February 3, 20188 yr dude give me a fucking break. You'd feel the same way in his shoes. No established player wants to waste years of their prime on this team for the next few years. Established player? The guy is just now entering his 4th season and thinks he's entitled to be on a championship team. No I would not feel the same way in his shoes. If I was in his shoes making millions to play baseball before only my 4th season I'd man up and live with a losing season or two knowing that I have the potential to be the veteran leader of a winning team in a few seasons. He could have been our Yadier Molina here down the line and that's not a joke or an exaggeration. Lastly, and I know I repeated this multiple times when talking about Yelich but far greater players have "manned up" and played on bad teams for years upon years. If Tony Gwynn, Ken Griffey Jr, Ichiro, Andre Dawson, Ernie Banks, Don Mattingly and others could play the majority of their careers on losing teams then JT Realmuto should have no problem doing the same thing.
February 3, 20188 yr Established player? The guy is just now entering his 4th season and thinks he's entitled to be on a championship team. No I would not feel the same way in his shoes. If I was in his shoes making millions to play baseball before only my 4th season I'd man up and live with a losing season or two knowing that I have the potential to be the veteran leader of a winning team in a few seasons. He could have been our Yadier Molina here down the line and that's not a joke or an exaggeration. Lastly, and I know I repeated this multiple times when talking about Yelich but far greater players have "manned up" and played on bad teams for years upon years. If Tony Gwynn, Ken Griffey Jr, Ichiro, Andre Dawson, Ernie Banks, Don Mattingly and others could play the majority of their careers on losing teams then JT Realmuto should have no problem doing the same thing. the guy is a top 5 catcher in the league. If you were in his shoes, you would feel the way youre relaying for a year or 2, not 4-5 years into your career. once youve established yourself as one of the top players at your position through 2-3 years of premier production and through 10-15 years of hard ass work to get you to where you are, you would not just be happy to be there. to say so is just to be saying so through your current position as a non major leaguer. He could have been our yadier molina? give me a fucking break. The cardinals lost the NLCS in his first year and won the fucking world series in his second year as a full time catcher, on top of having a proven front office who knows what theyre doing and has built in trust. In no way unless JT was to give unearned trust was he going to become our Yadier fucking Molina. Just because other players have sacrificed years of hard work and great production on terrible teams doesnt mean JT shouldnt use his power to exact as much pressure on the marlins to trade him.
February 3, 20188 yr Yadier Molina = centerpiece veteran leader from the catching position on a consistently competitive team. Realmuto had a chance to be that for the Marlins.
February 3, 20188 yr Yadier Molina = centerpiece veteran leader from the catching position on a consistently competitive team. Realmuto had a chance to be that for the Marlins. minus the consistently competitive part. Again, yadier was on an NLCS team his first full year and a WS winning team the second year. JT had no chance to become that for the marlins. it is beyond an absurd comparison for so many reasons.
February 3, 20188 yr You'd feel the same way in his shoes. No established player wants to waste years of their prime on this team for the next few years. Yep. Getting out is like a jailbreak at this point, for a crime you did not commit.
February 3, 20188 yr Marlins gave him a chance in the first place, ungrateful is the right word. He doesn't owe the Marlins anything. They just happened to draft him. He would have gotten his chance with any other team. Plus, the one's that "gave him a chance" to begin with are no longer here. It sure as fuck wasn't Jeter.
February 3, 20188 yr Established player? The guy is just now entering his 4th season and thinks he's entitled to be on a championship team. No I would not feel the same way in his shoes. If I was in his shoes making millions to play baseball before only my 4th season I'd man up and live with a losing season or two knowing that I have the potential to be the veteran leader of a winning team in a few seasons. He could have been our Yadier Molina here down the line and that's not a joke or an exaggeration. Lastly, and I know I repeated this multiple times when talking about Yelich but far greater players have "manned up" and played on bad teams for years upon years. If Tony Gwynn, Ken Griffey Jr, Ichiro, Andre Dawson, Ernie Banks, Don Mattingly and others could play the majority of their careers on losing teams then JT Realmuto should have no problem doing the same thing. Except that the Marlins are tanking it for the next few seasons. They aren't going to try to win. It might be for a good reason but that has to be demoralizing for a good player. He is going to put forth his best effort but the FO isn't? In this case I think he has a right to be upset and to want to leave. Also, there is no guarantee that we are going to be a winning team in 3 or 4 years. Just because you blow the whole thing up and start over doesn't mean that everything is going to go right. If it were that easy every mediocre team would blow it up and be a contender in 3 years. Astros and Cubs aren't going to be the norm. I've accepted the fact that this is the route that the FO has taken and I will be supportive because I love the Marlins. However, I also realize that there is no guarantee that this will work or work that fast. I'm wishing for the best but tempering my expectations.
February 3, 20188 yr minus the consistently competitive part. Again, yadier was on an NLCS team his first full year and a WS winning team the second year. JT had no chance to become that for the marlins. it is beyond an absurd comparison for so many reasons. Did you miss the whole thing about Jeter trying to build a sustainable winner here? Assuming the rebuild works, this team is, at least in theory, supposed to become consistently competitive. You know that. I don't see how it's an absurd comparison at all based on what I've said. You keep adding unnecessary details into my comparison.
February 3, 20188 yr I think it reflects badly on a player and is potentially bad for baseball if someone with only three full seasons under his belt can spout off (through his agent) about wanting to be traded with impunity. Not every single young player can be on a team "competing for a championship" especially when you consider that MLB's draft is constructed in a way to promote some semblance of parity around the league. Also because the firesale model has in various iterations become more commonplace around the league to get floundering teams back on track. Obviously not all franchises can spend their way into contention like the Yankees or Dodgers do. While I'm certainly disgusted with how Loria ran things and how the new Jeter regime sale and transition went down, I'm equally disgusted with how Yelich, Realmuto, Ozuna, Stanton, and Gordon have carried themselves in the face of what certainly seems like a necessary financial move to correct the lingering financial problems left over from Loria. If I were the commissioner, I'd be annoyed at all of those guys, but Realmuto's relative lack of experience really makes him stick out. Exactly this. fish20 has made me side with penguino. Fuck.
February 3, 20188 yr How long till we see the top 3-5 picks in every draft requesting to be traded to a championship team as soon as they sign? This is a slippery slope
February 3, 20188 yr Did you miss the whole thing about Jeter trying to build a sustainable winner here? Assuming the rebuild works, this team is, at least in theory, supposed to become consistently competitive. You know that. I don't see how it's an absurd comparison at all based on what I've said. You keep adding unnecessary details into my comparison. how is it not an absurd comparison? Yadier molina's first years in STL included an NLCS run and then a WS title. IT is a completely absurd and beyond ridiculous comparison. there is literally nothing comparable of the situations beyond the fact that its 2 catchers. Literally nothing. one is trying to convince prospects they are acuiring that they are a sustainable winner, the other was a legitimate sustainable winner.
February 3, 20188 yr Except that the Marlins are tanking it for the next few seasons. They aren't going to try to win. It might be for a good reason but that has to be demoralizing for a good player. He is going to put forth his best effort but the FO isn't? In this case I think he has a right to be upset and to want to leave. Also, there is no guarantee that we are going to be a winning team in 3 or 4 years. Just because you blow the whole thing up and start over doesn't mean that everything is going to go right. If it were that easy every mediocre team would blow it up and be a contender in 3 years. Astros and Cubs aren't going to be the norm. I've accepted the fact that this is the route that the FO has taken and I will be supportive because I love the Marlins. However, I also realize that there is no guarantee that this will work or work that fast. I'm wishing for the best but tempering my expectations. This is an odd way of looking at it. Who says the front office isn't putting forward their best effort to build a winner? They're arguably trying harder by tanking for a couple of seasons than by doing what Loria did and half ass trying to compete year after year by adding mediocre pieces to the same shit team year after year.
February 3, 20188 yr Exactly this. fish20 has made me side with penguino. Fuck. I would agree with both you and penguino if it weren't for the fact that the Marlins don't care about winning right now. They are tanking it and although it might be for the greater good, Realmuto doesn't have to see it that way.
February 3, 20188 yr I would agree with both you and penguino if it weren't for the fact that the Marlins don't care about winning right now. They are tanking it and although it might be for the greater good, Realmuto doesn't have to see it that way. exactly, im not blaming the marlins, but to blame realmuto for wanting the fuck out of this nonsense is absurd.
February 3, 20188 yr how is it not an absurd comparison? Yadier molina's first years in STL included an NLCS run and then a WS title. IT is a completely absurd and beyond ridiculous comparison. there is literally nothing comparable of the situations beyond the fact that its 2 catchers. Literally nothing. I don't care in what year the Cardinals won anything with Molina. This is not about specific team records per year. You are the one who keeps bringing that up, not me. Valid comparisons can be made without specfic details matching up. Again, all I said is that Yadier Molina has been a centerpiece veteran leader at the catching position on a consistently competitive team and that, assuming the Jeter rebuild works, if Realmuto were to stay here he could become a centerpiece veteran leader at the catching position on a consistently competitive Marlins team. I have no clue how that above paragraph is difficult to understand.
February 3, 20188 yr This is an odd way of looking at it. Who says the front office isn't putting forward their best effort to build a winner? They're arguably trying harder by tanking for a couple of seasons than by doing what Loria did and half ass trying to compete year after year by adding mediocre pieces to the same shit team year after year. I didn't say the weren't trying to build a winner. All I am saying is that they aren't trying to win the next couple of seasons. There's a difference. Yes, part of building that winner is to tank it for 2 years, but that really isn't Realmuto's problem. He wants a franchise that at least wants to try and win now. Again, I've accepted the fact that we are rebuilding and I am wishing for the best but I don't blame J T one bit.
February 3, 20188 yr This is what bothers me about the Realmuto comments. I know the Marlins have a history of firesales and all, but Realmuto wasn't around for any of those before this one. The White Sox haven't fielded competitive teams for the last 5 seasons. Does that mean that their young club controlled players should start whining about being traded to contenders? This stuff reflects poorly on the game of baseball. It's also interesting because I think we are on the verge of some kind of market correction in MLB. I think the reluctance to sign these top free agents this offseason is some kind of indication that teams are wising up how constricting it can be to have to pay a guy $28 million/season when he's 36. I don't know how exactly things will play out, but I think teams are becoming more reluctant to sign the Darvish and Martinez types to excessively bloated contracts. I'm hoping there is some kind of bubble bursting, because even Stanton doesn't seem worth the $300 million plus contract he was issued. I agree that there seems to be a market correction by the owners. It could also be why the Marlins didn't get as much back in these trades as we would have wished for. Teams are holding on to the young prospects tighter than ever.
February 3, 20188 yr I don't care in what year the Cardinals won anything with Molina. This is not about specific team records per year. You are the one who keeps bringing that up, not me. Valid comparisons can be made without specfic details matching up. Again, all I said is that Yadier Molina has been a centerpiece veteran leader at the catching position on a consistently competitive team and that, assuming the Jeter rebuild works, if Realmuto were to stay here he could become a centerpiece veteran leader at the catching position on a consistently competitive Marlins team. I have no clue how that above paragraph is difficult to understand. the difference is yadier molina came up to a consistently competitive team. Realmuto came up early to a team that has been terrible both on and off the field and is now looking in the face of a team who is going to lose close to 100 games each of the next 2-3 years. If you have no clue how that's a different situation, thats your problem. the situations are absolutel 100% completely not alike in the slightest aside from the fact that both guys play catcher.
February 3, 20188 yr the difference is yadier molina came up to a consistently competitive team. Realmuto came up early to a team that has been terrible both on and off the field and is now looking in the face of a team who is going to lose close to 100 games each of the next 2-3 years. If you have no clue how that's a different situation, thats your problem. the situations are absolutel 100% completely not alike in the slightest aside from the fact that both guys play catcher. You continue to bring up unimportant details. It doesn't matter how either guy came up. Realmuto can end up like Molina as the leader on his team. This whole thing between you and me is like if I was saying "apples are oranges are both fruits" and your response is "apples are red and oranges are orange so they're not comparable." Unimportant details that are irrelevant to my point. I'm done.
February 3, 20188 yr Also, if the Marlins aren't contenders by 2020, Realmuto would be on the verge of free agency and in the middle of his prime. At that point he would be free to sign with the contender of his choosing. What do you mean IF ? They have zero chance of reaching last year's win total by 2020, much less contenders. Zero. Did you just chug a glass of the Captain's Koolaid ?
February 3, 20188 yr What do you mean IF ? They have zero chance of reaching last year's win total by 2020, much less contenders. Zero. Did you just chug a glass of the Captain's Koolaid ? I hate Jeter and I despise trading the NL MVP but I don’t think it’s a stretch at all to say the Marlins can be a .500 ballclub in 2020.
February 3, 20188 yr What do you mean IF ? They have zero chance of reaching last year's win total by 2020, much less contenders. Zero. Did you just chug a glass of the Captain's Koolaid ? Oh geez. Zero chance? You don't understand how a rebuild works do you?
February 3, 20188 yr Author Fuck this entitled bullshit. I don't even want this guy on the team anymore
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.