Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

A Look Forward to Winter Meetings

Featured Replies

If the Marlins can stomach the thought of parting with former top prospect Jeremy Hermida, they should find a nice package waiting for them in return. And the Rangers might yet trade one of their young catchers -- Gerald Laird or Max Ramirez or Jarrod Saltalamacchia -- knowing that Taylor Teagarden is waiting in the wings.

 

MLB.com

 

I would personally want more than Salty or Ramirez in return for Hermida, who would probably tear up Arlington alongside Hamilton. BUT, this is certainly promising if the front office is looking to fill the void in the OF through another deal, or even better, an Ibanez or Abreu signing (which isn't too unrealistic after shedding more payroll with the loss of Hermida).

So if we did trade Hermida for a Texas catcher our OF would consist of:

 

Maybin

Ross

 

Yeh I know Amezaga can play there but he isnt an every day OF

 

In my opinion, we passed on the chance to trade for a catcher when we sent Scotty O to Washington

There are so many different reports coming from all over the place concerning catchers. It's either we are considering bringing back Pudge, or trading Hermida for Gerald Laird or Max Ramirez or Jarrod Saltalamacchia. There are too many rumors floating around and nothing is even close to being true.

 

Out of those two options, I say keep Hermida and sign Pudge. I don't think Texas will offer us enough for Hermida personally.

This is dumb because Texas has 4 outfielders - Hamilton, Murphy, Cruz, and Boggs - that all deserve some playing time. Sure one of them could perpetually be on the bench and another DH to make room for Hermida, but the Rangers need PITCHING for their catchers. This isn't even an option as far as I'm concerned. Let alone, the Marlins need for Hermida right now.

I don't see Hermida being traded. It will only open up another hole in the OF. I say sign Pudge to one year, let him platoon w/ Baker as he develops. Our team looks good as it is. Our only hole is the C position. Pudge could easily man that position for a year. Pudge could offer guidance to Baker and our Pitchers even though he won't offer much offensively. No loss there. He brings other things to the table. (Please don't say "syringes" and "needles" as one of the things he brings.)

This is dumb because Texas has 4 outfielders - Hamilton, Murphy, Cruz, and Boggs - that all deserve some playing time. Sure one of them could perpetually be on the bench and another DH to make room for Hermida, but the Rangers need PITCHING for their catchers. This isn't even an option as far as I'm concerned. Let alone, the Marlins need for Hermida right now.

 

True. If we were going to make a trade w/ TX, I believe Scott Olsen offered us the best chance. That ship has sailed.

Last time I looked Jarrod Saltalamacchia was playing first base in the winter leagues.

Oh he'd be perfect for multiple reasons, but Hermida isn't the guy.

 

It's Anibal or West. And now our SP depth, which is already low, disappears.

This is dumb because Texas has 4 outfielders - Hamilton, Murphy, Cruz, and Boggs - that all deserve some playing time. Sure one of them could perpetually be on the bench and another DH to make room for Hermida, but the Rangers need PITCHING for their catchers. This isn't even an option as far as I'm concerned. Let alone, the Marlins need for Hermida right now.

 

The only way the Rangers would need another OF/DH like Jeremy Hermida is if they don't re-sign Milton Bradley. I have to take issue with you Lou about Brandon Boggs as I just don't think he's that talented. Now, if the Rangers offered the Marlins Cruz and one of the catchers for Hermida then they would have to consider that....but they won't. If Beinfest calls the Rangers the name Anibal Sanchez will be the one the Rangers are interested in.

In my opinion, we passed on the chance to trade for a catcher when we sent Scotty O to Washington

Yeah when that happened when we decided to trade away Hammer

I am pleased with Baker and think he is underappreciated.

 

I'm pretty sure that most of us appreciate Baker just fine. The fact still remains though is that his defense needs work and we still need a solid backup.

This is dumb because Texas has 4 outfielders - Hamilton, Murphy, Cruz, and Boggs - that all deserve some playing time. Sure one of them could perpetually be on the bench and another DH to make room for Hermida, but the Rangers need PITCHING for their catchers. This isn't even an option as far as I'm concerned. Let alone, the Marlins need for Hermida right now.

 

 

Because you're assuming that a trade will be just Hermida for just one of the catchers. We can see a 4 or 5 player deal here that sees us swamping Hermida with a P or two for a catcher and an OFer.

I would not trade Annibal Sanchez. Two years ago he was simply outstanding. His last two starts of last season were excellent. If he returns to his form of a couple years back, with a return to sound health, he is the number one man in the Marlins rotation. If the Marlins can get Jonathan Sanchez for Cantu, I would look at trading Josh Johnson before moving Annibal. I'm not as sold on Johnson as the organization seems to be. If moving Johnson would yield an outstanding catcher, I would do it.

I would not trade Annibal Sanchez. Two years ago he was simply outstanding. His last two starts of last season were excellent. If he returns to his form of a couple years back, with a return to sound health, he is the number one man in the Marlins rotation. If the Marlins can get Jonathan Sanchez for Cantu, I would look at trading Josh Johnson before moving Annibal. I'm not as sold on Johnson as the organization seems to be. If moving Johnson would yield an outstanding catcher, I would do it.

 

Annibal Sanchez got hammered throughout his return and was all over the place.

 

Josh Johnson is strong and very healthy, there's absolutely no way the marlins would even consider this!!!

 

Josh Johnson after his return last season was solid he went:

W L ERA G GS CG SHO SV SVO IP H http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif R http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif ER http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif HR http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif HBP http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif BB http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/images/trans.gif SO

 

7 1 3.61 14 14 1 0 0 0 87.1 91 36 35 7 1 27 77

  • Author

I would not trade Annibal Sanchez. Two years ago he was simply outstanding. His last two starts of last season were excellent. If he returns to his form of a couple years back, with a return to sound health, he is the number one man in the Marlins rotation. If the Marlins can get Jonathan Sanchez for Cantu, I would look at trading Josh Johnson before moving Annibal. I'm not as sold on Johnson as the organization seems to be. If moving Johnson would yield an outstanding catcher, I would do it.

 

Josh Johnson is going to win 15 games next year, and I have no problem making that promise if he is healthy.

 

Moving Johnson would be moronic, on every level.

Sanchez of two years ago was much better than Johnson of last year. You really should take a look at the numbers Sanchez posted. I expect him back at full strength. I like him better than Johnson because he has proven he can be better.

Sanchez of two years ago was much better than Johnson of last year. You really should take a look at the numbers Sanchez posted. I expect him back at full strength. I like him better than Johnson because he has proven he can be better.

 

 

The current Sanchez is not the same as the Sanchez two years ago.

  • Author

Sanchez of two years ago was much better than Johnson of last year. You really should take a look at the numbers Sanchez posted. I expect him back at full strength. I like him better than Johnson because he has proven he can be better.

 

 

The current Sanchez is not the same as the Sanchez two years ago.

 

And Sanchez has NEVER possesed the kind of stuff Johnson has. And he's always had control issues, even in 2006.

 

Johnson >>>>>>>>>>> Sanchez

 

If you disagree, you're Venezualan or retarded.

Sanchez of two years ago was much better than Johnson of last year. You really should take a look at the numbers Sanchez posted. I expect him back at full strength. I like him better than Johnson because he has proven he can be better.

 

 

The current Sanchez is not the same as the Sanchez two years ago.

 

And Sanchez has NEVER possesed the kind of stuff Johnson has. And he's always had control issues, even in 2006.

 

Johnson >>>>>>>>>>> Sanchez

 

If you disagree, you're Venezualan or retarded.

 

 

Ummmm inappropriate much?

 

I happened to agree with you that Johnson is better but seriously, maybe you need to take a valium or something.

Sanchez of two years ago was much better than Johnson of last year. You really should take a look at the numbers Sanchez posted. I expect him back at full strength. I like him better than Johnson because he has proven he can be better.

 

 

The current Sanchez is not the same as the Sanchez two years ago.

 

He's not exactly tearing it up in the Winter Leagues right now either. Still lacks control.

I would assume that Salty is playing 1B to rest his knees more than anything.

 

All of the rumors I've been hearing have a pitcher going to Texas for a catcher, or a three way deal for Cantu to San Fran, bringing in a catcher. I think that if Pudge is reasonably priced we may bring him on board even if we acquire another young catcher, especially if it is Salty who can platoon some at 1B.

 

McPherson and Sanchez at the corners, Bonifacio in the OF?

 

 

 

Oh, and I keep hearing that the Cubs really want a lefty right-fielder, i.e. Hermida, but apparently they want a more talented guy.

Ill trade anibal for one of those catchers but I dont think texas would want damaged goods like anibal. I dont think we will ever see the anibal of 06 his sugery i sone where not many come back from and do well.

I would assume that Salty is playing 1B to rest his knees more than anything.

 

All of the rumors I've been hearing have a pitcher going to Texas for a catcher, or a three way deal for Cantu to San Fran, bringing in a catcher. I think that if Pudge is reasonably priced we may bring him on board even if we acquire another young catcher, especially if it is Salty who can platoon some at 1B.

 

McPherson and Sanchez at the corners, Bonifacio in the OF?

 

 

 

Oh, and I keep hearing that the Cubs really want a lefty right-fielder, i.e. Hermida, but apparently they want a more talented guy.

 

Link? I haven't heard any 3-way deals, although Cantu to San Fran, Sanchez to Texas, Max/Salty to us (or some variation) is an interesting though. If that deal was offered just like that, I'd want us to jump on it IMMEDIATELY!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.