June 17, 200719 yr Dukes? For what, turning the Dade County Jail a shade of teal? No thanks.......The Pinellas County Inmates can keep him.
June 17, 200719 yr Careful what you say about De Aza. He has a quirky set of followers that think he is a sure fire hall of famer. Well he did show us fans the way the position of CF should be played and he went hitless only once in the 10 games that he played. Is there anything not to like there? Hall of Famer , thats a little exagerated...Good ballplayer more like it. How good? only time would tell
June 18, 200719 yr If it wasn't for all the bad sh*t he's been doing lately, then I'm sure we would had made a run at Dukes. But why would you trade for someone who might be arrested every other month.
June 18, 200719 yr On the other hand if Tampa releases Dukes like its been rumored then I would be all for signing him. If he messes up he's gone and we dont lose anything and if he cleans up then we're set.
June 18, 200719 yr Before the season began I would say go after him, but not now. He'll be outta the league in a couple years if he keeps it up. Yeah, that's my feeling exactly. Hell, even 3 weeks ago, I'd have said go after him, but now, it's too much of a video-game trade. If we're going to make a move for a centerfielder, I'd rather just say "ah f*** it" and trade Volstad for a young legit player, not someone with red flags all over the place. See, I think saying "trade Volstad for a young legit player" is more of a "video game trade" than us trading for Dukes. What exactly do you think Volstad's value is? Because he would not get us back one of the top 2 tier CF prospects, no way. Maybe as a piece, but not as the centerpiece of a deal. I also don't believe chemistry plays any role whatsoever in the win-loss record. Boog Sciambi brings it up all the time, but he covered the 1997 Marlins team and he says that they had some of the worst "chemistry" you could imagine. The players simply did not get along well with each other and would fight all the time in the locker room. Who cares though? Chemistry means jack &**^ when it comes to this level of baseball. The risk then with Dukes is obviously will he flame out and be out of the league in two years ala a Jeff Allison? It is possible, I wouldn't deny that. But at this point we would not have to give up anything of high value. I think a Renyel Pinto would get it done, maybe even less...like say a Harvey Garcia. So at this low value, why not get a guy who if he stays out of trouble can be another building block position player(to go along with Hanley,Hermida and Cabs)? When talking about prospects you always talk about high risk/high ceiling type players, and this is that type of deal. This is a possible Gary Sheffield type offensive player. Well, now now now, the'97 team was not bad chemistry, it was just dysfunctional. Leyland knew how to talk to Brown, Sheff, Bobby Bo and Devo. Leiter and Leyland didn't exactly get along great, but when push came to shove, they really did like each other a lot after Daulton got here and essentially had an air it out players only session. Chemistry and winning and what not are essentially by products of themselves, there's no "bad" team that has "great" chemistry. Deep down, most teams learn to like each other over the course of the season and most guys know they're playing professional sports for a living and have a little character in them. If anything, it's the Jeters and Wrights of the world (the players who take themselves overly seriously) that make for some of the toughest teammates. My point with Dukes is essentially a line in the sand was drawn earlier, he was on the wrong side of one of our best players, to me, that doesn't scream no-brainer acquisition. Could he and Miggy work it out if they were made teammates tommorw? I'm sure, hell, I bet it never becomes an issue that's revisited, but he (Dukes) is an unquestioned head-case who has had a direct run in with our team, not a great first impression. As for the Volstad trade, I never named names, I'm very much aware that one for one he could never bring us a Jacoby Ellsbury type player (great draft, BTW, Beinfest) but I do also realize there have been multiple published articles that quoted unnamed General Managers (who I also realize could be the author's garbage men) saying that there's an absolute dearth of starting pitching on the trade market. What's more, one article asked the same unnamed GM if he were offered a Carl Crawford type player for the team's best pitching prospect (assuming the prospect was of high quality) and the GM said that was not a trade he would make because of the situation with pitching in baseball in general. I see no reason a pitching starved, positionally rich organization wouldn't at least consider dealing their blue-chip position player for our blue-chip pitching prospect...and I see no reason why the organization would be absolutely reluctant to deal one of our many arms in the anme of winning now and for the next 3 years.
June 18, 200719 yr Before the season began I would say go after him, but not now. He'll be outta the league in a couple years if he keeps it up. Yeah, that's my feeling exactly. Hell, even 3 weeks ago, I'd have said go after him, but now, it's too much of a video-game trade. If we're going to make a move for a centerfielder, I'd rather just say "ah f*** it" and trade Volstad for a young legit player, not someone with red flags all over the place. See, I think saying "trade Volstad for a young legit player" is more of a "video game trade" than us trading for Dukes. What exactly do you think Volstad's value is? Because he would not get us back one of the top 2 tier CF prospects, no way. Maybe as a piece, but not as the centerpiece of a deal. I also don't believe chemistry plays any role whatsoever in the win-loss record. Boog Sciambi brings it up all the time, but he covered the 1997 Marlins team and he says that they had some of the worst "chemistry" you could imagine. The players simply did not get along well with each other and would fight all the time in the locker room. Who cares though? Chemistry means jack &**^ when it comes to this level of baseball. The risk then with Dukes is obviously will he flame out and be out of the league in two years ala a Jeff Allison? It is possible, I wouldn't deny that. But at this point we would not have to give up anything of high value. I think a Renyel Pinto would get it done, maybe even less...like say a Harvey Garcia. So at this low value, why not get a guy who if he stays out of trouble can be another building block position player(to go along with Hanley,Hermida and Cabs)? When talking about prospects you always talk about high risk/high ceiling type players, and this is that type of deal. This is a possible Gary Sheffield type offensive player. Well, now now now, the'97 team was not bad chemistry, it was just dysfunctional. Leyland knew how to talk to Brown, Sheff, Bobby Bo and Devo. Leiter and Leyland didn't exactly get along great, but when push came to shove, they really did like each other a lot after Daulton got here and essentially had an air it out players only session. Chemistry and winning and what not are essentially by products of themselves, there's no "bad" team that has "great" chemistry. Deep down, most teams learn to like each other over the course of the season and most guys know they're playing professional sports for a living and have a little character in them. If anything, it's the Jeters and Wrights of the world (the players who take themselves overly seriously) that make for some of the toughest teammates. My point with Dukes is essentially a line in the sand was drawn earlier, he was on the wrong side of one of our best players, to me, that doesn't scream no-brainer acquisition. Could he and Miggy work it out if they were made teammates tommorw? I'm sure, hell, I bet it never becomes an issue that's revisited, but he (Dukes) is an unquestioned head-case who has had a direct run in with our team, not a great first impression. As for the Volstad trade, I never named names, I'm very much aware that one for one he could never bring us a Jacoby Ellsbury type player (great draft, BTW, Beinfest) but I do also realize there have been multiple published articles that quoted unnamed General Managers (who I also realize could be the author's garbage men) saying that there's an absolute dearth of starting pitching on the trade market. What's more, one article asked the same unnamed GM if he were offered a Carl Crawford type player for the team's best pitching prospect (assuming the prospect was of high quality) and the GM said that was not a trade he would make because of the situation with pitching in baseball in general. I see no reason a pitching starved, positionally rich organization wouldn't at least consider dealing their blue-chip position player for our blue-chip pitching prospect...and I see no reason why the organization would be absolutely reluctant to deal one of our many arms in the anme of winning now and for the next 3 years. I think that is one of those things where if they became teammates, they would have a laugh about what happened. They reacted the way they did, in part, because they were on different teams and are expected to respond the way they did. I doubt it would be a big deal if they were teammates. Id be interested/excited to see it happen.
June 18, 200719 yr Careful what you say about De Aza. He has a quirky set of followers that think he is a sure fire hall of famer. And there's an equal number of people who seem ready to dismiss him, despite what he's done before going on the DL.
June 18, 200719 yr if we were to trade for Dukes i'd love to see how hard everyone comes down on him for his low batting average like i've seen people get on Hermida.
June 18, 200719 yr A team this young does not need a personality like him, no matter the talent. And that talent has yet to control it on an MLB level yet, for that matter. Unlike some, i think team leaders and strong personalities (and role players, ftm) are VERY important parts to a winning team and from what ive seen from dukes, i dont want him anywhere near this team, imo. I say go for patchwork now (lofton) and then wait until the perfect situation arises in the offseason I'd make a trade for Patterson at the right price. I'd love to see him roaming CF.. and to think, he could have been a throw in the JP trade. You ask me when that trade happened and i was begging for CPat over Mtire or cpat thrown in.. amazing how far Sergio has come.
June 18, 200719 yr I would love to have Dukes and his many bastard children in teal. If a player performs noone cares about thier character, if he doen't all of a sudden his character is cancerous and negatively affecting the team. Proffesionals in all fields work with people they don't like, however if they are competant and do thier job well it is put aside.
June 18, 200719 yr Careful what you say about De Aza. He has a quirky set of followers that think he is a sure fire hall of famer. LOL!! Though I admit, I think he can play looking at his numbers. what numbers?
June 18, 200719 yr Isn't he the one that got arrested a few times and they said he threatened his wife to kill her on a text message? :mischief2
June 18, 200719 yr Isn't he the one that got arrested a few times and they said he threatened his wife to kill her on a text message? :mischief2 yes but he is also the one that is a potential 300/400/500 type player in CF with an arm like Vlad and speed. A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. Just a foolishness of albert belle. He came from a hard past and really needs to get away from tampa (where he was born area) and start fresh.
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not.
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not. I got to disagree there. Dukes is a phenomenal prospect (headcase aside)
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not. I got to disagree there. Dukes is a phenomenal prospect (headcase aside) Top ten in all of baseball? I think that's a tremendous stretch.
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not. I got to disagree there. Dukes is a phenomenal prospect (headcase aside) Top ten in all of baseball? I think that's a tremendous stretch. Yep, top 10 in all of baseball
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not. I got to disagree there. Dukes is a phenomenal prospect (headcase aside) Top ten in all of baseball? I think that's a tremendous stretch. Yep, top 10 in all of baseball How on Earth could you say that? I mean, the consensus top-3 are Philip Hughes, Homer Bailey and Delmon Young, then there are the guys like Tim Lincecum, Alex Gordon and Chris Young who are in the majors now and making an impact. Guys like Evan Longoria, Brandon Wood, Yovani Gallardo and Andrew Miller who aren't too far away and then you have the really young and somewhat polished players like Cameron Maybin, Jay Bruce...and plenty more like them. I mean, I realize you disagree, but top-10 seems like a huge stretch.
June 18, 200719 yr Well I was going more along the lines of top 10 positional prospect but he has as much talent as any of those guys listed
June 18, 200719 yr Well I was going more along the lines of top 10 positional prospect but he has as much talent as any of those guys listed After all his personal problems, I don't think he should be on the top 10 list. I don't care if he has the talent of Babe Ruth or Barry Bonds. These type of player tend to be a bust.
June 18, 200719 yr A top 10 talent in terms of prospects in baseball and a rare type of player. No he's not. I got to disagree there. Dukes is a phenomenal prospect (headcase aside) Top ten in all of baseball? I think that's a tremendous stretch. Yep, top 10 in all of baseball How on Earth could you say that? I mean, the consensus top-3 are Philip Hughes, Homer Bailey and Delmon Young, then there are the guys like Tim Lincecum, Alex Gordon and Chris Young who are in the majors now and making an impact. Guys like Evan Longoria, Brandon Wood, Yovani Gallardo and Andrew Miller who aren't too far away and then you have the really young and somewhat polished players like Cameron Maybin, Jay Bruce...and plenty more like them. I mean, I realize you disagree, but top-10 seems like a huge stretch. I would split positional and pitching talent but either way I would put him into that group and add that is close to major league ready if he gets consistent at bats and away from the headaches. In pure talent he can be argued against any of those players. The debate is to give up a Pinto or Tankersly for a guy of the caliber of names you are mentioning for a team that has crap for positional depth. Well I was going more along the lines of top 10 positional prospect but he has as much talent as any of those guys listed After all his personal problems, I don't think he should be on the top 10 list. I don't care if he has the talent of Babe Ruth or Barry Bonds. These type of player tend to be a bust. albert belle?
June 18, 200719 yr He came from a hard past and really needs to get away from tampa (where he was born area) and start fresh. Once a punk, always a punk. This isn't like the Mets-Milledge situation, where Milledge was just acting his age and upset members of the clubhouse with his 'unprofesional' attitude. The worst things he did was make a generic rap song and have sex with high school girls while he himself was in high school. A fresh start away from that is what Milledge needs. Dukes is going to be a criminal where ever he goes, a 'fresh start' isn't going to do sh*t for him. And I'd rather not sell out and give up morales for talent to better our chances of winning. I'd rather lose then sell out.
June 18, 200719 yr What about Jacques Jones from the Cubbies? He is obviously more of a left/right field kind of guy but can certainly play CF if needed. He's been platooned over there since Felix Pie came up and the fans don't like his horrible average. He's probably a cheap pickup (I think he signed a 3 year, $16 million deal a few years ago and not sure when that deal is up). They have been shopping a trade for months now. If they are willing to pay a big portion of his remaining salary, I'd like to trade for him. I think a change of scenery, a fresh start would do him good....and we could always use a good left handed bat in the lineup with a little pop in his bat. Just thinking out loud folks.....
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.