April 8, 200818 yr Holy crap guys, it is game #7. I think he needs to stay with the team at least until DeAza comes back because our IF utility guy is starting vs. RHP.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino.
April 8, 200818 yr lol We've already shown it statistically. You can LOL all you want at your own ignorance.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino. I still don't understand why you and some others treat Uggla as is he will forever be a .240, given the fact that both in 2006 and in the minors, he was a .280 hitter.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino. Now honestly, of all the reasons to go after Uggla, defense? For better or worse, he still probably our most consistent defensive starting IF. Nevermind that the 245 avg you're complaining about still came with an OBP over 320 and an OPS over 800.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino. I still don't understand why you and some others treat Uggla as is he will forever be a .240, given the fact that both in 2006 and in the minors, he was a .280 hitter. He is a hacker. He just lets it rip. He is a guess hitter. And that's just watching him. If we look at it analytically, he has poor contact rates, all through the majors and minors. It is nothing new. The thing is, he vastly overachieved in 2007 with his XBH which is the only thing that kept him slightly above average (offensively) for his position. His on base potential is extremely low overall, which is probably the most important negative. I'm not excited for him to normalize. You can already see it in the small sample size of this year. A lot of K, 2 bombs, nothing else. This is going to be an all or nothing trend as the league is fully aware of his deficiencies now.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino. Now honestly, of all the reasons to go after Uggla, defense? For better or worse, he still probably our most consistent defensive starting IF. Nevermind that the 245 avg you're complaining about still came with an OBP over 320 and an OPS over 800. .320 OBP is pretty bad. And as said multiple times, the slugging, i.e. what kept the OPS at .800, is not going to stay consistent with this contact rate. His ISO was CRAZY last year. It's just not going to happen again. He is going to need to have a 30-40 point average jump to maintain the same level. We'll see if 03 is right and he gets that extra hit per week. And comparing Uggla to the rest of our defense, is not a good comparison. He rated well below average for 2B last year, after a neutral 2006. We will see what the trend says at the end of the year here, but sorry if I am not optimistic after looking at the numbers and watching him for 2 years.
April 8, 200818 yr I don't think we should get rid of Uggla. I just think we should play the guy who is playing the best baseball at the moment. What harm could benching Uggla for a few games do? The problem with the line up is that you have too many streaky hitters. Uggla, Jacobs, Willingham. Those are supposed to be your main power guys (besides Hanley) but none of them are consistent. And having Cabrera in the line up made a lot of these guys look better than they actually are. I wouldn't be surprised if they had some low numbers this year. Do you think opposing pitchers are going to respect a middle of the line up like that? Most likely not. These guys can be pitched to and Uggla and Jacobs especially are very flawed hitters with holes in their swings. That being said, the Marlins have scored a lot of runs so far. But this is mostly from the long ball. The problem with relying on the long ball is that you are waiting for the guy on the mound to screw up. What if he doesn't? You better find another way to score. ooh....and yeah the pitching obviously needs to improve but that goes without saying.
April 8, 200818 yr I'd like to find some of those people who said last winter and this spring Andino couldn't play at the major league level. :brigginbounce. That said, the league will figure him out but in the meantime it's fun to watch. And maybe he'll learn to make a few adjustments of his own. I was/am one of those people and I still stand my opinion. You can quote me on that.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. Andino has two years of AAA at bats under his belt. His bat is ready for the majors (even if his ceiling isn't extraordinarily high) and he has nothing left to lose. I worry that sending him down would be counterproductive, as he is liable to get frustrated.
April 8, 200818 yr some of u guys have absolutely no idea wat u r talking about. Yes andino has done well IN 5 AT BATS. Uggla is a proven run producer and is actually very good with the glove. he makes some great plays and is very consistant. he is off to a slow start but he will definitely come around. Lets not forget he jacked one over 400 feet today.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. With Uggla and maybe I am nuts for saying this given this ownerships track record but I dont think money will be factor with Uggla , I think if the marlins trade him it will because they have a viable alternative that makes the team better . I like Dan Uggla , I have met him he seems like a nice guy , but I think the Club needs to determine what is more valuable his power , or obtaining a better defensive second baseman who puts the ball in play more. Moving forward I think the marlins need to alter their line up to improve defensively and cut down on the strike outs . You will not find a stronger supporter on this board to get rid of Uggla than myself for those very performance reasons. Low contact, low on base, below average defense, and there is no way in hell he hits that many XBH again batting .240 (where it is unlikely the average will significantly improve because of said contract rates), which is where his sole beneficial value is. I agree with all of this. I'd go as far to say, we have the viable alternatives now with Amezaga and Andino. Now honestly, of all the reasons to go after Uggla, defense? For better or worse, he still probably our most consistent defensive starting IF. Nevermind that the 245 avg you're complaining about still came with an OBP over 320 and an OPS over 800. .320 OBP is pretty bad. And as said multiple times, the slugging, i.e. what kept the OPS at .800, is not going to stay consistent with this contact rate. His ISO was CRAZY last year. It's just not going to happen again. He is going to need to have a 30-40 point average jump to maintain the same level. We'll see if 03 is right and he gets that extra hit per week. And comparing Uggla to the rest of our defense, is not a good comparison. He rated well below average for 2B last year, after a neutral 2006. We will see what the trend says at the end of the year here, but sorry if I am not optimistic after looking at the numbers and watching him for 2 years. I don't see any reason why Uggla can't maintain a reasonable ISO. Statheads give too much credence to statistical norms and don't seem to accept the fact that in baseball, one guy might just hit the ball a little better than the other. Ryan Howard doesn't make good contact, but yet he is one of the best hitters in the league. Does this mean that his performance is just the product of luck because he has a high ISO or a good BABIP? I think not.
April 8, 200818 yr I was thinking the same thing. If he keeps hitting like this, do we really have a choice? And while he hasn't really played any 3rd base, Cantu hasn't either. I can't see Andino fielding it worse that Cantu. Cantu played a fair amount of 3B with the Rays. His glove there isn't as incredibly awful as some would like to make it sound. He's been putting good swings on the ball and not getting the results, but I expect he will get luckier and start having some more fall very soon.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. Andino has two years of AAA at bats under his belt. His bat is ready for the majors (even if his ceiling isn't extraordinarily high) and he has nothing left to lose. I worry that sending him down would be counterproductive, as he is liable to get frustrated. i agree...im not saying anything drastic like start him everyday...but he should definitely be a fixture on our bench
April 8, 200818 yr has andino always had this sort of power? i always imagined him as a sort of amezaga style hitter
April 8, 200818 yr I'm happy for Andino. He's in a tough spot being stuck behind Hanley and it's nice to see him taking advantage of the opportunities he does get. I really like him in his current role, but I'm not sure I'd like him as much if he was playing everyday. That's not to say he wouldn't do well, but it's like how a backup QB is always the most popular person on an NFL team until he becomes the starting QB. Andino seems to be thriving in this bench role, let's leave him there for a while and see if he can keep it up.
April 8, 200818 yr I think we need to be patient here. Just because Andino his a couple of HR does not make him a superstar. He was totally over matched by big league pitching last year, but he looks much more comfortable this year. This should earn him some spot starts at 2B, SS, and 3B, especially while Amezaga is platooned in center. If he can consistently hit for power and average then he would have to be considered as the starting 3B if Cantu continues to falter. We would have to look at his OBP to see if he could be the lead-off hitter and move Hanley to the third spot in the lineup. Andino certainly has the speed and the defensive ability to help our team, but again, lets not get ahead of ourselves. He still needs to prove he belongs after the other teams take a good look at him and figure out his weaknesses.
April 8, 200818 yr has andino always had this sort of power? He hit 13 homers last year in AAA which was by far his most ever in the minors. So no, not a power guy.
April 8, 200818 yr Once MLB realizes that he can't catch up to a fastball he's screwed. We definitely need to keep him on the roster because Amezaga is starting in CF but don't expect anything near this output for much longer.
April 8, 200818 yr Uggla is an .800 OPS 2B... there just aren't that many of those and frankly you guys that want to get rid of him are just plain dumb.
April 8, 200818 yr Start him at 2B and give Uggla a reason to lite a fire under his sorry butt. Delicious. Although I want Andino getting everyday AB. AAA is probably the best place for that at the moment, but as soon as the Dan train rides out of town with arbitration, I would like an Andino/Amezaga 2B platoon for sure until Coghlan proves he can hack it. Andino has two years of AAA at bats under his belt. His bat is ready for the majors (even if his ceiling isn't extraordinarily high) and he has nothing left to lose. I worry that sending him down would be counterproductive, as he is liable to get frustrated. It's not counterproductive to have a player get consistent playing time, versus toiling no a bench and getting 250-300 PA over the course of a year. He made a lot of progression last year. Best he keeps at it unless the Marlins are going to play him regularly.
April 8, 200818 yr I don't see any reason why Uggla can't maintain a reasonable ISO. Statheads give too much credence to statistical norms and don't seem to accept the fact that in baseball, one guy might just hit the ball a little better than the other. Ryan Howard doesn't make good contact, but yet he is one of the best hitters in the league. Does this mean that his performance is just the product of luck because he has a high ISO or a good BABIP? I think not. Thanks for bringing up Ryan Howard, which supports my argument. His OPS dropped over 100 points last year with a drop in ISO, because he continued not making significant contact. This was a reasonably fluctuation due to his horrible contact rates, and easily predictable compared to his 2006. Is he still amazing? Yes. He walks like a maniac. He has legit baseline 45 HR/.600 slug power. Big difference from Uggla, who does not walk anywhere near as much, and at best, has baseline 30 HR/.475 power. Now what happened with Uggla? The strikeout rate brought the average decrease, but for some fluke Uggla still had the exact same slugging. This is literally, a statistical fluke. When Uggla hits 15-25 less XBH this year, he's going to fall into an average offensive 2B, and a below average defender. He is going to have to hit at least .270, and keep his 2007 BB rate versus his 2006 BB rate, to come close to the reputation he has as one of the better 2B around. Does a .750 OPS with a negative defense impact excite you? It's a solid 2B, but not an amazing one. And one not worth $3.5 in arbitration to this franchise. This is why I am upset with Uggla. We needed to trade him before the regression starts. I hope it's not to late and that you are right and he can maintain a rate that is very improbable. I would LOVE LOVE LOVE Uggla to prove me wrong.
April 8, 200818 yr i like for Andino to stay too. he been on fire for us. send down that be mistake but he first timer with team those first send down for player who have play big league more
April 8, 200818 yr I don't see any reason why Uggla can't maintain a reasonable ISO. Statheads give too much credence to statistical norms and don't seem to accept the fact that in baseball, one guy might just hit the ball a little better than the other. Ryan Howard doesn't make good contact, but yet he is one of the best hitters in the league. Does this mean that his performance is just the product of luck because he has a high ISO or a good BABIP? I think not. Thanks for bringing up Ryan Howard, which supports my argument. His OPS dropped over 100 points last year with a drop in ISO, because he continued not making significant contact. This was a reasonably fluctuation due to his horrible contact rates, and easily predictable compared to his 2006. Is he still amazing? Yes. He walks like a maniac. He has legit baseline 45 HR/.600 slug power. Big difference from Uggla, who does not walk anywhere near as much, and at best, has baseline 30 HR/.475 power. Now what happened with Uggla? The strikeout rate brought the average decrease, but for some fluke Uggla still had the exact same slugging. This is literally, a statistical fluke. When Uggla hits 15-25 less XBH this year, he's going to fall into an average offensive 2B, and a below average defender. He is going to have to hit at least .270, and keep his 2007 BB rate versus his 2006 BB rate, to come close to the reputation he has as one of the better 2B around. Does a .750 OPS with a negative defense impact excite you? It's a solid 2B, but not an amazing one. And one not worth $3.5 in arbitration to this franchise. This is why I am upset with Uggla. We needed to trade him before the regression starts. I hope it's not to late and that you are right and he can maintain a rate that is very improbable. I would LOVE LOVE LOVE Uggla to prove me wrong. I disagree that Uggla is a below average defensive second baseman. He was above average in 06, and average in 07 by most metrics.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.