January 26, 20188 yr The new list comes out tomorrow night. I'm assuming by our current rankings that Harrison will be in the top 100 and that Diaz will be falling off. Doesn't really matter as I think Diaz is still a good prospect. Either way he's around the bottom half of the top 100. Mlb.com hasnt released their top 100, but they had him as the 4th best 2b in the minors, so if he's not on the list he should be just off of it. Doesnt matter either way, he is a really good prospect. I think that mlb.com list might have all of Brinson, Harrison, and Diaz on it.
January 26, 20188 yr Imagine how nice it would look if they trade Realmuto and sign Martinez. All this improvement of the farm system and the team hasn't even played a single game nor drafted a single player under Jeter and Co yet. The people saying Jeter was only about saving money and wasn't really about acquiring talent are starting to lose that argument quicker than expected. Look, I'm a fan of the Marlins and I'm glad they received what seems to be a decent to very good return for Yelich. I'm also happy that our farm system is much improved. However, there's no doubt that this rebuild was predicated for financial reasons. Also, while Jeter is obviously trying to build a winner, that doesn't mean that profit isn't his first priority. Keep in mind that Loria in his own meddling way also wanted to win. Acquiring the talent was never going to be the problem considering the talent we were trading away. The fear with acquiring talent has always been and always will be Mike Hill. The real test is going to be how Jeter and company handle contracts and extensions when these players start to blossom at the MLB level. Also, even an idiot can see that his revenue projections the fist few years are going to be way off. Let's see how he handles that. Still a long way to go before Jeter and company prove anything. It's not just about acquiring the talent. I for one will never be a Jeter fan. #fuckJeter. I am however a Marlin fan and that means that I root for him to succeed no matter how I feel about him. It's in my best interest as a fan. That also doesn't mean that I have to blindly agree with everything that has been done so far. #GoMarlins #MarlinForLife
January 26, 20188 yr I would honestly wanna wait until June and avoid the Super 2 cut off. That won't work for guys with service time already, as that is based off no service time. The safe Super2 callup date this year is around June 7-13th. That makes sense for say Gallen or Brigham who hasn't been up yet. Brinson - .025 (days up in the bigs) - 146 days (days can be in bigs this year) - May 8 Alcantara - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Anderson - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Peters - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Wallach - .035 - 136 days - May 18 Sierra - .042 - 129 days - May 25 Those are callup dates (give/take 1 day) for when guys can come up and the Marlins retain their rights for the 2024 season. If they are called up before then, they become free agents after 2023. It's a big deal they hold at least Brinson and Alcantara down here, probably Anderson and Sierra, maybe Peters, and probably doesn't matter for Wallach. The major comparisons to this is how the Cubs kept Bryant down 2 weeks to start his career, and the Marlins idiotically not keeping Fernandez down 2 weeks to start his. If you want to prevent them from being Super2s, add 50-55 days to those call up days, so Brinson would need to be in the minors until mid-July, and the rest a few weeks later. That's going to be tough for them to do given they need warm bodies to play at this point. Brinson is flat out May 8th, and if he is awesome, you buy him out in 2-3 seasons and use that extra year of control you created as leverage. If he is in there opening day, that is the stupidest thing the Marlins will have done this entire offseason.
January 26, 20188 yr All of this is being done with multiple MAJOR LEAGUE championships as the ultimate goal. Just not in 2018. I hope this rebuild works so that one day you can see what we've been telling you all along. If I can use the time machine for one time,I would no doubt to set the time in the 2022 to see what this team become to…
January 26, 20188 yr That won't work for guys with service time already, as that is based off no service time. The safe Super2 callup date this year is around June 7-13th. That makes sense for say Gallen or Brigham who hasn't been up yet. Brinson - .025 (days up in the bigs) - 146 days (days can be in bigs this year) - May 8 Alcantara - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Anderson - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Peters - .031 - 140 days - May 14 Wallach - .035 - 136 days - May 18 Sierra - .042 - 129 days - May 25 Those are callup dates (give/take 1 day) for when guys can come up and the Marlins retain their rights for the 2024 season. If they are called up before then, they become free agents after 2023. It's a big deal they hold at least Brinson and Alcantara down here, probably Anderson and Sierra, maybe Peters, and probably doesn't matter for Wallach. The major comparisons to this is how the Cubs kept Bryant down 2 weeks to start his career, and the Marlins idiotically not keeping Fernandez down 2 weeks to start his. If you want to prevent them from being Super2s, add 50-55 days to those call up days, so Brinson would need to be in the minors until mid-July, and the rest a few weeks later. That's going to be tough for them to do given they need warm bodies to play at this point. Brinson is flat out May 8th, and if he is awesome, you buy him out in 2-3 seasons and use that extra year of control you created as leverage. If he is in there opening day, that is the stupidest thing the Marlins will have done this entire offseason. The added benefit of keeping those guys up is that you can fill your roster with crap, and aim for a top 5 pick in next year's draft.
January 26, 20188 yr If you want to prevent them from being Super2s, add 50-55 days to those call up days, so Brinson would need to be in the minors until mid-July, and the rest a few weeks later. That's going to be tough for them to do given they need warm bodies to play at this point. Goodness gracious I was wayyy off on that. I was thinking June was the cut off date. Brinson is the most major league ready of the group but starting him Opening Day would be idiotic. Bridge the gap with the 1 year deals or non roster invitees. Those games in April and May won't mean anything regardless.
January 26, 20188 yr Signing as many FAs as possible not guaranteeing the success,collecting as many prospects as possible the same,too.
January 26, 20188 yr The added benefit of keeping those guys up is that you can fill your roster with crap, and aim for a top 5 pick in next year's draft. Top 1 is what I'm shooting for at this point.
January 26, 20188 yr However, there's no doubt that this rebuild was predicated for financial reasons. Yes this rebuild was necessary for financial reasons. That doesn't mean that Jeter's primary goal isn't acquiring talent more than slashing payroll. Just because he had to slash payroll for his plan to work doesn't mean his plan isn't ultimately about acquiring talent and building a sustainable winner. Jeter making a profit has nothing to do with this. Every business owner/leader should want to make a profit because it means their business is doing well.
January 26, 20188 yr Signing as many FAs as possible not guaranteeing the success,collecting as many prospects as possible the same,too. Wrong. It's not the same. Neither guarantees success but signing as many FAs as possible leads to financial struggles down the line. Collecting prospects is a cheaper way to get to the same goal and, if done right, is a more sustainable way to get to that goal.
January 26, 20188 yr Wrong. It's not the same. Neither guarantees success but signing as many FAs as possible leads to financial struggles down the line. Collecting prospects is a cheaper way to get to the same goal and, if done right, is a more sustainable way to get to that goal. Its the sustainability aspect that people dont seem to get. Prospects obviously bust all the time, but hitting on prospects allows you for 6 years to build around them for relatively cheap, especially those first 3 years at the league minimum. And if you do hit on them, it frees you up to use more money to fill free agent holes, like the Cubs did with Lester and Fowler and even though it didnt work out, heyward, like the Astros did with a guy like Reddick, and like the Twins now appear to be trying to do with some of the frontline SP talent out there. On top of that, even if you double and triple up at certain positions and they all hit, you can use the excess prospect talent down the line when hopefully the team is improved to make a trade for a big piece, like the Cubs did with Chapman, Yankees did with Stanton, Astros did with Verlander, etc. Long story short, its not a sure thing, but it is the best way to build a team, specifically in a smaller market.
January 26, 20188 yr There will be a new CBA in place by the time any of these guys are free agents, so the Super 2 rules might be different by then. Keeping Bryant down for 2 weeks caused a bit of a stink that a lot of players weren't happy about, so it'll be interesting to see if any changes are made before 2023/2024 when the new guys are looking at free agency.
January 26, 20188 yr I'm not saying anyone Jeter has acquired this offseason is Hall of Fame bound but people like @taiwanmarlin and others need to read this article which reminds you that when the San Diego Padres had a fire sale in 1993 they acquired a no-name prospect named Trevor Hoffman, who got voted into the Hall of Fame this week. Complain about a fire sale and the acquisition of "just prospects" all you want but every player you've ever loved watching was once a prospect. Just because you don't know a guy's name when he's first acquired doesn't mean they can't be good. http://davegeorge.blog.mypalmbeachpost.com/2018/01/26/who-knew-trevor-hoffman-was-bound-for-cooperstown-when-marlins-traded-him-away/
January 26, 20188 yr Yes this rebuild was necessary for financial reasons. That doesn't mean that Jeter's primary goal isn't acquiring talent more than slashing payroll. Just because he had to slash payroll for his plan to work doesn't mean his plan isn't ultimately about acquiring talent and building a sustainable winner. Jeter making a profit has nothing to do with this. Every business owner/leader should want to make a profit because it means their business is doing well. We'll just have to disagree on that point for the time being as I could no more prove Jeters main motivation is financial than you can prove that it's not. Time will tell. I guess as long as he can succeed his main motivation doesn't really matter.
January 26, 20188 yr We'll just have to disagree on that point for the time being as I could no more prove Jeters main motivation is financial than you can prove that it's not. Time will tell. I guess as long as he can succeed his main motivation doesn't really matter. I agree with this. We just dont know at this point. We'll know more in the upcoming years based off IFA and draft activity as well as whether we add in free agency like other teams in years 2-4 of their rebuilds when their prospects start developing. And i've never had a problem with owners in any sport wanting to make money as long as they care about winning as well. Ill never fault owners for wanting to make money.
January 26, 20188 yr Signing as many FAs as possible not guaranteeing the success,collecting as many prospects as possible the same,too. its cheaper to go the prospect way
January 26, 20188 yr its cheaper to go the prospect way And the ramifications of a prospect working out are much better than signing a big time free agent and that guy performing to standards. It's about doing the most with the amount of money we will spend. You sign a big time OF for 15-20 million a year, thats great, but there is downside if that doesnt work out. If a prospect works out, you get 6 years of cheap team control and if it doesnt, it sucks if you gave up a guy like Yelich, but it doesnt kill you monetarily.
January 26, 20188 yr We'll just have to disagree on that point for the time being as I could no more prove Jeters main motivation is financial than you can prove that it's not. Time will tell. I guess as long as he can succeed his main motivation doesn't really matter. My point is that the more Jeter makes trades like the Yelich one the more likely my theory is more valid than yours, not to be condescending but moreso just showing that he is making "talent acquistion trades" now that he's done making "financially motivated trades."
January 26, 20188 yr My point is that the more Jeter makes trades like the Yelich one the more likely my theory is more valid than yours, not to be condescending but moreso just showing that he is making "talent acquistion trades" now that he's done making "financially motivated trades." I love that he has not added some of the salaries to Dee, Stanton, Ozuna, and Yelich. Maximize the returns. Plus I think Prado has a really good chance to go from straight salary dump to possibly being able to acquire a mid level prospect at the deadline or next offseason if he regains his form from 2 years ago. I think that's a really good possibility. But for all the shit Jeter has gotten for salary dumps, even the biggest haters of his should admit that it's been really nice to see him maximize the returns for those guys and eat the contracts like Ziegler, Tazawa, and Prado for the upcoming year.
January 26, 20188 yr I love that he has not added some of the salaries to Dee, Stanton, Ozuna, and Yelich. Maximize the returns. Plus I think Prado has a really good chance to go from straight salary dump to possibly being able to acquire a mid level prospect at the deadline or next offseason if he regains his form from 2 years ago. I think that's a really good possibility. But for all the shit Jeter has gotten for salary dumps, even the biggest haters of his should admit that it's been really nice to see him maximize the returns for those guys and eat the contracts like Ziegler, Tazawa, and Prado for the upcoming year. Oh yeah that's true... more proof of my theory. If he was only about shedding payroll and not about adding talent then Jeter could have easily tossed in Tazawa Ziegler and Prado with Yelich Ozuna and Gordon.
January 26, 20188 yr Oh yeah that's true... more proof of my theory. If he was only about shedding payroll and not about adding talent then Jeter could have easily tossed in Tazawa Ziegler and Prado with Yelich Ozuna and Gordon. I was always super against doing that and im happy he didnt do that. Specifically Tazawa and Ziegler. Never made sense to me to include them in a deal off of terrible years last year when their deals expire after this upcoming year. Prado made a little bit more sense to me, but im glad they havent included him yet and im hoping they let him regain some value this season when he is actually healthy and playing every day.
January 26, 20188 yr All this improvement of the farm system and the team hasn't even played a single game nor drafted a single player under Jeter and Co yet. The people saying Jeter was only about saving money and wasn't really about acquiring talent are starting to lose that argument quicker than expected. this post is inane. The team didn't need to play any games to improve the farm system if you're just going to trade away all the major league talent. And you have no idea whether he's about saving money until it comes time to spend it. I mean we all hope that's true but c'mon man.
January 26, 20188 yr this post is inane. The team didn't need to play any games to improve the farm system if you're just going to trade away all the major league talent. And you have no idea whether he's about saving money until it comes time to spend it. I mean we all hope that's true but c'mon man. He made good points as to why. Jeter could’ve easily dumped a tazawa or even Chen in a yelich trade to get rid of money and prospects be damned. He didn’t do that though.
January 27, 20188 yr this post is inane. The team didn't need to play any games to improve the farm system if you're just going to trade away all the major league talent. And you have no idea whether he's about saving money until it comes time to spend it. I mean we all hope that's true but c'mon man. I don't think I said anything insane.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.