Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Stanton Rumors

Featured Replies

I will (maybe) be at the Winter Meetings this year, so I'm hoping they actually sign Dongcarlo AT the Winter Meetings, not before.

 

 

Tweet this to Stanton and I'm sure he'll wait until the Winter Meetings to sign.

 

 

Tweet this to Stanton and I'm sure he'll wait until the Winter Meetings to sign.

 

I'm also sure he'll love the nickname Dongcarlo.

 

 

On FOX Sports.com, under "MLB 2014 Awards Predictions":

 

 

NL ROOKIE OF THE YEAR

 

Jacob DeGrom, 26, was a revelation for the Mets in 2014, posting a 9-6 record with a 2.22 ERA (144 K in 140 1/3 IP), finishing the second half on fire (0.93 WHIP, 9.7 K/9). The sky's the limit for DeGrom, suddenly a major part of the Mets' future.

 

But don't count out Giancarlos Stanton, who carried the Marlins on his shoulders the entire season. He led the NL in homers (31), RBIs (82) and walks (73). He's also tops in OPS (.960) and WAR (5.80).

 

 

 

Er ... whut?

 

Lulz

 

 

$300 million would be the biggest contract in baseball history. I love Stanton but before this season he had a few injury plagued seasons and a so so 2013 season. It is also true that the only recent player I can think of to hit the market as good as he is as young as he is was Alex Rodriguez (who hit the market at 25 years old, the age Stanton is now). I think ultimately it would take an eight year, $200 million extension to keep him here long term. That way he hits the open market for one last time when he's 32/33 years old, just towards the end of his prime where he can cash in one last time in the free agent market. I'd imagine Stanton doesn't want to go too long term with any extension and would rather sign a six or seven year deal to secure him financially but also keep things open for him to potentially cash in again later.

 

And like the yahoo article said the Marlins will definitely have to add a no trade clause and opt outs every other year or so, so that Stanton has the ability to leave if he feels Loria isn't holding up his end of the deal to try and produce a competitive team. At this point the Marlins really can't try and play hardball too much without risking losing their best true asset not named Jose Fernandez (who I'm still angry we lost a full year of simply because the Marlins couldn't wait two weeks to call him up in 2013).

 

I definitely have my doubts the gets done, but I do like that Stanton seems receptive at the moment. It's at least a tiny beacon that he will at least consider whatever offer the Marlins give. Lets just hope this doesn't turn out like some other negotiations we've had (Uggla comes to mind) where we low ball him and pretend that we gave him the best offer we could possibly give and ultimately Stanton is the one at fault. We all know it'll take an overpay to keep him at this rate.

 

 

$300 million would be the biggest contract in baseball history. I love Stanton but before this season he had a few injury plagued seasons and a so so 2013 season. It is also true that the only recent player I can think of to hit the market as good as he is as young as he is was Alex Rodriguez (who hit the market at 25 years old, the age Stanton is now). I think ultimately it would take an eight year, $200 million extension to keep him here long term. That way he hits the open market for one last time when he's 32/33 years old, just towards the end of his prime where he can cash in one last time in the free agent market. I'd imagine Stanton doesn't want to go too long term with any extension and would rather sign a six or seven year deal to secure him financially but also keep things open for him to potentially cash in again later.

 

And like the yahoo article said the Marlins will definitely have to add a no trade clause and opt outs every other year or so, so that Stanton has the ability to leave if he feels Loria isn't holding up his end of the deal to try and produce a competitive team. At this point the Marlins really can't try and play hardball too much without risking losing their best true asset not named Jose Fernandez (who I'm still angry we lost a full year of simply because the Marlins couldn't wait two weeks to call him up in 2013).

 

I definitely have my doubts the gets done, but I do like that Stanton seems receptive at the moment. It's at least a tiny beacon that he will at least consider whatever offer the Marlins give. Lets just hope this doesn't turn out like some other negotiations we've had (Uggla comes to mind) where we low ball him and pretend that we gave him the best offer we could possibly give and ultimately Stanton is the one at fault. We all know it'll take an overpay to keep him at this rate.

 

 

 

I don't agree with much of what you said.

 

1) Stanton will not sign for 8 years, and I doubt they would even consider an offer that long. With that said, 8 years $200M is a joke.

 

2) An opt out clause is only a good idea if he were willing to sign for more than 6 years.

 

3) We would not have an extra year of Jose had they waited 2 weeks to call him up. And that "wasted" year of service time was the only thing that made the Marlins interesting in an otherwise unbearable 2013. So it was probably well worth it.

 

4) Uggla was not a lowball, the Marlins made a very legit offer and he declined for two reasons: he hated the Marlins and he wanted a 5th year. The Marlins were smart not to give it to him, and got back a decent return as well.

We would've had an extra year of Jose if they waited two weeks to call him up. You need to read up on that one. It was not worth it since we lost a year of Jose for two weeks.

 

Also I have no idea how 8 years $200 million is a joke. That's $25 million a year. That allows Stanton to be a free agent again at 33 while making $200 million. And I'd give Stanton a no trade clause for any contract that extends him into at least one free agent year.

 

I don't think Uggla was really lowballed (4 years $48 million we offered him I believe), but in the grand scheme of things we've lowballed many, many players and pretended like we made legitimate efforts to keep them.

 

Nothing I said was wrong. Stanton won't get $300 million. All this talk is what always happens in early negotiations. The number eventually reaches a fair median where they can both agree. Given Stanton still has two arbitration years to deal with, 8 years $200 million seems fine when considering arb numbers and it'll pay Stanton more than really anyone not named Mike Trout is worth.

 

 

We would've had an extra year of Jose if they waited two weeks to call him up. You need to read up on that one. It was not worth it since we lost a year of Jose for two weeks.

 

Also I have no idea how 8 years $200 million is a joke. That's $25 million a year. That allows Stanton to be a free agent again at 33 while making $200 million. And I'd give Stanton a no trade clause for any contract that extends him into at least one free agent year.

 

I don't think Uggla was really lowballed (4 years $48 million we offered him I believe), but in the grand scheme of things we've lowballed many, many players and pretended like we made legitimate efforts to keep them.

 

Nothing I said was wrong. Stanton won't get $300 million. All this talk is what always happens in early negotiations. The number eventually reaches a fair median where they can both agree. Given Stanton still has two arbitration years to deal with, 8 years $200 million seems fine when considering arb numbers and it'll pay Stanton more than really anyone not named Mike Trout is worth.

 

 

 

Offering Stanton anything that doesnt start with a 3 in his free agency years is both stupid and an insult.

 

Some have argued that he is just as good as Trout.

 

Others have said he is the second best young position player behind Trout.

 

I tend to think the latter, which should be about 10% less than Trout signed for during his free agency years. But the longer the Marlins wait, the higher the tag goes up. The revenues in baseball are stupid.

 

Thats the market rate.

 

It should be one of the fucking easiest contracts to ever do. The only thing to really argue over is term.

 

Figure out what the last two arby years are worth, then something around 30-32 per for free agency years.

 

No trade clause, wham bam thank you maam.

 

 

GS holds all the aces. Without him, this team is done. Again. Cishek, Yelich & Ozuna are good but might never be great. Jose has to come back from TJ. Everyone else is completely disposable.

 

Loria has three choices:

 

a) Offer Stanton what he wants and add pieces to build a competing team.

 

b.) Let Stanton go and build a complete new team to compete.

c) Let Stanton go and build a half-assed team full of prospects and hasbeens and neverwases to battle it out with the fading Phillies for last place for the next three/four years

d) Sell the team

 

He'll go for c), obviously

 

 

if the Marlins offer $200/8 he signs.

 

the Marlins are not going to offer $200/8.

 

NTC

 

he deserves a 3-4 year contract for $20m/ and then a $300m contract in this market.

 

 

If the Marlins refuse to give him a NTC because of "club policy" they are absolute morons. IDK if that is still something they do but i remember samson saying all the time how they don't do no trade clauses.

 

 

if the Marlins offer $200/8 he signs.

 

the Marlins are not going to offer $200/8.

 

NTC

 

he deserves a 3-4 year contract for $20m/ and then a $300m contract in this market.

 

 

no way he signs that.

 

i dont know what part of there has to be a 3 in front of the aav for free agency years that people dont fucking get.

 

THATS WHAT THE FUCKING MARKET FUCKING DICTATES.

 

Lets assume he gets 13 in arby this year and then 18 next year, thats 21 mil. And thats being very conservative.

 

He is then getting paid about 29 AAV.

 

There is a 0 chance of that happening, there is no chance he is taking a discount. Why should he?

 

Especially after the Marlins fucked him over in pre arby, they didnt give any back then, why should he give any now?

 

 

If the Marlins refuse to give him a NTC because of "club policy" they are absolute morons. IDK if that is still something they do but i remember samson saying all the time how they don't do no trade clauses.

 

 

It sounds from a few sources that they're at least considering bending that club policy for this one.

 

 

no way he signs that.

 

Lets assume he gets 13 in arby this year and then 18 next year, thats 21 mil. And thats being very conservative.

 

what did you math right there

 

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.