Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

EricWiener

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by EricWiener

  1. Olivo isn't good enough for the Golden Glove, if he wins it, the win would only serve to illustrate the ignorance of sportswriters. Olivo is a poor reciever, with a great throwing arm. With his offense he is an overall good catcher this season, but Gold Glove? No way.
  2. Give Reggie a shot. Maybe he'll surprise us. One thing I do want to see him do more often is bunt. Good things usually happen when he bunts. Outright release.
  3. So around 98 homers at the position (3B) to go with 35 or so errors makes him the greatest of all time at third? Jeez you're generous. And, while he surely has the numbers to be remembered as one of the greatest players of all time, the premature position shift has hurt him to the extent that I think he'll be remembered as Pete Rose is, simply a great hitter, but the position maneuvering makes it hard to definitively call him the "best" ever at a position. Ernie Banks still has a great case to make that he's the greatest shortstop of all time, and at the moment, it's hard to argue against George Brett or Eddie Matthews as the greatest third basemen. If A-Rod was hit by a bus immediately after the Yankees acquired him he would still be the greated SS of all time. He should also be the SS of the Yankees because he is better than Jeter at the position. I can argue against Brett and Eddie Matthews with Schmidt who is much higher on the career OPS ladder.
  4. Michael Smith: Miguel Cabrera is the best 3rd baseman in baseball... :plain I love Miggy but even I think that's a stretch... He has the highest OPS among 3B in MLB, and is in a terrible hitters park. So that is not a stretch, though it is arguable with about 3-4 other players (Wright, Rolen, Rogriguez, maybe Chipper)
  5. Stop making Kool Aid a scapegoat...he has shown some growth and development...he has had some hits here and there. i wish he was playing everyday...that would be the only reason to send him down. Abs is gonna be a Marlin for awhile and i am OK with that Kool Aid is not a scapegoat. There is no guarantee that the team would be much closer to the WC if Abercrombie weren't a Marlin, but Reggie can't play baseball at the major league level. He's never even demonstrated the ability to play at the AA level. His sole attribute is that he looks like he should be a good player.
  6. It is by bullpen rest and days off to start the 2nd half. We also have a double header with Philly looming.
  7. The team is playing well but has a couple of holes. The team will not compete for the Wild Card without a CF and a couple more bullpen guys.
  8. He does have ability. I think you're being outlandish saying he has no future. There's a stark divide between having a future as a potential superstar and having a future, some fans here are just spoiled with all the young talent here. Even the best teams have guys who hit 7th or 8th, the sooner you and others realize that, the more rational this asylum will become. And for the record, I'm not even a huge Reggie fan, but I never was, I don't just flip back and forth based on the "what have you done for me lately" mentality. Based upon his age, we are seeing the first part of the prime of his career right now. Pretty, ain't it? He has athletic ability, but he has no baseball skills. There are supposedly 5 "skills" in baseball, he has none of them. He is a poor fielder, an unsuccessful baserunner, he can't hit the ball for either average or power and can't throw to the right base. Based upon his athletic prowess he should at least be able to field, throw, and steal bases. He swings really hard, but can't hit the ball so he can't get enough contact to have power. There is nothing there. It would be better for both the organization and Reggie's future if he gets started on his after-baseball career ASAP.
  9. I guess I agree with Reggie, I mean, everyone needs a scapegoat, but really, he's not as bad as everyone thinks he is nor is he as good as everyone thought he was when liking Reggie was the fashionable thing to do. Not as bad as everyone thinks he is? Name one thing he does well as a baseball player? Forget AAA, outright release, there is no future in him.
  10. We should start a poll. Can someone give me 3 other former marlins players that you think should give Reggie good competition on "who suck the most" thread? I'm serious. Charles Johnson in 1996 Luis Castillo in 1998 Greg Zaun in 1998 Chuck Carr in 1995 Alex Gonzalez in 2000 (might be the worst of all time) Eric Owens in 2001 Charles Johnson in 2002 Mike Lowell in 2003 Those are the ones I could argue have been at least as bad, and in A-Gon's case in 2000, far, far worse.(based mostly on OPS). Most of the seasons listed are far better than Reggie's performance or not comparable. (injury years or before the player was a full-time Marlin) and some of those seasons were by much younger ballplayers. My big complaint with Reggie is that there is no potential any longer, what we see is as good as it is going to be. If Hanley was having the same type of season, I'd be all for letting him work some more in AAA to get it together. Reggie needs to be replaced and released.
  11. We all know Reggie doesnt belong, but it's ridiculous to see these threads everyday. It's not like he isnt trying his hardest. He is probably still going to keep getting looks because we really arent making a run for the wild card this year(barring another June like run). Now if they would start Borchard in CF everyday for a few weeks, that would be nice. Every day until he's gone. If they want, the Marlins could pay me 6 figures to try my hardest.
  12. Reggie, when playing, is a major contributor to Marlins losses. He is a liability in every aspect of the game. The massive difference between with and without Reggie winning % is largely not due to Reggie, but any win the team has while Reggie plays is in spite of Reggie, not because. He is a zero tool player.
  13. You guys think Reggie is bad........ not breaking news or anything. No need to beat it over the head time after time after time. Reggie is bad. Reggie is still on the team. Reggie is getting a lot of playing time. Add all that up and it is cause for complaint. The team needs to obtain a legitimate CF, sooner rather than later.
  14. The difference is winning % is obviously not his fault Perhaps you should re-phrase it as "The difference is winning % is obviously not ENTIRELY his fault"
  15. Another loss, another Reggie start.
  16. reggie had an RBI , i think it was a sac fly....hermida didn't contribute at all.. it was a ground ball misplayed by Vidro And the only reason he got the RBI was because you can't 'assume the double play'. Otherwise, he wouldn't have had it at all. Reggie would have beat that out. Yeah he had that beat. BTW, Hermida drew a walk and scored a run, so in the micro-universe that is yesterday's game, they both contibuted somewhat.
  17. Petit should consider himself the luckiest SOB today. If the situation were any different, he would have also been pulled after the first inning. Nice job, guys for saving his ass. Starting pitchers are not pulled after 4 runs in the first during the regular season. Afterwards, he pitched well. It may have been related to inadequate warm-up pitches.
  18. The question of the day: Would FeLo still be willing to bear Reggie Abercrombie's children if he played for the Reds? :mischief2 :lol Well played. He would be in AAA for us, so yes I would. :mischief No, as a Red, he'd be given his outright release.
  19. We are starting to look like the April marlins, does anyone agree or disagree? I blame Abecrombie. Just compare the records with him in the lineup and not.
  20. u know wat we havent played well since martinez went on the dl and i had the feeling that we would stop playing well when we left becuase im very superstitous I dont believe in that bu I sure hope someone step ups for our team. :pray I blame Abercrombie! :cool
  21. Better win today, we must sweep TB. Time is running out! Time for what? We only have 2 more days left! After than we won't be able to sweep the Rays!
  22. I want to put Arizona and San Fran in the rear view by the end of next week
  23. Check Gathright OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/J...Gathright.shtml Check Chavez OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/Endy-Chavez.shtml Having speed doesn't make you a good leadoff hitter and Taveras doesn't exactly have a good k/bb ratio which would lead you to believe he will ever become a good leadoff hitter. I was in favor of trading for Gathright, because the Marlins have no legitimate CF in the entire organization. If you stop and read what I wrote, you may note that I said his speed would serve him well once he gets his OBP back up.
  24. We don't need a prospect here...We need a proven guy that can help the team. Otherwise this trade is worthless and best kept for the offseason. Identify the available CF player, on a team that is out of it, that won't cost $5,000,000+ this year, that would be a "proven guy". Pierre is struggling, Hunter would cost $5,000,000+ this season, and everyone else is on a team in the mix or is not trade bait (young, under contract, cheap, etc.). Tavares would help the team now (by getting on base), AND can be on the team for years to come. The fact that he would be the team's #7 hitter says more about the fine performace of most of the Marlins, than the deficiencies of Tavares. SS Ramierez 2B Uggla 1B Jacobs 3B Cabrera LF Willingham RF Hermida CF Tavares C Olivo That lineup is going to score runs. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/D/C...-Denorfia.shtml http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil..._pbp&pid=456121 http://cincinnati.reds.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...layer_id=456121 Chris Denorfia says hi. He could be you CF for now and the future. With Griffey,Dunn,Kearns, and Freel there is just no room in the major for Deno. He is definately MLB ready, and could step in and be your everyday CF. This guy looks pretty good to me. I like that he hits a lot of 2Bs and draws a lot of walks.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.