August 3, 201610 yr Btw, me saying trade Ramos before the deadline wasn't because I dislike Ramos. I think he's a good reliever. I get that, but selling your best reliever when you are in contention is really, really weird.
August 3, 201610 yr You just see no value in closers, we know I liked the Rodney deal. I like our bullpen depth. That's why.
August 3, 201610 yr I get that, but selling your best reliever when you are in contention is really, really weird. Pirates did it.
August 3, 201610 yr I dont think its being reactionary. I think its responding to a critical loss that was needed to avoid a sweep and where not only did our 8th inning guy and closer pitch like absolute shit, but our manager made a very questionable call that backfired in the more foreseeable way possible.
August 3, 201610 yr What a rough finish especially being there at Wrigley. 3 games, 3 losses. I'm glad I won't be attending any more Marlins games this year.
August 3, 201610 yr What a rough finish especially being there at Wrigley. 3 games, 3 losses. I'm glad I won't be attending any more Marlins games this year. Can I leave the country with you?
August 3, 201610 yr I get that, but selling your best reliever when you are in contention is really, really weird. by WAR and basically every metric besides "saves" Phelps has been our best RP. just sayin
August 3, 201610 yr He's walked the same # as last year in about half the innings which is why he always gets to pitch himself out of trouble. Sent from my HTC One using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
August 3, 201610 yr I dont think its being reactionary. I think its responding to a critical loss that was needed to avoid a sweep and where not only did our 8th inning guy and closer pitch like absolute shit, but our manager made a very questionable call that backfired in the more foreseeable way possible. No. It's being reactionary. There are two months of baseball left. Calm the F down.
August 3, 201610 yr I liked the Rodney deal. I like our bullpen depth. That's why. I liked the Rodney deal do tbh fwiw. Just check my post history if you dont believe me!
August 3, 201610 yr by WAR and basically every metric besides "saves" Phelps has been our best RP. just sayin That's fair, but on that same note, I wouldn't sell on him, either. I wouldn't have sold on any of our relievers unless we were somehow getting a legitimate starter in return.
August 3, 201610 yr And it was really, really weird. It's a forward thinking move which has to be done sometimes when you're a small market team. A big reason why we have no farm system is because we never sell high on relievers. All of the other small market teams do at some point. I bet they won't even entertain the thought of trading Ramos in the offseason, which is weird from a penny-pinching team.
August 3, 201610 yr It's a forward thinking move which has to be done sometimes when you're a small market team. A big reason why we have no farm system is because we never sell high on relievers. All of the other small market teams do at some point. I bet they won't even entertain the thought of trading Ramos in the offseason, which is weird from a penny-pinching team. Yeah, but you don't do it during the middle of the season when you are trying to contend, ESPECIALLY when you are a small-market team that doesn't get many chances to contend. I'd have no problem with entertaining trade offers for Ramos in the winter, but not in the middle of the season. You yourself were okay with giving up prospects for a starter because you said we HAD to go for it this year, so then why trade Ramos?
August 3, 201610 yr It's a forward thinking move which has to be done sometimes when you're a small market team. A big reason why we have no farm system is because we never sell high on relievers. All of the other small market teams do at some point. I bet they won't even entertain the thought of trading Ramos in the offseason, which is weird from a penny-pinching team. The marlins are big proponents of the sell low buy high school of thought.
August 3, 201610 yr Once Capps went down that would have been tough to do, granted. And that was even before we knew Chen would bomb. As it stands it was a good thing we had bullpen depth this season, as much as the FO and/or coach tried to mess it up. Sent from my HTC One using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app
August 3, 201610 yr Once Capps went down that would have been tough to do, granted. And that was even before we knew Chen would bomb. As it stands it was a good thing we had bullpen depth this season, as much as the FO and/or coach tried to mess it up. Sent from my HTC One using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app Capps' injury really screwed a whole lot of stuff up this season. More than you would think on the surface.
August 3, 201610 yr I liked the Rodney deal. I like our bullpen depth. That's why. The Rodney deal was dumb, if only because he was acquired at the absolute height of his value, due to the start of the season he had. He was bound to regress to his career mean.
August 3, 201610 yr Pirates did it. The Pirates front office at times appears more retarded than the Marlin front office. Them not going for it last year may have been one of the biggest crimes ever.
August 3, 201610 yr I liked the Rodney deal do tbh fwiw. Just check my post history if you dont believe me! Yep you were glad to get him for some A-ball pitcher, forgot his name even
August 3, 201610 yr Yeah, but you don't do it during the middle of the season when you are trying to contend, ESPECIALLY when you are a small-market team that doesn't get many chances to contend. I'd have no problem with entertaining trade offers for Ramos in the winter, but not in the middle of the season. You yourself were okay with giving up prospects for a starter because you said we HAD to go for it this year, so then why trade Ramos? I was only for trading Ramos if it meant getting some assets who could help this year. I wasn't for trading him just because. I do think he would've had good value. Would've been the best reliever on the market after Andrew Miller. More value than Melancon because of contract.
August 3, 201610 yr A good manager adapts to the situation. Just because they're the 8th & 9th inning guys doesn't mean that you're not allowed to take them out when they clearly can't throw a strike. Mattingly deserves partial blame just like the players deserve partial blame. Also, when a pitcher can't throw a strike, walking the bases loaded is usually not a good idea. I was thinking canadamarlin thoughts while listening to Felo on the radio. Felo needs to retire by the way. I agree with this. You have to go with recent trends. Just not based on past history. AJ is struggling like crazy lately and he cant find the plate to save his life. He should be no way guaranteed the "entire" 9th all the time based on what he has done for the first few months. You have to coach to win games and sometimes, go with the hot hand. It may not be popular but coach to win and not to hurt players feelings. AJ will get over it. He should of been yanked much earlier than that. For those that are harping on his 1 blown save coming in, this guy has been very fortunate this year. There is so many other games where he could of easily blew. You cant play with fire every damn time out there and expect not to get burned. Enough with all the damn walks AJ.
August 3, 201610 yr The Rodney deal was dumb, if only because he was acquired at the absolute height of his value, due to the start of the season he had. He was bound to regress to his career mean. You have to take chances and take advantage of your window to win. Paddack could turn out to be nothing.
August 3, 201610 yr You have to take chances and take advantage of your window to win. Paddack could turn out to be nothing. Ya but Rodney is proven to suck when it counts.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.