Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

59 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

People will look at their quote about them trying for players and say "Hey, we tried!" but at what point do you wake up and realize whatever it is you're "trying" isn't going to work. 

Ngcompetence 

8 hours ago, Entendu said:

This team is fucked lol. I don't know how much longer I can just not care about baseball. In a few years I may be rooting for the Mets. 

(Yes. I don't have "second teams" but that would be the closest to that for me)

 

2 hours ago, r5812 said:

It is truly pathetic they're going to sleepwalk through another offseason when the needs are so obvious. Why do I bother with this team year after year?

I think this is the biggest "threat" to this organization right now... apathy from the fanbase. I didn't watch a single inning after July of last season and if I don't see actual improvement this offseason then I'll continue not watching in 2023. I have to believe this sentiment is all over the Marlins fanbase. They can only string us along for so long. Time is essentially already up. 

59 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Some fans are still defending them saying "Players don't want to come here". I hate that BS lie/excuse. They'd come if the team offered realistic contracts.

You know the ole saying.."money talks and Ng doesn't make calls"

1 hour ago, SonOfJack said:

 

They need to complete that trade for Reynolds and then at least get Turner (we know Correa or Nimmo ain't happening) Reynolds, Turner, a healthy Jazz and hope Avi returns to career norms might make the lineup interesting. 

12 minutes ago, hovertical said:

They need to complete that trade for Reynolds and then at least get Turner (we know Correa or Nimmo ain't happening) Reynolds, Turner, a healthy Jazz and hope Avi returns to career norms might make the lineup interesting. 

If they go the trade route I could see them finding an interesting but under the radar bat to throw into the mix too. Not sure who though.

Still though, at this point the Reynolds trade is essentially a must. There isn't much left for them.

If they're not being super aggressive with that trade then I don't know what they're doing. It's gotta be a "must get done" priority.

"Sometimes you think you're close and you're not," Ng said. "But it's just hard to tell. It's really hard to gauge."

Another one of those lines where she just seems in over her head. 

#Ngcompetence

9 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

Still though, at this point the Reynolds trade is essentially a must. There isn't much left for them.

If they're not being super aggressive with that trade then I don't know what they're doing. It's gotta be a "must get done" priority.

2nd year in a row now with Reynolds too. I'd wager my house that she doesn't trade though. 

Turner should be able to be signed to a 2yr deal at his age. Reynolds comes in via trade. Very little extra cost. Would love to see Correa added but hahahhahahahha. I'd settle for a nice bp arm too that has closer potential instead of another bat at that point if they got both Turner and Reynolds.

Edited by hovertical

18 minutes ago, hovertical said:

2nd year in a row now with Reynolds too. I'd wager my house that she doesn't trade though. 

By all accounts it seems like the Pirates really didn't want to trade him last year, definitely a different vibe this year. But she's gotta take advantage of that.

19 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Turner should be able to be signed to a 2yr deal at his age. Reynolds comes in via trade. Very little extra cost. Would love to see Correa added but hahahhahahahha. I'd settle for a nice bp arm too that has closer potential instead of another bat at that point if they got both Turner and Reynolds.

Reynolds + Turner + a BP arm + an under the radar bat via trade would be a fair addition but I wish we could get that plus one big addition that's more of a "sure thing." The problem is that Kim tends to be able to get several decent fringe additions but never the one big centerpiece.

10 hours ago, Entendu said:

Realistically, how much more does this team need *beyond Reynolds* to be compete? They're a good 2-3 pieces away...

They would probably be a fringe contender if they can add 8+ WAR this offseason. Any normal owner would add 12-15+ and get to that above 85 win projection.

Reynolds would effectively be half of that, and if they got Bednar in that deal (which is super obvious and they should pay up), we're looking at 3+ WAR to go.

If they added on top of that say Kiermaier and Justin Turner in FA and did this, they'd have a chance:

Fortes, Stallings
Cooper
Jazz
Rojas, Wendle (I know, but it is what it is)
Turner, Berti
Reynolds, DLC
Kiermaier
Garcia
Soler

Sandy, Pablo, Rogers/Cabrera (other for Reynolds), Luzardo, Garrett
Bednar, Floro, Chargois, Nance
Okert, Bleier, Scott, Castano

Everything would need to go right and Eury would have to be awesome, but it could happen.

Practically this would need Correa or at least A. Rosario put on top of this to get a big SS upgrade. That would help A LOT.

So they are 3-5 players away depending on how good they are more than likely. The 3 scenario would have to include a Correa. Since this is the Marlins and they are cheap, it would be at least a Reynolds kind of guy, and nickel and diming the rest like above + Rosario. Or maybe some prospect explosion and they somehow get Peraza and Alek Thomas and they become Jazz level quickly.

At their payroll level and depth to trade SP/those minor league infielders, they have no excuses

 

30 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

Reynolds + Turner + a BP arm + an under the radar bat via trade would be a fair addition but I wish we could get that plus one big addition that's more of a "sure thing." The problem is that Kim tends to be able to get several decent fringe additions but never the one big centerpiece.

Didn't see this until I typed above, but yes. Exactly.

Reynolds
Turner
BEDNAR
KIERMAIER
Rosario

That might work if stars align. Or it gets you to July 20th and they can trade something else.

There might be better ideas, but this would at least be plausible and I think we'd have to give the FO credit for piecing those guys together and presumably only trading 1 MLB SP to do it.

Just now, MarlinsLou said:

Didn't see this until I typed above, but yes. Exactly.

Reynolds
Turner
BEDNAR
KIERMAIER
Rosario

That might work if stars align. Or it gets you to July 20th and they can trade something else.

There might be better ideas, but this would at least be plausible and I think we'd have to give the FO credit for piecing those guys together and presumably only trading 1 MLB SP to do it.

Yeah this sounds like it would be progress at least. 

And that really shouldn't be so difficult to pull off. We can complain about them not wanting to get the big money free agents but we never go there and there's plenty of teams who don't, it is what it is... but the above mentioned additions should be "standard fare" for any competent GM. If they can't even do that much then what the hell are we doing here?

5 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

And that really shouldn't be so difficult to pull off. We can complain about them not wanting to get the big money free agents but we never go there and there's plenty of teams who don't, it is what it is... but the above mentioned additions should be "standard fare" for any competent GM. If they can't even do that much then what the hell are we doing here?

Yes.

Like if it costs Cabrera, Salas, Miller, Sanchez, Burdick, and McCambley.... and you get Reynolds, Bednar, and Brubaker, who is saying no to that on either side? Extend Reynolds 5/$93 (effectively 6/$100 with this year). Bednar is controlled for 4 years and Brubaker is your stopgap innings for 2023.

And then you still have 6 SP, and you can jack up Cleveland with Pablo for Rosario, Curry (a play now back end SP prospect), and another prospect or two.... who is saying no? Extend Rosario 5/$70.

So get 1 year veterans to platoon in CF (Kiermaier) and 1B/3B (Turner, or how about Longoria? There are options) and this looks like a team.

They can probably do this plan for $95m.

Meaning they shouldn't sign Kiermaier, just sign Nimmo and go to $110M range and then that team looks REALLY good*

These people suck

And further - if you're Bruce. Why don't you at least try this for 2023-2025 with this team? After 4 years of bottom in MLB spending?

Take a page out of the Jeff playbook. If I'm cheap and will only spend $90m dollars on payroll, that's effectively $450m over 5 years..... So let's spend $110m for three seasons ($330m), and if we suck summer of 2025, let's SCORCH EARTH and trade everybody, and then just tank payroll to extremely low levels in a two year rebuild 26-27 to get us back to that $450m number over 5 years and circle 2028 to spend some money again. Obviously it is more difficult and complicated this, but this works in theory.

Count me in for a summer 2025 firesale if it means we get competency on paper 23-25.

These people suck.

8 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

Meaning they shouldn't sign Kiermaier, just sign Nimmo and go to $110M range and then that team looks REALLY good*

These people suck

I really cringe at Kiermaier having regular at bats on the team. I know his CF play is fantastic but man I cringe at his at bats.

27 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

They would probably be a fringe contender if they can add 8+ WAR this offseason. Any normal owner would add 12-15+ and get to that above 85 win projection.

Reynolds would effectively be half of that, and if they got Bednar in that deal (which is super obvious and they should pay up), we're looking at 3+ WAR to go.

If they added on top of that say Kiermaier and Justin Turner in FA and did this, they'd have a chance:

Fortes, Stallings
Cooper
Jazz
Rojas, Wendle (I know, but it is what it is)
Turner, Berti
Reynolds, DLC
Kiermaier
Garcia
Soler

Sandy, Pablo, Rogers/Cabrera (other for Reynolds), Luzardo, Garrett
Bednar, Floro, Chargois, Nance
Okert, Bleier, Scott, Castano

Everything would need to go right and Eury would have to be awesome, but it could happen.

Practically this would need Correa or at least A. Rosario put on top of this to get a big SS upgrade. That would help A LOT.

So they are 3-5 players away depending on how good they are more than likely. The 3 scenario would have to include a Correa. Since this is the Marlins and they are cheap, it would be at least a Reynolds kind of guy, and nickel and diming the rest like above + Rosario. Or maybe some prospect explosion and they somehow get Peraza and Alek Thomas and they become Jazz level quickly.

At their payroll level and depth to trade SP/those minor league infielders, they have no excuses

 

Fortes/Stallings = Suck

Cooper = Will get hurt, not really that good anyway

Rojas/Wendle = Garbage

Garcia = Garbage

Soler = Garbage

Kiermaier = Garbage

Turner = 38

Reynolds = Good

Jazz = Good

 

Not a fringe playoff team. I appreciate your optimistic outlook but you're kidding yourself 

18 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

if you're Bruce. Why don't you at least try this for 2023-2025 with this team? After 4 years of bottom in MLB spending?

This is such a big point to me and why I have a glimmer of optimism that we'll get a big push and maybe even a big signing at some point because I refuse to believe Bruce wouldn't want at least one strong season here so there just absolutely has to be a point where he goes for it, where he pushes all his chips in, like when the hell is that gonna happen??? I would think that's now but what is going on?

1 hour ago, SilverBullet said:

This is such a big point to me and why I have a glimmer of optimism that we'll get a big push and maybe even a big signing at some point because I refuse to believe Bruce wouldn't want at least one strong season here so there just absolutely has to be a point where he goes for it, where he pushes all his chips in, like when the hell is that gonna happen??? I would think that's now but what is going on?

Why would he care if he just keeps making money regardless

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.