Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

6 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

I've done the Cohen thing in video games and I'll say it is NOT fun. You think maybe it'll be fun when you first start doing it, but quickly it just is boring and feels un-earned even if you win anything.

That being said, I'd take the Cohen approach over the Sherman approach any day.

Best thing would be someone in the middle I guess.

Yea totally. It's stupid. It's not fun.

He can sign Ohtani for $50m next year and run a lower payroll. Just think about that. Other owners aren't going to put up with this shit if this is more than an enthusiasm blip (which I suspect it is not). I guess we shall see.

1 minute ago, SonOfJack said:

Yeah, and I think he will offer that at a minimum. Could see him going even higher. The rumor is he really really wants Ohtani.

$50M for hitter Ohtani and $50M for pitcher Ohtani and that's $100M for a whole Ohtani .........

51 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

I've done the Cohen thing in video games and I'll say it is NOT fun. You think maybe it'll be fun when you first start doing it, but quickly it just is boring and feels un-earned even if you win anything.

That being said, I'd take the Cohen approach over the Sherman approach any day.

Best thing would be someone in the middle I guess.

Watching live baseball games play out versus playing a video game with a stacked team are two totally different things though since you can still have direct control over the video game while in real life you have zero control over the outcome.  I don't care for the uber video game lineups either but I'd cheer the shit out of the Marlins going all out with a stacked roster.  I really don't see anyone on here complaining had Sherman signed Correa, Nimmo, Rodon, (traded for) Reynolds, and Turner plus a few bp arm upgrades and made this into a super team.

Edited by hovertical

1 hour ago, SilverBullet said:

Yes ultimately the Cohen thing is gonna create issues for the sport overall. The payroll gaps now are laughable. This will eventually create change. 

But wait until Mets fans get reminded that the payroll doesn't determine game results. Gonna be hilarious. 

 

1 hour ago, SonOfJack said:

I'd put them in 3rd place currently in the NL East. I still think the Braves and Phillies will do better.

The Mets got to play three more games than the Marlins in 2022 despite their already ridiculous payroll and all-star team.

13 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

Dodgers group did this same thing for a bit.

They're still doing it while also having insane player development. They end up getting stars in certain spots from their own farm and can then spend elsewhere.

Having Will Smith be as good as he is, then some of their young pitchers as well, has allowed them to crush the markets with guys like Freeman and Betts.

Just now, Michael said:

They're still doing it while also having insane player development. They end up getting stars in certain spots from their own farm and can then spend elsewhere.

Having Will Smith be as good as he is, then some of their young pitchers as well, has allowed them to crush the markets with guys like Freeman and Betts.

The Dodgers and Mets battling it out for Ohtani next winter will be enjoyable. 

 

also, the Dodgers are letting 300 million dollar shortstops just leave their organization for basically nothing which is interesting.

 

Wha tthe Dodgers have been doing is making trades with their farm system, then extending those guys that they like.  Unlike the Mets basically just buying whomever they feel like outright.

12 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

Also should any of us care when the Mets payroll + luxury tax this year is currently around $436 million dollars ($325 payroll, $111 luxury) and the Marlins payroll 2018-2022 was $350m.... meaning the Marlins might "barely" get over that amount for 6 seasons absent a real commitment coming out of nowhere. 

Six years of payroll for Bruce = 2023 for the Mets
Mets luxury tax 2023 > Marlins 2023 payroll (probably.... only Correa/Rodon/Swanson would get them over this)

I can understand the scorch earth philosophy of Bruce coming in to start over, so some of this is to be expected with lower payrolls as you trade out, build the farm, and then start going for it a few years later, but when will the faucet turn on even to CHEAP amounts? We're begging for $120m here after a 5 year average payroll of $70m which is exceptionally low?

Mets have $225m committed for next year, and adding in Alonso/McNeil/Raley increases, they probably get to $250m throwing in some club controlled players (Alvarez, etc.) on top. Meaning, if Steve is OK with $325 + luxury, they can sign Ohtani for $50m a season and still have $25m to play with. At minimum. Should any of us care if the Mets are just going to do this with a guy 25-30x the net worth of Bruce, and then obvious characters like the Dodgers and Yankees follow suit? Atlanta's payroll is $193m. This is well over double than Atlanta who just gave up numerous record long term deals. The Dodgers are actually sitting on $160m right now. Atlanta and LAD are models of responsibility here compared to the Mets?

Like, are Mets fans even going to be proud of their team if they do win because playing outside your weight class isn't fun? Are 10-15 fan bases in baseball going to stop caring soon because these top teams are just going to sign everyone? Are the other owners going to be happy with this? What a mess. Something will have to change here, so maybe we should champion Steve Cohen to keep doing this as his drunk spending may bring real change to the sport. Likewise, if/when the Mets lose in the playoffs, that is going to be hilarious.

Honestly though, it's the Mets!  They can fuck it up. they could fuck it up.  They will fuck it up!

20 hours ago, hovertical said:

Cohen does not deserve a title just because he spent that much money. That's a pretty bad precedent to set.

Why doesn't he deserve a title for investing in his team? If he has the means, it would be negligent of him to say "I need to stop for the sake of every other team". 

12 minutes ago, Entendu said:

Why doesn't he deserve a title for investing in his team? If he has the means, it would be negligent of him to say "I need to stop for the sake of every other team". 

Because he's not the one playing the games so he doesn't "deserve" a title.

Also, equating spending as much as he does to earn a title is unfair to all but a handful of teams because nobody else would ever be able to spend that much. 

19 minutes ago, Entendu said:

Why doesn't he deserve a title for investing in his team? If he has the means, it would be negligent of him to say "I need to stop for the sake of every other team". 

I think it's a larger competitive balance question. The Mets luxury tax is going to be higher than 8 teams opening day 2022 payrolls, and a stone's throw for 2 more. That's 1/3rd the league whose budget is, he's just paying a penalty on. Say what you will about Miami/Cleveland/Tampa/Oakland/Pittsburgh/etc. being cheap, but this is a big delta and Bruce spending $40m more dollars next year keeps Miami in this sphere.

Mets 2023 payroll and luxury is currently 1.6x the top 2022 payroll. He's running peak Dodgers plus another $130m. Just for perspective, 12 teams ran $130m and under payrolls in 2022. Also are they even paying Bauer on suspension? So It actually may be more as Bauer's contract was enormous.

So you outspend everyone, let's say it works and Mets win 3 of next 5 world series. What do fans of the sports think? Is this fun (even for some Mets fans?), just having some wealthy guy outspend teams by double or quadruple and overall radically lower interest and the product (which baseball is already in decline with younger audiences). Other fan bases aren't really going to care if there is no chance from day 1 - why should you? This could be half the league very quickly. Look at college football, I believe viewership in some of the premium games has been down way as everyone is really tired of Alabama/Ohio State/Georgia/Clemson and the Rose Bowl issued a press release that they weren't going to pick Ohio State if they didn't make the playoffs as their fan base (justifiably) wasn't selling their allotment because it was the same bowl over and over and over. Variety is the spice of life(?) and the league needs to maintain interest and not just have it be the Mets Mets Mets (which is what these payrolls will do). 

Basically, it's going to hurt the sport and that's not just a sad comment from a poor Marlins fan begging for some salary. The Dodgers spending $300m is one thing. The Mets spending $436m and counting is a whole different monster and really is knocking out half the league or more. Something is going to have to give here, so I do think we want to root for Steve to keep spending as that will only get us to a salary cap/floor faster. The union may oppose, but if the league suffers, they too need to take the longview of longevity. 

1 hour ago, TaiwanAstros said:

In the regular season we say it's still early, in the off-season we say it's still early.

We are number one.  Everyone else is number two, or lower.

  • Author
On 12/9/2022 at 6:13 PM, SilverBullet said:

The Athletic gave us a B grade on the offseason so far, based on good managerial and coaching hires and on doing well on all those minor trades thus far. 

I guess it's hard to say they've failed when there's still time to do more. Maybe it's more like "good job on what you have done, bad job on what you haven't done." And that kinda sums up Kim Ng in general, the moves she makes are mostly fine, it's the lack of moves that concern us.

This is beyond generous.  C at best.  As they've ignored the major league product....you know, the team they're supposed to be building...

 

On 12/11/2022 at 11:52 AM, SilverBullet said:

Yes ultimately the Cohen thing is gonna create issues for the sport overall. The payroll gaps now are laughable. This will eventually create change. 

But wait until Mets fans get reminded that the payroll doesn't determine game results. Gonna be hilarious. 

 

Except who's going to drive the change?

The union is loving these contracts, as it's mega-money for its players.

The owners will be split, as the bigger teams will still want to have big payrolls, and the smaller ones want limits.

7 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

There goes that idea.

I don't even know how they have the prospects to do this. This must indicate they are resigning Swanson (or Correa!) so they can make Grissom and Contreras available to the A's.

 

This division is getting beyond ridiculous and I hope a large feeling of hopelessness is befalling Bruce so he immediately sells tomorrow.

  • Author
25 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Screenshot 2022-12-12 at 3.29.22 PM.png

It is interesting to see the Marlins chase Turner after his comments last offseason

He's not signing here anyway.

 

Sure, money talks.  But if he had close offers from the Dodgers and Marlins, why would he come here?

They can't do nothing and then be shocked when 1) players don't come here, or 2) we have to overpay for middle-tier FA's.  You have to overpay when you're not competitive on the field.

Edited by rmc523

22 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Screenshot 2022-12-12 at 3.29.22 PM.png

It is interesting to see the Marlins chase Turner after his comments last offseason

Its embarrassing that they have to sign him for any hope to save face...more embarrassing if he accepts the offer.

Marlins always find new and creative ways to become the joke.

6 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

I think it's a larger competitive balance question. The Mets luxury tax is going to be higher than 8 teams opening day 2022 payrolls, and a stone's throw for 2 more. That's 1/3rd the league whose budget is, he's just paying a penalty on. Say what you will about Miami/Cleveland/Tampa/Oakland/Pittsburgh/etc. being cheap, but this is a big delta and Bruce spending $40m more dollars next year keeps Miami in this sphere.

Mets 2023 payroll and luxury is currently 1.6x the top 2022 payroll. He's running peak Dodgers plus another $130m. Just for perspective, 12 teams ran $130m and under payrolls in 2022. Also are they even paying Bauer on suspension? So It actually may be more as Bauer's contract was enormous.

So you outspend everyone, let's say it works and Mets win 3 of next 5 world series. What do fans of the sports think? Is this fun (even for some Mets fans?), just having some wealthy guy outspend teams by double or quadruple and overall radically lower interest and the product (which baseball is already in decline with younger audiences). Other fan bases aren't really going to care if there is no chance from day 1 - why should you? This could be half the league very quickly. Look at college football, I believe viewership in some of the premium games has been down way as everyone is really tired of Alabama/Ohio State/Georgia/Clemson and the Rose Bowl issued a press release that they weren't going to pick Ohio State if they didn't make the playoffs as their fan base (justifiably) wasn't selling their allotment because it was the same bowl over and over and over. Variety is the spice of life(?) and the league needs to maintain interest and not just have it be the Mets Mets Mets (which is what these payrolls will do). 

Basically, it's going to hurt the sport and that's not just a sad comment from a poor Marlins fan begging for some salary. The Dodgers spending $300m is one thing. The Mets spending $436m and counting is a whole different monster and really is knocking out half the league or more. Something is going to have to give here, so I do think we want to root for Steve to keep spending as that will only get us to a salary cap/floor faster. The union may oppose, but if the league suffers, they too need to take the longview of longevity. 

We'd go back to the days of the Yankees being the evil empire. The postseason is all about who gets hot at the right time, so I'm not worried about the game being boring. It'll be about who can take down those evil Mets. It'll be a nice storyline for a sport that hasn't really had one in a while.

 

It's being reported DBacks are talking Varsho to Houston.

Now that's the one where Kim/FO needs to put on their big boy and girl pants and muscle out every other team for a CF.

4 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

It's being reported DBacks are talking Varsho to Houston.

Now that's the one where Kim/FO needs to put on their big boy and girl pants and muscle out every other team for a CF.

They won't.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.