Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

7 hours ago, hovertical said:

Because he's not the one playing the games so he doesn't "deserve" a title.

Also, equating spending as much as he does to earn a title is unfair to all but a handful of teams because nobody else would ever be able to spend that much. 

Well, sure he's not playing in the game but he's an important part of building the team. It's semantics. I guess no owner deserves a title, by that logic. Kinda weird to single Cohen out if that was the point you were trying to make.

It's not about fairness, it's about building a competitive team. I don't see how anyone can expect him to sit back and say "this is enough; my team is good enough". I always assumed that owners stopped spending because they couldn't or didn't have the appetite to any further, but it's never occurred to me that they stop because it would be unfair for them to continue. I'm not sure that should be going through any owner's mind.

If MLB wants to step in and try to regulate this, then that's their funeral. But Cohen isn't doing anything wrong.

The Mets also aren't guaranteed a World Series. It'll be fun to watch teams combat them next season. Definitely gives evil empire vibes.

22 minutes ago, Entendu said:

Well, sure he's not playing in the game but he's an important part of building the team. It's semantics. I guess no owner deserves a title, by that logic. Kinda weird to single Cohen out if that was the point you were trying to make.

 

not really weird to single out the guy who will probably have a payroll close to half a billion after they pick up Ohtani next year as well.  It's bad precedent to set if literally only 4-5 teams are capable of spending as much as he does for a payroll and that's what "deserves" a title.  That's it.

 

MLB absolutely needs a hard cap AND a floor - having the floor should actually extend some player's careers as well as there will inevitably be some vets who get signed for more than they should make just for the cheapo owners to meet the floor. 

 

I have zero issue with Cohen as an owner and would LOVE to have him. He's not doing anything wrong. I'm just saying that he doesn't deserve a title because he's spending far more than anyone else. 

1 hour ago, MarlinsLou said:

It's being reported DBacks are talking Varsho to Houston.

Now that's the one where Kim/FO needs to put on their big boy and girl pants and muscle out every other team for a CF.

Kim probably doesn't even know who Varsho is.

But count me in under the hopeless banner... I still believe they'll make several roster adjustments because Kim "has to" since it's her contract year but Sherman won't let her make any real free agent signings and the Pirates don't wanna trade Reynolds so even if they change their mind Kim will be too slow and another team will swoop in and so all of the additions the Marlins are gonna make are gonna be, as usual, fringe pieces that ultimately don't make a difference.

This front office doesn't have what it takes to make the real moves to get this team where it needs to be.

And with the division so strong the hill to climb is even larger so at the end of the day 2023 will be another wasted season in Miami. And hey, I'm the positive one! 

Marlins still want Reynolds but aren't gonna wait around for the Pirates to budge. That's great news because I think that's what fucked them over last year. 

Their offer to Justin Turner is considered competitive, I still don't think he chooses them if he has other offers.

The offer to Abreu was good but they wouldn't go for a 3rd year so they screwed themselves there.

If you know he wants an extra year and you're supposedly desperate to improve the team then just fucking give him the extra year, fuck give him two extra years.

You like the guy so just bite the fucking bullet.

You offered 2/40, he wants 3/60? Give him 4/80, maybe even go a little lesser at around 4/75 and I bet he comes to Miami! Sprinkle in opt outs and he'll bite. 

They did the same shit with Marte knowing he wanted an extra year. So they wanted him but didn't want him enough to outbid and overpay? Come on.

5 minutes ago, The_Punisher said:

Report came out that Marlins got Arraez for Lopez? Anyone else see this?

Source?

12 minutes ago, TaiwanAstros said:

Apologized already, but it's really ridiculous to “prepared ” it.

Must be a breeze for Marlins writers. Don't have to prepare a damn thing.

19 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

 

What's the connection with signing Bassitt and then trading a catcher? Seems weird, what am I missing there?

1 minute ago, SilverBullet said:

What's the connection with signing Bassitt and then trading a catcher? Seems weird, what am I missing there?

I think the general idea with them was they were going to trade pipeline catching surplus for Starting Pitching.  

27 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

What's the connection with signing Bassitt and then trading a catcher? Seems weird, what am I missing there?

I don't know, but Toronto could use another SP and an OF upgrade. You know, like Braxton Garrett and Max Kepler.

For instance, assuming the Twins don't get Correa (or even if they do?), Polanco/N. Gordon are heavy RHP splits guys and they can cover SS/2B and Farmer who they traded for, plays both and hits lefties. Rojas would be perfect for them to split everyone out in the infield (this is assuming Arraez is the Marlins trade target of course). Lewis could also take over SS in a year. Twins also need depth lefties - they could really use Bleier/Scott/Okert as a 2nd/3rd bullpen lefty and Nardi/Simpson/Reynolds would all be welcome AAA depth and future pen arms. I took a look and they have two on their 40 man.

What I'm getting here is, in a world Larnach-Buxton-R. Lewis/A.Martin/Wallner cover the Twins OF (and N. Gordon and I believe Farmer and Kiriloff can pop out there also), Kepler isn't needed and he makes a lot of sense for the Blue Jays. Arms will always be appreciated for a contender

So:

Marlins - Arraez, D. Janson, Mid-Tier Twins Prospect
Twins - P. Lopez, Rojas, Scott/Okert, Nardi/Simpson
B. Jays - B. Garrett, M. Kepler

Pablo and Garrett are steep here, but these are two longterm bat solutions (assuming Arraez can play 100+ games at 3B/2B) for their lowest control and lowest upside SP, and frankly, that Twins prospect may be more important than depth lefties which they are good at finding. And they can trade Stallings to recoup a depth lefty, so it's effectively Pablo/Garrett for Arraez/Jansen once the smaller guys and payroll net out.

I think everyone is pretty happy here? Twins get a massive starter and depth options, Blue Jays two very useful guys to break up their catcher redundancy, and the Marlins two big bat upgrades + shedding payroll

So now, the Marlins are sitting at $75 million-ish for this:

Jansen, Fortes
Cooper (Arraez)
Jazz
_____, Wendle
Arraez, Berti
DLC, Sanchez
______
Garcia
Soler

Sandy, Rogers, Cabrera, Luzardo, ______
_____, Floro, Chargois, Nance, Sixto/Brazoban/Whoever
Bleier, Okert/Scott, Castano

We're likely talking about signing a stop gap 1 year SP and maybe a bullpen longman/innings eater (unless they think Castano/Sixto can do that?) while we wait for Eury, Eder, Fulton, and then Meyer and Bender. All of whom are virtually untouchable given two SP were just shot out. Wade Miley? If we believe in the young pitcher, I say let's believe in the young pitching.

And then I'd say, what does Cleveland want for A. Rosario which I imagine could be a prospect trade and avoid using Berry/Salas/Cappe/upper level pitchers for that. Maybe they'd go for something based on Miller and Peguro/Gerardo. This clears $8-9m for Cleveland so they could use that to sign someone more useful for them and take some HR prospect swings. I think the Marlins have the goods here to do it if Cleveland would take a longterm approach. They have other options so doesn't impact MLB team.

And then figure out CF. This could even be Michael Taylor who is unspectacularly solid and wouldn't cost the top prospects again, and they could play Sanchez out in CF 60 games vs RHP. It's a band aid yes and I am CF cheerleader # 1, but if C/3B/SS are figured out with longterm options (I imagine a Rosario 5/$70 extension sort of thing), that is acceptable to me.

So that's yea another hypothetical of the Marlins having an interesting team on paper that would stand a chance for under $100m. I'd like to say, push it to $115m and just sign Rodon and not a stop gap SP there, but let's not get crazy. Spending bottom 20th payroll after 20 years of being lowest in baseball is absurd.

9 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

I don't know, but Toronto could use another SP and an OF upgrade. You know, like Braxton Garrett and Max Kepler.

For instance, assuming the Twins don't get Correa (or even if they do?), Polanco/N. Gordon are heavy RHP splits guys and they can cover SS/2B and Farmer who they traded for, plays both and hits lefties. Rojas would be perfect for them to split everyone out in the infield (this is assuming Arraez is the Marlins trade target of course). Lewis could also take over SS in a year. Twins also need depth lefties - they could really use Bleier/Scott/Okert as a 2nd/3rd bullpen lefty and Nardi/Simpson/Reynolds would all be welcome AAA depth and future pen arms. I took a look and they have two on their 40 man.

What I'm getting here is, in a world Larnach-Buxton-R. Lewis/A.Martin/Wallner cover the Twins OF (and N. Gordon and I believe Farmer and Kiriloff can pop out there also), Kepler isn't needed and he makes a lot of sense for the Blue Jays. Arms will always be appreciated for a contender

So:

Marlins - Arraez, D. Janson, Mid-Tier Twins Prospect
Twins - P. Lopez, Rojas, Scott/Okert, Nardi/Simpson
B. Jays - B. Garrett, M. Kepler

Pablo and Garrett are steep here, but these are two longterm bat solutions (assuming Arraez can play 100+ games at 3B/2B) for their lowest control and lowest upside SP, and frankly, that Twins prospect may be more important than depth lefties which they are good at finding. And they can trade Stallings to recoup a depth lefty, so it's effectively Pablo/Garrett for Arraez/Jansen once the smaller guys and payroll net out.

I think everyone is pretty happy here? Twins get a massive starter and depth options, Blue Jays two very useful guys to break up their catcher redundancy, and the Marlins two big bat upgrades + shedding payroll

So now, the Marlins are sitting at $75 million-ish for this:

Jansen, Fortes
Cooper (Arraez)
Jazz
_____, Wendle
Arraez, Berti
DLC, Sanchez
______
Garcia
Soler

Sandy, Rogers, Cabrera, Luzardo, ______
_____, Floro, Chargois, Nance, Sixto/Brazoban/Whoever
Bleier, Okert/Scott, Castano

We're likely talking about signing a stop gap 1 year SP and maybe a bullpen longman/innings eater (unless they think Castano/Sixto can do that?) while we wait for Eury, Eder, Fulton, and then Meyer and Bender. All of whom are virtually untouchable given two SP were just shot out. Wade Miley? If we believe in the young pitcher, I say let's believe in the young pitching.

And then I'd say, what does Cleveland want for A. Rosario which I imagine could be a prospect trade and avoid using Berry/Salas/Cappe/upper level pitchers for that. Maybe they'd go for something based on Miller and Peguro/Gerardo. This clears $8-9m for Cleveland so they could use that to sign someone more useful for them and take some HR prospect swings. I think the Marlins have the goods here to do it if Cleveland would take a longterm approach. They have other options so doesn't impact MLB team.

And then figure out CF. This could even be Michael Taylor who is unspectacularly solid and wouldn't cost the top prospects again, and they could play Sanchez out in CF 60 games vs RHP. It's a band aid yes and I am CF cheerleader # 1, but if C/3B/SS are figured out with longterm options (I imagine a Rosario 5/$70 extension sort of thing), that is acceptable to me.

So that's yea another hypothetical of the Marlins having an interesting team on paper that would stand a chance for under $100m. I'd like to say, push it to $115m and just sign Rodon and not a stop gap SP there, but let's not get crazy. Spending bottom 20th payroll after 20 years of being lowest in baseball is absurd.

Yeah yeah yeah but once again... the Marlins don't think like you do so, meh?

Just now, SilverBullet said:

Yeah yeah yeah but once again... the Marlins don't think like you do so, meh?

If I can do this while on hold on a call, I am optimistic they have minimal levels of creativity. That is, unless they really just value someone differently than prevailing wisdom which of course can be the case. Maybe Arraez can't play 3B? It only works if he can do that (or Jazz SS TBH and then replace Turner/Drury/Longoria with Rosario above).

3 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

If I can do this while on hold on a call, I am optimistic they have minimal levels of creativity.

They never show an inkling of being able to think about the roster the way you do.

I read your posts and I'm nodding like that Jack Nicholson meme...

Jack Nicholson Yes GIF

...and then I realize Kim Ng just got finished folding last week's laundry and nothing as interesting or as creative as your post will happen with this team.

 

Ultimately this front office is just flat out boring for anyone interested in this team. That's a term we don't use enough when it comes to the Marlins and their operations...

Boring.

Miami Marlins? Nothing to see here, move along.... 

Boring.

6 minutes ago, Entendu said:

I'd like to know what the fuck Kim Ng has been doing this whole time?

Seriously dude? We're like a week and a half before Christmas Eve, I'm sure she's busy preparing her family's holiday plans. What else should she be doing now?

10 minutes ago, Entendu said:

I'd like to know what the fuck Kim Ng has been doing this whole time?

Absolutely nothing, just like last off-season and then the trade deadline this past season. Also can't forget her old trick of playing a man down during the season.

7 minutes ago, Entendu said:

I'd like to know what the fuck Kim Ng has been doing this whole time?

Honest answer... probably passively having trade talks with multiple teams but since no one wants to budge yet she's waiting for someone to make the first move. So basically the lack of urgency is again the problem.

If trades start to pick up then maybe she'll get something done but don't expect her to initiate any of it. She'll keep listening and checking in but we'll get to spring training and nothing will be done. Then after camp opens she'll check on any remaining free agents who are desperate and out of options.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.