept taking mostly slot or under slot guys.

 

That is again inconsistent with a plan to maximize talent but IS consistent with a plan to save money.

 

This was NOT just about a lousy 1.2 mill or even 1.2 mill plus a .9 mill penalty (which nobody whining about Loria above even knew about, never mind the potential loss of future picks.) This was just nothing but the usual supposition and conclusion-jumping about Loria.

 

As I said earlier I was very aware of the penalty. They could have easily avoided that by taking underslot guys with other picks WHICH THEY DID ANYWAY. Again this penalty is irrelevant because there is no way Loria would pay it.

 

As it turns out, the fact that the FO was MUCH more interested in Kolek than Rodon all along (nobody knew the travel schedules of the FO guys until now -- as they said "We spent a lot of hours on him. We helped the economy in Shepherd, Texas") and the very serious implications of what Rodon/Boras was demanding on the rest of the draft and possibly next year's draft almost certainly had everything to do with our choice.

 

Which EVERY team says about EVERY pick they make.

 

And again those penalties could have been avoided by taking underslot guys with other picks (which they did anyway) and those penalties are irrelevant because Loria would never spend nearly that much.

Again, It's possible that they saw Kolek as the better pick, but there's no real evidence for that yet. There's no hard evidence that signability was the main concern, but the circumstances point in that direction.

 

You're point about drafting younger arms because the Marlins have a lot of near MLB ready pitching is still idiotic. First, that would go against the BPA philosophy. Second, the Marlins have a potential to be a legitimately good team on the horizon if they manage to keep Stanton around for a year or two. With that in mind, you absolutely play for the near future than the distant future. This team could be crazy good in 2016, and having someone like Rodon would be a great asset. Even if they trade Stanton soon, the pieces they get in return could be a big part of the near future too.

The problem with your theory is the assumption that Rodon takes no time to develop and can be in the majors next year. I think the Astros thought Mark Appel would be the same way. He was a much bigger "can't miss" pick than Rodon and look how that turned out. Now you sound like me, assuming a best case scenario...

Gatewood's hit tool had become so questionable Law actually ridiculued the Brewers for taking him so early... The SS we got from Texas actually sounds like a hell of an athlete with some unreal bat speed and I am glad they took him.

 

He has unreal speed, not sure about bat speed.Twine is a track star. Regardless, it looks like the fish would have to pay over slot to sign him (He's committeed to TCU) so say goodbye to him.

He has unreal speed, not sure about bat speed.Twine is a track star. Regardless, it looks like the fish would have to pay over slot to sign him (He's committeed to TCU) so say goodbye to him.

From what I read on him he is a potential 5-tool guy. His bat speed and strength could eventually generate some nice power, and his speed not only translates to the bases but he has great range and will never outgrow the middle infield.

The problem with your theory is the assumption that Rodon takes no time to develop and can be in the majors next year. I think the Astros thought Mark Appel would be the same way. He was a much bigger "can't miss" pick than Rodon and look how that turned out. Now you sound like me, assuming a best case scenario...

 

For the record, I don't even think about timetable when it comes to first round picks. It's always about BPA for me. However, I don't feel that it's a stretch to expect Rodon to be ready by 2016 at the latest. There was one rumor stating that the Marlins might even give him a shot this season already if they called him up.

 

It's pure logical fallacy to look at Mark Appel and use that as any indication that anyone should be less enthused about Rodon. Appel's struggles, some of which are injury related, are in no shape or form a sign of what will happen to Rodon.

What about the rest of the picks? I'm hearing they were mostly questionable

 

Yea the next two picks after Kolek were considered reaches.

About Blake Anderson...

The Miami Marlins pulled a surprise move by snagging high school catcher Blake Anderson with the No. 36 pick.

According to J.J. Cooper of Baseball America, Anderson was a polarizing prospect, and some teams viewed him as a seventh- to 10th-round selection. The biggest question facing Anderson is just how much he will hit as a professional.

One explanation on Miami's reach, as suggested by Bleacher Report's Adam Wells, is that the club drafted Anderson in order to save money to sign right-hander Tyler Kolek, the No. 2 overall pick.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2087837-mlb-draft-2014-ranking-the-4-potential-busts-of-day-1/page/5

 

Anderson is a tall athletic catcher (6'4", 200 lbs) who already has good defensive skills behind the plate. He traveled with the East Cobb Braves (one of the best traveling AAU teams in the country) and hit the prospect showcase circuit pretty hard this past year. His arm is arguably his best asset as he consistently hit 92 mph from the mound, while leading his high school team to a 4A State Championship in Mississippi. His bat, however, has a lot of question marks.

After adding 15 pounds of muscle to his lanky frame in the offseason, Anderson saw a big jump in offensive production his senior year. He hit .438 with eight home runs and 14 doubles in 105 at-bats, but scouts question his bat speed and his ability to square up the ball against advanced pitching.

The overall consensus among draft analysts is that the Marlins sprung Anderson a bit early. Baseball America had him ranked as the eighth best prospect in the state and the 216th best prospect overall. There were lots of intriguing prospects on the board who had more widely recognized talent, but there's also reports that Anderson really impressed a lot of teams in recent workouts. Clint Longenecker from Baseball America reported that many teams were interested in Anderson in this range.

http://www.fishstripes.com/2014/6/5/5784756/mlb-draft-2014-miami-marlins-blake-anderson-catcher-profile

 

Yet to West coach Jerry Boatner, Thursday’s selection came as no shock. “I’m not surprised,� Boatner said of Anderson getting picked so high. “He has everything you’re looking for: great size, a great arm, great strength and speed.� Anderson was the first player from Mississippi to be taken in the draft, and while that’s bound to bring good publicity to West Lauderdale, Boatner said the day was more about Anderson’s individual accomplishments. “It’s just a great feeling for the whole coaching staff and community,� Boatner said. “People have always talked about how good he is and what a great kid he is.� In 2013, Anderson compiled a .420 average with five home runs. In his last season at West Lauderdale, Anderson was even more dominant as the backstop registered a .438 average and recorded team-highs in home runs (eight) and RBI (40). “Blake’s a special young man,� said Neal Anderson, Blake’s father. “He matured really quickly and worked extremely hard to get here.� Anderson learned the value of hard work at a young as he traveled around the country in the summer, competing against some of the best high schoolers from around the nation. Anderson was a member of the East Cobb Astros as a 16-year-old, who finished as the No. 1 travel ball team in the country that year under coach Guerry Baldwin. “Blake’s been blessed to play on some great travel ball teams,� Neal said. “He learned what it would take to improve game.� Boatner said the greatest thrill he gets from coaching is seeing his players make it to the next level, whether in college or professionally. He pointed to Anderson’s work ethic - See more at: http://www.meridianstar.com/sports/x611390450/West-s-Anderson-goes-on-first-day#sthash.YeLLFDy8.dpuf

 

The Marlins brought Anderson in for a workout recently. Right now, he is more advanced defensively, and he needs to add more strength, which should improve his offense.

"We think it's way above-average Major League catch-throw skills now," Meek said. "The bat is the little bit behind. He's not real strong. We think the bat is going to play. The way the swing works is great. He just needs a little more bat speed

and a little more strength to get that."

http://miami.marlins.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20140605&content_id=78391926&notebook_id=78455942&vkey=notebook_mia&c_id=mia

 

The knock on Anderson has always been his hitting ability, though he did have a breakout year as a senior (he hit .438 with 40 RBIs and eight homers). Even so, Anderson possesses the top-end defensive skills behind the plate that has scouts intrigued. The hitting concerns might send Anderson to Southern Miss next season

http://www.clarionledger.com/story/sports/high-school/2014/06/05/west-lauderdale-catcher-drafted/10047415/

Nope, no evidence at all that they really wanted a guy who can throw 102 in high school. Stan Meek, Marlins’ VP of scouting:

 

“There were some other guys that we had interest in, too. But in the end we targeted this as the guy we hoped fell to us.�

 

Besides the fastball, Kolek throws an 80-82 mph curveball and 88-90 mph changeup.

 

“His delivery jumps out at you,� Meek said. “For such a big man, he’s got a very quiet easy delivery which should equate to a plus strike-thrower. The one thing that we’ve got to do is get his breaking ball a little more consistent.�

 

When asked for comparisons, Meek naturally went to another hard-throwing Texan from the Houston area, Roger Clemens.

 

“You hate to put these kinds of names on him,� Meek said. “But you kind of see some Roger Clemens in his delivery, in the power delivery that he has … He’s just way bigger than Roger.�

 

Meek said the closest thing he had seen to Kolek from a high school pitcher was Jose Fernandez, who hit 98 mph.

http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/sports/marlins-select-hard-throwing-high-schooler-with-no/ngFf2/

 

"88-90 mph changeup." Randy "My fastball hits 90 on a good day" Wolf, eat your heart out.

 

Meanwhile, the desire to trash Loria continues unabated.

Remember when the Marlins drafted Jose Fernandez and some thought he'd become a high-leverage reliever? As I said before, draft analysis is always great. Trying to project high school players you've never seen is a waste of time. Even if you've seen them, it's probably still a waste of time as it's difficult to project how that'll translate to professional baseball.

Nope, no evidence at all that they really wanted a guy who can throw 102 in high school. Stan Meek, Marlins’ VP of scouting:

 

 

http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/sports/marlins-select-hard-throwing-high-schooler-with-no/ngFf2/

 

"88-90 mph changeup." Randy "My fastball hits 90 on a good day" Wolf, eat your heart out.

 

Meanwhile, the desire to trash Loria continues unabated.

 

You make some fair points, but would you argue as a whole that Loria isn't more rigid than the average owner with money?

I'm not sure if the mid first round picks that the Marlins have had thus far really serve as accurate historical precedent for a 2nd overall pick. In my opinion at least, the 2nd overall pick demands for less "raw talent" and more polish, because it's a can't miss scenario.

 

 

The last time we had the 2nd overall pick we took a prep power arm from Texas.

 

I guess I'm just surprised so many people were surprised. This is the most Marlins pick ever. Heaney was a departure from tradition. Kolek fits the traditional Marlins mold much more than Rodon does. Even the ballpark fits pitchers like Kolek. And while I'm far from a scout, I'm very impressed by Kolek's athleticism. He is a nimble giant.

It's the 28th round

 

This might be more of a personal thing as i have friends who've worked hard and life dreams are to be drafted this week but seeing them take someone who in no way shape or form is going to be playing baseball is such a waste.

Cleveland selected Arod's nephew in the 35th round I like that kid a lot the Marlins should have chosen him over several player they selected at SS but hey hope he proves the Marlins and everyone else wrong that didn't draft him

Let me start by saying I was a little disappointed with the first pick. It had nothing to do with the player they selected but more about who they did not take.

 

 

 

Now that the draft is over I see what they were doing and let me say this I like it I like it a lot.

They address a lot of needs and that's what you want coming out of a draft. I personal think this is the best overall they had since the josh johnson draft. Alot good value late in the draft.Yes its been a while now lets see if they can sign this kids.

I give it a B it could have been higher but I understand with money they can spend on draft picks. They had to take some questionable picks to sign those higher value picks. People believe me this was a very good draft for the fish. The best they had in awhile.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.