February 17, 201412 yr The team is saying yet again that they aren't going to make him an offer until after the season. Getting tired of this. The team is already being blamed. Stanton says he dosen't want to talk contracts until after the season.
February 17, 201412 yr The team is already being blamed. Stanton says he dosen't want to talk contracts until after the season. The team had an entire off season to make him an offer.
February 17, 201412 yr This is the second year in a row of 'hey, we'll talk after the season' followed by complete silence. Then rinse and repeat.
February 17, 201412 yr The team is already being blamed. Stanton says he dosen't want to talk contracts until after the season. He actually said that he didn't want to talk during the season. The season hasn't started yet
February 18, 201412 yr I really think they've decided that it doesn't matter whether they keep him or not, since it's not like people are going to show up to games just because he's there. I'm sure the baseball people want him, but God knows that Loria thinks.
February 18, 201412 yr I really think they've decided that it doesn't matter whether they keep him or not, since it's not like people are going to show up to games just because he's there. I'm sure the baseball people want him, but God knows that Loria thinks. Him staying won't bring people to the ballpark... but him staying longterm "should" increase our chances of being a consistently winning team, and THAT is what brings people to the ballpark. I hope Loria sees that.
February 18, 201412 yr The way Loria sees it is that people are gradually jumping off the Stanton train and instead hopping on the Fernandez Express.
February 18, 201412 yr The way Loria sees it is that people are gradually jumping off the Stanton train and instead hopping on the Fernandez Express. Which is idiotic since he could have had both and still be bottom 5 in payroll for years and years. I can't wait till they trade him and then he signs some shlubs like Buck, Bell, Dobbs, and C. Lee to longterm deals.
February 18, 201412 yr Which is idiotic since he could have had both and still be bottom 5 in payroll for years and years. I can't wait till they trade him and then he signs some shlubs like Buck, Bell, Dobbs, and C. Lee to longterm deals. With Loria's track record, I wouldn't rule out him literally signing Buck, Bell, Dobbs, and C. Lee again.
February 20, 201412 yr just read about the extension the Braves gave Simmons and couldn't help but think about MarlinsLou's posts in this thread
February 21, 201412 yr Stanton is as good as gone after this season. He has said nothing in the past two years that makes me think wants to stay in Miami. I hope he has a banner season so that his value will peak, then he can be traded to a contending team with deep pockets for several of their top prospects. The thought of Stanton leaving the Marlins won't be so painful every time I see him swing and miss at a low and outside curve ball for the third strike.
February 21, 201412 yr Stanton is as good as gone after this season. He has said nothing in the past two years that makes me think wants to stay in Miami. I hope he has a banner season so that his value will peak, then he can be traded to a contending team with deep pockets for several of their top prospects. The thought of Stanton leaving the Marlins won't be so painful every time I see him swing and miss at a low and outside curve ball for the third strike. Well that's the problem. If he has the banner season, a team acquiring him will have to dish out a $175-200 million contract to secure him past arbitration, i.e. that is not trading him for peak value. A rational team is not unloading their farm system for the risk Stanton walks in two years or paying him the King's ransom. Likewise, if he stinks, he is not as valuable as he is right now where he is a year removed from a murderous season and 2013 is 'forgivable' based on the state of franchise and lack of lineup protection (not that he had a bad year, just not 'star' level production that is expected). Either way, next offseason is not as much in a trade as this offseason so the peak is gone. The only way keeping him on an arbitration tender makes sense, is if they plan on buying multiple free agents 2015-2016 (and I'm not talking Furcal, Jones, McGehee, Baker level players) to build a legitimate contender with him still here. I think we all know the chances of that happening, meaning they choose the only bad option. Signing longterm or trading him would both be better for the longterm picture. Keeping him for 1 year, does nothing for this franchise. But maybe they go nuts in June/July and trade and all of this is moot. Guess we'll see. I'm not optimistic these clowns have a plan besides padding Loria's bank account with that revenue sharing cash.
February 21, 201412 yr I just hope that if the Marlins do trade Stanton in the near future.....that they don't get a big bag of crap like the Tigers gave them for Cabrera. That was a shockingly bad return for the best hitter of this generation!
February 21, 201412 yr Well that's the problem. If he has the banner season, a team acquiring him will have to dish out a $175-200 million contract to secure him past arbitration, i.e. that is not trading him for peak value. A rational team is not unloading their farm system for the risk Stanton walks in two years or paying him the King's ransom. Likewise, if he stinks, he is not as valuable as he is right now where he is a year removed from a murderous season and 2013 is 'forgivable' based on the state of franchise and lack of lineup protection (not that he had a bad year, just not 'star' level production that is expected). Either way, next offseason is not as much in a trade as this offseason so the peak is gone. The only way keeping him on an arbitration tender makes sense, is if they plan on buying multiple free agents 2015-2016 (and I'm not talking Furcal, Jones, McGehee, Baker level players) to build a legitimate contender with him still here. I think we all know the chances of that happening, meaning they choose the only bad option. Signing longterm or trading him would both be better for the longterm picture. Keeping him for 1 year, does nothing for this franchise. But maybe they go nuts in June/July and trade and all of this is moot. Guess we'll see. I'm not optimistic these clowns have a plan besides padding Loria's bank account with that revenue sharing cash. Not to be totally positive here, but what if the young pitching staff clicks this year and the Marlins are in contention for a Wild Card spot this July 31st? Then Loria has proven in the past (2003 especially), that he's willing to spend to make his team better at the trade deadline. I know that's probably a pipe dream.......but is it impossible? No.
February 21, 201412 yr Not to be totally negative here, but what if the young pitching staff clicks this year and the Marlins are in contention for a Wild Card spot this July 31st? Then Loria has proven in the past (2003 especially), that he's willing to spend to make his team better at the trade deadline. I know that's probably a pipe dream.......but is it impossible? No. To Loria's credit, he also spent money after the World Series by keeping a good part of our core around as well as adding Delgado. He will spend if he sees something should come of it.
February 27, 201412 yr Stanton doesn't want to stay in Miami. He will if they throw a boatload of cash at him and the years are limited enough to allow him to be a free agent in his prime (huge). It's that simple. 5 years, $90-100 million. That will get it done and thats all the Marlins can hope for at this time. next offseason, when he is guaranteed another significant arbitration tender, makes it worse and no shot they offer him a contract $200+ million because this is Loria we're talking about. Enjoy him while he is here. Actually, I think Loria is more than willing to spend money. He went and got Carlos Delgado. He went and go Jose Reyes and offered Albert Pujols. The issue isn't whether he would get impulsive and sign somebody. The issue is he would trade him 10 months later.
February 28, 201412 yr I just hope that if the Marlins do trade Stanton in the near future.....that they don't get a big bag of crap like the Tigers gave them for Cabrera. That was a shockingly bad return for the best hitter of this generation! Actually, it was a fair return at the time. Maybin and Miller were top ten prospects at the time. They failed miserably and the Marlins lost the trade down the road, however, at the time, it was probably the best and fairest deal available. We're never going to really know with these prospects and it didn't pan out that time.
February 28, 201412 yr Actually, it was a fair return at the time. Maybin and Miller were top ten prospects at the time. They failed miserably and the Marlins lost the trade down the road, however, at the time, it was probably the best and fairest deal available. We're never going to really know with these prospects and it didn't pan out that time. The Marlins probably could have gotten a better deal (lower risk prospects) if they didn't ask so much from the Dodgers.
February 28, 201412 yr The Marlins probably could have gotten a better deal (lower risk prospects) if they didn't ask so much from the Dodgers. That's speculation, and at the time Maybin was considered incredibly low risk with a "Mike Cameron" floor, which would have been awesome. I agree completely that you can't knock the trade, but in hindsight it was obviously a disaster.
February 28, 201412 yr Actually, I think Loria is more than willing to spend money. He went and got Carlos Delgado. He went and go Jose Reyes and offered Albert Pujols. The issue isn't whether he would get impulsive and sign somebody. The issue is he would trade him 10 months later. I agree Loria is going to just splurge when he thinks the time is right (hopefully not on Bucks, Bells, Dobbs, and Buerhles...) but Stanton is a different animal than Delgado and Reyes. His next contract is going to be worth more than those two combined. I think it's a lock Stanton gets a deal top 25 most lucrative in the history of baseball (that is assuming he does what we all think in 2014, 35+ HR/.900+OPS/etc). If you think that is crazy, Freddie Freeman got the 29th highest contract in the history of baseball. Freddie Freeman. Top 25 is $141 million, and I bet he pushes into Top 15 which is $160 million. Top 10 is $180 and if he really crushes, not out of the question. This is just not Loria splurge territory. He'll sign 3-4 free agents for that amount of money, which is still a heap of talented players. They missed their opportunity with Stanton. He gone unless he gets hurt and they can't trade him/still cheaper for 2015.
March 1, 201412 yr That's speculation, and at the time Maybin was considered incredibly low risk with a "Mike Cameron" floor, which would have been awesome. I agree completely that you can't knock the trade, but in hindsight it was obviously a disaster. It's not entirely speculation, really. At the time, there were numerous rumors about the massive basket of prospects that the Marlins wanted from the Dodgers. Based on the way the deal fell apart, it seems like the Marlins shifted their attention away from the more developed prospects in LA (like Kemp) in favor of much younger, riskier talent like Maybin. Maybin was highly touted because of his tools. He deserved to be ranked as a top prospect and it could not have been predicted at the time that he would have been a bust, but the fact that he had hardly played above high A ball before the Marlins acquired him makes him somewhat of a risky piece in the acquisition. He demonstrated the potential to be a great player through his tools, but he had not done much at that point to back it up.
March 1, 201412 yr I agree Loria is going to just splurge when he thinks the time is right (hopefully not on Bucks, Bells, Dobbs, and Buerhles...) but Stanton is a different animal than Delgado and Reyes. His next contract is going to be worth more than those two combined. I think it's a lock Stanton gets a deal top 25 most lucrative in the history of baseball (that is assuming he does what we all think in 2014, 35+ HR/.900+OPS/etc). If you think that is crazy, Freddie Freeman got the 29th highest contract in the history of baseball. Freddie Freeman. Top 25 is $141 million, and I bet he pushes into Top 15 which is $160 million. Top 10 is $180 and if he really crushes, not out of the question. This is just not Loria splurge territory. He'll sign 3-4 free agents for that amount of money, which is still a heap of talented players. They missed their opportunity with Stanton. He gone unless he gets hurt and they can't trade him/still cheaper for 2015. Yea, it's going to be more than he ever did. I wouldn't put it past him. Just like I'm sure he would trade him soon thereafter. I agree they ruined it with him by not signing him yet.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.