Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

1 hour ago, Michael said:

 

Why is "the team will look different" the sell? 

The team should look reloaded...competitive. Anything less should be meaningless for a fan base.

1 minute ago, Major-Minor said:

Why is "the team will look different" the sell? 

The team should look reloaded...competitive. Anything less should be meaningless for a fan base.

I am in agreement, friend. It's fine if it looks different so long as it's GOOD.

1 hour ago, Michael said:

 

I had to check the date on that again - I swear he said almost the exact same thing last season as well as the last two trade deadlines.

53 minutes ago, hovertical said:

I had to check the date on that again - I swear he said almost the exact same thing last season as well as the last two trade deadlines.

"I tweet and I know things." - Craig "Tyrion Lannister" Mish

5 hours ago, Entendu said:

I think the Marlins could do a Werth contract and no one would still believe they're serious

I remember the backhanded and skeptical media questions and comments when they gave Stanton his contract extension here. 

2 hours ago, Major-Minor said:

Why is "the team will look different" the sell? 

I would think that automatically implies an attempt to be an improvement. 

17 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

I remember the backhanded and skeptical media questions and comments when they gave Stanton his contract extension here. 

Keith Olbermann even had a whole segment on one of his shows saying it was a scam.

9 hours ago, SilverBullet said:

Yea but you can't do that with every free agent either or you're just overpaying for the sake of overpaying.

I'm saying for a mid level free agent like Kiermaier, also Justin Turner, you can give an overpay and they still won't choose us because we're the Marlins unless they're out of options. That's how we got Soler here.

Sure, overpay on Correa and Trea Turner to make a statement but I don't want them stupidly overpaying for every fringe free agent too. 

Have no “overpaying ” this word in the FA market, have only the “do your best to sign the players ” in the FA market. 

You need to WIN the BIDDING WAR to sign the good FAs, players don't want to play for the Marlins shouldn't be the excuse, Sherman should know players don't want to play for a shit team like Marlins when he tries to buy this franchise. 

Sherman needs to do his best to sign good FAs to make the Marlins no more a shit team and good FAs would no more see the Marlins a shit team that they don't want to play for.

15 hours ago, Michael said:

Oh my god are you also MarlinsLou?

Two thoughts:

1 - I don't think this is an independent thought from Das or I, many have suggested the Marlins doing a "Werth" acquisition is the necessary next step to telegraph to the league they mean business. So;

2 - No personal attacks

12 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

Two thoughts:

1 - I don't think this is an independent thought from Das or I, many have suggested the Marlins doing a "Werth" acquisition is the necessary next step to telegraph to the league they mean business. So;

2 - No personal attacks

1. You might even call it a Werthwhile acquisition....

2. No politics.

2 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Technically I don't see how he was attacking you or Das with that comment. For all we know, it was a compliment.

omg are you @Michael?!?!?

38 minutes ago, hovertical said:

1. You might even call it a Werthwhile acquisition....

2. No politics.

I will adopt this nomenclature

Also should any of us care when the Mets payroll + luxury tax this year is currently around $436 million dollars ($325 payroll, $111 luxury) and the Marlins payroll 2018-2022 was $350m.... meaning the Marlins might "barely" get over that amount for 6 seasons absent a real commitment coming out of nowhere. 

Six years of payroll for Bruce = 2023 for the Mets
Mets luxury tax 2023 > Marlins 2023 payroll (probably.... only Correa/Rodon/Swanson would get them over this)

I can understand the scorch earth philosophy of Bruce coming in to start over, so some of this is to be expected with lower payrolls as you trade out, build the farm, and then start going for it a few years later, but when will the faucet turn on even to CHEAP amounts? We're begging for $120m here after a 5 year average payroll of $70m which is exceptionally low?

Mets have $225m committed for next year, and adding in Alonso/McNeil/Raley increases, they probably get to $250m throwing in some club controlled players (Alvarez, etc.) on top. Meaning, if Steve is OK with $325 + luxury, they can sign Ohtani for $50m a season and still have $25m to play with. At minimum. Should any of us care if the Mets are just going to do this with a guy 25-30x the net worth of Bruce, and then obvious characters like the Dodgers and Yankees follow suit? Atlanta's payroll is $193m. This is well over double than Atlanta who just gave up numerous record long term deals. The Dodgers are actually sitting on $160m right now. Atlanta and LAD are models of responsibility here compared to the Mets?

Like, are Mets fans even going to be proud of their team if they do win because playing outside your weight class isn't fun? Are 10-15 fan bases in baseball going to stop caring soon because these top teams are just going to sign everyone? Are the other owners going to be happy with this? What a mess. Something will have to change here, so maybe we should champion Steve Cohen to keep doing this as his drunk spending may bring real change to the sport. Likewise, if/when the Mets lose in the playoffs, that is going to be hilarious.

36 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

Like, are Mets fans even going to be proud of their team if they do win because playing outside your weight class isn't fun?

Likewise, if/when the Mets lose in the playoffs, that is going to be hilarious.

I know I'd be absolutely enthralled by being a die-hard fan of a team that signs everyone to make a mega team and trounces other teams throughout the season. I don't know what fan wouldn't be absolutely stoked by that? We'd lose our collective minds if somehow Bruce learned he was terminal and wanted to dump all his money into the team and we made the same signings as the Mutts.  I certainly wouldn't sit here saying "oh gee, now it won't be any fun because we'll beat everyone". 

It just REALLY sucks to be a fan of a team like the Marlins who COULD be great but aren't because of a skinflint owner.

 

also, it's not a question of if, it's definitely a question of when the Mutts lose in the playoffs.  They are the Mutts afterall.

Yes ultimately the Cohen thing is gonna create issues for the sport overall. The payroll gaps now are laughable. This will eventually create change. 

But wait until Mets fans get reminded that the payroll doesn't determine game results. Gonna be hilarious. 

2 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

But wait until Mets fans get reminded that the payroll doesn't determine game results. Gonna be hilarious. 

I'd put them in 3rd place currently in the NL East. I still think the Braves and Phillies will do better.

1 minute ago, TaiwanAstros said:

Cohen deserves a World Series title, Sherman deserves the worst record in the regular season, it is what it is.

Cohen does not deserve a title just because he spent that much money. That's a pretty bad precedent to set.

34 minutes ago, hovertical said:

I know I'd be absolutely enthralled by being a die-hard fan of a team that signs everyone to make a mega team and trounces other teams throughout the season. I don't know what fan wouldn't be absolutely stoked by that? We'd lose our collective minds if somehow Bruce learned he was terminal and wanted to dump all his money into the team and we made the same signings as the Mutts.  I certainly wouldn't sit here saying "oh gee, now it won't be any fun because we'll beat everyone". 

It just REALLY sucks to be a fan of a team like the Marlins who COULD be great but aren't because of a skinflint owner.

 

also, it's not a question of if, it's definitely a question of when the Mutts lose in the playoffs.  They are the Mutts afterall.

TBH, if the Marlins got to a $325m payroll this offseason, I'm not sure how interested I would be. Like, this is comical below and was it a challenge to build this team? Is this doing it the right way under the rules or just throwing money at problems and highlighting in sports wealth disparity? Is this fun? I'm not sure this is fun. This is a video game lineup.

Verlander ($42m)
DeGrom ($42m)
Correa ($34m)
Rodon ($30m)
Nimmo ($24m)
E. Diaz ($21m)
Contreras ($20m)
Rizzo ($20m)
R. Montero ($12m)
Drury ($11m)

And then trading the house for:

Reynolds ($7m) and
Bednar ($750k) - Cabrera/Rogers, Meyer/Berry, Salas, Eder/Fulton, send them back Stallings, and who cares

Y. Diaz ($5.5m) - Pablo, send them Wendle back, send them Cooper, and juice them prospects if needed

The $325m Marlins:
Contreras, Fortes
Rizzo
Jazz, Berti
Correa, Rojas
Y. Diaz, Drury
Reynolds
Nimmo
Garcia
Soler
(Top AAA - Groshans, DLC)

Sandy, Verlander, DeGrom, Rodon, Luzardo, Rogers/Cabrera
E. Diaz, Bednar, R. Montero, Floro
Scott, Bleier, Okert
(Top AAA - Garrett is kicked to AAA here and we actually kept Eury doing this shenanigans. I suppose we could use him to get an even better 3B maybe or use him as a Salary dump for Garcia/Soler)

Would this be fun or is it just a bit much over the top? 

 

2 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

TBH, if the Marlins got to a $325m payroll this offseason, I'm not sure how interested I would be. Like, this is comical below and was it a challenge to build this team? Is this doing it the right way under the rules or just throwing money at problems and highlighting in sports wealth disparity? Is this fun? I'm not sure this is fun. This is a video game lineup.

Verlander ($42m)
DeGrom ($42m)
Correa ($34m)
Rodon ($30m)
Nimmo ($24m)
E. Diaz ($21m)
Contreras ($20m)
Rizzo ($20m)
R. Montero ($12m)
Drury ($11m)

And then trading the house for:

Reynolds ($7m) and
Bednar ($750k) - Cabrera/Rogers, Meyer/Berry, Salas, Eder/Fulton, send them back Stallings, and who cares

Y. Diaz ($5.5m) - Pablo, send them Wendle back, send them Cooper, and juice them prospects if needed

The $325m Marlins:
Contreras, Fortes
Rizzo
Jazz, Berti
Correa, Rojas
Y. Diaz, Drury
Reynolds
Nimmo
Garcia
Soler
(Top AAA - Groshans, DLC)

Sandy, Verlander, DeGrom, Rodon, Luzardo, Rogers/Cabrera
E. Diaz, Bednar, R. Montero, Floro
Scott, Bleier, Okert
(Top AAA - Garrett is kicked to AAA here and we actually kept Eury doing this shenanigans. I suppose we could use him to get an even better 3B maybe or use him as a Salary dump for Garcia/Soler)

Would this be fun or is it just a bit much over the top? 

 

I've done the Cohen thing in video games and I'll say it is NOT fun. You think maybe it'll be fun when you first start doing it, but quickly it just is boring and feels un-earned even if you win anything.

That being said, I'd take the Cohen approach over the Sherman approach any day.

Best thing would be someone in the middle I guess.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.