Apparently he's too busy in the Las Vegas to answer you.

 

Well at least someone was busy there.

 

 

Some people haven't given up on him yet including me. 

 

I definitely haven’t given up on Brinson either. 

 

He gets all of 2019 to prove his worth.  

 

And they better not bat him 8th. 

 

 

You rang? Hell no I haven't given up on Brinson. Count me in. 

 

 

Excellent piece from Sherman breaking down in pretty simple terms why Realmuto is so good and has so much value and why the Marlins are right to ask for so much for him. This was pretty much written for New Yorkers who are wondering why the Mets are entertaining the Marlins high price tag but it's a solid read for anyone here as well. 

 

https://t.co/UKRESUmKbb

 

 

Excellent piece from Sherman breaking down in pretty simple terms why Realmuto is so good and has so much value and why the Marlins are right to ask for so much for him. This was pretty much written for New Yorkers who are wondering why the Mets are entertaining the Marlins high price tag but it's a solid read for anyone here as well. 

 

https://t.co/UKRESUmKbb

 

Damn it, now I really don't want them to get rid of him...

 

 

Which one would you prefer to have ?

 

A. Trade JT for the package that not the best.

 

B. Keep him for the next two seasons then lose him for nothing, but this team made it to the playoffs for at least one time in these two seasons.

 

 

I’d rather keep Realmuto than get plundered again ala Yelich. I can easily see him go 30/100/300 once he gets away from Marlins Park. Rosario et al does nothing to excite me. Put up a Miguel Rojas year in 2017. Whippee.

 

 

Excellent piece from Sherman breaking down in pretty simple terms why Realmuto is so good and has so much value and why the Marlins are right to ask for so much for him. This was pretty much written for New Yorkers who are wondering why the Mets are entertaining the Marlins high price tag but it's a solid read for anyone here as well. 

 

https://t.co/UKRESUmKbb

 

Ok, I agree to give him 5/100 now, anybody else ?

 

 

Damn it, now I really don't want them to get rid of him...

 

 

 

Ok, I agree to give him 5/100 now, anybody else ?

 

Except he doesn't wanna be here. 

 

How great he is works to our advantage as far as trade value but it doesn't change the fact that he wants out of Miami. 

 

 

 

Except he doesn't wanna be here. 

 

How great he is works to our advantage as far as trade value but it doesn't change the fact that he wants out of Miami. 

 

I think nobody knows what Jeter wants to do now, trade him this off-season or try to sign him again next off-season ?

 

 

Which one would you prefer to have ?

 

A. Trade JT for the package that not the best.

 

B. Keep him for the next two seasons then lose him for nothing, but this team made it to the playoffs for at least one time in these two seasons.

 

Playoffs

 

 

Do not take a shit package back on JT. It would be an awful mistake. He does NOT have to be traded right now. If the offers are shit, wait until July or even next off-season. That extra year of control is negated if you take shit back anyway.

 

 

I’d rather keep Realmuto than get plundered again ala Yelich. I can easily see him go 30/100/300 once he gets away from Marlins Park. Rosario et al does nothing to excite me. Put up a Miguel Rojas year in 2017. Whippee.

 

Rosario was 22 last year (1.5 WAR) and better than a 29 year old Rojas (1).

 

Rojas is an excellent bench player, Rosario has major breakout potential and could become something like Didi/Segura real quick. Marlins would be lucky to get him in a package. He'd be the best player in the Marlins organization IMO.

 

 

Ok, I agree to give him 5/100 now, anybody else ?

 

No, too much. 5/$80, maybe $85.

 

 

Crasnick throws the Brewers into the mix...

 

[MEDIA=twitter]1073619309665181697[/MEDIA]

 

 

 

Alright, they can send that Yelich kid back. Has several years of control and is affordable.

 

 

Alright, they can send that Yelich kid back. Has several years of control and is affordable.

 

Imagine if we kept Brinson and Yelich together in the outfield that would actually be cool.

 

 

I believe the story development of Realmuto was as below,

 

a. He was open-minded for the extension before we made the first offer.

 

b. We lowballing him in the first two extension contract offer.

 

c. He felt disrespected from this team and decided not to continue to talk.

 

d. His agent said publicly that JT won't sign extension contract with Marlins.

 

 

I believe the story development of Realmuto was as below,

 

a. He was open-minded for the extension before we made the first offer.

 

b. We lowballing him in the first two extension contract offer.

 

c. He felt disrespected from this team and decided not to continue to talk.

 

d. His agent said publicly that JT won't sign extension contract with Marlins.

 

Did I completely miss the first two offers, or are you just assuming they were made?  I don't remember them.

 

 

Did I completely miss the first two offers, or are you just assuming they were made?  I don't remember them.

 

[MEDIA=twitter]1069694363536642050[/MEDIA]

 

This, and you're really completely missed it.

 

 

7 hours ago, taiwanmarlin said:

 

[MEDIA=twitter]1069694363536642050[/MEDIA]

if those were indeed the offers, then yeah, they're pretty insulting. I would love to have known the counteroffer by his side because that at least means his mind wasn't "f*ck this team" at that point.

 

 

Realmuto is coming off a career year. This offer was made just before the all star break.  He had a great first HALF.  So the team probably put together the offer during that period of time.  When you consider that it isn’t as insulting as it seems now with the benefit of hindsight that he put together a great full season.  It’s certainly low and yes the team could easily up their offer.  But I don’t think this is a double barrel middle finger by the marlins like some are making it out to be 

 

 

if those were indeed the offers, then yeah, they're pretty insulting. I would love to have known the counteroffer by his side because that at least means his mind wasn't "f*ck this team" at that point.

 

I thought we already know his counteroffer, he asked for Buster Posey money aka 8/167

 

 

I thought we already know his counteroffer, he asked for Buster Posey money aka 8/167

 

That’s the rumor.  Was that a Mish report ?

 

 

That’s the rumor.  Was that a Mish report ?

 

I consider the numbers from both sides to be rumors anyway and I don't think either should be completely believed. Both were likely leaked by the opposing side and fudged a bit. Not sure who reported that one.