Everything posted by 30plus
-
Nunez, Mujica sign one year deals
That's hocum. What your fancy biased statistics didn't tell you is that Gaby Sanchez once gave BroncoBob the finger in traffic and immediately became expendable.
-
Ozzie Martinez
You clearly didn't understand what BroncoBob was trying to say. Once again you continue to twist his words around. Perhaps if you spent more time "watching" the game instead of compiling statistics that favor your arguments then you would learn something about the game. But nice try. I love how you didn't even attempt to make an argument. When you have eyes like mine, you don't need arguments. Not to mention I'm a season ticket holder, so my opinions already hold more merit than others. Bonifacio struck out 95 times in 2009 compared to 42 in 2010. That's a clear improvement. Unlike Gaby Sanchez, who struck out a whopping 101 times last year. Clearly Bonifacio has better plate discipline and trading Gaby Sanchez is in the team's best interests. If not for the enlightenment provided by BroncoBob on this matter, I confess I may have at one point allowed my judgement to be clouded by biased statistics. We should all follow his lead. I knew this was sarcasm/satire. Well played, sir. :lol There's nothing satiric about taking a stand against the majority opinion, sir. Not everyone can be a maverick like BroncoBob and I, but we're willing to bear the burden for the good of the team. I guess for some people it's just easier to conform.
-
Ozzie Martinez
You clearly didn't understand what BroncoBob was trying to say. Once again you continue to twist his words around. Perhaps if you spent more time "watching" the game instead of compiling statistics that favor your arguments then you would learn something about the game. But nice try. I love how you didn't even attempt to make an argument. When you have eyes like mine, you don't need arguments. Not to mention I'm a season ticket holder, so my opinions already hold more merit than others. Bonifacio struck out 95 times in 2009 compared to 42 in 2010. That's a clear improvement. Unlike Gaby Sanchez, who struck out a whopping 101 times last year. Clearly Bonifacio has better plate discipline and trading Gaby Sanchez is in the team's best interests. If not for the enlightenment provided by BroncoBob on this matter, I confess I may have at one point allowed my judgement to be clouded by biased statistics. We should all follow his lead. That'll happen when you have 461 AB's in 2009 and 180 AB's in 2010. Way to twist around what I was saying again. But if you're just going to start ridiculing me, then there's no point in responding to this. News flash. I guess some people just aren't capable of grasping certain concepts. Nice try though.
-
Ozzie Martinez
You clearly didn't understand what BroncoBob was trying to say. Once again you continue to twist his words around. Perhaps if you spent more time "watching" the game instead of compiling statistics that favor your arguments then you would learn something about the game. But nice try. I love how you didn't even attempt to make an argument. When you have eyes like mine, you don't need arguments. Not to mention I'm a season ticket holder, so my opinions already hold more merit than others. Bonifacio struck out 95 times in 2009 compared to 42 in 2010. That's a clear improvement. Unlike Gaby Sanchez, who struck out a whopping 101 times last year. Clearly Bonifacio has better plate discipline and trading Gaby Sanchez is in the team's best interests. If not for the enlightenment provided by BroncoBob on this matter, I confess I may have at one point allowed my judgement to be clouded by biased statistics. We should all follow his lead.
-
Ozzie Martinez
You clearly didn't understand what BroncoBob was trying to say. Once again you continue to twist his words around. Perhaps if you spent more time "watching" the game instead of compiling statistics that favor your arguments then you would learn something about the game. But nice try.
-
Rockies announcers call Marlins attendance on Monday "Pathetic"
I wish more people would go to games, but hey, we all know the reasons and some excuses why people don't go. Also. Strasburg game = friday. Ubaldo "over rated" Jimenez game = monday. No one has shutup about strasburg since before the season started. How is he overrated? He's 15-2 with an ERA under 3... He's 15-1 And, because people always like to forget, he pitches at Coors. If they didn't put the balls in the humidor there, he wouldn't even be in the CY Young conversation. But you have to give him some props. Just not as much as JJ. Edit: His home ERA with the humidor is 3.52 and his road ERA is 1.6. JJ: Home 1.41 Road 2.00. (How come when you avererage those together it comes out slightly higher than their actual total ERA?:confused) Because of the inning differential between home and away.
-
Uggla Staying
If they want to keep him another year, cool...but Uggla isn't worth a long-term contract, sorry. There's no need, either. Dominguez should be ready to take over third by 2012, with Coghlan shifting over to second. We're going to need his production next year with all the youth settling in, but after 2011 you can let him walk and take the compensation picks. Which may even be a better return than what you could get for him this offseason.
- Stanton Called Up
-
Is Hanley in a major funk?
His production is down this year compared to his usual OPS range. Not by enough to get you seriously worried, and it's only June, but enough to warrant some concern. The only thing I've noticed is he seems to swing at the first pitch more often this year than previous years. Obviously this is just based on perception, but I think this is also why his K's are slightly down this year. It also seems like sometimes he tries the drive the ball the other way too often, rather than pulling it when he should. But it's only June, and he's only one serious tear away from being back on track.
-
Matt Lindstrom traded to Astros
Great. Now look up the definition of "ad hominem." You're making this way too easy. An ad hominem argument has the basic form: Person 1 makes claim X There is something objectionable about Person 1 Therefore claim X is false Very good. Now point to the part where I made an objectionable comment about the character of another person and this should be wrapped up. No, no, no, my friend. I have made two claims: 1. That Lindstrom for Lowell and cash would be a good trade, and 2. That you are a hypocrite. Neither one of those can be nullified via ad hominem, which you have claimed. I am Person 1 making claim X in both scenarios. You claimed ad hominem about something, which I am still unclear, meaning you find something objectionable about me, making either one of my claims false. So, YOU point to the part where there is something objectionable about my character, and this should be wrapped up. This is all kinds of fail. The fact that person 1 allegedly has something objectionable about their character (i.e., penguino being a hypocrite), does not render that person's claim false. It's unrelated. Hence the fallicious nature of ad hominem. Punching "ad hominem" into wikipedia doesn't mean you automatically understand what it means. You still have to "read" the text.
-
July 31st Trade Deadline
I'd like to give Cliff Lee a chance. So one possible deal could be Lee and Jamey Carroll for Dan Uggla and a mid level prospect then we Could either A. Move Coghlan to 2nd and call Up Maybin or B. Move Bonifacio to 2nd and Gaby to 3rd. Or we can try to go straight up Lee for Hermida which I don't think they would do so you could throw in a mid/lower level prospect. You can also do the same things for Pavano but Pavano for Hermida straight out sounds like a reasonable deal both ways if not then just throw in a mid to low level prospect like I stated before. Are you serious? Lee is going to cost more than Uggla and Hermida together.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread 7/19 - 7/25
what happened to skipworth he was supposed to be so good He's 18. So was Dominguez when he tore it up in Greensboro. I'm not calling Skipworth a bust at 18, but there's literally nothing positive about what he's done in his pro career. All of the numbers are awful. To struggle that much in a hitter's environment is troubling. He's yet to even put up a .700 OPS over a month in his pro career. Hasn't even come close. I don't even want to think about the K's he's ammasing.
-
Marlins going from buyers to holders...
Make that two outfielders needed.Maybin sucked. You might want to take a look at what that 22 year old is doing in AAA.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread -- 7/12-7/18
Morrison continues to walk at a ridiculous rate (32/21 BB/K). It's something he did ok with in Jupiter, but he's been a marked improvement in Jax. The average and slugging are bound to go up as he's really starting to look like the complete package.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread -- 7/12-7/18
Wow, i called fr Vandy to be up and Sanches to be down a couple weeks ago. nice Why would you call for that a couple weeks ago? All things considered, Sanches has been solid. By default, it has to be him sent down but at least we know we can call on him in the future. Because Sean West was no longer pitching well. And Sanches has good numbers, but he has been awful with runners inherited West wasn't pitching that badly two weeks ago. We hadn't even acquired Donnelly at that point, so there would have been no reason to send Sanches down.
-
Josh Willingham
Hermida was the #4 prospect in baseball going into 2006. He was basically as highly rated as Delmon. Delmon Young was also coming off a year when he only had a .723 OPS. Hermida had a .729 OPS, so he actually out OPS'd delmon. however, you can only get what's offered to you. All offseason we heard about how nobody wanted to give up much. TB offered Jackson or Sonnanstine and we asked for me. I don't remember the exact offer but Seattle offered a bunch of sh*t and we said no adam moore no thank you and they walked away. I don't remember the other things. I mean, something to also remember with Delmon was he was traded to Min, a team that is basically the polar opposite of sabr and total scouting/small ball. Maybe they'd give up something great for Hermida if they didn't have Delmon. BUt their OF is crowded now. You can only get as much is as offered. The thing is Young's .723 OPS year came as a 21 year old in his first full season. It's hard to believe he's only 23 right now. 2008 was Hermida's third year in the bigs, and he was 24 (though he had actually shown something at the big league level unlike Young). Still, in limited playing time in 2006 (131 PA), Young also put up an OPS of .812. Young was as highly touted as they come. Baseball America actually ranked him as the #3 prospect in baseball before he had even played an inning of pro ball. He was considered a top-three prospect in every year of his pro career. Despite his mediocre 2007 as a 21 year old, I doubt his status diminished as much as Hermida after 2008. Regardless, we weren't going to pull anyone's #1 organizational prospect for Hermida last offseason (like Garza was for the twins in 2007).
-
Josh Willingham
I never believed that Maybin was ready and I said as much many times in the offseason. Same for Miller, but he has actually pitched pretty well. Secondly, Delmon Young was highly rated- I'll give you that. But until this year Jeremy Hermida was very highly rated as well, if not as high as Young. Only this year have teams caught on that Hermida isn't the player he was supposed to be. I don't know what exactly you would have gotten in exchange for Hermida. But I guarantee it could have gotten more than a fringe-prospect middle infielder and a low minors infield prospect. And seriously- lets stop this whole hypothetical if Hermida had a .900 OPS. Willingham had dramatically out OPSed Hermida in his time as a Marlin and Hermida sure didn't look like he was edging closer as he put up a .720 OPS last year. This is while Willingham put up an .830 OPS. The probability of Hermida putting up a .900 OPS this year and Willingham doing the same is just not even in the same ballpark. Even if Hermida's 2007, his OPS was only 10-20 points better than what Willingham has been doing consistently. And Hermida only did that for 123 games in one season. Clearly the numbers point to Willingham being the much better player. And yes, he was the older player, but Hermida had dramatically regressed. Yet despite this regression, Hermida was still the one who was highly value around the league because those who didn't see his ineptitude every day didn't have any idea how far he was from ever reaching his ceiling. People still thought of Hermida as the highly touted prospect who was supposed to win the rookie of the year, not the guy who had fly balls bounce off his face in RF. When you consider how much better a player Willingham was, compared to how much higher the perception of Hermida was, it's absolutely BAFFLING that we gave Hammer away. I'm infuriated just thinking about it. No, Hermida wasn't rated nearly as high as Young, who some scouts considered the #1 prospect in baseball at one point. In addition, Hermida was coming off a very mediocre 2008 which further decreased his value. If you were talking about trading Hermida in the 2007 offseason, it would be a different story. And Hermida's .870 OPS in 2007 was not 10-20 points better than Willingham's career .833 mark as a Marlin. Not sure where you come to the conclusion that Hammer was far more likely to .OPS .900 than Hermida. Especially considering Willingham's back injuries. If you knew that before this season started, then perhaps you wouldn't mind sharing your crystal ball with me. The return we got for Willingham and the decision to trade him are two seperate issues. The decision to trade him instead of Hermida, at the time, was the right one. The players we got in return were underwhelming to say the least. Out of the three, Smolinski is the only legit piece. Willingham was one of my favorite Marlins, and trading him for Bonifacio is just as infuriating to me. Even still, its too early to fully assess the trade. I understand Hermida hatred on this board is at an all-time high, but don't act like you saw this coming. And if you want to discuss what we could have gotten for Hermida, try to be realistic instead of citing names like Garza and Bartlett as being of equivalent value in a return.
-
Josh Willingham
But here is the problem in that. We traded away the guy whose trade value was at an all-time move. And while Smolinski or whoever might be a nice prospect, the fact of the matter is that Olsen and Willingham were both practically give-aways for salary reasons. And a give-away does absolutely nothing to help your team win next year. I realize that the Hermida thing is somewhat hindsight, but we're talking about guys whose job it is 24/7 to put together a good baseball team. They have to be approaching situations with a certain degree of foresight and if they aren't, they are only going to be mediocre. And just giving away parts leaves you as nothing but mediocre. How was our team supposed to improve in last year's record if all we did was give a couple guys away without adequate replacements? What would have been much better for this team is to make some sort of trade that actually benefited this ballclub. We needed to cut salary, we all know that, but trading a guy like Hermida whose value was much higher than Willingham's would have made a lot more sense because we could have gotten something more than spare parts. And I know that some still imagine Hermida with some incredible talent ceiling but the reality that we're looking at is that the best he could become is what Josh Willingham already is and has been. Hermida is just another "tools" guy who hasn't and likely won't maximize his potential while Willingham is the very under-rated player who actually performs. There's a reason why I'm rooting for a blockbuster deal (with some of our major league players) come deadline time. If we stay as-is, we're not gonna make it. Giving away any of our starting players would be a gamble, but it's time we roll the dice again. Because when Dan Uggla, Josh Johnson, Jorge Cantu, and Cody Ross all price themselves out of our market, we're gonna be wishing we tried to do what it took to make the playoffs instead of being content with mediocrity. If you're gonna lose players inevitably, at least make their value work for you. It's still hindsight though. We wouldn't be having this discussion if Hermida was the one with the .958 OPS. There is a reason Hermida had the value he did in the offseason, and nine times out of ten you trade Willingham in that situation. The poor return in that trade is a seperate issue. Our guess was as good as the FO when determining who would have the .958 OPS in July. There was a reason why Delmon Young's value was high when he was traded for Matt Garza and Jason Bartlett. There was also a reason why the Rays went to the WS last year and it has a lot to do with this trade. If your team operates under a constricted budget, with the inability to bring in free agents, the only way you are going to improve is by making trades that make the most of the value you have. And while some trades can be sort of a gamble, that's simply what it takes sometimes in order to improve your team. First of all, there's no garuntee that if we traded Hermida, we would have gotten back equal to greater value in return. Let alone pieces that would help us to a title run. It's far more likely we would have gotten prospects. Secondly, Delmon Young is a bad comparable. We're talking about a guy who was, at one point, considered a top three prospect in all of baseball. His value was significantly higher than what Hermida's was last offseason. You're also ignoring the fact that, at the time, it appeared we had adequate in house replacements for both Willingham and Olsen. Maybin was to solidify CF, and Miller slid into Olsen's spot in the rotation. Again, we wouldn't be having this conversation if Hermida's OPS was hovering around .900. Hind to the sight.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread -- 7/12-7/18
Wow, i called fr Vandy to be up and Sanches to be down a couple weeks ago. nice Why would you call for that a couple weeks ago? All things considered, Sanches has been solid. By default, it has to be him sent down but at least we know we can call on him in the future.
-
Josh Willingham
But here is the problem in that. We traded away the guy whose trade value was at an all-time move. And while Smolinski or whoever might be a nice prospect, the fact of the matter is that Olsen and Willingham were both practically give-aways for salary reasons. And a give-away does absolutely nothing to help your team win next year. I realize that the Hermida thing is somewhat hindsight, but we're talking about guys whose job it is 24/7 to put together a good baseball team. They have to be approaching situations with a certain degree of foresight and if they aren't, they are only going to be mediocre. And just giving away parts leaves you as nothing but mediocre. How was our team supposed to improve in last year's record if all we did was give a couple guys away without adequate replacements? What would have been much better for this team is to make some sort of trade that actually benefited this ballclub. We needed to cut salary, we all know that, but trading a guy like Hermida whose value was much higher than Willingham's would have made a lot more sense because we could have gotten something more than spare parts. And I know that some still imagine Hermida with some incredible talent ceiling but the reality that we're looking at is that the best he could become is what Josh Willingham already is and has been. Hermida is just another "tools" guy who hasn't and likely won't maximize his potential while Willingham is the very under-rated player who actually performs. There's a reason why I'm rooting for a blockbuster deal (with some of our major league players) come deadline time. If we stay as-is, we're not gonna make it. Giving away any of our starting players would be a gamble, but it's time we roll the dice again. Because when Dan Uggla, Josh Johnson, Jorge Cantu, and Cody Ross all price themselves out of our market, we're gonna be wishing we tried to do what it took to make the playoffs instead of being content with mediocrity. If you're gonna lose players inevitably, at least make their value work for you. It's still hindsight though. We wouldn't be having this discussion if Hermida was the one with the .958 OPS. There is a reason Hermida had the value he did in the offseason, and nine times out of ten you trade Willingham in that situation. The poor return in that trade is a seperate issue. Our guess was as good as the FO when determining who would have the .958 OPS in July.
-
Josh Willingham
Epic Fail: for some things, there's just no excuse Well saving $5+ million off a $36 million payroll and still being in contention for the division are both pretty decent excuses. The move was a salary dump, first and foremost. Its hilarious how people try to ignore that aspect of our franchise. Its the same swiss-cheese logic that results in threads about acquiring Joe Mauer. Well we're not gonna make the playoffs this year with the offense we have now. Is that really a win? I don't think so. Besides, the guy we kept over him we couldn't even trade to the Pirates. Hindsight. At the time, nobody was complaining that we retained Hermida instead of Willingham. It was clear one of the two had to go, and Hermida was slightly cheaper, younger, and with more upside. Plus there was Willingham's back issues.
-
7/11 Post Game
Exactly, and its been this way since '06. Im not quite sure how Presley still has a job. This has got to be one of the most overrated notions in baseball. You ever consider that the offense is inconsistent because it happens to be comrpised of several inconsistent hitters? Well then what would be the point of hving a hitting coach then? Plain and simple, we havent been a good offense since he's gotten here and we have had pretty bad discipline and have been near the top of the league in k's since 06. Everyone could use a change. You do realize that we had a massive personel change in 06? I mean it's ridiculous to make assumptions like that. It's the same thing when managers like Manny Acta are put on the hot seat and the media encourages the scapegoating. A hitting coach gets way too much credit when an offense peforms well and way too much blame when it doesn't. Do you honestly believe that there's something another hitting coach can do to make our hitters more consistent? Like saying "hey Uggs, try keeping your head down on the ball next time" is going to turn Uggla into a .280 hitter? I suppose this means Andy Fox is responsible for every error me make too.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread 7/5-7/11
Maybin is just ridiculous right now. He's finally showing some power and he's extended his hitting streak to 11 games (including 6 multi-hit games during that span). His season line sits at .343/.425/.497 (.922 OPS). Believe me, I understand the service time argument, but those numbers are hard to ignore. One bright spot with West being sent down is his arbitration will probably be delayed till 2013. Perhaps it's wishful thinking on my part, but this could conceivably increase Maybin's chances of getting the call. the service time arguement would only keep him down for about 5 more games thanks to the ASB Going by Lou's post, we'd need to keep him down until September to ensure he doesn't get Super 2'd. That's what I meant by the service time argument. Gotcha :thumbup there's two service time arguements, one is that if we keep him down until the 19th we get an extra year of club control, the other is if we keep him down until september we get him super 2 free. I agree that super 2 isn't that big of a deal because we should be looking at increased revenue and such and yadda yadda but the extra club control is huge so he needs to stay down until then in my opinion. Agreed. I messed up on the service time calculations. Didn't realiize we hadn't already secured the extra year of club control from him. But yes, he should stay down until the 19th and hopefully get called up soon after.
-
Daily Farm Report Thread 7/5-7/11
Maybin is just ridiculous right now. He's finally showing some power and he's extended his hitting streak to 11 games (including 6 multi-hit games during that span). His season line sits at .343/.425/.497 (.922 OPS). Believe me, I understand the service time argument, but those numbers are hard to ignore. One bright spot with West being sent down is his arbitration will probably be delayed till 2013. Perhaps it's wishful thinking on my part, but this could conceivably increase Maybin's chances of getting the call. the service time arguement would only keep him down for about 5 more games thanks to the ASB Going by Lou's post, we'd need to keep him down until September to ensure he doesn't get Super 2'd. That's what I meant by the service time argument.
-
7/11 Post Game
Exactly, and its been this way since '06. Im not quite sure how Presley still has a job. This has got to be one of the most overrated notions in baseball. You ever consider that the offense is inconsistent because it happens to be comrpised of several inconsistent hitters?