Who gets your vote as the best Marlin of the first half and why?

Casey Mcgehee because he was the most consistent Marlins hitter.

No one, cause the team is 44-50. Get your shit together, Marlins.

Stanton. 3.8 WAR. No one else is close.

Mcgehee and Alvarez are my two picks.

Stanton, McGehee, Ozuna, Alvarez and Bryan "Freaking" Morris have all been pretty great so far.

This really isn't close.

Hendy, for 200, alex. Only reliable starter.

I would say McGehee, surprising stats for a surprising team

Alvarez, if we are talking about individual performances. Unfortunately, his record isn't so hot because of his team around him, so it's hard to say he his stellar performance has impacted the team drastically.

 

Otherwise, Stanton. Both in terms of individual and team impact.

Hitters' pick

 

Best : Stanton (Way to go to career-best like a MVP. I'm ready to enjoy the derby)

Worst : Salty (Almost 200k pace with horrible defense. A veteran with lack of situational hitting.)

 

Pitchers' pick

 

Best : Alvarez (No doubt about it)

Worst : Turner (Suspicious about intentional slowdown. Very disappointed. Another fraud from Dombrowski?)

Stanton. Team still lives and dies with his offensive production.

This really isn't close.

 

It's amazing people on this board think there is another choice

I was just expecting everyone to reply and say "Stanton, you idiot".

Hech. he's been the most consistent.

I kinda like the worst idea considering we're 6 games under .500 aka we're not very good. I think Salty is a fair choice since he's currently having the 2nd worst season of his career and striking out 1/3 of the time.

 

HA would be my best SP. Heaney probably the worst for me if we're going by just 1st half. I didn't expect anything out of Turner so leaving him off that.

I would say McGehee, surprising stats for a surprising team

 

What's surprising about the Marlins being 6 games under .500 and 4th place in the NL east?

I was just expecting everyone to reply and say "Stanton, you idiot".

 

I mean again it really depends. If you dissect it down to single performance, Alvarez is pitching phenomenally. He's right up there with Stanton.

 

But if you look at impact, there's zero competition. Alvarez hasn't had a big impact, because his stellar performance has largely gone to waste.

Stanton, you idiot.

Stanton, you loathsome buffoon.

I mean again it really depends. If you dissect it down to single performance, Alvarez is pitching phenomenally. He's right up there with Stanton.

 

But if you look at impact, there's zero competition. Alvarez hasn't had a big impact, because his stellar performance has largely gone to waste.

 

Stanton, you idiot.

the absence of Greg Dobbs

Kevin Gregg. He comes in there expecting to set up, but usually blows things up.

 

 

 

That Morris guy ain't bad.

 

 

You get nothing, Stanton. Nothing.

Stanton arguably the NL MVP, so yea, him.

Stanton, you idiot.

 

Okay Kevin Gregg.