Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Realmuto Trade Rumors

Featured Replies

I agree with you on the motivation/appeal of trading for someone like Straily, I just don’t understand why it was Castillo. Castillo was not only also capable and controllable but also ready to go. It’s not like he was years out, and his projections were great so it’s not like his success was something no one saw coming. I think loria knew he was selling so he told hill to pawn every single guy for whatever he could to try their best to win now, regardless of how it handicapped the team later. 

 

Oh yeah I agree with you about Castillo but my take on that has always been that at the time there was almost no one of any value in our farm and if we were gonna get anyone here via trade it had to be by trading Castillo. That's always been the feeling I've gotten especially since they basically traded Castillo twice. It's like if he was an expiring gift card that needed to be used immediately. 

 

 

Overall you're right but the Straily trade was not awful even if we gave up Castillo. A young guy who can be a capable starter with years of club control. Maybe the timing wasn't the best but I'll make that trade again.

 

We can argue if it was bad or awful, but regardless it was another example of a poor transaction by the marlins that set us back. 

 

His last season with cincy was legitimately his only solid year in his career. We overpaid for a guy whose ceiling was that of an average pitcher with a limited track record. 

 

I’ve just never understood the move from any angle. 

 

 

Overall you're right but the Straily trade was not awful even if we gave up Castillo. A young guy who can be a capable starter with years of club control. Maybe the timing wasn't the best but I'll make that trade again.

 

I don't think teams would be interest in the other Luis Castillo he's been retired and out of shape

 

 

Really !?

Meh, they have to say that for negotiation purposes. Some teams even go as far as signing a player who is supposedly “replacing” the player they were trying to trade for to increase their bargaining position. 

 

 

What do you expect him to say?

 

Honestly just depends on the GM and the team policies. There are GM's out there that are more open about saying what is going on with negotiations. I'm calling the bluff as well though.

 

 

If we got Robles or Soto for JT,we win.

 

If we keep JT because those two were unavailable,we win.

 

If we trade JT but didn't got at least one of those two,we lose.

 

because they believe JT would be a "good soldier",so I don't think they would be forced to trade JT…

 

 

If we got Robles or Soto for JT,we win.

 

If we keep JT because those two were unavailable,we win.

 

If we trade JT but didn't got at least one of those two,we lose.

 

because they believe JT would be a "good soldier",so I don't think they would be forced to trade JT…

 

when did JT enlisted in the Army?

 

 

  • Author

If we can't get exactly what we want for JT, let's just keep him and build around him. If we sign him to an extension that includes 2-3 FA years, we'll have him under contract through this rebuild and beyond.

 

A good catcher means consistency for a developing pitching staff. There's something to be said for having consistency in that position

 

 

If we can't get exactly what we want for JT, let's just keep him and build around him. If we sign him to an extension that includes 2-3 FA years, we'll have him under contract through this rebuild and beyond.

 

A good catcher means consistency for a developing pitching staff. There's something to be said for having consistency in that position

 

My feelings exactly. At this point I'd say only trade him for a package headlined by a clear "can't miss"  #1 starting pitching prospect. Otherwise, why trade an eventual 4-5 WAR catcher in the hopes of getting a 4-5 WAR outfielder to inevitably replace him with a catcher playing below replacement level. That's a stupid gamble in my opinion considering how hard catchers are to come by, and contributing outfielders are available every offseason. 

 

 

If we can't get exactly what we want for JT, let's just keep him and build around him. If we sign him to an extension that includes 2-3 FA years, we'll have him under contract through this rebuild and beyond.

 

A good catcher means consistency for a developing pitching staff. There's something to be said for having consistency in that position

 

thats the big if.  No one wants to trade him if he is willing to sign an extension.  the entire issue is that he very likely wont at this point, and you dont want to take the risk of figuring this out later and losing value in a trade for him or in the worst case scenario losing him in free agency for nothing.

 

 

Really !?

 

Does this upset you? You want JT traded after spending the offseason saying you were gone if they traded one person? Now after trading the four top players you're still here and upset that they might not trade JT? 

 

 

Realmuto may not sign an extension right now but if he sticks around and the young guys prove something in 2018 it's not out of the question that JT would sign an extension around 2019 or 2020 to officially become the veteran leader of this team. There's actually a huge opportunity potentially in place for JT here that he may not even realize yet. 

 

 

Realmuto may not sign an extension right now but if he sticks around and the young guys prove something in 2018 it's not out of the question that JT would sign an extension around 2019 or 2020 to officially become the veteran leader of this team. There's actually a huge opportunity potentially in place for JT here that he may not even realize yet. 

 

I still think 5/$55 gets it done (probably lower). He just has to have the right attitude to want to be here as the money would make his agent give four thumbs up.

 

 

JT has to be a good soldier because if he sulks he won't get a better arbitration tender next year. The one silver lining to not buying him out, complete motivation to make it.

 

 

I remember Stanton being 'upset' with the future of the Marlins and the tight purse strings, but he saw Loria open up the checkbook and progress with young developing guys like himself and he signed. Realmuto just lost several friends and teammates, if he wants to be upset, I get it. But like others have mentioned, getting a legit franchise catcher is very difficult. And having a guy entering his prime being the face of your franchise like Buster Posey has been for the Giants and mentoring/assisting your young pitchers is a very good thing to have.

 

I'm sure his mood and attitude toward the team will change by year end when some of our promising prospects start getting called up and he builds relationships with these guys. But if someone wants to unload top prospects on us, so be it.

 

 

First time I can say I have been 100 percent in agreement with you. I like this version of you.

 

 

 

source.gif&key=07cc5f3e1cca870a90b79146a8fc3c35a3d381c26b57eda0c4c7a648d4d06c43

 

 

I still think 5/$55 gets it done (probably lower). He just has to have the right attitude to want to be here as the money would make his agent give four thumbs up.

 

Do you really believe there is a chance in hell, that he would sign a contract to stay here any longer than he has to ?

 

I don't.

 

 

Ungrateful. 

 

dude give me a fucking break.  You'd feel the same way in his shoes.  No established player wants to waste years of their prime on this team for the next few years.

 

 

Marlins gave him a chance in the first place, ungrateful is the right word.

 

what chance did the marlins give him?  being drafted?  he would have been drafted not soon after the marlins did if the marlins didnt draft him.  He's a professional athlete who has put years and his body towards a goal, and at the peak of that goal the team you are on has essentially admitted they are working for a goal 4 years from now.  I dont blame the marlins for making the smart baseball business decisions, but i will never blame a player in his prime doing everything possible to not waste everything theyve worked for to waste their best production on a team that has 0 intention of contending for the next 3 years.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.