Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

1st base

Featured Replies

I disagree Jimmy.

I think Gaby can hit around 15 HR's...maybe some more.

 

Ryan Garko type #'s.

I believe Sanchez is penciled in at first base for next season. As the MVP of the Carolina League, I think he has little more to prove at the minor league level. He's a good glove and has a great on base percentage. He may even be the Marlins number three hitter in the lineup on opening day. If a trade of Uggla can net a starting pitcher of the caliber of Cain, I would take a long look at Cantu at second base. Under that kind of scenario, third base would certainly be MacPherson's job to lose.

My feeling is that Gaby Sanchez is the favorite to take 1B. And if he wins the spot, I think you'll see him as the main 1B with no platoon. But if he does have a terrible start, he'll probably be demoted in favor of McPherson as the new main 1B. I doubt you'll see anything crazy like Uggla being moved to 1B. Hammer being moved to 1B if both Sanchez (who'll be given a lot of rope IMHO) and McPherson fail is within the realm of possibility, but as a latch ditch maneuver.

Fredi's a moron if Gaby Sanchez isn't platooned. It's a position you have to get power out of and that is something Gaby Sanchez will not provide.

 

Traditionally you expect power from your first baseman. But we aren't a traditional team. Our biggest power hitters are at positions you traditionally expect better gloves than bats - short and second. We have more than enough power in our lineup as it stands to do without getting 30 homeruns from our first baseman.

I totally agree with you. Just let the Sanchez get some at bats, in my opinion he will demonstrate great power (20-25HR) even though we aren't going to be very dependable on him to hit homers like Jacobs because we will have Hanly, Uggla, Cantu and if Hammer stays healthy he could go back to the 20's HR like in 06-07. As long as Sanchez hits with avg.(.280-.300+) and gets decent extra base hits(30's) and few HR(15-20) I'm cool with him.

If Gaby Sanchez hits more than 8 home runs I will buy you an X-Box.

If it's a 360, you're on (based on 400 at bats).

If Gaby Sanchez hits more than 8 home runs I will buy you an X-Box.

 

Thank you, I always wanted one!

I remember G. Sanchez first MLB hit against the Nationals, that just missed hitting it out of the park by a feet. Then after that hit came another double and a single. Once he gets in the grove, you never know what he can end up doing.

 

Note- He has 43 XBH in Carolina, a portion of that will turn to HR's as he matures.

Very little maturing left to do. He also wont be facing 20 and 21 year old pitching as a 25 year old anymore.

My feeling is that Gaby Sanchez is the favorite to take 1B. And if he wins the spot, I think you'll see him as the main 1B with no platoon. But if he does have a terrible start, he'll probably be demoted in favor of McPherson as the new main 1B. I doubt you'll see anything crazy like Uggla being moved to 1B. Hammer being moved to 1B if both Sanchez (who'll be given a lot of rope IMHO) and McPherson fail is within the realm of possibility, but as a latch ditch maneuver.

Fredi's a moron if Gaby Sanchez isn't platooned. It's a position you have to get power out of and that is something Gaby Sanchez will not provide.

 

Traditionally you expect power from your first baseman. But we aren't a traditional team. Our biggest power hitters are at positions you traditionally expect better gloves than bats - short and second. We have more than enough power in our lineup as it stands to do without getting 30 homeruns from our first baseman.

I totally agree with you. Just let the Sanchez get some at bats, in my opinion he will demonstrate great power (20-25HR) even though we aren't going to be very dependable on him to hit homers like Jacobs because we will have Hanly, Uggla, Cantu and if Hammer stays healthy he could go back to the 20's HR like in 06-07. As long as Sanchez hits with avg.(.280-.300+) and gets decent extra base hits(30's) and few HR(15-20) I'm cool with him.

If Gaby Sanchez hits more than 8 home runs I will buy you an X-Box.

I will take that bet

 

But any platoon with either Gaby/Cantu at 1B or Cantu/ Dallas at 3b will be good

but most likly vs LHP it will be Gaby Cantu and vs RHP Cantu Dallas

 

But We probably won't be able to keep Hammer and i doubt he would be able to bounce back from his back injury so we should try to keep Uggs and trade Ole/Ani Gregg and Hammer

I will take that bet

 

But any platoon with either Gaby/Cantu at 1B or Cantu/ Dallas at 3b will be good

but most likly vs LHP it will be Gaby Cantu and vs RHP Cantu Dallas

 

But We probably won't be able to keep Hammer and i doubt he would be able to bounce back from his back injury so we should try to keep Uggs and trade Ole/Ani Gregg and Hammer

 

I don't think Cantu will be playing 3B next season, remember we have Helms. But then again, that's only my opinion.

I will take that bet

 

But any platoon with either Gaby/Cantu at 1B or Cantu/ Dallas at 3b will be good

but most likly vs LHP it will be Gaby Cantu and vs RHP Cantu Dallas

 

But We probably won't be able to keep Hammer and i doubt he would be able to bounce back from his back injury so we should try to keep Uggs and trade Ole/Ani Gregg and Hammer

 

I don't think Cantu will be playing 3B next season, remember we have Helms. But then again, that's only my opinion.

 

I don't think they intend for Helms to start many games..although I definitely don't like Cantu playing 3rd, way too many errors.

I will take that bet

 

But any platoon with either Gaby/Cantu at 1B or Cantu/ Dallas at 3b will be good

but most likly vs LHP it will be Gaby Cantu and vs RHP Cantu Dallas

 

But We probably won't be able to keep Hammer and i doubt he would be able to bounce back from his back injury so we should try to keep Uggs and trade Ole/Ani Gregg and Hammer

 

I don't think Cantu will be playing 3B next season, remember we have Helms. But then again, that's only my opinion.

 

I don't think they intend for Helms to start many games..although I definitely don't like Cantu playing 3rd, way too many errors.

 

Yeah I've got to agree with you. I don't think Helms is here to start, but rather to platoon and provide veteran influence. However, we never really know this team. :)

I will take that bet

 

But any platoon with either Gaby/Cantu at 1B or Cantu/ Dallas at 3b will be good

but most likly vs LHP it will be Gaby Cantu and vs RHP Cantu Dallas

 

But We probably won't be able to keep Hammer and i doubt he would be able to bounce back from his back injury so we should try to keep Uggs and trade Ole/Ani Gregg and Hammer

 

I don't think Cantu will be playing 3B next season, remember we have Helms. But then again, that's only my opinion.

 

I don't think they intend for Helms to start many games..although I definitely don't like Cantu playing 3rd, way too many errors.

 

If you only look at the final numbers on the season, I would agree. But I'm not, so I don't. I prefer to give Cantu a learning curve for last season. I think for a guy that only had 69 career starts at 3B, none since 2006, and only 4 appearances there in '07, he did a fine job learning the position. Especially seeing he only had 5 errors after the ASB. Of the 15 errors pre-ASB, I have to wonder how many could actually be tagged on Jake. Most of Cantu's errors in that time period were throwing, and I do remember some were way off the mark, but not all. I believe that if he is our starting 3B come April, he will be the 3B we saw post-ASB. And that ain't bad at all. It would also be pretty interesting to see how he and Hanley do error-wise with a decent glove at 1B, whoever that may be, and once they show some confidence in their team mate over there.

Why don't any of you see Cantu at second base? His offensive production is better than Uggla and his fielding numbers at that position while at Tampa Bay were comparable.

Why don't any of you see Cantu at second base? His offensive production is better than Uggla and his fielding numbers at that position while at Tampa Bay were comparable.

 

His offensive production is NOWHERE CLOSE to Dan Uggla's.

His offensive production is better than Uggla

 

What? How'd you come up with this one?

He's drinking buddies with Dayton Moore

Why don't any of you see Cantu at second base? His offensive production is better than Uggla and his fielding numbers at that position while at Tampa Bay were comparable.

Wrong on the first, wrong on the second.

Why don't any of you see Cantu at second base? His offensive production is better than Uggla and his fielding numbers at that position while at Tampa Bay were comparable.

 

 

What? Uggla destroys him offensively and defensively.

His offensive production is better than Uggla

 

What? How'd you come up with this one?

He's drinking buddies with Dayton Moore

lmao

And didn't Cantu beg off a move to 2nd at one point in the season as well. I don't think it's his favorite position.

And didn't Cantu beg off a move to 2nd at one point in the season as well. I don't think it's his favorite position.

He said earlier this year that he wasn't comfortable playing 2B when asked about playing there when Uggla was out with an injury.

Cantu is a horrible 2nd baseman, at least to put in day and day out. He can play the position in a pinch and only in a pinch. I agree with a platoon scenario with Sanchez. BTW in 550 abs Gabby Sanchez would hit between 18 to 20 homers

Cantu is a horrible 2nd baseman, at least to put in day and day out. He can play the position in a pinch and only in a pinch. I agree with a platoon scenario with Sanchez. BTW in 550 abs Gabby Sanchez would hit between 18 to 20 homers

His minor league average would put him in the 11-14 range in 550 at bats, but once again...he wont be facing competition that he is 2 to 3 years too old to face in the majors. I would he shocked to see him hit more than 8 getting every at bat.

Cantu is a horrible 2nd baseman, at least to put in day and day out. He can play the position in a pinch and only in a pinch. I agree with a platoon scenario with Sanchez. BTW in 550 abs Gabby Sanchez would hit between 18 to 20 homers

His minor league average would put him in the 11-14 range in 550 at bats, but once again...he wont be facing competition that he is 2 to 3 years too old to face in the majors. I would he shocked to see him hit more than 8 getting every at bat.

 

I think you're the minority on that.

 

And by minority, I mean you're the only one who believes it.

Cantu is a horrible 2nd baseman, at least to put in day and day out. He can play the position in a pinch and only in a pinch. I agree with a platoon scenario with Sanchez. BTW in 550 abs Gabby Sanchez would hit between 18 to 20 homers

His minor league average would put him in the 11-14 range in 550 at bats, but once again...he wont be facing competition that he is 2 to 3 years too old to face in the majors. I would he shocked to see him hit more than 8 getting every at bat.

 

I think you're the minority on that.

 

And by minority, I mean you're the only one who believes it.

I predict 15-20 HR and .280-.300 AVG.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.