Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Don Martingly needs his head examined by a physician

Featured Replies

To me it's when he tries something and it doesn't work... he stays with it!!!

 

PLAYOFFS GAME 1 - Mattingly's Lineup

 

CF - Yefri Perez

 

LF - Cole Gillespie

 

3B - Chris Johnson

 

1B - Don Kelly

 

C - Jeff Mathis

 

SS - Miguel Rojas

 

2B - Tomas Telis

 

RF - Cole Figueroa

 

P - Jose Urena

 

 

I wanna know his reason why. Considering Stanton being at first in that situation didn't matter unless they tie the game anyway. Stanton isn't blazing fast but he isn't slow either. Slightly above average speed when needed.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app

 

Stanton doesn't have a tremendous amount of acceleration, but he is fast. Not super fast, but he's no liability around the bases. But you put a pinch runner in for slow players. Not Stanton. So, why was Perez thrown out? Do you blame him for trying to take 3rd? No, of course not. He was put in the game strictly to try and take 3rd or round for home in the event that it was close. What's the consequence? You removed your best hitter from the lineup to have his replacement be thrown out. Stanton probably would've stayed, and that inning would've been extended. The only reason Perez ran was because he was tasked to do so. 

 

Oh, and can we talk about how Mattingly burns relief pitchers on the routine? Wittgren pitched 4 pitches.... Rodney pitched what, 8 or 9? I didn't see. Why were neither of those pitchers asked to come and pitch an additional inning? I feel like Mattingly has a thing for under utilizing his bullpen. 

 

 

He used to put in defensive replacements for Justin Bour regularly which also used to bother me since Bour is perfectly capable there.  It seems like generally he's gotten better with the bullpen over the course of the season as it's been drilled into his head.  But like a lot of managers he's locked in to old ideas.

 

 

Big shutout to Stanton to work the walk when last month he probably would have struck out on 4 pitches. If he doesn't work that walk Ozuna never even gets the chance to deliver the hit.

 

Now back to substitution it was basically a moot point because Ozuna swung at the first pitch anyway and since Yelich was on a 3rd he easily score, only would have held big had Yefri been on 2nd base.

 

I don't see the sense in taking out your best threat in the lineup who has been hitting well lately with the good chance that the game was going into extra innings anyway.

 

@Dr Beinfest I would believe Mattingly's reason would be that if he uses them 2 innings they won't be available for a couple days after that. Which I could understand his reasoning when our pitchers pretty much only go 6 innings anyway. 

 

 

He used to put in defensive replacements for Justin Bour regularly which also used to bother me since Bour is perfectly capable there.  It seems like generally he's gotten better with the bullpen over the course of the season as it's been drilled into his head.  But like a lot of managers he's locked in to old ideas.

 

I mean, it's difficult to screw up managing this current bullpen.

 

With that said, I do give him credit for giving Phelps the 8th early on in the year. Probably his best on-field managerial move.

 

Pretty easy to manage the pen now though. Front office has done a nice job putting it together. 

 

 

Stanton doesn't have a tremendous amount of acceleration, but he is fast. Not super fast, but he's no liability around the bases. But you put a pinch runner in for slow players. Not Stanton. So, why was Perez thrown out? Do you blame him for trying to take 3rd? No, of course not. He was put in the game strictly to try and take 3rd or round for home in the event that it was close. What's the consequence? You removed your best hitter from the lineup to have his replacement be thrown out. Stanton probably would've stayed, and that inning would've been extended. The only reason Perez ran was because he was tasked to rdo so. 

 

Oh, and can we talk about how Mattingly burns relief pitchers on the routine? Wittgren pitched 4 pitches.... Rodney pitched what, 8 or 9? I didn't see. Why were neither of those pitchers asked to come and pitch an additional inning? I feel like Mattingly has a thing for under utilizing his bullpen. 

 

Or is Mattingly wanting to keep those he used in the game for possible use in the game tonight?  Do you want Dunn in or possibly Wittgren? This way it gives Don a choice to use one of many than one of few

 

 

Or is Mattingly wanting to keep those he used in the game for possible use in the game tonight?  Do you want Dunn in or possibly Wittgren? This way it gives Don a choice to use one of many than one of few

 

And when tonight goes extra innings? And when none of these guys are available? 

 

He burns through pitchers like it's nobody's business. When we go into extra innings, we always have an exhausted scorecard. If Wittgren only throws 4 pitches, it's not a bad idea to ask him to pitch fhe 9th. You preserve Rodney for the remainder of the game, if not the series. 

 

I fail to see how using more pitchers preserves pitchers for future games. Hate to break it to you, but Dunn is part of the bullpen and will get his work eventually.

 

 

I don't think that McKeon would have taken Stanton out in the ninth.

McKeon was known for make had scratching moves that usually worked. Not sure if McKeon but certainly would be something I could see him doing.

 

 

 

 

McKeon was known for make had scratching moves that usually worked. Not sure if McKeon but certainly would be something I could see him doing.

 

 

 

 

I wouldn't categorize what Mattingly did as one of those bold, gutsy moves that some managers do that raise an eyebrow. Like when McKeon pulled one of his relievers in the middle of an AB.

 

But what Mattingly did with Stanton was more sloppy/clumsy. He just wasn't using enough brain cells to think that he should be saving Stanton for extra innings.

 

I would guess that like 99% of MLB managers would agree that what Mattingly did was stupid.

 

 

I wouldn't categorize what Mattingly did as one of those bold, gutsy moves that some managers do that raise an eyebrow. Like when McKeon pulled one of his relievers in the middle of an AB.

 

But what Mattingly did with Stanton was more sloppy/clumsy. He just wasn't using enough brain cells to think that he should be saving Stanton for extra innings.

 

I would guess that like 99% of MLB managers would agree that what Mattingly did was stupid.

I'm not condoning what he did. I myself scratched my head at the move. But he felt it could work and since they won it didn't really backfire even if it ultimatelydidn't play into the decision. I doubt he'll be doing it again any time soon but he took a shot, the team rallied, and the team won. So, time to focus on tonight's game.

 

 

 

 

I'm not condoning what he did. I myself scratched my head at the move. But he felt it could work and since they won it didn't really backfire even if it ultimatelydidn't play into the decision. I doubt he'll be doing it again any time soon but he took a shot, the team rallied, and the team won. So, time to focus on tonight's game.

 

 

 

 

You can't really forget about something like this. Going into the postseason I would be very wary of a manager who has pulled a boneheaded move like this.

 

There's no way to say that the move "worked." It just didn't produce the disastrous consequences that it could have if the game went further into extras.

 

Arguably though the game might not have even gone into extras if there weren't an idiot like Perez on the basepaths who ran the Marlins out of the inning.

 

Last night's victory doesn't redeem a really dumb managerial decision.

 

 

I disagree with taking Stanton out there. However, Mattingly's thought process was we need to tie this game up at any cost, including taking Stanton out. So if Ozuna hit a slow/deep ground ball to the SS, Yefri's speed could avoid the force at second and the tying run would score. If the game was already tied he would have left Stanton in. Because it wasn't tied, if Yefri gave us a 5% better chance of tying the game, Mattingly would take that and let our bullpen and other batters win the game in extra innings (or win it that inning with speedy Yefri being the go ahead run). All I'm saying is, I get why he did it. I almost always agree that teams need to play for that moment (for example, bringing in your best reliever in a high leverage situation even if it's not the 9th) not a few innings later. There was no force at second, Yefri got thrown out at 3rd and Stanton's spot in the lineup actually came up again - all terrible outcomes. But, we won it without Stanton and if Yefri's speed broke up a force out we'd be singing Don's praises today.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using MarlinsBaseball.com mobile app

 

 

Also... Even with these stupid moves, I wouldn't trade him for any other manager right now.

 

I remember a time not so long ago...

 

When a clown who only managed HS ball club ... became a MLB Manager for a Professional MLB Ball Club

 

Yeah I'm good with Mattingly 

 

 

  • Author
I remember a time not so long ago...

 

When a clown who only managed HS ball club ... became a MLB Manager for a Professional MLB Ball Club

 

Yeah I'm good with Mattingly 

 

I actually forgot that ever happened.  I think my brain treated it like a traumatic event that it wanted to bury. 

 

 

We're 9 games over .500 with a staff who you could literally replace with 3 people and not feel bad about it. I think sideburns is doing fine

 

 

  • Author

Shocked how many posters played the result.  Mattingly made a critical managerial error and luckboxed his way to a win and all is forgiven.

 

I'm not saying fire the guy or I WANT DAN JENNINGS back but, man, taking Stanton out in those circumstances was awful.

 

 

Or is Mattingly wanting to keep those he used in the game for possible use in the game tonight?  Do you want Dunn in or possibly Wittgren? This way it gives Don a choice to use one of many than one of few

 

Yep, Mattingly's limit inning use of relief pitchers Monday night allowed Mattingly use the same Tuesday night in that win.  So possibly Mattingly is smarter then some think..........or possibly some jump the gun trashing anyone for anything (just not Mattingly) and need just to cool in my opinion

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.