Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Catching upgrade (Who can Fish target?)

Featured Replies

26 minutes ago, Michael said:

SirMarlinsLou.

I think you mean SirMarlinsWog.

Edited by SirFishFan

Just going to throw this out there.... Real.. Real recognize real.

JK, FML Realmutto would be clutch right now but they should have atleast taken a look at Gary Sanchez on the same deal he signed with the Mets. No one is going to give up a decent catcher. Better to keep as a backup no matter what.

Hate to say it but we should have tried to get Sean Murphy from Oakland. Are there any 1B we can convert to a catcher in our system?

6 minutes ago, Piazza31 said:

they should have atleast taken a look at Gary Sanchez on the same deal he signed with the Mets. No one is going to give up a decent catcher. Better to keep as a backup no matter what.

Sanchez stinks, don't see the point

  • Author
1 minute ago, Piazza31 said:

Just going to throw this out there.... Real.. Real recognize real.

JK, FML Realmutto would be clutch right now but they should have atleast taken a look at Gary Sanchez on the same deal he signed with the Mets. No one is going to give up a decent catcher. Better to keep as a backup no matter what.

Hate to say it but we should have tried to get Sean Murphy from Oakland. Are there any 1B we can convert to a catcher in our system?

We can't even convert a 1b into a 1b! LOL

1 hour ago, SirFishFan said:

If Marlins would have gotten Jean Segura and Yuli Gurriel in 2019-2021 the team would have been vastly improved. It always seems like the Marlins get formerly good players right at the tail end of their careers when they’re on a big decline. Like when you wait until some groceries are on sale but it’s because they’re about to expire in a few days.

But that’s the story of most of the Marlins history. Either have great players right at the beginning of their careers and still developing and then trade them right when they’re about to reach peak years and then they go to other teams and play their best years of baseball after the Marlins did all the work of developing them. It’s like the Marlins have always been a farm team for the rest of MLB team’s future star players.

Either that or they get formerly good or great players when they’re close to retirement like Andre Dawson, Tim Raines (but those two gets a pass since the Marlins weren’t around in their peak years), Luis Gonzalez, Ichiro, Curtis Granderson, Aaron Boone and others.

 

Only very few times have the Marlins had star players in their peak years.. Most of ‘97 team, Pudge in 2003, Stanton for a couple of years, m and right now with Sandy and maybe Arraez.

But yeah, the point remains, most of the time the Marlins have good and great players either at the start of their careers while they are developing into star players but get traded or leave in free agency right on the cusp of their peak years, or they get former superstar and good players right when they are close to retiring.

 

A lot of great players have played for the Marlins. They just haven't been great players in the time they wore Marlins uniforms. 

10 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Maybe Marlins park was built on a burial ground lol.

I think it was more of hauling Ali out there on opening day for the new park that has cursed us forever.

12 minutes ago, hovertical said:

I think it was more of hauling Ali out there on opening day for the new park that has cursed us forever.

That's true.  It was like "oh that's cool" and then you quickly realized his deteriorated condition and they awkwardly slowly drove him out

7 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

That's true.  It was like "oh that's cool" and then you quickly realized his deteriorated condition and they awkwardly slowly drove him out

The PA guy having to start an "Ali" chant while the cart was about 1/3 of the way there ... that wasn't too fun.

  • 3 weeks later...
On 5/16/2023 at 12:10 PM, rmc523 said:

Maybe Marlins park was built on a burial ground lol.

Yeah the Orange Bowl, and the Hurricanes Dynasty.

To be fair, 90 percent of Marlins fans themselves wouldn't have even known what Nick Fortes looked like until like a month ago.

1 hour ago, Valid said:

To be fair, 90 percent of Marlins fans themselves wouldn't have even known what Nick Fortes looked like until like a month ago.

90% of Marlins fans wouldn't have known what Sandy looked like.

BUT NOW THAT THE TEAM IS WINNING A TINY BIT

7 minutes ago, Michael said:

90% of Marlins fans wouldn't have known what Sandy looked like.

BUT NOW THAT THE TEAM IS WINNING A TINY BIT

BuT LIke ITs AgaInst tHe As and RoYalz so iT doeSnT COUNt uNLeSs iTS the BRAveS or METs beaTing tHose TeAms

2 minutes ago, Michael said:

Back to the thread topic - Giants just optioned Joey Bart.

I am aroused and so should Kim

2 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

I have some photos that I need framed, give me his info

Check VIP forum on alternate site

The main area of concern at catcher isn’t the position but the bat.  Just fix it by adding an elite bat at a different position. Focusing on a position in this case when it’s not the problem will cost more capital (prospects) for an already weak return just because you want to replace a bat.  Replacing bad with average only keeps you average. 
 

I’d go after an elite bat in fix the main problem.  Devers at 3B would be great. 

23 minutes ago, Zeal4teal said:

The main area of concern at catcher isn’t the position but the bat.  Just fix it by adding an elite bat at a different position. Focusing on a position in this case when it’s not the problem will cost more capital (prospects) for an already weak return just because you want to replace a bat.  Replacing bad with average only keeps you average. 
 

I’d go after an elite bat in fix the main problem.  Devers at 3B would be great. 

Devers just signed a massive extension (10/314) with Boston over the winter. There's next to no chance the Red Sox move him, and even if they do, that's a whole lotttt of money for a guy who is pretty bad defensively and is only a good (not elite) bat.

1 minute ago, Valid said:

Devers just signed a massive extension (10/314) with Boston over the winter. There's next to no chance the Red Sox move him, and even if they do, that's a whole lotttt of money for a guy who is pretty bad defensively and is only a good (not elite) bat.

I’m pretty he sure he’s elite but that’s a different topic.  Devers is a bad example you’re right.   

2 hours ago, Zeal4teal said:

I’m pretty he sure he’s elite but that’s a different topic.  Devers is a bad example you’re right.   

He is a lifetime .280/.339/.510 hitter. That's really good, but it's definitely not elite, and he has actually been fairly inconsistent throughout his career. The cost for him both in terms of players and dollars would be wayyy too much.

Edited by Valid

45 minutes ago, Valid said:

He is a lifetime .280/.339/.510 hitter. That's really good, but it's definitely not elite, and he has actually been fairly inconsistent throughout his career. The cost for him both in terms of players and dollars would be wayyy too much.

Validate Dick Wolf GIF by Wolf Entertainment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.