Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The Pudge Rodriguez Market

Featured Replies

This was post on mlbtraderumors. What u all think?

 

Ivan Rodriguez is past his prime by about a decade, but still he caught over 100 games last year and put up an OPS of .713. Let's take a look at the possible suitors for Pudge and the teams that have said they won't pursue him:

 

  • Astros GM Ed Wade said earlier in the week that he doesn't intend to sign Pudge, regardless of Toby Hall's shoulder.
  • The Mets don't appear to be interested either.
  • On Sunday, Pudge said he wants to sign with the Astros, Mets or Marlins. The first two teams don't seem interested, so could the Marlins offer him a minor league deal? Currently their catchers are John Baker and Mike Rabelo.
  • DRaysBay suggests the Rays could use Rodriguez to back up Dioner Navarro.
  • This is pure speculation on my part, but the A's, whose current backup is Rob Bowen, have been willing to give veterans second chances before. Mike Piazza, Frank Thomas (twice) and now Nomar Garciaparra have all attracted Billy Beane's attention, so why not Rodriguez?

Lots of teams could use catching depth; which one's the best fit for Pudge?

[*]On Sunday, Pudge said he wants to sign with the Astros, Mets or Marlins. The first two teams don't seem interested, so could the Marlins offer him a minor league deal? Currently their catchers are John Baker and Mike Rabelo.

the problem with this is the marlins said they werent' interested either, so.... no

  • Author

[*]On Sunday, Pudge said he wants to sign with the Astros, Mets or Marlins. The first two teams don't seem interested, so could the Marlins offer him a minor league deal? Currently their catchers are John Baker and Mike Rabelo.

the problem with this is the marlins said they werent' interested either, so.... no

 

I think they just want to see his value drop more so they can do an offer even though they have say the only way this could be possible is if he agrees on the league's minimun, which I think its gonna happen if he sticks on the free agency 4 more longer.

I think the market for Pudge is non existent . As Marlins fans we have become accustomed to a limited payroll and the notion that 1 million dollars is alot to pay for a back up player , for every other team this is not a consideration . if another team wanted Pudge they would have already signed him . Right now I suspect Pudge would jump at the first offer he gets .

for every other team this is not a consideration . if another team wanted Pudge they would have already signed him

 

Any year prior to this year that was no doubt true. The economic uncertainty all owners now face has probably caused everyone to pull in their horns to some (varying by team) extent. The overall net effect has been to make Pudge a much, much less valuable commodity. Which probably increases the odds of us picking him up for peanuts, since we're on his short list.

If the Marlins wanted Pudge, they would make an offer already. Its almost March. At this point it really doesn't make too much sense to wait any longer.

i cant believe this is happening to a future hall of famer

 

 

A completely reasonable thought in normal times.

 

Now, look at it as an owner in 2009. Dicey season-ticket sales. Unknown day-of-game sales. Both likely down. Maybe sharply. (Then there's Loria, who Huizenga treats like he's Bubba's prison roomie when it comes to ancillary revenues.)

 

All networks' advertising revenue is sucking wind big-time. Long-term, future network contracts are in doubt as far as level of revenue. Revenue sharing could even be in doubt if George starts bitching.

 

Present looks like crap. Future doesn't look much different, maybe worse. How much are you going to offer for an over-the-hill catcher?

 

From Pudge's standpoint, he's made a ton of money, and assuming he hasn't blown all of it, he's set for life. He wants to play, it's his life. He's probably shocked that he's worth so little, but prices are set at the margin and he has little value in this environment.

 

It makes some degree of sense for him to accept a very minimal deal where he can mentor both a great young pitching staff and their catcher, play where he lives and play where he won before.

 

We can hope.

i cant believe this is happening to a future hall of famer

 

 

A completely reasonable thought in normal times.

 

Now, look at it as an owner in 2009. Dicey season-ticket sales. Unknown day-of-game sales. Both likely down. Maybe sharply. (Then there's Loria, who Huizenga treats like he's Bubba's prison roomie when it comes to ancillary revenues.)

 

All networks' advertising revenue is sucking wind big-time. Long-term, future network contracts are in doubt as far as level of revenue. Revenue sharing could even be in doubt if George starts bitching.

 

Present looks like crap. Future doesn't look much different, maybe worse. How much are you going to offer for an over-the-hill catcher?

 

From Pudge's standpoint, he's made a ton of money, and assuming he hasn't blown all of it, he's set for life. He wants to play, it's his life. He's probably shocked that he's worth so little, but prices are set at the margin and he has little value in this environment.

 

It makes some degree of sense for him to accept a very minimal deal where he can mentor both a great young pitching staff and their catcher, play where he lives and play where he won before.

 

We can hope.

 

thats a good post.

Judging by how long this is taking, and by comments written in todays Herald, I feel that Pudge potentially being a Marlin depends more on Mike Rabelo than anything else. If Rabelo can be the healthy and "solid if unspectacular" backstop that the Marlins expected him to be when they got him from Detroit, then the Marlins feel they don't need Pudge at all. If Rabelo completely falters early in the spring, the Fish will give up on him and pounce on Pudge as a last minute option.

 

So basically I feel the Fish are waiting on Rabelo's performance before committing to Pudge.

 

Kinda sad actually...but thats that

rabelo/pudge

rabelo/pudge

rabelo/pudge

 

hmm doesnt take me long to decide who i rather have.

 

Have rabelo as a 3rd option in the Minors (injuries happen people)

 

And this is coming from some one who likes rabelo.

Astros might be even more interested

 

Astros Void Hall's Contract

By Alex Walsh [February 22 at 10:12am CST]

Jose de Jesus Ortiz of the Houston Chronicle reports the Houston Astros will void the minor league contract of Toby Hall.

 

Hall's shoulder requires surgery, which will keep him out of the game for nearly four months. The Astros had expected Hall to recover from his injury via rehab over a timeframe closer to one month.

 

Presumably, Hall will re-enter the market once his health is firmly established. It's not a stretch to suggest some competitive team might need catching help in the middle of the 2009 season, so Hall may find a job yet.

 

As for the Astros, their catcher competition going forward consists of a battle for two spots between Humberto Quintero, J.R. Towles, and Rule 5 pick Lou Palmisano.

rabelo/pudge

rabelo/pudge

rabelo/pudge

 

hmm doesnt take me long to decide who i rather have.

 

Have rabelo as a 3rd option in the Minors (injuries happen people)

 

And this is coming from some one who likes rabelo.

 

Never knew such a species existed....

i cant believe this is happening to a future hall of famer.

Frank Thomas can't get a job either....

I've gotta think that if he signs anywhere for the minimum, it will be here. He could easily be our everyday catcher by showing he's even just 70% of what he once was. Most other teams either have a better option, or an option they are hoping to groom.

 

But if he's going to play for the minimum, there's no point in signing until he absolutely needs to. That offer will always be on the table.

 

Plus, there's always the chance that he only wants to play b/c he sees this as his last chance to make a few extra million. In that case, he may just wait until spring training to see if someone's catcher gets hurt.

I just want to add this comment..Can Pudge still play? Well the Puerto Rico team on it's roster has Yadi Molina and Geovany Soto, oh and Pudge, It was reported today in El Nuevo Dia the major newspaper in the country, that Pudge will be starting as catcher. Not so washedup I guess!

Pudge isn't close to the player he once was and the fact that Pudge is starting over Molina and Soto suggests their manager is quite silly.

Pudge isn't close to the player he once was and the fact that Pudge is starting over Molina and Soto suggests their manager is quite silly.

 

Agreed. Sounds like a sentimental pick - he shouldn't be starting over those two IMO.

FWIW, impressive trio of catchers for Puerto Rico.

I just want to add this comment..Can Pudge still play? Well the Puerto Rico team on it's roster has Yadi Molina and Geovany Soto, oh and Pudge, It was reported today in El Nuevo Dia the major newspaper in the country, that Pudge will be starting as catcher. Not so washedup I guess!

He's got that spot on name recognition alone.

It is much more than that Rabb Pudge had a strong Winter League performance with the bat and behind the plate. He was in great shape. He may not be quite the same but the looked like his tank is far from E

It is much more than that Rabb Pudge had a strong Winter League performance with the bat and behind the plate. He was in great shape. He may not be quite the same but the looked like his tank is far from E

It looked like that... in Puerto Rico. Hardly the bigs. Hell, hardly the minors.

It is much more than that Rabb Pudge had a strong Winter League performance with the bat and behind the plate. He was in great shape. He may not be quite the same but the looked like his tank is far from E

 

Why would a strong Winter League be more important that the regular season in the Majors? Pudge should be third on the depth chart for his WBC team.

It is much more than that Rabb Pudge had a strong Winter League performance with the bat and behind the plate. He was in great shape. He may not be quite the same but the looked like his tank is far from E

 

Why would a strong Winter League be more important that the regular season in the Majors? Pudge should be third on the depth chart for his WBC team.

 

It's not but its a glymps of why kind of condition Pudge is in right now. His bat hasnt slowed down and defensively he was exceptional. It may not hold for 150 games but he can still play a hell of a game

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.