Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Stanton Rumors

Featured Replies

I sometimes think that Sandoval's postseason performance(s) makes people forget or ignore that he tends to be nothing special in the regular season on a yearly basis.

 

 

WAR

 

2011 - 5.5 (117 games)

 

2012 - 2.6 (108 games)

 

2013 - 2.3

 

2014 - 3.0

 

I would say that is a pretty good player. Not spectacular (besides 2011), but as a 28 year old, that's a $12-15 a year player depending on the team.

 

But the Marlins should pass, buy a pitcher, and trade Cishek and Eovaldi for infield bats. Much smarter and economical than devoting $80+ million to Panda.

 

 

I just cant see Stanton turning down a 100+ million deal. just cant.

 

 

It depends on the years. He would have to think really hard about a 4/$110 or 5/$125 deal. The rub is he needs an opportunity for a second big contract and a 6-7 year deal likely doesn't offer that.

 

Marlins need to be smart about this and overpay him for 2-3 years only and then let him go. Take what you can realistically get.

 

 

WAR

 

2011 - 5.5 (117 games)

 

2012 - 2.6 (108 games)

 

2013 - 2.3

 

2014 - 3.0

 

I would say that is a pretty good player. Not spectacular (besides 2011), but as a 28 year old, that's a $12-15 a year player depending on the team.

 

But the Marlins should pass, buy a pitcher, and trade Cishek and Eovaldi for infield bats. Much smarter and economical than devoting $80+ million to Panda.

 

Thats also what the Marlins got from Casey McGehee this year.

 

 

Thats also what the Marlins got from Casey McGehee this year.

 

Not that Im disagreeing with you on the whole "lets not get panda" thing (I think we would have to seriously overpay for him) but you and I both know Mcgehee played way above his head in the first half and his WAR is a bit inflated as a result. Your compairing someones peak with another persons norm.

  • Author

Thats also what the Marlins got from Casey McGehee this year.

 

 

Casey McGehee's positive WAR was only a result of his extremely lucky ground ball hitting in the first half of the season. Panda is a far superior player. But you know already this.

 

 

Sigh...wasnt comparing them as players. I was pointing out that even in the first half, there were many that werent all that impressed with the production at 3B for the Marlins that Casey McGehee was giving them and he still rated at about the 6th or 7th best 3B in the league at the All Star break, pretty much neck and neck with Sandoval coincidentally. That was my point, we got a Sandoval like performance for half a year this year and people were still talking about upgrades and he was still close to middle of the pack in the league. So I dont get why people want to throw money at a player that is basically that full time.

 

 

  • Author

Sigh...wasnt comparing them as players. I was pointing out that even in the first half, there were many that werent all that impressed with the production at 3B for the Marlins that Casey McGehee was giving them and he still rated at about the 6th or 7th best 3B in the league at the All Star break, pretty much neck and neck with Sandoval coincidentally. That was my point, we got a Sandoval like performance for half a year this year and people were still talking about upgrades and he was still close to middle of the pack in the league. So I dont get why people want to throw money at a player that is basically that full time.

 

 

I get what you're saying, but the thing is Casey will never come close to his 2014 production again.

 

PS I agree we should not pay the ridiculous price Pablo will require especially with the whole fat guy decline after 30 thing.

 

 

Admin I have no hope on Panda he is asking a minimum of a 100 million contract to stay with the WS winning SF Giants...What would he ask to come to the Marlins?

 

We have a better chance at affording AROD

 

 

If I was in charge of the FO I would be looking at signing another Giant F/A, Michael Morse. He can play 1st & 3rd base and Outfield. He has significant power, as early as 3 seasons ago he hit 31 HRs. Above all he is a native S. Floridian. He would make a big addition to the Marlins and would not command a huge amount of money

 

 

Admin I have no hope on Panda he is asking a minimum of a 100 million contract to stay with the WS winning SF Giants...What would he ask to come to the Marlins?

We have a better chance at affording AROD

 

A-Rod isn't a free agent.

If I was in charge of the FO I would be looking at signing another Giant F/A, Michael Morse. He can play 1st & 3rd base and Outfield. He has significant power, as early as 3 seasons ago he hit 31 HRs. Above all he is a native S. Floridian. He would make a big addition to the Marlins and would not command a huge amount of money

 

You say he can play all those positions, but the truth is he can't play any positions at all. He is an awful defender and despite his offensive numbers, ended up with only 1.0 fWAR.

 

 

You say he can play all those positions, but the truth is he can't play any positions at all. He is an awful defender and despite his offensive numbers, ended up with only 1.0 fWAR.

 

 

 

Morse will end up in Oakland or Tampa

You say he can play all those positions, but the truth is he can't play any positions at all. He is an awful defender and despite his offensive numbers, ended up with only 1.0 fWAR.

 

You think he is worse than Garrett Jones at 1st base defensively?

 

Morse is not the greatest glove guy but he is 10 times the defender that Jones is and he can play 3rd base, he has the arm and the agility

 

 

You think he is worse than Garrett Jones at 1st base defensively?

 

Morse is not the greatest glove guy but he is 10 times the defender that Jones is and he can play 3rd base, he has the arm and the agility

 

Yes. He might be the worst defensive player in baseball. He cannot play third base. He HAS played third base, but that doesn't mean he CAN.

 

 

Michael Hill expects to have Stanton sign an extension by the Winter Meetings

 

 

 

Necessary move

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.