June 8, 20233 yr 8 minutes ago, Rydawg said: Old dogs can learn new tricks! I'll use metrics to support my argument when need be. Other than that, metrics suck! 😆 I just can't imagine Wilson Fisk ever using an emoji.
June 8, 20233 yr also, for those of you seemingly taking this as a personal threat against Jazz, it's not. None of us want him OFF the team so the only reason this thread is odd is because ya'll are blowing it out of proportion like someone drilled ya mama. concern here is more along the lines of Jazz will be replacing someone higher up in the lineup so he'll end up pushing DLC or Sanchez down further and getting those guys, who have been fueling this run, fewer at bats. Jazz hasn't done shit this season to show he should be batting higher in the lineup at this juncture but I think we all feel like he'll immediately be given a top 3 slotting. I'm 99.99% certain nobody on here would prefer Davis or Hampson is a preferable start over Jazz in CF, which is where Jazz plays.
June 8, 20233 yr Jazz will be the starting CF when he returns. The only question is where he bats in the lineup. I'd be thrilled if they just plugged him into the 9 hold where Hampson and Davis bat. Don't see why he can't bat 7th, 8th, or 9th.
June 8, 20233 yr 3 minutes ago, TheMarlinsProject said: Jazz will be the starting CF when he returns. The only question is where he bats in the lineup. I'd be thrilled if they just plugged him into the 9 hold where Hampson and Davis bat. Don't see why he can't bat 7th, 8th, or 9th. Rather plug him in 6th and have him work his way back up to the heart of the order. 2B Arraez DH Soler RF Jeezy LF DLC 1B Gurriel CF Chisholm SS Amaya C Fortes / Stallings 3B Segura / Berti / Wendle
June 8, 20233 yr @Zeal4teal is a legend. First post here and he starts up an active debate. That's more than a lot of us can say.
June 8, 20233 yr 32 minutes ago, Rydawg said: Jazz had 14 HR's and an .860 OPS in 216 AB's before he got hurt last year. This is actually my concern with Jazz. He is hurt a lot. Even Stanton didn't get this dinged up. At least not early on.
June 8, 20233 yr 6 minutes ago, Michael said: Rather plug him in 6th and have him work his way back up to the heart of the order. 2B Arraez DH Soler RF Jeezy LF DLC 1B Gurriel CF Chisholm SS Amaya C Fortes / Stallings 3B Segura / Berti / Wendle Acceptable
June 8, 20233 yr 2 minutes ago, Valid said: This is actually my concern with Jazz. He is hurt a lot. Even Stanton didn't get this dinged up. At least not early on. Sure he did! Stanton missed time in 2011 due to hamstring stuff. He missed time in 2012 due to the floating bodies in his knee. He missed time in 2013 due to hamstring stuff. 2014 was a freak accident [heck you, Fiers]. 2015 he broke his hand. Stanton missed a lot of time early. Jazz had a stress fracture in his back and a torn meniscus last year. This year was a freak incident because the ballpark had a random concrete space out underneath the wall that he landed on. Concerning? Sure. But I think he's going to be fine long term.
June 8, 20233 yr Just now, Michael said: Sure he did! Stanton missed time in 2011 due to hamstring stuff. He missed time in 2012 due to the floating bodies in his knee. He missed time in 2013 due to hamstring stuff. 2014 was a freak accident [heck you, Fiers]. 2015 he broke his hand. Stanton missed a lot of time early. Jazz had a stress fracture in his back and a torn meniscus last year. This year was a freak incident because the ballpark had a random concrete space out underneath the wall that he landed on. Concerning? Sure. But I think he's going to be fine long term. I stand corrected then. I thought most of Stanton's missed time came in the back half of his tenure here. Just goes to show how much of a blur most of those years in the 2010s were because this team was so bad. Everything just blended together.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, Valid said: I stand corrected then. I thought most of Stanton's missed time came in the back half of his tenure here. Just goes to show how much of a blur most of those years in the 2010s were because this team was so bad. Everything just blended together. It was pretty constant, yeah. 2017 was the year everything came together.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, Michael said: It was pretty constant, yeah. 2017 was the year everything came together. I would actually argue 2014. He probably would have won MVP that year if not for Fiers. But I'm splitting hairs.
June 8, 20233 yr Just now, Valid said: I would actually argue 2014. He probably would have won MVP that year if not for Fiers. But I'm splitting hairs. I think Kershaw was going to win it regardless but it would have been closer. If we went on a bit more of a hot streak to end the year and Stanton was healthy then we're talking veeery close. But you're right, 2014 was a very complete year for him. Menechino worked wonders with him.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, Valid said: The streak has nothing to do with Jazz's absence and everything to do with guys like Sanchez and DLC getting hot, the starting pitching being stronger overall and Arraez being an unstoppable force. Add Jazz into the mix and the Marlins are even better. Playing the Athletics and Royals also helps
June 8, 20233 yr 10 minutes ago, SonOfJack said: @Zeal4teal is a legend. First post here and he starts up an active debate. That's more than a lot of us can say. shoulda have gone with Zeile4teal -1 but welcome to the board !
June 8, 20233 yr 2 minutes ago, LordMagnus said: Playing the Athletics and Royals also helps They also swept the Angels two series before being Oakland, and Sanchez and DLC were hitting better far before the last couple of series. Arraez has been great all year. Why are the Marlins the only team we do this for? Edited June 8, 20233 yr by Valid
June 8, 20233 yr 15 minutes ago, Michael said: Rather plug him in 6th and have him work his way back up to the heart of the order. 2B Arraez DH Soler RF Jeezy LF DLC 1B Gurriel CF Chisholm SS Amaya C Fortes / Stallings 3B Segura / Berti / Wendle Are you insane? Segura has to bat 6th or 7th. This is the law of the known universe.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, LordMagnus said: Are you insane? Segura has to bat 6th or 7th. This is the law of the known universe. Aw shit you're right! [but srsly Jean 9th might be a decent idea]
June 8, 20233 yr Just now, Valid said: They also swept the Angels two series before being Oakland. Why are the Marlins the only team we do this for? I wasn't expecting them to sweep either team, but when Jazz was playing, the Marlins were playing better teams. So yeah they probably didn't win as much then and has nothing to do with him.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, LordMagnus said: I wasn't expecting them to sweep either team, but when Jazz was playing, the Marlins were playing better teams. So yeah they probably didn't win as much then and has nothing to do with him. Sorry, misunderstood you.
June 8, 20233 yr Author I should have explained my stance on this topic so it wouldn’t have sounded so trollish for some. I think it’s a logical topic because the same should be consider for Avi. Avi shouldn’t get more ABs than Gurriel as he did before being injured. The same goes for Jazz, he shouldn’t be batting 1-4 but rather in the bottom half of the order. He should also be out of the lineup in a lefty matchup so yes, in some cases I’d rather have Hampton, Berti or Davis out there before KJazz. Lastly & most concerning is his k-rate and how it seems “statistically” to spread within the team itself. I don’t think Jazz makes this team better if he continues with no progress. I think that’s a fair assessment. Edited June 8, 20233 yr by Zeal4teal
June 8, 20233 yr 42 minutes ago, Zeal4teal said: I should have explained my stance on this topic so it wouldn’t have sounded so trollish for some. I think it’s a logical topic because the same should be consider for Avi. Avi shouldn’t get more ABs than Gurriel as he did before being injured. The same goes for Jazz, he shouldn’t be batting 1-4 but rather in the bottom half of the order. He should also be out of the lineup in a lefty matchup so yes, in some cases I’d rather have Hampton, Berti or Davis out there before KJazz. Lastly & most concerning is his k-rate and how it seems “statistically” to spread within the team itself. I don’t think Jazz makes this team better if he continues with no progress. I think that’s a fair assessment. Bat him lower in the lineup until his performance warrants moving him up. Avi should be batting left bench, which I believe is the furthest away from home plate.
June 8, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, Zeal4teal said: I should have explained my stance on this topic so it wouldn’t have sounded so trollish for some. I think it’s a logical topic because the same should be consider for Avi. Avi shouldn’t get more ABs than Gurriel as he did before being injured. The same goes for Jazz, he shouldn’t be batting 1-4 but rather in the bottom half of the order. He should also be out of the lineup in a lefty matchup so yes, in some cases I’d rather have Hampton, Berti or Davis out there before KJazz. Lastly & most concerning is his k-rate and how it seems “statistically” to spread within the team itself. I don’t think Jazz makes this team better if he continues with no progress. I think that’s a fair assessment. Forgive me if I disagree with your assessment. Last season, the average K rate in MLB was around 24%. Jazz's K rate was around 28%. His K rate was a little higher than league average while OPSing .860. If Jazz can OPS .860 again, I don't care too much about his K rate. He also played excellent defense at 2nd. You're judging him harshly on a small sample size in a year where he was learning a new position and after a long layoff due to missing half the season. Also, in no universe should Hampson, Davis or Berti take at bats away from Jazz. Anyway, welcome to the blog.
June 8, 20233 yr 10 minutes ago, Rydawg said: Forgive me if I disagree with your assessment. Last season, the average K rate in MLB was around 24%. Jazz's K rate was around 28%. His K rate was a little higher than league average while OPSing .860. If Jazz can OPS .860 again, I don't care too much about his K rate. He also played excellent defense at 2nd. You're judging him harshly on a small sample size in a year where he was learning a new position and after a long layoff due to missing half the season. Also, in no universe should Hampson, Davis or Berti take at bats away from Jazz. Anyway, welcome to the blog. i don't think he played "excellent" defense at second and I think he's actually become a better CF than he ever was a second baseman. He'd make some great plays at second but man he'd make a lot of crap ones too - regardless if anyone here actually thinks Berti, Hampson, or Davis is gonna take at bats away from him (not counting rest days of course) then they should be banned. This whole thread is filled with a lot of bizarrely overreaching responses to a legit question. It should more be looked at who Jazz will be stealing at bats from in the lineup (by virtue of where in the lineup he's hitting) versus any defensive alignment because he's unquestionably the best CF we have and will 100% be playing there when he's ready to go again.
June 8, 20233 yr 4 minutes ago, hovertical said: i don't think he played "excellent" defense at second and I think he's actually become a better CF than he ever was a second baseman. He'd make some great plays at second but man he'd make a lot of crap ones too - regardless if anyone here actually thinks Berti, Hampson, or Davis is gonna take at bats away from him (not counting rest days of course) then they should be banned. This whole thread is filled with a lot of bizarrely overreaching responses to a legit question. It should more be looked at who Jazz will be stealing at bats from in the lineup (by virtue of where in the lineup he's hitting) versus any defensive alignment because he's unquestionably the best CF we have and will 100% be playing there when he's ready to go again. He did grade out well at second but some routine plays he'd make some easy mistakes. Which is why I suggested the move to center to begin with ... lol.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.