Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins listening on everyone except Sandy

Featured Replies

6 hours ago, Rydawg said:

Hypothetical question!  How would you all feel about trading Pablo to the Dodgers for Bellinger and some good prospects?  Too risky?  Maybe he bounces back to form?  I mean, he's really talented and plays CF.  Even prospects in AA and AAA are risky.   Just a thought. 

Bellinger has gotten worse for three straight seasons now. I wouldn't want him.

If the Marlins trade Pablo, it's likely we'll have below average pitching next year.

The answer never was to trade from pitching "depth". They need to sign hitters.

 

21 minutes ago, Entendu said:

If the Marlins trade Pablo, it's likely we'll have below average pitching next year.

The answer never was to trade from pitching "depth". They need to sign hitters.

 

Ng - I did sign hitters. I don't get it?

I'm going to hold out hope that Ng will get something good for Pablo. She did make a good trade to get Jesus Lizard for a 1/3 of a season of Marte. She's deliberate af so that may finally bode well in terms of max value on Pablo. That may also mean we just keep him in the end as well which is also semi-ok. 

1 hour ago, Entendu said:

If the Marlins trade Pablo, it's likely we'll have below average pitching next year.

The answer never was to trade from pitching "depth". They need to sign hitters.

 

This is what I think, as well. Most of the fanbase disagrees for some reason.

I don’t see us getting a major league proven hitter for Pablo so I don’t see the point.

Best I can see happening is Seattle trading us a guy like Kelenic who has nothing to prove in AAA and basically just needs to prove he can hit in the big leagues, but that would require us to develop a big league hitter…

14 minutes ago, Erick said:

This is what I think, as well. Most of the fanbase disagrees for some reason.

I don’t see us getting a major league proven hitter for Pablo so I don’t see the point.

Best I can see happening is Seattle trading us a guy like Kelenic who has nothing to prove in AAA and basically just needs to prove he can hit in the big leagues, but that would require us to develop a big league hitter…

Young pitching is very fickle. Honestly, are we really even happy with our staff right now outside of Pablo and Sandy? As we've seen, pitchers can take steps back (Rogers, Hernandez), or get injured (Sixto, Meyer, Luzardo). I just don't see how we are a good club unless we spend on two premium proven bats.

I'm talking Judge and Correa-type signings. Not going to happen, but this is the reality if we want to win next year.

If we are OK mailing next year in, then maybe you can trade Pablo, but it has to be a great trade. You also at some point need to learn how to develop hitters. This is unsustainable.

This team's strengths are hanging on by scotch tape, and its weaknesses have no solution in sight. It's a shittier position than it seems.

19 minutes ago, Erick said:

This is what I think, as well. Most of the fanbase disagrees for some reason.

I don’t see us getting a major league proven hitter for Pablo so I don’t see the point.

Best I can see happening is Seattle trading us a guy like Kelenic who has nothing to prove in AAA and basically just needs to prove he can hit in the big leagues, but that would require us to develop a big league hitter…

You're correct that no playoff team (who would be asking for Pablo) would give us back a proven MLB hitter. You are going to get a prospect(s) back and that's what you should target for him. But don't trade him for some dude already 25 and still in the minors (Brinson). You need to aim for a guy in his early 20s who is already showing a plus bat and preferably in at least aa/AAA. 

1 hour ago, Entendu said:

If the Marlins trade Pablo, it's likely we'll have below average pitching next year.

The answer never was to trade from pitching "depth". They need to sign hitters.

 

The answer was to trade from pitching depth, albeit depth in the minors at which Ng failed and hoarded guys like MM who pitched a few innings and now seems to need TJ.

12 minutes ago, hovertical said:

You're correct that no playoff team (who would be asking for Pablo) would give us back a proven MLB hitter. You are going to get a prospect(s) back and that's what you should target for him. But don't trade him for some dude already 25 and still in the minors (Brinson). You need to aim for a guy in his early 20s who is already showing a plus bat and preferably in at least aa/AAA. 

That guy probably doesn’t exist, and the team that would be willing to trade that bat would probably trade it for Luis Castillo before trading it for Pablo. 
 

I don’t see why we have to trade Pablo now other than our owner is cheap, which he is. 

Edited by Erick

A good organization would keep Pablo, get a solid hitting prospect for Bass/Okert, and spend some money on a hitter in free agency in the offseason. 

Edited by Erick

25 minutes ago, hovertical said:

You're correct that no playoff team (who would be asking for Pablo) would give us back a proven MLB hitter. You are going to get a prospect(s) back and that's what you should target for him. But don't trade him for some dude already 25 and still in the minors (Brinson). You need to aim for a guy in his early 20s who is already showing a plus bat and preferably in at least aa/AAA. 

Took a 2 month break off here, but just to chime in. Nolan Gorman. I suppose he is not "proven," but he's having a nice showing even if striking out a bit. Bad defensively at 2B, Arenado not opting out, Goldy signed for 2, and a better prospect Walker 1+ year away. Gorman is a DH future for them which loses value as a 3B. Marlins can put him on 3B or 1B for years. A real nice 1-2 thump with Berry presumably.

So the idea in my head is Pablo + Wendle/Rojas/Berti + Bass/Floro/Okert (maybe Cooper also and they move on from Pujols). You figure out 2B for them with an upgrade for this year (and next) and get them the pitching (and maybe Cooper) they need. They also have GREAT salary dumps (Dickerson, Dejong) to throw them a kicker if the Marlins agree to pay for a better package (like they did with Luzardo). The Marlins should absolutely do that with at least Dickerson if they decide to trade. For second pieces, the Cardinals have 1-2 year away FV50 SP (Graffeco) and SS (Winn) they could live without if the Marlins made it worth their while with the secondary pieces (Wendle would be tremendous I believe to play with Donovan, etc.), and they have fifteen other FV40+/FV40 prospects and the Marlins could take a few more of those.

There is a package here somewhere with Gorman (MLB ready!) + Graffeco/Winn as the double centerpiece if the decision to move Pablo. Gorman helps a lot now, and they could sign Nimmo/Swanson to start making the longterm major upgrades they need.

 

Of course, a better idea is to keep Pablo and frankly Bass who is really good, trade off the whatever group (Wendle/Rojas, Berti, Floro, Okert, Cooper if he's OK), and then you enter 2023 with this at approx $72-73m.

Fortes, Stallings
Lewin
Jazz
_____, Rojas/Wendle
Anderson, Williams
Bleday/Sanchez
_____, ____/Sanchez
Garcia
Soler

Sandy, Pablo, Luzardo, Cabrera, Rogers/Garrett
Bass, Bender, Pop, Poteet, Hernandez
Scott, Bleier, Rogers/Garrett

I mean how much do we have to scream for them to sign Nimmo/Swanson for one hole which gets payroll to low $90s.... and then trade Meyer/Salas/Watson, Lewis/Cappe/Fulton, and Morisette/A. Santos/outside top 15 prospects for the other of SS/CF in a 4-1 play now trade. This isn't Yelich level, but would net a longterm guy and will be pretty good given what's being traded. Rojas/Wendle is here to ease this person in. Then, maybe you sign a better 3rd/4th OF for 1 year if Sanchez (or Bleday) completely tanks, or do a real low cost trade just to have someone better while they work it out or not. The idea there is, Berry is coming and Anderson can kick out to the OF if all works out well with Berry and the OF still suck.

This is a low $90s team that still has Eury, three other top 100 prospects, and 10-15 interesting FV45/FV40 guys. The only potential injury of this group is Meyer.

Preaching to the choir here to do the above and just go to $110m and sign BOTH of Swanson (yes BABIP is high, but defense is great and he has pedigree. He's a safe 3+ WAR guy for me with upside) and Nimmo (he's great) and do this literal exact thing (could also shave payroll moving Anderson/Bleier/Hernandez and replacing with club controlled options - so use the farm and them to get those, etc.... so this could even be a $100m projection).... but since Bruce is cheap, I *think* they could put together something we mostly like for $90+m. This is the best $90m plan with Pablo I can think of and Nimmo/Swanson becomes the "Jayson Werth" moment.

Assuming that payroll is acceptable, I think this is the way. So it's ho-hum trades and play the kids. I'm hoping for this $90m vision to note. That's a good team above with Nimmo/Swanson, a Cabrera/Meyer level play now SS/CF prospect gained from a farm trade, and TBD Sanchez/Bleday/legit 4th OF..... with Eury and Berry god willingly midseason.

Assuming Bruce won't spend even $80m again - there is no solution absent 2-3 Jazz level breakouts, no major injuries like this year (Luzardo in particular), Rogers getting his head out of his ass, and Stallings/Garcia/Soler combining for 5 WAR next year. Currently, they are a negative. If this is the expected payroll, the rational move is sell it all and circle 2024. Because 2023 ain't going to happen with Meyer, Eder, and Sixto coming off injuries, who knows with Lewin/Bleday/Cabrera, and Eury and Berry not having wet feet. 7 years is quite a rebuild, but they'd be good on paper? Assholes.

19 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

 

The teams with the top payrolls are perpetually competitive AND have the farm system to trade for top talent. 

Meanwhile, what do the Marlins actually have...2 top pitchers, 2 solid pitchers, and Jazz? Wendle? 

They aren't developing talent, they aren't getting enough talent back in trades to compete, and they aren't signing free agents that are difference makers.

What are we doing here? How do people still have jobs? It is truly remarkable.

  • Author
4 minutes ago, Michael said:

I like how Joe is blaming the fans for not wanting to support an inferior product.

Yep. Not on the fans to spend their hard earned money on a minor league team. Ownership has to make the investment upfront.

7 minutes ago, Michael said:

I like how Joe is blaming the fans for not wanting to support an inferior product.

Yep. I'm kinda shocked he's supporting the owner here. You literally have a fan base that has seen NOTHING but disengenous actions from owners refusing to actually keep stars or sign stars for DECADES now and somehow everyone is just supposed to show up and spend tons of money at the park on a product that is utterly boring? Where's the incentive? 

And I GUARANTEE you that if they magically averaged even 25k a game that Sherman would still say some shit about how they want to build a sustainable future instead and not commit giant contracts - or he'd make some shit up about having to pay off debt to get the club into a better position. He's an awful owner. Probably the worst in all of baseball. 

5 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Yep. I'm kinda shocked he's supporting the owner here. You literally have a fan base that has seen NOTHING but disengenous actions from owners refusing to actually keep stars or sign stars for DECADES now and somehow everyone is just supposed to show up and spend tons of money at the park on a product that is utterly boring? Where's the incentive? 

And I GUARANTEE you that if they magically averaged even 25k a game that Sherman would still say some shit about how they want to build a sustainable future instead and not commit giant contracts - or he'd make some shit up about having to pay off debt to get the club into a better position. He's an awful owner. Probably the worst in all of baseball. 

P.S.  His grammar also sucks

1 hour ago, Major-Minor said:

The teams with the top payrolls are perpetually competitive AND have the farm system to trade for top talent. 

Meanwhile, what do the Marlins actually have...2 top pitchers, 2 solid pitchers, and Jazz? Wendle? 

They aren't developing talent, they aren't getting enough talent back in trades to compete, and they aren't signing free agents that are difference makers.

What are we doing here? How do people still have jobs? It is truly remarkable.

They have a bit more than Sandy, Pablo, Luzardo, Cabrera, Jazz, and Wendle.

 

This is a bit rough of an analysis. But, you can sell this pretty quickly to a contending path:

Fortes, Stallings - 2 WAR combo
Lewin - 1+ WAR
Jazz - 3.5+ WAR
_____, Rojas/Wendle as super backups - 1.5+ WAR + addition
Anderson - 2.5+ WAR
Bleday - 1.5+ WAR with massive potential. You gotta believe Bleday is an "OK" starter for this to work, or I guess Sanchez.
______, Sanchez as backup - 1+ WAR + addition
Garcia - I want to say he has a good "odd" year and is 1.5+ WAR. He still hits the ball hard. Sort of. Just needs to cut chase rate. Regardless, he is signed so you have to hope for this at a minmum
Soler - 2+ WAR and a return to 2019/post-2021. His statcast hit rates are good. He needs to be healthy and probably has a monstrous September to frustrate all of us
Bat 13 - ______ - I don't know who this is, but I think it's a 1B/3B starter and can move Anderson around
=16.5 WAR potential with some upside with Jazz/Lewin/Bleday and THREE empty spots where they easily have 1500+ PA to give here minimum

Sandy - 5+ WAR with can't believe I am saying this, upside on top of this as he's incredible
Pablo - 3+ WAR, probably upside here too
Luzardo - 2+ WAR (he has paced 2.8+ WAR this since last 7 starts last year... SSS over 60+ innings but potential is here). Massive upside on this one.
Cabrera - 1.5+ WAR with massive upside
Rogers/Garret - 1.5+ WAR with massive upside with Rogers if he rebounds, and some with Garrett.
Bass - 1+ WAR. Doing it this year plus some
Bender and Pop - 1+ WAR. Bender was much better last year so this could be low.
Poteet and Hernandez - 1+ WAR. Could be low as this could be 175+ Innings as bulk relievers if used correctly
Scott and Bleier - 1+ WAR
other of Rogers/Garret - 1+ WAR bulk reliever/6th SP
=18+ WAR fully internal staff, with some big upside with 7-8 guys here

35ish WAR projection..... plus room for three big bats..... roughly $72-73m. 

If payroll is $90m as mused above.... Nimmo/Swanson (4+), get a legitimate Meyer/Cabrera level prospect for SS/3B/CF around that big signing (1.5+ WAR) and use Salas/minor leaguers to get it, and another solid bat anywhere (1+ WAR).... and this is getting interesting with Eury, Eder, Sixto, and Berry perhaps midseason. You're easily at a 40 WAR projection if everyone is healthy and not being an asshole, of course those are two huge concerns with this group right now but what else can they do absent spending $130-150m? Yes I know we're taking some liberties with Stallings/Lewin/Bleday/Sanchez/Garcia/Soler but there is no other choice. You have to believe they cumulatively do something, and 8 WAR out of those dudes should be reasonable!

 

I'm not saying this is going to happen - I'm saying if we're weighing blow it up or no we want to contend in 2023, this has to be what the FO is thinking about as the best case scenario. I think we can all feel free to disagree here, but I think Ng/all can have some conviction in this group assuming they can actually land thee "Jayson Werth" FA and then FINALLY do the plant my flag farm trade for a second major bat.

I can buy this team next year if they get 3 smart bats here.... leaving right now Aguilar, Cooper, Berti, Wendle/Rojas, Floro, and Okert to trade at the deadline. They can just get prospects for them honestly, and then figure it all out in the offseason for that 1 bigger trade for the Meyer/Cabrera level play now bat.

 

So just saying, they have a bit more than just a few good dudes. What they need is some OOMPH at the top with a BIG free agent and to hit on a trade ala Sandy/Jazz to shore up presumably SS or CF long term. Do those two things, and they will go as far as the SP will take them. I'm definitely very interested in seeing what happens to determine the vision here. They still have good books/trade assets so are they going for it or circling 2024. Big moment for them now till spring training.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.