Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
How much longer will the Marlins show patience?
This will be an interesting thread to revisit in a few months. :mischief2
-
Post Game thoughts... (June 15th)
I don't think anyone here wants Hermida to fail, or be as it's been phrased here (in this thread) a bust, because tonight should he start a fifteen game hitting streak we'll probably be five above .500 before it's over. But that said, it's impossible to ignore his mediocre defense so far this season or what appears to be his march towards the Mendoza line, and should he cross it, I think he becomes fair game for honest criticism. By that I don't mean the name-calling "he's garbage", "He sucks", "blah blah blah" but rather honest debate about his place on this team, although I suspect were he to approach .200 Gonzalez would bench him rather than let him sink further as a previous Marlins manager benched Prston Wilson before he could cross the 200 strikeout mark in a season. I don't think anyone would disagree he looks over-matched up there alot of the time. It may be the lingering effects of a previous injury, information we're not privy to, or it's in his head, but were he to continue his lackluster play a stint either on the bench or in AAA may be in store for him.
-
Game 3 thoughts (June 14th)
I'm just sick of the damn rain every night :thumbdown
-
Marlin transactions
I don't pretend to know anything (as in zero, zip, nada none) about Chris Seddon but I suppose he has two things going for him if nothing else. He's 23 and a lefty. There is no downside to taking a look in the minors. Maybe he's just fodder, maybe some scout thinks the Mudcats' pitching coach can do something with him.
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
lololol I take it you are looking in a mirror as you absolutely made 0 sense in this thread and were called out on it. And as usual your ideas about baseball are as cockeyed as have ever been posted here. As you sink deeper and deeper into the folly of your words it's just wonderful to watch you squirm and change the subject from what you said, parsing words to make believe you never said what you said. I really am laughing at you. I suppose it's in bad taste to laugh at your pathetic efforts, but I can't help myself. Lest we forget, and I quote you, "...Post 2004, Cabrera would have been around a 5/$25 buyout deal through 2009." You want to use Baldelli's insanely bad contract (which I know I'm repeating myself but he fired his agent and negotiated himself) or Blalock's because it fits your flawed theory that's there's a sucker born every minute, but you refuse to see the logic of Miguel Cabrera having to look no further away than across the clubhouse to the 2004 contract Mike Lowell signed for 4/$32 million and you want people to believe with that information in hand and nothing else, that he would give away his services for chump change. Miguel Cabrera... 5/$25... in your dreams. The facts always betray you Lou, and they always will. :brigginbounce
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
lololol
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
I realize in some roto league you can snooker the other guy but in the real world it doesn't work that way. You really think Miguel Cabrera, having watched Mike Lowell sign for about $30million over four years was going to take a penny less even back then. $5/$25, it's a joke. As for Blalock, I used him because you used him Lou, I guess you see them as equivalent players. And there's problem with your horribly erroneous thinking. Miguel Cabrera and Hank Blalock should never be mentioned in the same sentence. You can argue all you want but you can't get past the point that this isn't theold Soviet Union where you sign the contract offered or go the gulag. Pavano is to Willis what Lowell is to Cabrera and those $$$ are a helluva lot more than 5/$25. But of course you can't be wrong, ever.
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
You are 100% wrong on this one. So Cabrera and Willis will both be traded with 2 arbitration years left because their is no way that the Marlins will pay either of them what they are worth. If they would have bought them out this wouldn't be an isssue. I wonder if the Marlins could give you any other reason than that they were trying to save money on the short term over as to why they didn't sign Cabrera and Willis long term? Didn't they think they were going to be good in the near future? Anyone with two eyes and any baseball acumen knows that these guys would be worth the investment. This is exactly the reason why the Marlins will never have consistent success like some of the better run baseball teams. This is a completely different argument and I can't say I disagree with the contention of "what they should have done". I don't agree with the Marlins philosophy on this but what is missing is the recognition the other parties, the players, may not have wanted to do so. There seems to be this absolute belief here that if the Marlins waved a few bucks under these guy's noses they'd sign anything. That's what I disagree with. And I think your guarantee that the Marlins won't pay them is based not on speculation masquerading as fact. It may turn out to be true but not because you said it was so, that is unless you have some insider info or have discussed this with ownership or the GM and they've told you so. Alot of things could change that would keep both players in the fold for a long time.
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
And Lou, while there are exceptions, what your're using are second tier players unless you think Hank Blalock and Nick Johnson, Bill Hall Jhonny Peralta are the equivalent of a Miguel Cabrera. Even some of picks like Mauer and Bay and others just took the safe route to secure what they could have gotten in arbitration. In any group (in this at any given moment there are approximately 750 major league ballplayers) you can the exceptions and hold them up as represntativeof the whole group. You can do that but it would be wrong. Miguel Cabrera knew what he was doing in waiting. I doubt there was any reasonable offer the Marlins could have made that would have bought out his arb years and made it worthwhile for the franchise, or the player for that matter. And this idea salaries weren't esclating since the turn of the century is just ridiculous. Just look at what a Gil Meche got in 2007 and tell me what he would have signed for all things being equal in 2004. My guess is the number has risen at least, at the very least 100% in the last four (04-05-06-07) years. The reality is, if you have good representation and you're a superstar in the making (insert the name Miguel Canrera here) it isn't hard to see the handwriting on the wall. You know you can get through arbitration what the best of the best are getting and if you wait that number is sure to go up, so why throw money away? The answer is you don't. You can think whatever you want to think but of course you'd be wrong.
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
How come all of these other young players have signed their arbi years away then 03? I have absolutely zero doubt in my mind that at age 21, Cabs would have signed a deal like that. Same goes for Willis. It holds plenty of water, but just because you don't believe that to be the case makes it not so in your eyes. And that's ok too. Who are "all these young players" you speak of? Actually they are the exceptions. You may think Cabrera would have given away his big payday but his comments over his first few years in MLs were the opposite. He repeatedly said he understood how things worked and knew he was in line for the big $ down the line. In a rising market he knew (or his advisors knew) he was going to be worth more and more as time went on and player contracts escalated. Never sell yourself short in a rising market. *edit* Besides it takes two to tango. Even if the Marlins wanted to buy out arbitration years, it doesn't mean the players would have. The fact others made bad deals for themselves (Baldelli the idiot actually fired his agent and negotiated his own deal and look what it got him - peanuts) only provides proof of what not to do if you're a talented player in baseball today.
-
What doesn't the front office understand about buying out arbitrat
All this woulda - coulda - shoulda rotisserie league talk about buying out arb years of Willis and Cabrera are based on the false assumption that both fell off turnip trucks, walked around with blinders on and had no idea what was happening throughout baseball or what they were worth on the baseball market. Cabrera especially has spoken over the years about not minding making minimum wage because he knew in a few years the big payday was coming. Cabrera has been on the fast track to superstardom since he was 19 and it isn't like he didn't surround himself with intelligence in an effort to guide his career. His english may beflawed but so far his business acumen has been first rate. Cabrera would no more have signed for 5/$25 than the man in the moon. It's lunacy to believe otherwise. Ditto Willis. You watch Pavano go get $10 million a year three years ago, it doesn't take rocket science to figure out what kind of dollars you can expect just around the corner. Both I think would welcome extended contracts more for the desire to play here than the money which will come their way regardless of where they play. All this talk reads well until you look at it realistically and then it doesn't hold water.
-
Craptastic Sunday game/series thoughts
Does it not dawn people that perhaps there's a reason he didn't use his curveball, or much of any other breaking pitch? Pitchers do have days when they suffer from control or mechanical issues or their curveball just stays flat or their slider doesn't slide. I would say that more and more it becomes obvious that the complexities of the game are completely lost here. This childish view that everything is black and white, that people here could actually call a game or even have the faintest idea what the right pitch is at a given time without scouting reports, film and other info on opposing batters is just laughable. As for Olivo he could be guilty as sin, but just is likely is he's calling for a pitch down and away and getting one down the middle or calling for a curveball and watching it come in straight as a string. I don't say that to defend Olivo but rather make the point we don't know. We just don't know. We can use every loss as a launching pad for more naysaying and bad-mouthing but in the end none of us has the faintest idea what was going on between pitcher and catcher on Sunday. Or any other game for that matter.
-
Overall thoughts.
One game was against Sheilds who has been great this year and today the D-Rays had an obvious edge in the starting pitching department. I agree with much of what you said but I don't think Dontrelle pitched bad yesterday. It was "ball finds the hole nite at Dolphins Stadium". The guy eats up a ton of innings and don't get me started on the Beckett thing. Josh Beckett is the DL's best friend and Dontrelle is the opposite. Sometimes on this board Dontrelle gets bashed like he's a bust. We have PLENTY of other potential busts in the works on this team and he isnt one of them. Again, he's no Roy Oswalt but Olsen is a head case, JJ, Anibal and Nolasco are on the DL and where's Dontrelle? Making all his starts and going deep in games like he always does. And all I ever hear is......we should have traded him. I'm with Ramp, unless we get offered everything plus the ranch, he stays put. :Clap :Clap Just major league average defense behind a good pitcher makes him very good and a handful of runs to work with works wonders as well. When both are missing even the best pitcher is doomed to nights like Saturday. There's no rhyme or reason to the blame game played here so I've come to the conclusion it's best to ignore it. You' think we were twenty games under .500 instead of two. I'm in agreement with these posts above. :thumbup
-
Who should the Marlins go after? (Centerfielder)
Well the Marlins took three (3) centerfielders out of their first ten picks, so I guess they are pretty open about the future at the position. :brigginbounce
-
Marlins Grumblings
If the Angels were our trading partner I doubt Chone Figgins or most of the above-mentioned cast of characters would be the guys Beinfest would be focusing on. I do want to congratulate Figgins though for finally getting his BA over the Mendoza line.
-
Beinfest and Chatsworth HS
Someone (newspaper reporter, online guy like Mayo, etc. - don't remember who) referred to the school as a "baseball factory" which very well may be the case considering the number of kids from this year's squad being drafted in the early rounds. It may just be that if you are of a certain talent level entering HS this is THE ONE you go to, for development purposes and to be seen.
-
Where does Ricky Nolaso fit in the scheme of things
Having too many starters is a dream come true with a GM like Beinfest and front office support like Fleming and Hill. I look forward to the day we have seven, eight or possibly nine healthy major league starters.
-
Steve Finley DFA'd
Joey Gathright-OF-Royals Jun. 6 - 10:53 pm et Joey Gathright, recalled earlier in the day, enjoyed a solid opening game Wednesday to help the slumping Royals edge Cleveland 4-3. He was 2-for-3 with a run, a steal and a sac bunt, giving KC the spark it needed to win for just the third time in 13 games. If you're in need of speed, grab Gathright, one of the fastest players in the game. Given that the Royals have struggled to score runs lately, he's likely to be given plenty of burn to help jump start the offense. source: rotoworld
-
Congratulations to Vanden Hurk
If I say he ought to be sent back down everyone will jump down my throat but that said - as I suggested about not rushing Josh Johnson back - I look at the huge improvement the kid showed tonight from his earlier starts and I have to at least consider the notion that perhaps another month, maybe two in the minors (read, another five to ten starts) working on what he learned tonight (with maybe another ML appearance along the way) might pay more dividends down the line than throwing him out there every five days at the MLB level starting five days from now.
-
Steve Finley DFA'd
Can a player who only has speed really "languish" when the rest of his skill set is crap? Eric Reed put up nice #s in AAA too. And Gathright wouldnt fix anything. Just another weak 8th hitter or someone they would try to foolishly put at leadoff. He only has speed. He only has a glove. He's only hitting .390 in his last ten games. He only has on OBP of .425+ against both righties and lefties and an overall OBP north of .450. He's only hitting .358 in with runners on. He's only walked 37 times against a measely 23 strikeouts in 186 at bats. And oh yeah, 21 stolen bases. The fact you find it necessary to bash the guy and belittle his abilities when he's having a fabulous year by almost every benchmark is the biggest endorsement I think of for his skills. (note: I was wrong above. Since walks don't count in calculating at bats he's actually only struck out 23 times in 223 "total" at bats.)
-
Steve Finley DFA'd
If you want to fix centerfield go to Omaha and get Joey Gathright who, if you'll all stop laughing for a minute go to MiLB and look at his numbers. The incredible thing is besides hitting like .330/.450 and slg .850+/-, the thing that says to me he's maturing at the plate is his walk/strikeout ratio is at 1 to 1. The Marlins would *lead* the NL East if a few of their hitters could have BB/K ratio like that. He's languishing in AAA and yet he's isn't packing it in, he's stealing bases, playing excellent defense. All I ask is people take a look and not think about Joey Gathright circa 2005-2006 when the Rays thought he should hit for more power and he screwed himself into the ground trying to reach the warning track. I think having an .850 OPS with no homeruns is a damn good number. *edit typo*
-
Dontrelle Willis will "definitely be traded"
All this because Kevin Kernan says so? Kevin bleepin' Kernan?
-
Page 2 and the Onion
Funny thing is Benitez probably weighs less today than when the Giants signed him. (comment on some of linked material)
-
Johnson pitching in Jupiter
After so long away from anything approaching the level of play in MLB, I'd like to see him at least go to AA or better AAA to get some work in rather than pronounce him ready after a few games against A ball guys. I am so not in a hurry to see him rushed back. Take your time, you have the rest of your career ahead of you.
-
Strikeouts and our Offense
Im sorry to say this... but the reason why we didn't win this game today was because of the 3rd spot (hanley). On the other hand, you might say... yeah but we have a winning record with hanley batting 3rd... well, let me just say this; The reason why we won those game was not because of hanley batting 3rd, but the reason why we lost today was because of hanley batting third. i don't know if u guys get me. I don't know how you can blame Hanley's place in the lineup for his inability to hit w/ RISP or whatever you want to call it. He couldn't do it when he was hitting first, he hasn't done it hitting third with Miguel Cabrera standing in the on-deck circle as protection (sheesh, how much more protection can a guy get?). Uggla and Amezaga did their jobs. If everyone feels the obligation to blame everyone but the guy who didn't come through so be it but we lost this game as much because Ramirez and Cabrera struck out five times between them as anything. Miggy was culpable as well. You want to move Hanley back and Amezaga into the two hole, fine, and have Uggla hit fourth or fifth. Okay with me, but at least be objective about what happened today. Ramirez was the only guy in the starting lineup without a hit and I submit it wouldn't have mattered if he was hitting first or third or seventh - he isn't swinging the bat well or making consistent contact - he's been through this before (wasn't he once last season something like 0 or 1 for 30 ??? when he slumped and he still came back and was just gangbusters down the stretch) and in my mind if you can't hit what's offered with Miggy coming up behind you, it's you're problem and no one elses. This too shall pass. he's too good a hitter not to. We were having a similar concern for Uggla three weeks ago and he came out of it. Ramirez will too. If tomorrow he's back leading off, okay, but if he's not better baseball minds than ours have determined it's whats best for the team and I'll go with it.