Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins SIGN Jean Segura. ... TO AN MLB DEAL

Featured Replies

5 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Sounds like a pornstar 

I think we found the Marlins sales pitch this year:

 

"Come watch 'Pipe Dream's' Big Bat slide into the bases"

4 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

I think we found the Marlins sales pitch this year:

 

"Come watch 'Pipe Dream's' Big Bat slide into the bases"

Why do I feel like David Samson actually considered porn-themed promotions at one time

3 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Why do I feel like David Samson actually considered porn-themed promotions at one time

Bahaha.  I could totally see it.

I mean, hell....they had the Mermaids forever.

4 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Why do I feel like David Samson actually considered porn-themed promotions at one time

Sex sells

13 hours ago, Entendu said:

A 2-ish WAR player. If we replace all of our garbage with just average position players, we'd be in it. This needs to be the first of many more moves

Dude that’s the issue I have. The pitching is good enough that an average MLB lineup would put them at least in the realm of competition and they haven’t done that. 

2 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Dude that’s the issue I have. The pitching is good enough that an average MLB lineup would put them at least in the realm of competition and they haven’t done that. 

With a little luck they might get there! We had awful luck last year if you hadn't heard.

  • Author
40 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

Ya but Segura really has no business at 3b full time given his offensive skills, also there are injury concerns with Segura, just like with Anderson.

OK, I have to ask again ... and yes I understand the team lacks power overall, all over the place, but why does a specific position have to fit a particular offensive profile? That seems like such an early 1920s baseball mindset.

If Babe Ruth happened to be a second baseman, would that be the preferred position to look for power?

2 minutes ago, Michael said:

OK, I have to ask again ... and yes I understand the team lacks power overall, all over the place, but why does a specific position have to fit a particular offensive profile? That seems like such an early 1920s baseball mindset.

If Babe Ruth happened to be a second baseman, would that be the preferred position to look for power?

I feel the same way. Who cares who hits at which position as long as the lineup is balanced. A lot of people want that big power at 1b but would we really be upset if we had a first baseman who got on base at a .390 clip but only hit 8 hrs all year? Just give me a balanced lineup that plays well at our own park.

  • Author
3 minutes ago, hovertical said:

I feel the same way. Who cares who hits at which position as long as the lineup is balanced. A lot of people want that big power at 1b but would we really be upset if we had a first baseman who got on base at a .390 clip but only hit 8 hrs all year? Just give me a balanced lineup that plays well at our own park.

Exactly!

Wade Boggs wasn't your prototypical power hitting third baseman [except for a couple random years], I doubt anyone was upset at him not hitting 30+ a year.

  • Author
Just now, SonOfJack said:

I was.

You just carry biases from @Jack obviously, who was absolutely set on his corner bats hitting 45 home runs a season.

Looking at our starting lineup, who is good enough?

SS - Segura

1B - Cooper

2B - Jazz

OF 1 - One of Avisail/Soler will be good enough, I'm betting

That leaves us with SS, 3B, CF and a corner OF position.

It's not impossible to field a contender if they fill 3 of those 4 positions with AVERAGE talent. Even better if they trade for an above average hitter to fill one of those holes. 

7 minutes ago, Michael said:

OK, I have to ask again ... and yes I understand the team lacks power overall, all over the place, but why does a specific position have to fit a particular offensive profile? That seems like such an early 1920s baseball mindset.

If Babe Ruth happened to be a second baseman, would that be the preferred position to look for power?

 

2 minutes ago, hovertical said:

I feel the same way. Who cares who hits at which position as long as the lineup is balanced. A lot of people want that big power at 1b but would we really be upset if we had a first baseman who got on base at a .390 clip but only hit 8 hrs all year? Just give me a balanced lineup that plays well at our own park.

Its that way because of the profile of a guy capable of playing a position from a defensive standpoint.  Generally a 3b was a guy that had a cannon for an arm and lacked side to side range of a ss/2b whom profiled as a quicker leaner guy largely because of the ground that needed to be covered to play the position defensively.   The extreme shifting took away that positional ideal, will be curious to see if things move back or not.  Though as players body types have changed you've seen guys maintain that quickness of a ss and take it to different positions on the infield mostly, so its an outdated viewpoint but you'd still like a bit of power out of your 3b, especially if you dont have a ss or cf that has power, its mitigated by having one of those positions manned by a guy with plus power.

The Marlins have no power anyway so its a moot point.  They also dont have a cf as discussed over and over.

4 minutes ago, Michael said:

Exactly!

Wade Boggs wasn't your prototypical power hitting third baseman [except for a couple random years], I doubt anyone was upset at him not hitting 30+ a year.

I wasnt aware that Jean Segura was hitting .330 every year though. 

  • Author
1 minute ago, Das Texan said:

I wasnt aware that Jean Segura was hitting .330 every year though. 

On base at that rate maybe.

[Actually that's his exact career OBP, bam, nailed it.]

1 minute ago, Entendu said:

Looking at our starting lineup, who is good enough?

SS - Segura

1B - Cooper

2B - Jazz

OF 1 - One of Avisail/Soler will be good enough, I'm betting

That leaves us with SS, 3B, CF and a corner OF position.

It's not impossible to field a contender if they fill 3 of those 4 positions with AVERAGE talent. Even better if they trade for an above average hitter to fill one of those holes. 

I dont understand this fascination with Garrett Cooper.

He is a. awful defensively b. has no power c. had a really bad second half d. was still only a 1 WAR player.   

Are we setting the bar THAT low?

Garrett Cooper would be a nice bench complementary piece.  The Marlins should have sold ultra high on him at the all star break in 2022.

  • Author
2 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

 

Its that way because of the profile of a guy capable of playing a position from a defensive standpoint.  Generally a 3b was a guy that had a cannon for an arm and lacked side to side range of a ss/2b whom profiled as a quicker leaner guy largely because of the ground that needed to be covered to play the position defensively.   The extreme shifting took away that positional ideal, will be curious to see if things move back or not.  Though as players body types have changed you've seen guys maintain that quickness of a ss and take it to different positions on the infield mostly, so its an outdated viewpoint but you'd still like a bit of power out of your 3b, especially if you dont have a ss or cf that has power, its mitigated by having one of those positions manned by a guy with plus power.

The Marlins have no power anyway so its a moot point.  They also dont have a cf as discussed over and over.

Just give me .275 and 20 HR from every position on the field.

1 minute ago, SilverBullet said:

Why hasn't Lou come in to tell us what to think about this signing yet? 

Baseball is a game of skill that is played with a hard ball and a bat between two teams of nine players each at a time on the playing field at once. Although many different people play Baseball all over the world it is most popular in the United States. It is so popular in fact, it is referred to as the national pastime of the United States because of the tradition and popularity associated with the game. Baseball consists of many complicated rules. It also has a very elaborate history. One can not fully understand the game America has grown to love until learning about not only the rules but also the history.

HISTORY


A popular legend of the history of baseball claims that Abner Doubleday, who was a Union officer during the American…show more content…
In each half of an inning one team bats while the other plays the field. If the score is tied after nine innings are over then the game is continued into extra innings and is concluded when one team is winning after an extra inning. These are the basic rules of baseball.


THE FIELD AND EQUIPMENT


Baseball is played on a field, which usually covers about two acres. The field is divided into an infield and an outfield. These two parts are considered fair territory and the rest of the field is considered foul. The infield is in the shape of a diamond and is 90 ft on each side. One point of the diamond is home plate which batters hit from. The other three points are bases: first, second, and third base. In the middle of the diamond is a pitchers mound which is slightly raised off the ground. The edges of the diamond from home plate to first base and home plate to third base are the foul lines, which extend all the way to the wall in the outfield. Behind first base is right field, behind second base is called center field, and behind third base is called left field. Fences are placed at the farthest limits in the outfield. In foul territory beyond the foul lines in the infield are dugouts where players sit when they are not playing or waiting to bat.

1 minute ago, SonOfJack said:

Baseball is a game of skill that is played with a hard ball and a bat between two teams of nine players each at a time on the playing field at once. Although many different people play Baseball all over the world it is most popular in the United States. It is so popular in fact, it is referred to as the national pastime of the United States because of the tradition and popularity associated with the game. Baseball consists of many complicated rules. It also has a very elaborate history. One can not fully understand the game America has grown to love until learning about not only the rules but also the history.

HISTORY


A popular legend of the history of baseball claims that Abner Doubleday, who was a Union officer during the American…show more content…
In each half of an inning one team bats while the other plays the field. If the score is tied after nine innings are over then the game is continued into extra innings and is concluded when one team is winning after an extra inning. These are the basic rules of baseball.


THE FIELD AND EQUIPMENT


Baseball is played on a field, which usually covers about two acres. The field is divided into an infield and an outfield. These two parts are considered fair territory and the rest of the field is considered foul. The infield is in the shape of a diamond and is 90 ft on each side. One point of the diamond is home plate which batters hit from. The other three points are bases: first, second, and third base. In the middle of the diamond is a pitchers mound which is slightly raised off the ground. The edges of the diamond from home plate to first base and home plate to third base are the foul lines, which extend all the way to the wall in the outfield. Behind first base is right field, behind second base is called center field, and behind third base is called left field. Fences are placed at the farthest limits in the outfield. In foul territory beyond the foul lines in the infield are dugouts where players sit when they are not playing or waiting to bat.

Close enough

2 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

Why hasn't Lou come in to tell us what to think about this signing yet? 

Man, that's bad optics.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.