Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

jonnylons

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jonnylons

  1. jonnylons replied to BIG Z's topic in Miami Marlins
    I dont want White. I am not all that thrilled about him, he is a mediocre player at this point and cannot carry a team. Castro, however, could be a very vital offensive player - especially considering he is a catcher. Catchers with his offensive ability are rare these days. Keep him, and win out with Cabs. It would be smarter for this team to keep Cabs in LF, keep getting him experience and try and win with what they have. The Marlins dont have to win it all this year, it is going to take a long period of winning, not just one season, to repair the damage done to this market. If we are going to pull the trigger on a deal to help this team win, get serious and go for a player with more - Giles - or even Guillen or Drew.
  2. So basically, parlay prospects to the Pirates (which would net us Drew in 3 way deal) for Freddy Garcia? I dont think we need a starter as much as we need another strong bat. Drew has big time ability, but does have health issues. But if we got Garcia, our pitching would improve immensely, even better than it already is and we would have arguably one of the better/deeper rotations in all of baseball. Very good idea, but I think we should stick with Drew, and while I am dreaming, deal Encarnacion as part of a package deal for Giles. Then we would be very, very deadly.
  3. I read about this Drew deal too. I think this would be a very good deal for us, depending on what prospects the Pirates wanted. The other thing I think we have to look at, and would make for a lively debate, is the possibilities with Encarnacion. Say we get Drew, Cabs goes down to AAA. Next season, you want to bring in Cabs - possibly as a starter - which means En is expendable. You could turn around and deal him (or lose him outright, I think he has a 1 year deal too...). In fact, I would be curious to see us deal Encarnacion for Giles. There might be more needed from the Pirates, but putting Giles in RF and leaving Cabs in LF would be a strong upgrade too. Heck, you can even still deal for Drew in this 3 way deal and end up with Drew, Giles and Pierre in OF (2 lefty with power!) and still have Cabs in AAA! The Marlins have a lot of opportunity here...very interesting... :thumbup :w00t
  4. Drew would be a great fit here, and would give us a pleasant dilemma - what to do with Encarnacion and Cabrera? Obviously, keep Cab and trade Encarnacion - if you want to keep Drew (and I think we would). I would make that deal if we werent in playoff contention, but I also think Castillo and one of our starting pitchers is a lot for just Drew and Hart. Drew seems to be a hot rumor right now...Sun-Sentinel mentioned him in a 3 way deal with Pittsburgh, us, and St. Louis. Suppan to Cards, Drew to us, and we deal prospects to Pirates.
  5. If Giles would rather go to SD than here, he is just blind. The Padres have a long way to go to make it to our level - they have to beat out the Dodgers, D Backs and Giants first. We are in arguably one of the toughest divisions in baseball, but we have bona fide star pitchers on this team and a young nucleus to build around and win with. Giles should be thanking his lucky stars to leave Pitt to come here. But some guys are just retarded - I mean, look at his brother, Marcus. That guy is no genius either... Anyway, I hope Giles does come here if we are going to make a deal. Otherwise, keep the team together and let everyone else sort out the trash that is left. Sanders, White...oooh. Guillen is a good possibility. And Odom, if we are going to keep people next year, I would rather see Penny and Castillo gone from that group you mentioned. They can be easiliy replaced, Lee is much harder to replace than you think. That will take at least 2 years for Stokes to get here.
  6. If something does happen, I think it will be right around the deadline. I think all these rumors are not going to happen and if something does, it will be something we least expected. That is usually how these things work. The Yankees are asking too much for Mondesi and I am sure the Reds were asking too much for Guillen. At this point, that is what they are supposed to do. You wait until the last minute to make a deal, and try and drum up the best deal possible. You have to start high and bid down - that is why I think we cant necessarily rule out Giles or even Klesko. I dont know if we will get them, but we could very well make a significant move like that. I dont want to see us take on White or Sanders and send Cabrera down though. If we are going to waste the time in making a trade, at least make it a significant upgrade - and that is what is dragging this thing on I believe. Besides, some of these teams have to just face they are sellers and not buyers. We are buyers, for the first time in 5 years... :w00t
  7. Sham, I agree with you that we shouldnt deal Castro. But the only thing I can make of the Marlins continued interest in trading him, or what seems to be a recent trend anyway, is that perhaps they are working with Pudge to keep him around. Pudge may just want to stay put, he is close to home, feels comfortable, and sees the Marlins FO took a bit of a chance on him where other teams wouldnt. If the Marlins deal Castro, I wont accept anything less than Giles in the deal AND Pudge would have to be back next year. Anything else is a step backwards.
  8. I think Pavano has come throug very nicely for us. I always liked this guy, even back with the Expos (when he was traded to them for Pedro). He always had front line ability, but never could stay healthy. He is still young, and could be a strong starter for years to come. Truthfully, if I had to pick between Pavano and Penny, I would take Pavano. Penny has more value being traded anyway, and with some of these propects down on the farm, we could possibly make up for losing Penny's talent - not to mention Pavano may cost us less money over the long haul. The other guy I absolutley love is Pierre. This guy is an excellent ballplayer, he is like Counsel with more ability. Just a smart, 'heady' ballplayer who is going to get better. It seems like he has improved all season. I think he could even end up with 70+ SBs - that would be very nice.
  9. I admit, I was intrigued by Mondesi at first, thinking he could bring a big bat to our lineup, but it appears he is not an upgrade at this point. I just hope we dont make a trade just to make a trade at this point. I think the only player I feel we should deal for is Giles, and that depends on what the Pirates want in return. We may have to give up Bautista to get him, and I am not that thrilled about that. I think we keep the current team intact and keep our future intact as well. We are improving, and at this stage that is a success for this current ownership group. Here is another thought that occured to me, but it may be along the same lines as damning the future for now. We could trade AJ Burnett, straight up even, for Giles. We have some good young arms in the minors who may be ready by the time AJ is, and Giles would certainly play a lot more between now and then. I dont want to give up AJ, but it is a thought.
  10. I dont want us to deal Castro unless we are keeping Pudge. The way things are going, who knows. But Sanders is a better choice than White. Here are some stats, for those of you who need numbers: Sanders - no one on .276 .945OPS 12HR 152ABs runners on .228 .674OPS 127ABs RISP .273 .861OPS 5HR 77ABs He actually gets better with RISP than when runners are just on. Also, not too much difference between his hitting with RISP and no one on. White - no one on .270 .794 9HR 174ABs runners on ..277 .790 7HR 159ABs RISP .222 .709 5HR 90ABs Gets better with runners on, but fails when RISP. Could be good at top of lineup, but we seem to have that area set. We need someone at the bottom to knock in runs, Sanders seems to be a better fit, based on stats. I also like intangibles like experience and chemistry, I think Sanders is a strong vet who could help out in those two areas. White has never been consistent and his career has been indicative of that - so his credibility would not be as great as Sanders by my estimation.
  11. Sham, sorry, but when I see something inconsistent in an argument, I expose it so that I make sure I am understanding it right. Perhaps I just dont understand your point, but having many 'great' baseball minds think one thing and you follow suit just because they do shows that you are not an independent thinker and shows that you truly dont understand what they are theorizing. If it is luck when a hitter gets a hit when a guy is on base, then if follows that the guy who got on base got lucky to get a hit to get on base in the first place. After all, how can you have skill be built on top of luck? By that I mean, if a guy gets a hit, which is a skill, he is going to get on base. Therefore, when a guy is on base, he did so according to a skill he possesses. Then, when a guy comes up, gets a hit when that hitter is on base, he is still excercising a skill - getting a hit - and knocks the guy on base in. I see why you want to call it luck, but it is inconsistent with how you define a skill in the first place. It means the art of getting a hit is luck, because how could it not be luck if you knock a runner in and not luck when you get a hit with no one on? And if a guy routinely keeps getting hits with a runner on base, he seems to demonstrate a trend that can be detected by stats. At that point, when does one acknowledge there is some skill involved? Or is this particular hitter just more 'lucky' than everyone else? That would mean Pudge is much more 'luckier' than Lee. I think you misunderstand the point. I think some guys may get more OPPORTUNITY to hit with runners on, and that is what is being deemed 'luck'. But that can be dismissed when you consider the hitters that are on the team in that particular lineup... Look, I can go on all day. I will stop. I think you get my point. Dont be so quick to toss yourself into a category jsut because it is different, controversial. That does not denote somekind of premium on intellect and surely not on genius or even wisdom. 'Great' minds? Sounds like greatly fractured minds to me, that is all...interesting debate though. Please dont think I am trying to make your point insignificant, I just fail to see the logic in it. :confused
  12. This may make you re-think your position on Mondesi, as it has mine. Mondesi is batting .184 with runners on (174ABs), .154 with RISP. Batting in the 5th adn 6th spots, he has been productive (in the .300's), but most of his ABs have been in the 8th spot. He is a better hitter with no one on than with runners on. He makes Lee look clutch. Mondesi is a gaping hole in the Yankees lineup, making too much money with no future. I'll pass. Now White? .277 with runners on (with no one on, .270). .222 with RISP. a lot of his success (.299) has come in the 3 hole. We would have to move him down, but he seems a better option than Mondesi right now. Rank him above Mondesi at this point.
  13. Odom has a point though. Downrodeo, if Lee was batting .800 with bases loaded, you would be all over it. So would you Wild Card. The fact is, you Lee-lovers tried to show how well he was doing in certain situations of RISP in another thread. I shot it down based on how few ABs that is. Fact - Lee is a worse hitter when guys are on base. Pudge is leading the league with a .400+ AVG with RISP. Lowell is a better hitter when there are runners on base. These are the guys you keep around. Lee is hardly irreplaceable. That is a fact. Now, two things. I am glad you compared Lee's stats to Thome's stats (overall), because I thought before teh season began Thome was overrated and over-priced. I wanted to compare the two to show a) that Lee is not as bad as some would have you think, and b) that Thome is not as good as some would have you think. You can make an argument that Lee is the best 1B in our division...and it seems you are intending that. Not much argument from me about that. Having said that, Wild Card, I got to call you out on one more thing. How can you compare Thome's AVG with RISP (.277) with Lee's (.248) and say there isnt that much of a difference??!! That is 29 points lower! Sure, out of a hundred ABs, that means roughly 2-3 less hits from Lee. But if it were that simple, .250 batters would be in the same category as .280 hitters. Also, look at the RBI difference - 45 to 36. That is 9 more RBI from Thome, production that could potentially netted us 9 more wins. Now, I am not someone who believes stats so much, but I am hesitant to say that there really isnt that much difference between Thome and Lee with RISP. I think that is generalizing it too.
  14. I think Mondesi is a better acquisition than White. I would like for us to stick with Cab and TH in platoon (or at least righty, lefty matchup) but I think if you have a chance to go out and get another quality bat and not give up too much to get it, do it. It all depends on who the Yankees want for Mondesi - they may not want much b/c he is retiring after this season and is making a lot of money. Plus, he is whining about PT, which with us he certaily would get. I think Mondesi in our lineup gives our offense a huge boost - teams would have to take notice. You send Cabs back down to tear up AAA until next year. I think that would be a very solid move. It just goes to show you what options are coming up today and we dont know what tomorrow may yield. Maybe the Pirates get desperate and ship Giles off to a team with little in return. But if I were to rank our possibilites, Mondesi would be right behind Giles and right next to Guillen. I dont know if chemistry would be a problem though and breaking up this current team could go either way (by that I mean sending Cab down). I think the players would be excited to get a big bat added to the lineup though.
  15. Capefish and Marlingirl, I agree with both of you. I would like for us to upgrade our LF, but not at the expense of our farm system. I think we may not win the WC with our current roster, but we will come damn close. Look at the way the Marlins are taking it to the Phils...how could you vote against them right now? But I think the cost outweighs the reward at this point.
  16. I just wanted to say this past couple of nights, I have seen the Marlins go from possible contenders to definites. They are playing like a team. In the past, when we had a runner on 3rd and 1st, you could expect an inning-ending double play. But lately, the ball has been ripped through the infield for a base hit to score a run (Pudge did it tonight...). Also, at the end of the game, the Marlins are showing a previously unfathomed killer-instinct to score runs. We had that 8 run rally last night, and the 6 run rally tonight. This team is playing good, real good right now. I know you all see it. I mean, Willis ripped a hit last night and Looper (?!) tonight! Things are going our way - for once! Good job fellas... :thumbup
  17. Then Sham, why not be consistent and say that the word skill does not exist. After all, doesnt a batter get lucky - he doesnt actually hit the ball so much as the ball just happens to strike the bat and fall in for a hit. If the word clutch does not exist, why even say there is skill involved at all? But seriously, I think we should just play with the current team. I think we have enough to keep it close, maybe not overcome the Phils and D Backs to take the top spot, but enough to keep up with them on most nights. Besides, that is how you build a guy like Cabrera up - put him in the heat, and let him take it. He seems to be up to the challenge at this point. And that is also how you build a team up. Guys will have something to fall back on they never had before - experience. I also agree that the only hitter worth giving up prospects at this point is Giles - and his salary is just too steep for our liking and his age makes me suspect (yes, I know now-a-days hitters are staying better longer, but his power is not where it should be). Also, the Pirates asking price may be too high. Guillen would be nice, but I am a little skeptical of a hitter having a break out year. It is hard to depend on him for the stretch run. I do like him, but I dont know enough about his stats when he is not at home - it seems the Reds have a hitter friendly ball park. And White? This guy has yet to be consistent. No thanks.
  18. Compare him to Giambi (which is ridiculous, but you did it) Home .246 8Hr 30RBI .856OPS Road .280 20HR 49RBI 1.064OPS I believe the original comment was something to the effect that Derrek Lee's road numbers are similar to Giambi's overall numbers... Lee on the road: .288 BA, .950 OPS Giambi overall: .262 BA, .961 OPS Doesn't seem like such a ridiculous comparison to me. Of course you dont think that would be such a ridiculous comparison - BECAUSE IT FAVORS YOUR SIDE OF THE ARGUMENT! Why wouldnt you compare Lee's Home numbers to Giambi's overall, would that be ridiculous?? Lee is a good 1B. I am not one of his haters. But I do think that there are those of you (Sham, Wild Card) who oversell him and some of you are just haters of the guy. He plays good D, has excellent power. His biggest flaw is that he K's a lot and usually performs when it doesnt matter. If he cut down on his long swing, he would be able to get his bat through the zone faster and not be so susceptible to inside whiffs. I think that is something that he has been working on, and something that he will, with time, fix. I like Lee, but it isnt like he is irreplaceable - and when it comes to money, I would rather Lowell than Lee. But Sham, I fail to see how only 105 ABs with RISP is a good indication of how he is a good hitter - because he hasnt exactly thrived in those situations in the first place. And it is funny how you guys are trying to gauge how good of a hitter he is in 'clutch' situations when one of you doesnt even believe the word exists...Oh, and he doesnt have a .900 OPS with runners on 2nd, that would be .880 and that is with 43 ABs out of 105 with RISP. Pretty solid, and like you pointed out 45% of the time more or less. But since you like stats, here are some more: with no one on: .262 13HR .868OPS (202AB) with runners on: .247 8HR .824OPS (162AB) Overall, a better hitter with no one on than with someone on base. You cannot argue against that. And as long as you play 1B, you are SUPPOSED to be one of the biggest run producers on the team. Lee is solid, but dont oversell him.
  19. I have been trying to figur that out. I was recently at the Reds mlb board, but I cant find that damn thread now, trying to gauge the likelihood of the Reds dealing guillen to us. I propsed a deal - Wayne, Neal, Grilli, and V Nunez for him. Or maybe 3 of the 4. The Reds fans seemed convinced that they should deal him b/c he is a free agent and they cant afford to re-sign him. They also think his trade value is not as high as it should be because of his impending free agency. I would agree, and I would prefer Guillen to White by far.
  20. I am not a Lee hater, but I cant deal with this. I have to set the record straight. I cant deal with the misiinformation Shamrock and Wild Card are dealing here - a little knowledge is truly a dangerous thing. First off, one of you said Lee is batting .500 with runners on 2nd and 3rd, correct? Well, that is true, but what you failed to mention is that he has only had 4 ABs! 2 for 4??!! C'mon... How about 1st and 3rd? .333, but only 9 AB's... 1st and 2nd? .259, 27 ABs... Bases Loaded? .000, 0 for 8... Now for home vs. road. Home .217 6HR, 27RBI .727 OPS. Road .288 15HR 30RBI .950OPS. Compare him to Giambi (which is ridiculous, but you did it) Home .246 8Hr 30RBI .856OPS Road .280 20HR 49RBI 1.064OPS I fail to see how you could actually compare Lee to Giambi. I even fail to see how you could rely on such scant statistics to prove Lee is a very good hitter, let alone comparing him to a great hitter like Giambi. And Giambi is certainly having a down year. Lee is right about on stride for his typical year. Now, I like Lee for now, and I dont think he is hurting us too much. If we can fill the void in LF, we can make due. But I dont want us to trade the farm to get Giles, that would be way too much. I dont want White either, the guy is garbage. Guillen may be useful, but his price may be too steep too. If they take Neal, Wayne, and Grilli or Bridges, I am fine with that...but I dont know if that is enough.
  21. He is right that in a week, we will know a lot more about the GM's than we do now. LF is our only glaring weakness, but with some of the other teams in front of us, it is going to be tough even if we fill that. I do like the prospect of the Dodgers falling out of the race soon, and I still think that the D Backs/Giants has a long way to go, and anything could happen there. The Phils are a good team and are the team to beat in my mind. We are a damn good team, but I dont know if we have enough to make up all the ground. It is exciting though...
  22. I've always liked Drew. He has big time ability, but probably wont put it all together until late in his career. La Russa never uses him correctly in my opinion. And injury has cost him. I dont think the Cards are shopping him though, the Cards do need pitching though (Morris just went down). But that doesnt mean they will trade Drew to get that, and we probably dont have enough to trade for Drew at this point, or at least I am not comfortable trading away our big prospects down on the AA and lower levels. Unless an unbelievable deal comes along, I dont see us doing much of anything right now. That is fine with me.
  23. Beinfest has done an amazing job. I dont question his moves at this point; the Dempster/Floyd deal has worked to our favor, the CJ/PW deal was a minor miracle to pull off and has worked out for us (Pierre has been great, and Spoon, when healthy, has been very good), and dare I say that the AA/Clement deal has worked out for us (D-Train anyone?). That said, I dont think there is a chance in hell we get Giles. The Pirates may be trying to trade him and his big salary, but the teams that are listed in that article have the money to take on his and Kendall's deals. We dont. I think this may be a similar deal to PW and CJ's, unloading salary for some talent. I dont think we have a Pierre or Spoon that we could spare in order to get Giles at this point. Let alone take on the salary. So, Guillen is our best bet at this point. But who knows...
  24. Not to get off topic here, but Guillen is a free agent at end of season. I am currently on the Reds board trying to gauge whether or not Guillen would be dealt. I think we could have him for 3-4 solid pitching prospects (Grilli, Wayne, Neal, Nunez, Bridges...). They need pitching, defense, and a lead off hitter (according to posts I have seen).
  25. That is a steal. I think MLB should look into that deal, the Cubs should be locked up for that one. Or the Pirates should, because they certainly didnt live up to their name, they got their booty taken from them... Agonizing... :banghead

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.