Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Big_Rob

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Big_Rob

  1. I think McGwire deserves a spot in the HOF, plain and simple hitters weren't the only ones juiced during this period of time. His worst offense is his botched testimony at the congressional hearings. I'll agree with that. By most accounts more than half of MLB players were on something illegal during that era.
  2. Too many people get snubbed by idiotic writers. And, any writer who did not vote for both Gwynn and Ripken Jr. should have his voting priveleges revoked. Ditto for the one clown who voted for Jay Buhner.
  3. I can't find any record of him making more than just over $1million in a season. He played a total of 17 seasons, but salaries weren't nearly what they are now back then. I'm sure he's got some money, but he's not filthy rich.
  4. Who didn't vote for Ripken?
  5. I doubt a guy with a known elbow problem of that severity would even attempt to pitch in winter ball. Or maybe that's why he got shut down..... Anybody know about that?
  6. Big_Rob replied to a post in a topic in Miami Marlins
    OK can someone give me some info on this guy? Mostly want to know his age. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/H/C...Hermansen.shtml
  7. Guarantee Bernie would play a better LF than Willingham and a better RF than Hermierda. Likely a pretty expensive pickup though.
  8. The last thing I heard about Albert Belle was something about stalking his ex-girlfriend last year. That guy was a great player, but i'm not sure he's HOF quality.
  9. Big_Rob replied to a post in a topic in Miami Marlins
    I'd really like to come out there for fanfest. If I was a betting man, i'd put money on easy autographs in the poker room at the Hard Rock late at night, all that week. In the clubs at the Hard Rock too. :drunks
  10. January 5, 2007 Prospectus Today My Hall of Fame Ballot by Joe Sheehan Next Tuesday, the Hall of Fame will announce the results of the 2007 BBWAA balloting. Unlike last year, when just one player earned induction and no newly-eligible players made a dent in the voting, this year's voting will certainly honor two first-time eligibles and could see at least one other elected. There's also a minor controversy about a player on the ballot for the first time. Thirty-two players are listed on the ballot, including 14 newcomers. Let's start there: 11 of those guys were good ballplayers in their day, making some All-Star teams, winning MVPs and Cy Youngs, and have no business making the Hall of Fame. Thanks for the memories, Harold Baines, Dante Bichette, Bobby Bonilla, Scott Brosius, Jay Buhner, Ken Caminiti, Wally Joyner, Paul O'Neill, Bret Saberhagen, Devon White and Bobby Witt. Of the 18 holdovers, I've covered the candidacies of most in recent years, and I haven't changed my mind on any of them: put Albert Belle, Dave Concepcion, Andre Dawson, Steve Garvey, Orel Hershiser, Tommy John, Don Mattingly, Jack Morris, Dale Murphy, Dave Parker, Jim Rice, Lee Smith and Alan Trammell into this category. I'll take a look at some of these guys in a piece next Monday, but none will be getting my theoretical vote. That leaves eight players to discuss. First, the three who I would not vote for, but who deserve a bit more coverage: Jose Canseco. At 34, he looked set to make a late-career push for the Hall, coming off of two productive seasons as a DH and in line to reach the 500-homer mark. At 37, he was out of baseball with just 462 homers and a well-deserved reputation for fragility. After age 23, he had just three seasons (of 13) in which he played in more than 130 games. If you want, give him credit for a fourth in 1994, when he played in 111 of the Rangers' 114 games. The Hall of Fame isn't a place for part-time players, and Canseco's peak wasn't long enough or high enough to counter his short career. Eric Davis. Davis isn't a serious Hall candidate, but I felt weird about lumping him in with the Bichette/Brosius class of first-timers. Davis was even less available than Canseco was, peaking at 135 games played in any season, his game a constant battle between what his body could doamazing things on a baseball fieldand what it could handle. There are people who will hold up Pete Reiser as an example of a player whose potential Hall of Fame career was derailed by his style of play and what it did to his body. Davis, a greater talent, replaces Reiser as the archetype for this player. Remember that Davis suffered a career-altering kidney injury while helping the Reds to the 1990 world championship. That's the kind of thing we should celebrate. Let's also remember his comeback in the late 1990s, which is one of the great forgotten baseball stories of that era. Eric Davis was a great, great player. Tony Fernandez. Alan Trammell with better defense and longevity. That's not quite right, but it illustrates one of the problems with Trammell's candidacy, that he's not superior enough to peers like Fernandez and Barry Larkin to make him a strong candidate for the Hall. Those two players, and not the ones who came after them, are Trammell's problem. G AB H 2B 3B HR SB CS BB AVG OBP SLG EqA WARP Fernandez 2158 7911 2276 414 92 94 246 138 691 .288 .347 .399 .273 105.4 Trammell 2293 8288 2365 412 55 185 236 109 850 .285 .352 .415 .283 123.3 Fernandez wasn't as good as Trammell. He was essentially as valuable as Dave Concepcion, and I don't think he'll do nearly as well in the voting as Concepcion has over the years. Take this with a grain of salt, but Fernandez hit .327 in 43 postseason games and .395 in his two World Series. That's the kind of point that often is used as a marker for borderline cases, and I suspect a Keltner List would treat Fernandez very kindly. For the first time that I can remember, my fictional ballot would include a whopping five names. Two are holdovers from last year: Bert Blyleven remains the best starting pitcher in history not enshrined. It may be that no player's career has been so analyzed, and despite arguments that his won-loss record reflects a mix of underperformance and poor chance, I come back to first principles: a pitchers' job is to keep runs off of the board, and he bears little to no responsibility for his run support. Blyleven did that well enough in his career to warrant enshrinement. The election of Bruce Sutter makes the inclusion of Rich Gossage on the ballot a necessity. Gossage was Sutter's superior during their careers, and his effective career was basically twice as long as Sutter's. Sutter may be in the Hall due to an accident of historyhe had the highest vote total of any returning player on a very weak ballotbut he's there now, and his presence opens the door to arguments for a dozen or more closers over the next decade. "He was better than Bruce Sutter!" is going to be the rallying cry for fans of Lee Smith and Billy Wagner and a number of other pitchers whose candidacies would have seemed silly 18 months ago. Two of the three new players on the ballot are obviously going to be elected. Cal Ripken Jr. is one of the two greatest shortstops in history and may be the all-time leader in media-awarded character points. If any player is going to be a unanimous selection between now and Greg Maddux's eligibility, it will be Ripken. This is a terrific opportunity to identify the voters who should have their privileges revoked. The other automatic is Tony Gwynn, who fits the classic mold of a high-average hitter who didn't contribute as much in other areas, leading him to be a bit overrated during his career. That doesn't mean he doesn't belong in the Hallhe absolutely doesjust that he's not really an inner-circle guy. Gwynn had a five-year stretch in the middle of his career in which he slugged .415, .424, .415, .432 and .415. You won't find many corner outfielders in the Hall of Fame who did that in any era. On the other hand, his career WARP of 124.3 is almost a dead match for a borderline Hall of Famer likewell, Alan Trammell. I make this point about Gwynn not to denigrate him or his candidacy. I don't know him personally, but what I do know about him aside from his stat line I like a lot. He was an analytical player, one of the first to use video to improve his game. He's impressed me as a broadcaster, although his path there may be curtailed by the lack of a velvet throat. The idea of "loyalty" is an overwrought one, but there is something...attractiveabout a player who spends 20 years in one uniform. Well, six or seven uniformsthis was the Padres, after allbut all for one team. No, I make the point about Gwynn to cut off one line of attack against the fifth name on my ballot. There's been some revisionist analysis of Mark McGwire that argues he was a one-dimensional player, a home-run hitter with little else in the way of skills. Now, a year ago, the BBWAA elected Sutter, the most one-dimensional player to ever be so honored. Sutter's case rested on two poleshe succeeded in a highly-limited role and he specialized in one particular pitch. The argument that a player is "too one-dimensional" to be elected rings a bit hollow the year after that. To use that argument against McGwirewho drew 1300 walks and had a career .394 OBPis laughable on its face. But to make a "one-dimensional" argument against McGwire while at the same time allowing Gwynn to pass through is just comic. Gwynn was a singles hitter, a batting-average specialist who was so known for slapping singles that the Padres drew a "56" on the infield in the last days of his career to represent Gwynn's favorite hole. Gwynn wasn't one-dimensional throughout his career, but you can point to swaths of it, such as 1990 through 1992, when his batting average was his entire value. McGwire isn't the most one-dimensional player who's a deserving candidate on this ballot, and pasting that label on him while letting Gwynn pass is either ignorant or biased. Of course, that's not really the issue with McGwire. McGwire has become the scapegoat for the media-anointed "Steroid Era," that period from 1993 through 2003 when offense reigned supreme and there was no enforcement of the game's policy against the use of performance-enhancing substances. Despite mounting evidence that the higher-offense/rampant-steroid-use connection is a fragile one, and the presence of many other factors driving power and run scoring up during that period, this notion that the statistics of that timeframe are to be discounted and the players suspect has been established as common knowledge. McGwire, the highest-profile player of that era, the guy who hit 70 homers, who hugged his kid on the field and won the approval of Roger Maris' family and millions morehe's the one to blame. Why? The case against McGwire is based loosely on three elements. One is his admitted use of androstenedione during the 1998 season. Andro, a steroid precursor, was not banned by baseball at the time. After the initial controversy, this was rarely brought up in conversations about McGwire, and there's no way his use of a legal substance, one he subsequently stopped using and recommended against using, would be enough to keep him out of the Hall. Jose Canseco's book, Juiced, did McGwire no favors, with its claims that McGwire used steroids early in his career. As I've written in the past, though, the idea that Jose Canseco is some kind of oracle is a bit difficult to stomach. He was considered a buffoon for much of his career, and only when he wrote a story that the media wanted to hear was he suddenly granted credibility. I take few of the claims in that book, and none of the ones about other players, seriously. Others do, but I don't think that would be enough to keep McGwire out, even for one year. No, McGwire is going to be denied election this year for one reason, and one reason only: his appearance in front of Congress in March of 2005. He didn't grandstand the way players such as Rafael Palmeiro and Curt Schilling did. He didn't admit guilt and beg forgiveness the way many people wish he had. He didn't stand defiant of a Congressional committee less interested in public policy than in positive press for threatening peoplemajor-league baseball playerswho could cost it few votes and little money and who would be unlikely to publicly point out the cynicism and bullying rampant in the process. In his testimony, McGwire held to a point"I'm not here to talk about the past"that was actually in keeping with the theoretical spirit of the hearings. After all, if advancing public policy was the desired effect, if preventing PED use among the youth of America was the goal, the actions of a retired player during his career would have little bearing on the matter. McGwire offered his name and his image to campaigns that would further the goals of education and prevention. He also showed a humanity and a vulnerability that had no place in an arena so vicious. He didn't feed the beast. McGwire refused to participate in the dog-and-pony show by parroting the acceptable lines or by making himself a cautionary tale. He made perhaps the most accurate statement of the day: "Asking me or any other player to answer questions about who took steroids in front of television cameras will not solve the problem." Since that day, McGwire has been held in contempt by the baseball media. The numbers we're seeing todayan ESPN poll indicates that he will receive approximately 25 percent of the vote in this year's ballotingare the direct result of that day in Congress. The voters have decided, based on the flimsiest of evidence, that McGwire not only took steroids, but that those steroids were responsible for his achievements, and that the connection between the two voids his claim to greatness. Will Carroll has pointed this out, but it's worth bringing up again: how can McGwire be so vilified for steroid use that has never come close to being proven, while Shawne Merriman is perhaps the most celebrated defensive player in the NFL during the same season in which he tested positive for steroids? The hypocrisy in the coverage of steroids in sports has never been so evident as it is today, the gulf between the media's handling of MLB and the NFL wide enough to drive the truth through. I would vote for McGwire for the Hall of Fame, because his accomplishments, his performance, warrant his induction. Whatever questions there may be about how he achieved what he did on the field are simply not answered well enough to void his claim to a spot in Cooperstown. But for the afternoon of March 17, 2005, we wouldn't even be having this discussion, and I'm just not willing to give a grandstanding Congressional committee that much sway over my thinking. The steroids-in-sports story is an embarrassment to the American sports media. The shaming of Mark McGwire is just another point of evidence that this is really about creating a story, rather than covering it. Joe Sheehan is an author of Baseball Prospectus. You can contact Joe by clicking here or click here to see Joe's other articles.
  11. I'm officially doing the happy dance :happydance but i'd be happier for Al Davis to leave. :guillotine He needs to give up some control, likely a condition any quality coach would require before coming to Oakland.
  12. If I was getting paid like Peavy i'd park wherever the hell I wanted to. Fine me, who cares. I couldn't agree with him any more, seems like the cops overreacted.
  13. Both of the guys we got from the Mets look pretty good in the closer role. Henry Owens tore it up in AA last year, seemed to be flustered in his first MLB appearances, and then looked good again in the Dominican. Lindstrom throws gas and has put up nice numbers too, i'm sure we'll see plenty of them during spring training.
  14. Just when you thought it was safe to go in the water this is not even a slogan. Some of the options that have lots of votes is simply stupid and would never sell anything. makes me glad a lot of you have no say in the official team slogans, as many have no clue what a slogan actually is to start with. Feel free to moderate your poor grammar. sorry i didnt realize my rants had to be grammatically correct. gotta love the grammar police, when all else fails and you have nothing else to say, rip on grammar. True, nothing better to do.
  15. Just when you thought it was safe to go in the water this is not even a slogan. Some of the options that have lots of votes is simply stupid and would never sell anything. makes me glad a lot of you have no say in the official team slogans, as many have no clue what a slogan actually is to start with. Feel free to moderate your poor grammar.
  16. Come on guys! "Shave This" is the best one. Imagine the possibilities. I still stand by my promise to send a t-shirt to the first one I see with facial hair. Something along these lines...
  17. Todd Williams is the loser who tried to intentionally walk Cabrera that fateful summer night. LMAO, yet again. I'll never forget that.
  18. Gagne is represented by Scott Boras, so he's gonna be trying to play financial hardball, but... I think he'd take a deal that was highly incentive based. We might be able to afford him, might be the only guy we can afford IMO. What do you guys think?
  19. That looks absolutely legitimate. Here's the difference with their training and the US version: these guys do that and the guy leading the drills just watches and shakes his head. If a US soldier or marine did that, they would be getting screamed at and fearing for their lives, even on day one of basic training. You think that's bad, you should have seen the first group of new Iraqi Army soldiers that helped my squad on a raid. They all ran and hid behind a truck when the first shots were fired (all by us, no danger) and the couple of brave ones stuck their AK's over the top of the truck and just shot at random. Two of them urinated on themselves, no lie.
  20. OK, for starters, i'm a former US Army Sergeant, and spent about 14 months in Baghdad. I know for a fact that we don't need more troops over there, I spent more time playing poker than on patrol. I also know that we didn't need more troops when we invaded, we drove into Baghdad virtually unresisted. All the military needs is less red tape or a plane ride home. When I was there, al Sadr was leading huge protests against the US occupation. Given a detailed enough map, I guarantee I could still to this day pinpoint within a 10 meter gridsquare the exact location al Sadr gave his speeches from on a regular basis. If the US government wanted him gone, he would have been. Also, I'm sick of people looking at this as a WAR. Congress declares war, and it never did. This is supposed to be a peacekeeping operation. Operation Iraqi freedom was built up as this great mission to get rid of a maniac with all of these nuclear capabilities that he couldn't be trusted with. We went in there, blew some stuff up, chased all the bad guys out, looked for all of these weapons that were supposedly there, and what did we find??? Nothing. Nothing at all. The Iraqi military wasn't even getting paid or fed. Their equipment was sitting in their motorpools rusting. They had virtually zero military. The most resistence we encountered was from the Fedayeen fighters, who obviously had very little training other than "here is a gun, here are some bullets, have fun." I'm done. I'm not going to be paying any attention to this thread, so PM me if you have any questions or concerns. Thanks.
  21. I hope Reggie crushes every ball thrown to him, makes highlight reel catches all day long, and steals two bags a game. I hope he not only gets the starting nod in CF, but gets the starting nod for the NL all-star team. I just don't think it will happen. Any of it.
  22. Reggie will be in AAA. Great guy, I like him a lot, but he needs to put in work and regain his confidence.
  23. I don't know why everyone's going so nuts over Hamilton. He was a 25 year old in the New York Penn League last season. That's the level that Volstad dominated and graduated last season. Hamilton posted a .687 OPS in the NYPL this past season, at least 5 years older than anyone else in the league with a "future." If he goes gangbusters, I'll be the first to eat my words, but he's got his life back in order, and I assume he'll see the rest of his $4 million signing bonus...minor victories are about it at this point. First action he's seen in years though. I think it's worth the 50K for the Reds to take a look at him. I'm sure he's not ever going to live up to the hype he had at one point, but there was so much hype at the time that he was naturally going to get a chance somewhere. I hope the guy has his $h!t together and makes the most of this opportunity, you don't usually get a second chance.
  24. MLB.com is saying it's a done deal this morning.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.