January 10, 20188 yr Why does everyone think they can really request a trade? He doesn't have a choice of being in a rebuild or not. That's not how this works. Still, I want him gone anyways so if this helps the process then so be it. With that said, it is quite funny that the guy wants out before even touching a Marlins uniform.
January 10, 20188 yr Who cares? They should trade him anyways. Only thing that Castro should realize is that saying things like this publicly make it harder for the Marlins to trade him, as teams may think the Marlins will move him just to get a cancer out of the clubhouse and/or Castro is viewed as a primadonna because LOL at Starlin Castro, a complimentary starting player, requesting a trade.
January 10, 20188 yr Only thing that Castro should realize is that saying things like this publicly make it harder for the Marlins to trade him My question though, did he really say this publicly? I haven't seen him say a thing. Castro could have very well said this privately to his agent for it to be passed on to the Marlins privately... and then it's the media that somehow gets wind of it and lets it out. It's such a horrible process really.
January 10, 20188 yr Good. I hope they are able unload that contract and get a decent player out of the trade.
January 10, 20188 yr My question though, did he really say this publicly? I haven't seen him say a thing. Castro could have very well said this privately to his agent for it to be passed on to the Marlins privately... and then it's the media that somehow gets wind of it and lets it out. It's such a horrible process really. Regardless, the Marlins will get ahold of the news. I don't think Castro will deny it either. I am not crazy about sources, but Rosenthal usually gets it right. His contract is a waste and holding up until the trade deadline would be ridiculous. Allocate that money towards stop gap players or the draft.
January 10, 20188 yr Why does everyone think they can really request a trade? He doesn't have a choice of being in a rebuild or not. That's not how this works. Still, I want him gone anyways so if this helps the process then so be it. With that said, it is quite funny that the guy wants out before even touching a Marlins uniform. Because any player can request anything through their representatives? I don't see what's so OMG about that. Its not like the Marlins have to honor any requests.
January 10, 20188 yr Regardless, the Marlins will get ahold of the news. I don't think Castro will deny it either. I am not crazy about sources, but Rosenthal usually gets it right. His contract is a waste and holding up until the trade deadline would be ridiculous. Allocate that money towards stop gap players or the draft. I love Rosenthal, I'm not blaming him but it doesn't sound like Castro went public with anything... neither did Yelich or Realmuto for that matter. It's just stupid that a player can do something privately between him and the team and then before they know it, it's a public matter.
January 10, 20188 yr I was very interested in the process of who should be traded, what should we get, is the full rebuild the right way, was the slashing necessary (yes, if you believed a $40 mill loss was an annual thing with the core group) now knowing that a large profit was imminent without it. The back and forth discussions as to how much value we were getting back, Astros/cubs did it this way and on and on. Now, everytime we discuss a player moving, it reeks of Jeter saying "well, he didn't want to be here" and knowing that for each major league player moved to bring in a minimum salary player is a move in the right direction for Jeter and his pocket. The lack of incentive of fielding a team of nothing more than minor league quality players at minimum cost is troubling and the consideration of promoting attendance is disingenuous when your bonus is not based on success in the field and that it doesn't matter much if there are 5000 people in the stands or 15,000 when the goal will always be payroll discipline. He promoted nothing more than profits to his potential investors, nothing more. So, it doesn't matter if Castro is moved now or later, he will be moved. Is it the right baseball move? Sure, why not, the team sucks and we can put Billy the Marlin at second and it will not matter, but will you watch this team or go.
January 10, 20188 yr I love Rosenthal, I'm not blaming him but it doesn't sound like Castro went public with anything... neither did Yelich or Realmuto for that matter. It's just stupid that a player can do something privately between him and the team and then before they know it, it's a public matter. But I thought players cant request trades or whatever you have been spouting? So doing so privately is ok. Doing so pubically is not (which neither Yelich, Realmuto or Castro have done)
January 10, 20188 yr For all we know the Marlins met with players or at least their representatives and it was a very cordial meeting along the lines of Jeter - "sup" Castro/Castro Rep - "sup" Jeter - "we're trying to get Castro moved but just waiting for right parts and deal" Castro/Rep - "ok good, I was going to mention I/he didn't want to be here for a rebuild. Just wanted to confirm with you... Can I grab some ribs?" Jeter - "yea man, we catered from flanigans" Castro/Rep - "oh sick, I love flanigans" And then someone (Rosenthal) talks to the agent or rep or someone in the Marlins and they're like "Yea Castro asked to be traded" just kind of matter of fact and it becomes this whole diva type issue. And as Lou mentioned, this leaking doesn't help the agent/player and it doesn't help the Marlins because we have a bad rep we need to change so teams will low ball us even more now. It's going to get to the point that we might need to hold on to players through the trade deadline because teams just expect us to cough up players to shed salary and will lowball us. Hopefully they'll realize that's not the case and give a real offer. But unlike the Realmuto/Yelich discussion, that they're worth building around like Cubs did with Rizzo or Astros with Altuve, etc ... there is zero reason to hold on to Castro so I hope this gets done. Between his contract and the fact that he's never worn our uniform, hope it gets done before the season starts.
January 11, 20188 yr Keeping running that mouth, Starlin. Nobody wants you around, either. running that mouth?
January 11, 20188 yr Man you sure are obsessed with him. if i was randomly infusing his name into discussions he wasnt a part of, id say i was.
January 11, 20188 yr Keeping running that mouth, Starlin. Nobody wants you around, either. He betta get some Listerine
January 13, 20188 yr I think we match up on paper with the Brewers needs. They could use an upgrade in the rotation and at second base. We should try to package Castro and Straily and see what we could get from them. The Brewers have a deep system. I realize we won't get any top 100 guys back but they are deep enough to still get quality prospects back. They can't break the bank on FA's and they are close enough where they might want to make a run at it.
January 13, 20188 yr I think we match up on paper with the Brewers needs. They could use an upgrade in the rotation and at second base. We should try to package Castro and Straily and see what we could get from them. The Brewers have a deep system. I realize we won't get any top 100 guys back but they are deep enough to still get quality prospects back. They can't break the bank on FA's and they are close enough where they might want to make a run at it. if we package straily and castro we would get a top 100 guy. obviously not near the top of the top 100 but straily has a lot of value and would get back a lower end top 100 guy.
January 13, 20188 yr if we package straily and castro we would get a top 100 guy. obviously not near the top of the top 100 but straily has a lot of value and would get back a lower end top 100 guy. Ozuna didn’t get a Top 100 guy but Straily/Castro will? I doubt it.
January 14, 20188 yr Ozuna didn’t get a Top 100 guy but Straily/Castro will? I doubt it. have faith in Mike Hill....
January 14, 20188 yr if we package straily and castro we would get a top 100 guy. obviously not near the top of the top 100 but straily has a lot of value and would get back a lower end top 100 guy. Lol
January 14, 20188 yr Lol lol all you want. Straily has a lot of value because he's an innings eater and has 3 more years of team control. He'll get you a guy around the lower end of the top 100.
January 14, 20188 yr He didn't get the Reds that and at that time he had even more years of team control left. he also had only one year of the type of performance he's shown he's capable of as opposed to 2 straight years now of similar performance and he was DFA'd at the beginning of the prior year.
January 14, 20188 yr lol all you want. Straily has a lot of value because he's an innings eater and has 3 more years of team control. He'll get you a guy around the lower end of the top 100. No he doesn't and no he won't.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.