Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Stanton Rumors

Featured Replies

no way he signs that.

 

i dont know what part of there has to be a 3 in front of the aav for free agency years that people dont fucking get.

 

THATS WHAT THE FUCKING MARKET FUCKING DICTATES.

 

Lets assume he gets 13 in arby this year and then 18 next year, thats 21 mil. And thats being very conservative.

 

He is then getting paid about 29 AAV.

 

There is a 0 chance of that happening, there is no chance he is taking a discount. Why should he?

 

Especially after the Marlins fucked him over in pre arby, they didnt give any back then, why should he give any now?

 

 

I think 9/$253 or 10/$276 would get it done (those are respectively $1 million each higher than A-Rod's two biggest deals). He couldn't walk away from the 2nd or most lucrative contract in baseball history. Especially if he has trade protection and maybe an opt out around 31 or 32 years old.

 

I think 8/$200 doesn't make sense on years of price. They need to either go small - 4 years for like $110, or all in 9-10 years and buy out all the prime. Nothing in the middle makes sense. He either needs to get the opportunity for the second large deal when he is under 30, or be bought out of all the prime and exiting prime years. Nothing in between.

 

I also would value Stanton at a $40 million arbitration ($15-25, assume a go for broke year this year when offense is down in baseball and looks to set arbitration records). He's the guy to push the envelope with in arbitration, especially against this front office's arbitration record, which is the worst in baseball during their tenure.

 

I just don't see them offering 9/$253 or some 4 year deal with insane annual values. We'll see though. I wouldn't draw a line in the sand at "$300." If I was his agent, that's what my initial offer would be, but come on. $253? You're saying no to $253 just to try and get $300 in 2 years? That's the worst gamble of all time, even if you're banking $30-40 in arbitration.

 

 

I think 9/$253 or 10/$276 would get it done (those are respectively $1 million each higher than A-Rod's two biggest deals). He couldn't walk away from the 2nd or most lucrative contract in baseball history. Especially if he has trade protection and maybe an opt out around 31 or 32 years old.

 

I think 8/$200 doesn't make sense on years of price. They need to either go small - 4 years for like $110, or all in 9-10 years and buy out all the prime. Nothing in the middle makes sense. He either needs to get the opportunity for the second large deal when he is under 30, or be bought out of all the prime and exiting prime years. Nothing in between.

 

I also would value Stanton at a $40 million arbitration ($15-25, assume a go for broke year this year when offense is down in baseball and looks to set arbitration records). He's the guy to push the envelope with in arbitration, especially against this front office's arbitration record, which is the worst in baseball during their tenure.

 

I just don't see them offering 9/$253 or some 4 year deal with insane annual values. We'll see though. I wouldn't draw a line in the sand at "$300." If I was his agent, that's what my initial offer would be, but come on. $253? You're saying no to $253 just to try and get $300 in 2 years? That's the worst gamble of all time, even if you're banking $30-40 in arbitration.

 

It's always been about overpaying and it remains so as time goes by.

 

I pretty much agree with the numbers you present and with your conclusion. Yes, 9/253, 10/276 would probably be accepted....but I don't see the Marlins committing 253-276 million to any one player at the moment. That's too high of a percentage(roughly 30%) of what the entire franchise is worth. That's too big a gamble for a franchise....not when one pitch or one run shoulder first run into the wall can happen. That's why I was lobbying for 10/150+ 2 years ago, when it only would have been roughly 15% instead of 30% of franchise value.

 

.

 

I also don't see much incentive for Stanton to sign a BIG 4 year contract. THE 4 years in a superstars prime...it would have to be some insanely high number wayyy beyond 40M in arbitration plus 35m per year for the 2 extra years.

 

.

 

I still see 5/140-150 or 6/165-175 as the likeliest outcome...I hope.

 

I'd give it a 25% probability of happening.

 

I'd give a Stanton/Puig megatrade as the next likeliest outcome(maybe 15% prob), structured in a way that costs the Marlins present franchise owners less than keeping Stanton....I hope that doesn't happen.

 

 

So are we in a general agreement that Stanton does accept "something" just not exactly a mega deal? That's what I tell people when they ask my opinion at least.

  • Author

So are we in a general agreement that Stanton does accept "something" just not exactly a mega deal? That's what I tell people when they ask my opinion at least.

 

 

IMO he accepts nothing because the marlins will not propose anything reasonable

 

 

I think 9/$253 or 10/$276 would get it done (those are respectively $1 million each higher than A-Rod's two biggest deals). He couldn't walk away from the 2nd or most lucrative contract in baseball history. Especially if he has trade protection and maybe an opt out around 31 or 32 years old.

 

I think 8/$200 doesn't make sense on years of price. They need to either go small - 4 years for like $110, or all in 9-10 years and buy out all the prime. Nothing in the middle makes sense. He either needs to get the opportunity for the second large deal when he is under 30, or be bought out of all the prime and exiting prime years. Nothing in between.

 

I also would value Stanton at a $40 million arbitration ($15-25, assume a go for broke year this year when offense is down in baseball and looks to set arbitration records). He's the guy to push the envelope with in arbitration, especially against this front office's arbitration record, which is the worst in baseball during their tenure.

 

I just don't see them offering 9/$253 or some 4 year deal with insane annual values. We'll see though. I wouldn't draw a line in the sand at "$300." If I was his agent, that's what my initial offer would be, but come on. $253? You're saying no to $253 just to try and get $300 in 2 years? That's the worst gamble of all time, even if you're banking $30-40 in arbitration.

 

 

 

Now we are talking, that pretty much is what the Marlins need to do if they are going long term on Stanton. I guess the alternative is that 4 year deal, which Stanton honestly would be stupid to turn down if its actually offered for him. It gives him the cash he deserves and it allows him to get the fuck out of town if Loria doesnt bounce and in turn does his shit again in the near future.

 

 

So are we in a general agreement that Stanton does accept "something" just not exactly a mega deal? That's what I tell people when they ask my opinion at least.

 

 

 

If the Marlins actually offer the money to go along with it w/ the no trade, then I see him saying yes.

 

His agent would be a fucking moron to not tell him to accept.

 

 

  • Author

He's just saying we won't trade him just because he rejects an extension which is what the FO is saying.

 

 

Exactly. They're in the middle of contract negotations. What're they gonna say? IF YOU DON'T SIGN, YOU'RE GETTIN TRADED PAL.

 

 

Guesses as to what those 8 dollars are being allotted for? Heath Bell's next fast food meal? English lessons for Hechavarria? A new chain for Dietrich?

 

 

Guesses as to what those 8 dollars are being allotted for? Heath Bell's next fast food meal? English lessons for Hechavarria? A new chain for Dietrich?

 

-Not enough for 1% Heath Bell's fast food meal.

 

-¿Que?

 

-Flea Market chain?

 

 

Rosenthal says the Marlins are discussing a 10 year, $300 million deal with Dongcarlo.

 

Here's how I imagine the discussions are going:

 

Stanton's agent: "We won't sign for less than 10 years, $300 million"

 

Marlins Front Office: "LOL"

 

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.