Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Opportunity for the front office?

Featured Replies

I recently wrote this on the fangraphs article about who the Angels should trade, but I'll say it here too.

 

The Marlins are spending no money/likely won't be in position to spend next year either.

 

Considering the talent on the roster sucks, adding a guy like Bourjos (a real CF'er) would be cool. Nolasco for Bourjos straight up probably doesn't get it done.

 

Thus, I think we should take on Vernon Wells contract as though we'd be taking on an expiring contract in the NBA.

Difference between Nolasco/Wells contracts in '13 is 10 million.

Wells, I believe, is under contract in '14, but who cares? We'll probably suck then, too.

 

After '14, he leaves when we're probably ready to compete again.

Most importantly, it gives us leverage to add a talented CF'er in Bourjos. Nolasco leaves, opening up an opportunity for a younger pitcher.

 

If free agents are reluctant to sign, we need to trade for talent. Taking on Wells contract should be no problem here considering how cheap the rest of the team is going to be.

Especially if they don't extend Stanton, the team becomes even cheaper/cost-controlled.

Take on a bad contract from some team and get some better talent without having to give much in return.

 

 

I'm sorry, but this is incredibly dumb in my opinion. Like one of the worst ideas I've ever heard dumb.

 

Why would the Marlins want to take on all of that salary when they aren't going to be competing? I mean, what's the point of paying for Vernon Wells far above his market value when they just got rid of a bunch of contracts?

 

And you think that taking on Vernon Wells' contract would be worth it just so they can get Bourjos? Let's not kid ourselves. Bourjos has some potential and I'd like to have him but while the glove is there, the bat isn't. That's not even close to being worth taking on that much payroll.

 

Bourjos is a 3-4 win player with consistent playing time in CF.

 

I'm having the same discussion on another board and don't really feel like having the same argument on two boards so if you want the link to the other board, I'll PM it to you. Perhaps it wouldn't be so ridiculous with an explanation.

 

 

I don't think an explanation is necessary. You basically want to buy Bourjos for the difference between Nolasco's and Wells' salaries, which is close to $30 million over the next two years. I don't think that is good value for a 3-4 centerfielder, especially if you consider the situation the Marlins are in. They shed payroll for a reason--they claim to have lost a lot of money this past season. It would be silly to take on that much payroll over the next 2 seasons when they aren't likely to be in competition.

We're getting too far into Stanton to Texas... can we get back to the thought of Nolasco to the Angels for Bourjos with obviously some other pieces involved? Is this even remotely possible to anyone else?

re: your Bourjos idea Erick -

 

the point about maybe needing to get better through trades is valid enough, but it's not like they have to do something nuts like that for next season, and I wouldn't go through this just to get Peter Bourjos anyway. There's no way Loria is handing Vernon Wells 42 mil just to get that done. I like Bourjos well enough but outfield is actually something we have a fair amount of depth at in solid minor league prospects. And I say that realizing none of the Yelich/Ozuna/Marisnick group have done squat at AA level yet, but it's an area we can at least be optimistic about. Yelich is the best bet of course, but if they keep Stanton then it's a fair bet that at least one of Ozuna/ Marisnick/ Silverio will work out and then they should be okay in the outfield.

 

But even Bourjos aside, you're suggesting Loria spend a bunch of money to get better over the next season or two when I don't think there's been any signs to suggest that's going to happen. He's gonna play the kids.

Stanton is a generational player. No smart team lets a player like that go.

 

However, the Marlins put themselves into a really tricky position. That Blue Jays trade may have upset Stanton enough that he may not even want to consider re-signing here regardless of the money we offer because he feels betrayed by the front office. If that's the case, we have no choice but to trade him at some point in the future.

 

However, if there's even the slightest chance that Stanton would consider an extension, there's no way you can trade him.

 

This wouldn't be an issue though if the Marlins actually did the right thing and gave Stanton that extension that should've been done right after his first few months in the majors (or at the very least at the end of his first or second full seasons). The Marlins front office screwed themselves over, and it's pretty annoying that they've been doing that quite often the last few years.

 

agreed. and like Erick mentioned the FO needs to decide very soon what they're going to do with him. If they are indeed the a*holes we think and aren't going to extend him, go ahead and make the move. Otherwise let's freaking keep the superstar, eh? Don't waste this guy. Miller and Maybin flamed out, it happens. Stanton isn't going to flame out. They would have to get such a giant return for him that I can't imagine it happens. And then most of them would have to hit their ceilings to make it seem worthwhile a few years from now looking back on a trade like this.

  • Author

Yelich and Marisnick project to be corner OF'ers. Even if Marisnick becomes a CF'er, it just means you have a surplus of something to trade for an organizational need when the time comes. Or you can just have an outfield with multiple players capable of playing CF. Plenty of teams have that now and it results in very good defensive outfields.

 

Players like Bourjos are very valuable on the trade market. Ben Revere cost the Phillies a major-league starter and a top prospect; Bourjos is a better player than Ben Revere.

 

Getting Bourjos and only having to give up a shitty Ricky Nolasco would be awesome.

 

In 2013, the difference between Nolasco/Wells is $10 million (5 of those 10 million they have already promised they'd spend after trading Escobar).

 

If Stanton does not get extended and he's traded for prospects, basically the whole team is going to be making league minimum or close to league minimum for the next two years.

 

The Marlins can absorb the Vernon Wells contract (because, for the next two years, no free agent is going to sign here, anyway) in order to get a 3-4 WAR CF'er in the process.

The Marlins could let Wells sit on the bench for two years and probably still have the lowest payroll in the big leagues the next two years. Just about every other spot is filled internally except long-term CF'er, especially if they trade Stanton for Profar/Olt+.

 

Bourjos is an asset entering his prime. Even if you assume no improvement with the bat and he hits like he's done for his career (low-700's OPS), he's still a valuable asset.

 

This team is low on talent, in a spot where it's going to be difficult to get free agents to come here without overpaying and not going to compete for a couple of years.

 

Realistically, this team is a couple of years away from being competitive. In a couple of years, Vernon Wells is gone and we still have Bourjos under club control and as a part of our core. Or we have him as a potential asset that we can trade for young pitching, etc.

 

I don't think it's horrible.

 

Perhaps we just value a player like Bourjos differently. I think he has great upside especially considering the context of our situation. A CF'er that can cover lots of ground in our ballpark is essential.

I think the problem is that they are flat just NOT going to spend a bunch of cash on a useless player like Wells. They are in cost-cutting mode, not looking to add payroll.

The opportunity for the front office is not to trade a probable generational superstar. Unless you consider saying goodbye to what's left of their fanbase an opportunity. The opportunity if they want to crawl back to respectability is to SIGN Stanton and build around him. I feel that he'll accept an above market contract as I've proposed before. All of you can bitch and whine after the fact that we paid too much and you can tell us how you'd prefer to have him on another team instead of overpaying the bum....when it happens.

  • Author

The opportunity for the front office is not to trade a probable generational superstar. Unless you consider saying goodbye to what's left of their fanbase an opportunity. The opportunity if they want to crawl back to respectability is to SIGN Stanton and build around him. I feel that he'll accept an above market contract as I've proposed before. All of you can bitch and whine after the fact that we paid too much and you can tell us how you'd prefer to have him on another team instead of overpaying the bum....when it happens.

 

He's not getting 10/200...

The opportunity for the front office is not to trade a probable generational superstar. Unless you consider saying goodbye to what's left of their fanbase an opportunity. The opportunity if they want to crawl back to respectability is to SIGN Stanton and build around him. I feel that he'll accept an above market contract as I've proposed before. All of you can bitch and whine after the fact that we paid too much and you can tell us how you'd prefer to have him on another team instead of overpaying the bum....when it happens.

 

He's not getting 10/200...

 

Agree, but I'm much more inclined now to believe we'll have to overpay some to keep him here.

  • Author

While he's a great player, if this team gives him an overpay, they better be willing to spend on the rest of the team, too. It's never good to have so much of your payroll invested into one player.

 

I hope he stays but if the intent is to be cheap forever, I really don't care. They're never going to win with Giancarlo Stanton and a yearly version of who cares who the other 24 guys are.

While he's a great player, if this team gives him an overpay, they better be willing to spend on the rest of the team, too. It's never good to have so much of your payroll invested into one player.

 

I hope he stays but if the intent is to be cheap forever, I really don't care. They're never going to win with Giancarlo Stanton and a yearly version of who cares who the other 24 guys are.

 

The opportunity is to sign Stanton and build around him...not all at once for this year, but a 2-4 year process of growth and smart acquisitions. And an out-of-bounds TEN year contract immediately shows that long-term commitment. A final team payroll of say 50, 70, 90 over the next 3 years. Build...and the fans will come..and if the players perform at least up to expectations the place will be packed.

.

But the first step is to sign Stanton asap and one has to think that after recent events the amount we have to overpay has gone up. 10/150 plus incentives as proposed I'd hope should still be fair for both sides. In fact, if Loria can creep out from under the dungpile he created costing him and the franchise a measly 2-3 million a year for 10 years it's a bargain.

What if Texas offers Holland instead of Profar. Assuming the deal is something like Perez, Holland, Buckell, Olt for Stanton. Would you do it?

While he's a great player, if this team gives him an overpay, they better be willing to spend on the rest of the team, too. It's never good to have so much of your payroll invested into one player. I hope he stays but if the intent is to be cheap forever, I really don't care. They're never going to win with Giancarlo Stanton and a yearly version of who cares who the other 24 guys are. The opportunity is to sign Stanton and build around him...not all at once for this year, but a 2-4 year process of growth and smart acquisitions. And an out-of-bounds TEN year contract immediately shows that long-term commitment. A final team payroll of say 50, 70, 90 over the next 3 years. Build...and the fans will come..and if the players perform at least up to expectations the place will be packed..But the first step is to sign Stanton asap and one has to think that after recent events the amount we have to overpay has gone up. 10/150 plus incentives as proposed I'd hope should still be fair for both sides. In fact, if Loria can creep out from under the dungpile he created costing him and the franchise a measly 2-3 million a year for 10 years it's a bargain.

 

Fans won't come until we are legitimately in a playoff hunt. As in leading the nl east or wildcard.

 

Signing one player long term isn't going to change anyone's minds about how the organization works.Casual fans wont care about a Stanton extension but I think true fans like those on this board would see a Stanton extension as a huge deal here. And it would more than likely improve our future here in the longterm. Stanton leaving though, likely cripples us even further.

The Marlins inevitably having a low payroll next season doesn't justify adding on $30 million. You keep neglecting the fact that the Marlins reduced payroll for a reason. In other words, that's terrible logic to say the move is justifiable because the Marlins would still have a very low payroll even with Wells paid to ride the bench.

 

Bourjos is a decent talent and underrated. But he's not the type of player that you go out and spend $30 million on just to acquire. Even if the Marlins don't have a definite lock for CF among the surplus of outfielders, that doesn't really justify doing something rash like trading for Wells just to get Bourjos.

 

I'm sure that if the Marlins really wanted a 3-4 CFer down the stretch, there are thousands of better ways of doing so that don't require adding $30 million of another team's mistake.

I can't get excited about anything concernig the Marlins these days.

Any way I look at it, the 2013 season and beyond are going to be a painful. We will hear how Miggy, Reyes, Hanley, JJ, Anibal and the others are doing while we watch our triple A team struggle.

 

I don't really see any end in sight. No respectable free agent is willing to come here.

 

It's really tough being a Marlins fan right now.

 

What a difference a year makes!

I can't get excited about anything concernig the Marlins these days.

Any way I look at it, the 2013 season and beyond are going to be a painful. We will hear how Miggy, Reyes, Hanley, JJ, Anibal and the others are doing while we watch our triple A team struggle.

 

I don't really see any end in sight. No respectable free agent is willing to come here.

 

It's really tough being a Marlins fan right now.

 

What a difference a year makes!

Let's hope the young talent we now have in this organization will blossom into what we think it will. We have a lo if major league ready bats and arms to build with.

 

You know, look on the bright side... You don't need free agents to sign here if you have enough financial stability to retain your own talent, which we haven't been able to do. If our talent in place now becomes what we hope it will, and we can build the franchise back into contention, people will eventually sign here again. Everyone wants to play for a winner...

I recently wrote this on the fangraphs article about who the Angels should trade, but I'll say it here too.

 

The Marlins are spending no money/likely won't be in position to spend next year either.

 

Considering the talent on the roster sucks, adding a guy like Bourjos (a real CF'er) would be cool. Nolasco for Bourjos straight up probably doesn't get it done.

 

Thus, I think we should take on Vernon Wells contract as though we'd be taking on an expiring contract in the NBA.

Difference between Nolasco/Wells contracts in '13 is 10 million.

Wells, I believe, is under contract in '14, but who cares? We'll probably suck then, too.

 

After '14, he leaves when we're probably ready to compete again.

Most importantly, it gives us leverage to add a talented CF'er in Bourjos. Nolasco leaves, opening up an opportunity for a younger pitcher.

 

If free agents are reluctant to sign, we need to trade for talent. Taking on Wells contract should be no problem here considering how cheap the rest of the team is going to be.

Especially if they don't extend Stanton, the team becomes even cheaper/cost-controlled.

Take on a bad contract from some team and get some better talent without having to give much in return.

 

 

I'm sorry, but this is incredibly dumb in my opinion. Like one of the worst ideas I've ever heard dumb.

 

Why would the Marlins want to take on all of that salary when they aren't going to be competing? I mean, what's the point of paying for Vernon Wells far above his market value when they just got rid of a bunch of contracts?

 

And you think that taking on Vernon Wells' contract would be worth it just so they can get Bourjos? Let's not kid ourselves. Bourjos has some potential and I'd like to have him but while the glove is there, the bat isn't. That's not even close to being worth taking on that much payroll.

Thank you! I read through 10 posts and was afraid no one had said it yet. The guy is terrible at the plate. The good glove doesn't make up for it.

 

If we only have to give up Nolasco for him, sure. But like Erick said, that doesn't get done.

 

Also, as Erick said, we probably suck in '14, anyways. By '15, Bourjos is 28 and all of our OF prospects are ready. So why take on the $30 mil?

  • Author

It's not as if 28 is old. As I said, worst-case scenario is we have assets to trade by then.

 

Maybe it would make more sense if the Angels added a prospect or two or if the Marlins only paid some of Wells salary instead of all of it.

Read that the Marlins may have interest in a Nolasco for Bourjos deal. I think the trade is possible if Miami eats half or more of Nolasco's contract

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.