Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins listening on everyone except Sandy

Featured Replies

8 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

A lot of board and twitter overrating Pablo’s value. Looking forward to the Ng bashing when return is significantly less than Castillo 

I won't be looking forward to it but I know the return will certainly be less. 

1 minute ago, hovertical said:

I won't be looking forward to it but I know the return will certainly be less. 

Or they don’t trade him at all because the offers aren’t good enough and everyone yells at NG. Lose lose for big Ng

1 hour ago, pollythewog said:

Or they don’t trade him at all because the offers aren’t good enough and everyone yells at NG. Lose lose for big Ng

I'm good with moving him or keeping him tbh. But if they keep him they need to be jettisoning as much dead weight off this team as possible with guys like Aguilar for instance (some team will take him even for a low end prospect because he can still get hits). Does no good to keep the team intact and just try again next season with the same trash heap. Really push hard to find a taker for Soler too.

1 hour ago, pollythewog said:

Or they don’t trade him at all because the offers aren’t good enough and everyone yells at NG. Lose lose for big Ng

Nobody here will be mad at Kim for not trading him. I don't think we want him gone unless the return is massive. 

16 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Does no good to keep the team intact and just try again next season with the same trash heap. 

Correct. This is why I want changes made. Tired of this stale no energy group. 

Actually, knowing how passive a GM Kim seems to be, I'm more "confident" in her not giving him up for a poor return. She either gets what she wants or she goes back to folding that laundry that she started last weekend. She doesn't make rushed trades. 

31 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

knowing how passive a GM Kim seems to be

It seems not something good. 

Edited by taiwanmarlin

1 hour ago, taiwanmarlin said:

It seems not something good. 

I know but im just saying in this situation it might be an advantage. 

4 hours ago, pollythewog said:

Pablo bigger injury risk. 

Is he?

Regardless, Castillo is better inning per inning (not to say Pablo is a slouch as he has 5.7 WAR his last 51 starts which is well over a 3+ WAR pace), but the extra year of control and lower salaries via arbitration make Pablo more valuable on paper. At "worst," if we accept Castillo should get more as its more bang for the 1 roster spot (I agree some value here), the floor is they are equal value with the extra year of time and cheaper $$$ Pablo brings. I'd say, Pablo is worth the same centerpieces of value, and gets a better 3rd or 4th player minimum. (This also isn't including an acquiring team could immediately resign Pablo for 5 and create more value for themselves. Castillo is 1 year away from FA so you'd have to blow him away with a Berrios level deal. I don't think we can put too much stock into this, but it is a selling point.)

It's all package dependent. You keep him if you don't get what you want/need.

I think St. Louis and Texas make a lot of sense. They have infielder surplus and the Marlins could use their longterm 3B..... as Berry is going to be at 1B or more likely DH by all indications. Texas was apparently in on Castillo, so I have to imagine they are looking to gear up for next year. Something like....

Gorman
Graffeco or Winn
Hence
M. Nunez
Love or Pacheco
C. Dickerson or maybe DeJong (salary dump to bail them out a few dollars)

For Pablo, Wendle/Rojas/Berti (their pick, becomes their right now platoon 2B over Gorman. Gorman has no defensive future with them so hes a perfect play now target and everyone wins), Cooper (Pujols sucks), and maybe send them back Castano to bring him full circle and he can be a depth AAA arm this year for them. Could be a better reliever than Castano too if they do need Bass/Okert/Floro to get this done but their pen is pretty good. 

Jung
D. Harris
E. Carter or Zavala
Acosta
FV40 arm (they have many)

For Pablo and Burdick - they are low on OF in their system so kick in Burdick who is 2+ years MLB ready over their other OF prospects. Marlins don't really need him with Bleday, Sanchez, and Garcia, and they will have to get a CF in another deal shortly so they'd be 4 deep of reasonable options (or ones they must play). To note, Harris can dabble in LF and Carter/Zavala are OF for this hypothetical so there is still an OF pipeline.

 

These work based on what Castillo/Benintendi were traded for as all the Marlins guys have control. Just depends on how much these teams like Pablo.

We can do this with the Yankees with Volpe/Peraza also, maybe a bulk package from the Dodgers for Pablo/Cooper centered around Cartaya, Pages, and M. Vargas, and likely others.

There are a lot of options. Pablo is awesome, and the middle class of the Marlins (Cooper, Berti, Rojas, Wendle, Bass, Floro, Okert, Bleier) all make sense for contenders looking to shore up a platoon/bench spot with some future control.

 

2 hours ago, SilverBullet said:

Nobody here will be mad at Kim for not trading him. I don't think we want him gone unless the return is massive. 

Exactly.

I will be mad if over 50% of Cooper, Berti, Rojas, Wendle, Bass, Floro, Okert, Sulser, and Aguilar are not moved. It's just dumb to not cash in with this group.

Get 6-10 FV45/40 prospects for these guys so you ideally fill up some bench/bullpen holes/AAA depth next year, as well as build out farm so you can have more confidence "Yeliching" for a CF.

4 hours ago, pollythewog said:

Or they don’t trade him at all because the offers aren’t good enough and everyone yells at NG. Lose lose for big Ng

She could just say other teams low balled offers to the Marlins because she is a woman.  Maybe Sherman could cry his way to compensation from Manfred.

  • Author
4 hours ago, pollythewog said:

Or they don’t trade him at all because the offers aren’t good enough and everyone yells at NG. Lose lose for big Ng

Yeah right. People bend over backwards to find ways to excuse her so I am sure she'll be excused even if she trades Pablo for a 27 year old in Single-A. Her people will just blame Caroline O'Connor again.

5 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Yeah right. People bend over backwards to find ways to excuse her so I am sure she'll be excused even if she trades Pablo for a 27 year old in Single-A. Her people will just blame Caroline O'Connor again.

Who ever defends kim!

Seattle also blew every other offer out of the water for Castillo because they are beyond desperate to reach the playoffs.

 

I dont think any other organization is coming close to the Castillo package for any other starter*, so you might as well not go down this path of 'assuming' the price for a starter is basically that Seattle package. 

 

*Unless that starter is also a hitter when he isnt pitching

16 minutes ago, Michael said:

MarlinsBaseball listening to offers on everyone, especially Das Texan.

only way would be taking a sub-par return and that's packaging with Pablo = (

Mish really tried pressing Kim with the Pablo trade questions but I think she actually gave the right answers in that setting. Basically said she doesn't want to get rid of Pablo but will listen to offers to see if anything actually makes us better. I ultimately don't think he's dealt because he doesn't need to go but she has to listen. Now my fear is that her listening on Pablo means she doesn't have the time to listen on guys like Bass and Aguilar who really should be dealt. 

1 hour ago, SilverBullet said:

Mish really tried pressing Kim with the Pablo trade questions but I think she actually gave the right answers in that setting. Basically said she doesn't want to get rid of Pablo but will listen to offers to see if anything actually makes us better. I ultimately don't think he's dealt because he doesn't need to go but she has to listen. Now my fear is that her listening on Pablo means she doesn't have the time to listen on guys like Bass and Aguilar who really should be dealt. 

Don't worry I'm sure Mish heard the words Pablo Lopez will be traded somewhere along the way so he will blabber on that Pablo Lopez is being traded as a result.

I'm sure he is also just hours away from his, BIG TRADE BEING DISCUSSED tweet or podcast or whatever as well. 

39 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

Don't worry I'm sure Mish heard the words Pablo Lopez will be traded somewhere along the way so he will blabber on that Pablo Lopez is being traded as a result.

I'm sure he is also just hours away from his, BIG TRADE BEING DISCUSSED tweet or podcast or whatever as well. 

I get it... but it was last trade deadline when that backfired on him and he said he wasn't making that mistake again so we probably get a really subdued Mish the next few days. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.