Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jazz to Yankees

Featured Replies

2 minutes ago, Admin said:

Keep the updates coming every single day, don't only update when he does well

had Jazz always hit like this here maybe he wouldn't have been traded and the team would have actually been winning?

just a silly goose of a thought!

10 minutes ago, hovertical said:

had Jazz always hit like this here maybe he wouldn't have been traded and the team would have actually been winning?

just a silly goose of a thought!

They made the playoffs last year and jazz was a big part of the run in September we had! 😸

35 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

They made the playoffs last year and jazz was a big part of the run in September we had! 😸

How nice of him to decide to play again after being on the IL again for 3 months like usual.

6 hours ago, hovertical said:

How nice of him to decide to play again after being on the IL again for 3 months like usual.

It really wasn't his fault that the FO was cheap and didn't have padding on the chain link fence in CF.

7 hours ago, hovertical said:

had Jazz always hit like this here maybe he wouldn't have been traded and the team would have actually been winning?

just a silly goose of a thought!

Maybe if the owner wasn't cheap and had other hitters around him, he would be able to do what he's doing in NY.  I mean, that's also a valid thought, no?

22 minutes ago, Rydawg said:

Maybe if the owner wasn't cheap and had other hitters around him, he would be able to do what he's doing in NY.  I mean, that's also a valid thought, no?

There are other hitters and then there are Judge, Soto, and to a lesser extent, Stanton...(who can still put up Jazz-like production)

18 hours ago, Rydawg said:

Maybe if the owner wasn't cheap and had other hitters around him, he would be able to do what he's doing in NY.  I mean, that's also a valid thought, no?

On what planet were the Marlins having Judge, Soto and Stanton all in the same lineup? We literally couldn't even keep one of them.

If that's what it takes for Jazz to actually produce consistently then we won't miss him at all.

Edited by Valid

12 minutes ago, Valid said:

On what planet were the Marlins having Judge, Soto and Stanton all in the same lineup? We literally couldn't even keep one of them.

If that's what it takes for Jazz to actually produce consistently then we won't miss him at all.

In the end, Jazz had PLENTY of chances to become a superstar in Miami and he NEVER got there. He might do well elsewhere, but it just wasnt the case in Miami. 

He was good when he wasn't injured but never had a special season. It just flat out didn't make sense to keep him here as Bruce wasn't going to pay what he wanted and this was the only season where he wasn't injured so he could actually be moved lol. 

He's a fun player but unless surrounded by legit all-stars he's not that franchise cornerstone we need. 

7 minutes ago, hovertical said:

In the end, Jazz had PLENTY of chances to become a superstar in Miami and he NEVER got there. He might do well elsewhere, but it just wasnt the case in Miami. 

He was good when he wasn't injured but never had a special season. It just flat out didn't make sense to keep him here as Bruce wasn't going to pay what he wanted and this was the only season where he wasn't injured so he could actually be moved lol. 

He's a fun player but unless surrounded by legit all-stars he's not that franchise cornerstone we need. 

I’m not really sure what’s so hard to understand about this.  Jazz didn’t become a new player overnight, he had every chance to produce like this here and didn’t.  He didn’t develop into the ultimate version of his talent in 24 hours on a new team.  Wether he wasn’t playing that hard for Miami or he no longer has the pressure to be The Guy with Judge and Soto there, but either way the situation wasn’t changing in Miami while he was here so we needed to trade him.  I’m happy for him and glad he is doing well in New York, I’m rooting for him, but it was clear he would never do this here.  It honestly would have been malpractice for Bendix to hold on to him two more seasons, and then lose him for nothing while this same thing happened.

7 hours ago, Valid said:

On what planet were the Marlins having Judge, Soto and Stanton all in the same lineup? We literally couldn't even keep one of them.

If that's what it takes for Jazz to actually produce consistently then we won't miss him at all.

The point is that he had no help at all in Miami.  He doesn't need those guys per say, but he did need help. He never got it. He had total garbage around him here. 

7 hours ago, DTrainSTA said:

I’m not really sure what’s so hard to understand about this.  Jazz didn’t become a new player overnight, he had every chance to produce like this here and didn’t.  He didn’t develop into the ultimate version of his talent in 24 hours on a new team.  Wether he wasn’t playing that hard for Miami or he no longer has the pressure to be The Guy with Judge and Soto there, but either way the situation wasn’t changing in Miami while he was here so we needed to trade him.  I’m happy for him and glad he is doing well in New York, I’m rooting for him, but it was clear he would never do this here.  It honestly would have been malpractice for Bendix to hold on to him two more seasons, and then lose him for nothing while this same thing happened.

I totally disagree that we "needed" to trade. We only "needed" to trade him because Bruce is cheap.

On 7/30/2024 at 8:35 PM, SirFishFan said:

Jazz is just being added to the list of former Marlins who left the team and all of a sudden reached their full potential:

Yelich,

Jazz,

Donovan Solano,

Ozuna,

plus many more I can’t remember off the top of my head.

 

Cody Ross in the playoffs with SF

4 minutes ago, Rydawg said:

I totally disagree that we "needed" to trade. We only "needed" to trade him because Bruce is cheap.

Maybe, but he is cheap and it’s not changing, so we would have just let him walk in two years and got nothing in return.  He likely would have kept being a decent player with star potential, and then broke out on his next team.  So we either trade him while he has some value now and get some guys who could end up being under team control for six year, or we keep him and he hits .240-.260 with 18 home runs and 25-30 stolen bases for two years, signs with the Yankees/Dodgers/Phillies and is suddenly a star and we don’t have the three guys we got.  Best case is having a new owner who will actually extend folks and pay guys to come here but it’s just not reality.

2 hours ago, Rydawg said:

The point is that he had no help at all in Miami.  He doesn't need those guys per say, but he did need help. He never got it. He had total garbage around him here. 

Player A: .262/.322/.445 (Best year: 3.5 WAR)

Player B: .248/.311/.447 (Best year: 2.6 WAR)

Who are you taking?

Spoiler

Player A is Cody Ross

Player B is Jazz Chisholm

12 hours ago, Rydawg said:

The point is that he had no help at all in Miami.  He doesn't need those guys per say, but he did need help. He never got it. He had total garbage around him here. 

I don't disagree, but counterargument here....

 

If we're not going to get him that help in the rest of the lineup in the next 2 years before he's gone, why keep him?

10 hours ago, Valid said:

Player A: .262/.322/.445 (Best year: 3.5 WAR)

Player B: .248/.311/.447 (Best year: 2.6 WAR)

Who are you taking?

  Reveal hidden contents

Player A is Cody Ross

Player B is Jazz Chisholm

Cody was 27 when he had that year (and was like 2 WAR year before that) and jazz is currently 26 🧐 . I love them both either way

4 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

Cody was 27 when he had that year (and was like 2 WAR year before that) and jazz is currently 26 🧐 . I love them both either way

Cody wasn't viewed as a "star," though. Just a good role player.

Also Cody was a 2.2 WAR in 2007 only because he missed more than half the season with an injury. He may have ended up being a 4.0 WAR player that year had he not gotten hurt (yes I understand the same argument can be made for Jazz in 2022, but again, very different reputations for both players).

Edited by Valid

11 minutes ago, Valid said:

Cody wasn't viewed as a "star," though. Just a good role player.

Also Cody was a 2.2 WAR in 2007 only because he missed more than half the season with an injury. He may have ended up being a 4.0 WAR player that year had he not gotten hurt (yes I understand the same argument can be made for Jazz in 2022, but again, very different reputations for both players).

Somewhat related the Cody Ross playoff HRs with the SFG during those playoffs one of my fav non marlin moments in baseball 

12 hours ago, Valid said:

Player A: .262/.322/.445 (Best year: 3.5 WAR)

Player B: .248/.311/.447 (Best year: 2.6 WAR)

Who are you taking?

  Hide contents

Player A is Cody Ross

Player B is Jazz Chisholm

My point was that Jazz didn't have help.  Cody Ross was in some really powerful offenses in Miami. Not sure what point you were trying to make?

6 minutes ago, Rydawg said:

My point was that Jazz didn't have help.  Cody Ross was in some really powerful offenses in Miami. Not sure what point you were trying to make?

also, if he's an actual star player, or franchise cornerstone - those types of guys produce special seasons without any help.  so again, Jazz was just a good player - but nothing in the franchise changing mold. 

  • Author
1 minute ago, Iowa said:

Jazz is a superstar.

 - Jazz Chisholm, Jr.

 

 

In seriousness - he 100% has the potential to be a superstar, so long as he gets his ego out of the way. Jazz' biggest weakness is Jazz, as we've said. Once he gets out of his own way, he'll truly take off.

47 minutes ago, Michael said:

 - Jazz Chisholm, Jr.

 

 

In seriousness - he 100% has the potential to be a superstar, so long as he gets his ego out of the way. Jazz' biggest weakness is Jazz, as we've said. Once he gets out of his own way, he'll truly take off.

And not get injured.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.