July 10, 200620 yr I don't know what Olsen said to Cabrera but the lazy way Cabrera ran after the ball is not acceptable and someone should have said something. Just because he's the best player on the team doesn't make it okay to dog it on some plays like the did today.
July 10, 200620 yr Cabs is the veteran. If Olsen did show him up, handle it privately. Don't do that crap in the dugout. Cabs should know better and be more mature regardless of how old he is. Joe handled it well, sitting Cabs down and having a little chat with him as Olsen left. If he did show him up, he's dead wrong as well but still that stuff can't be done in the dugout like that. You mean like how Girardi showed up Olsen not too long ago by publicly berating him in the dugout for his lackluster play in front of the entire team? Funny...I thought this was PRAISED behavior on this board. it's different when a manager does it, it's his job to straighten out problems. a player showing up his teammate in public is unacceptable I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too.
July 10, 200620 yr It's possible Girardi had already tried the behind-closed-doors thing with Olsen, not gotten any results and thus went for the public scene. However I don't have any problem with what Girardi did either way - different situations.
July 10, 200620 yr They've been replaying it a hundred times every half hour on ESPNEWS, if you haven't seen it yet then put it on.
July 10, 200620 yr I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too. I'm guessing you didn't like McKeon very much either. They've been replaying it a hundred times every half hour on ESPNEWS, if you haven't seen it yet then put it on. Why is not suprising ESPN replays something ugly like this happening to the Marlins 100 times but only grudgingly dedicates a couple segments on BBTN to the Marlins awesome run from late May through June?
July 10, 200620 yr Cabs is the veteran. If Olsen did show him up, handle it privately. Don't do that crap in the dugout. Cabs should know better and be more mature regardless of how old he is. Joe handled it well, sitting Cabs down and having a little chat with him as Olsen left. If he did show him up, he's dead wrong as well but still that stuff can't be done in the dugout like that. You mean like how Girardi showed up Olsen not too long ago by publicly berating him in the dugout for his lackluster play in front of the entire team? Funny...I thought this was PRAISED behavior on this board. Had to somehow get a Girardi jab in there didnt ya? You are amazing. With that said, Olsen is now officially a punk and has shown he has the maturity of a newborn giraffe.
July 10, 200620 yr this is clearly Olsen's fault...he himself has admitted to being quite stubborn in situations like these...the incidents with Girardi, Messenger, and now Cabrera have all been his fault...in some ways, I actually don't blame him...competitive desire and passion is a good thing...but he needs to channel this in the right way, like Beckett did actually...because turning against his teammates and manager is not the way to do this... and by the way, NOBODY should blame Cabrera for this...there's no way he meant to commit that error...it was simply a mistake...what happened on that play YES was Cabrera's "fault," but it's not like he did that on purpose, and there's likely nobody more upset about it than Cabrera himself...to call Cabrera out on this is sad... if anything...I blame Reggie AAAbercrombie for all this! Call up Fulchino!
July 10, 200620 yr I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too. I'm guessing you didn't like McKeon very much either. Which Marlins player did McKeon show up in public?
July 10, 200620 yr Not making the play is just something that happens but we've all seen Cabrera get lazy going after balls on occasion. Personally, I don't like it regardless of how good he is, how much I like him as a player and what an asset he is to the team. Just because he's Miguel Cabrera we can't pretend we haven't seen it. Having said that, there's no excuse for Olsen's attitude. One thing I've never seen Cabrera do is publicly diss his teammates. How would Scott Olsen feel if his fielders had hissy fits every time he walks someone or makes a bad pitch? I've never seen Cabrera make any exasperated motions or disrespect his pitchers. Olsen should seriously take a look at the way Dontrelle carries himself and try to learn something and show a little class. One thing I'll give him is that at least he's quick to admit fault. Now if he would just stop the behavior.
July 10, 200620 yr if anything...I blame Reggie AAAbercrombie for all this! But what about that shot he hit in Cincinatti? You can't forget about that!
July 10, 200620 yr I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too. I'm guessing you didn't like McKeon very much either. Which Marlins player did McKeon show up in public? If I recall correctly, for one, not long after McKeon was hired he paid a mound visit to Dontrelle and told him he better start pitching better or he would be sent back to the minors after he had started walking a bunch of batters while the Marlins had a comfortable lead... except Jack used more expletives. Much more embarassing than chastising a player inside the dugout.
July 10, 200620 yr I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too. I'm guessing you didn't like McKeon very much either. Which Marlins player did McKeon show up in public? If I recall correctly, not long after McKeon was hired he paid a mound visit to Dontrelle and told him he better start pitching better or he would be sent back to the minors after he had started walking a bunch of batters while the Marlins had a comfortable lead, except Jack used more expletives for one. Much more embarassing than chastising a player inside the dugout. Yeah and I recall Beckett talking about a similar incident during a McKeon visit to the mound and not having a problem with it.
July 10, 200620 yr if anything...I blame Reggie AAAbercrombie for all this! But what about that shot he hit in Cincinatti? You can't forget about that! You must mean Cincinnati
July 10, 200620 yr I respectfully disagree. Girardi's behavior and the way he conducts himself is an example to all of our players of how they should act in the big leagues. Many of our players have had little experience in the majors. I have NO doubt that every manager has berated a young rookie in front of his team for poor performance...but generally that is done behind closed doors. There is no reason to do it in public, and I think it sends the message that this kind of behavior is OK. Girardi would have NEVER done that to Cabs. Seriously, Girardi spent what seems like an hour respectfully consoling Willis on the bench after he was taken out early a few months ago. But...since Olsen is a rookie, I guess it is OK to berate him in public, right? Well, apparently Cabs thought it was OK too. I'm guessing you didn't like McKeon very much either. Which Marlins player did McKeon show up in public? If I recall correctly, for one, not long after McKeon was hired he paid a mound visit to Dontrelle and told him he better start pitching better or he would be sent back to the minors after he had started walking a bunch of batters while the Marlins had a comfortable lead... except Jack used more expletives. Much more embarassing than chastising a player inside the dugout. Yelling at a pitcher while he is on the mound does not count in my book, and if it does - Girardi did it just a few days ago against Nolasco (which by the way didn't help Nolasco who preceded to give up I think another 5 earned runs - but I have no problem with Girardi doing that, Nolasco needed a stern talking to). However, it is not the same thing as confronting a player (and physically touching him) in the dugout in view of ALL of your teammates and TV. Cabs is the veteran. If Olsen did show him up, handle it privately. Don't do that crap in the dugout. Cabs should know better and be more mature regardless of how old he is. Joe handled it well, sitting Cabs down and having a little chat with him as Olsen left. If he did show him up, he's dead wrong as well but still that stuff can't be done in the dugout like that. You mean like how Girardi showed up Olsen not too long ago by publicly berating him in the dugout for his lackluster play in front of the entire team? Funny...I thought this was PRAISED behavior on this board. Had to somehow get a Girardi jab in there didnt ya? You are amazing. With that said, Olsen is now officially a punk and has shown he has the maturity of a newborn giraffe. *yawn* So, you don't think that the Manager publicly berating (and physically grabbing) an adult major league player in front of his other teammates has ANYTHING to do with Cabs thinking he can do it too?? Particularly when Girardi would never have done that with D-Train or Miggy. Everyone on this board was praising that kind of behavior, but IMO this is the downside of such conduct. It's like a parent who beats one of his kids telling his other child that it's not OK to hit your brother. You live by the sword, you die by the sword, right?? For all the praise Girardi got for publicly embarrasing Olsen, isn't this rationally related to his behavior? To my knowledge, I've never seen Joe Torre do that, and I don't see Joe Torre's players hitting each other in his dugout.
July 10, 200620 yr I must be the minority because I thought Cabs went at the ball non-chalantly, or however you spell it. But I don't know what Olsen said so maybe that really pissed Cabs off. I've been in a situation where I thought a player on my team isn't trying that hard and I can see why Olsen was mad, but you should confront him the right way. The good thing is after losing some close ones in DC we split on the road against the Muts, I think that is a pretty good rebound.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.