Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Ideas from a frustrated fan (Warning Long post)

Featured Replies

I'm sure we can find another cheap decent catcher and maybe platoon them but buck getting most of the starts just can't happen unless he improves. And brett Hayes is the worst backup I've ever seen.

The best catchers available in free agency are the 36-year old A.J. Pierzynski and Mike Napoli who will more than likely be overpaid and not worth it.

 

And there's nothing in the system.

 

You're better off just sticking with Buck since you're already paying him. For what it's worth, he's bad but he's not 2012 bad either. He's underachieved this year.

Hanley sucks. Doesn't live up to contract. Same goes for nolasco, buck, bell, Gaby, gaudin, Webb, Dunn, kearns, and guillen. They need to go.

 

 

McKeon a third time will be the charm lol

anibal has been our most consistent pitcher for awhile now...i realize that he has more value than probably anyone else on the team at this point aside from Stanton but trading him opens a big hole in the rotation...consistent starters (unless consistently bad) are not the easiest things to come by...as for trading other people i'm open to almost anything but you HAVE to keep in mind the casual fan who brings in the bucks to the new ballpark...you NEED name recognition in return somewhere along the line...casual fan will not give a crap about a ton of prospects whether they are hyped or not if some of the NAME players go elsewhere in trades.

If the Marlins really want to keep Anibal then I think they need to offer him a contract now. You can't risk him walking in the off-season (which he will) and then getting essentially nothing besides a draft pick or two. I think you need to trade him though. You'd most likely be overpaying a bit to keep him on the team even if he does accept your contract offer. Trade him, get some solid prospects, and then use the money saved to improve the offense.

The reason why we're at this point is that the Marlins fire people who do their job. If you fire good people you can't expect anything good to come out of it. They fired Joe Girardi and they fired Jim Presley, and this mess that they have now is just the consequence of that. When they did those things there had to be a feeling that they were going to pay for that. If they luck up and hire good people they need to leave them be. Until they do hire people that are good at their jobs the state of the team as it is right now will stay the same.

I don't know why people want to get rid of Anibal Sanchez. Take a look at his numbers through the years and you'll see that he's been consistent, and not consistently bad, he's been more than serviceable and he's been our 2nd best pitcher this season.

As to the points to improve the team, I don't think Carlos Lee has done a bad job at 1st, but he's obviously not coming back so we better find somebody to play LF next season since LoMo has to be moved back to 1st. We can always trade LoMo and get some value for him and give Gaby another shot at 1st next season although I think the FO wants to move on from Gaby.

I agree with the fact that Hayes is the worst backup in the league right now. The guy is not that good defensively and he can't catch up to an 89 MPH fastball. At this point, even Montz with his 243 AVG in the hitters paradise the PCL is would be an upgrade. We all know that Buck is not going anywhere, so we just need to pray that he finds his 220ish stroke again.

I'd trade Infante, only if we can get a good OF bat back. I think we can always put Solano there and our D won't suffer although I see some drop in the hitting aspect. Anyways, we need some OF bats so maybe trading Infante will net us one. One other option is to bring Gil Velazquez from 3A.

Ricky to me is the most exasperating pitcher in the staff, so I'd definitely try to trade him, even if we need to eat some of his ludicrous salary. Again, I will try to get a bat from him now that we have Brad Hand pitching well in 3A, Wade LeBlanc who can't be worse than him, and Sanabia in 3A with a decent year down there.

Zambrano falls into the same category as Ricky.

I wouldn't trade Hanley either, although I will definitely entertain the idea if we get a massive haul in return and we can go ahead and dump another of our bad contracts, a la Heath Bell, with him.

 

In reality, this team has a lot of talent. The players just need to perform up to their career averages.

i think we SHOULD trade carlos lee but is it possible that in just a couple of weeks we won't get anything close to what we gave up for him?

I don't know why people want to get rid of Anibal Sanchez. Take a look at his numbers through the years and you'll see that he's been consistent, and not consistently bad, he's been more than serviceable and he's been our 2nd best pitcher this season.

As to the points to improve the team, I don't think Carlos Lee has done a bad job at 1st, but he's obviously not coming back so we better find somebody to play LF next season since LoMo has to be moved back to 1st. We can always trade LoMo and get some value for him and give Gaby another shot at 1st next season although I think the FO wants to move on from Gaby.

I agree with the fact that Hayes is the worst backup in the league right now. The guy is not that good defensively and he can't catch up to an 89 MPH fastball. At this point, even Montz with his 243 AVG in the hitters paradise the PCL is would be an upgrade. We all know that Buck is not going anywhere, so we just need to pray that he finds his 220ish stroke again.

I'd trade Infante, only if we can get a good OF bat back. I think we can always put Solano there and our D won't suffer although I see some drop in the hitting aspect. Anyways, we need some OF bats so maybe trading Infante will net us one. One other option is to bring Gil Velazquez from 3A.

Ricky to me is the most exasperating pitcher in the staff, so I'd definitely try to trade him, even if we need to eat some of his ludicrous salary. Again, I will try to get a bat from him now that we have Brad Hand pitching well in 3A, Wade LeBlanc who can't be worse than him, and Sanabia in 3A with a decent year down there.

Zambrano falls into the same category as Ricky.

I wouldn't trade Hanley either, although I will definitely entertain the idea if we get a massive haul in return and we can go ahead and dump another of our bad contracts, a la Heath Bell, with him.

 

In reality, this team has a lot of talent. The players just need to perform up to their career averages.

 

 

1) we want to get rid of Sanchez because he is about to be a free agent commanding money he doesnt deserve. He is an above average pitcher but he isn't anything that deserves 10 million.

2) Gaby is pretty much done as a starter here.

3) totally agree with ricky. can't stand him. enough. just trade the guy.

4) brad hand if he comes back up here is going to be the same as last year. His era is fine but as was the problem last year, he simply doesnt throw strikes. Sanabia is a guy who i want to see up here.

Trade Sanchez, Zambrano, Nolasco, Infante, and Lee. Try to force somebody to eat Bell to get what they want. Bring Gaby back up to see if he can produce at all to have him to trade for some mid-level guy that isn't redundant in the off-season.

 

Of those, I expect Anibal would bring the best return.

The Tigers were scouting Anibal at the game yesterday.

 

Anibal + Infante for Castellanos?

1) we want to get rid of Sanchez because he is about to be a free agent commanding money he doesnt deserve. He is an above average pitcher but he isn't anything that deserves 10 million.

2) Gaby is pretty much done as a starter here.

3) totally agree with ricky. can't stand him. enough. just trade the guy.

4) brad hand if he comes back up here is going to be the same as last year. His era is fine but as was the problem last year, he simply doesnt throw strikes. Sanabia is a guy who i want to see up here.

 

1) I'd definitely give Sanchez 3/30. We can then have, providing we dump Ricky, a 1-2-3 that consists of JJ, Buehrle and Anibal, I'd say that's not the worst 1-2-3 in the League and if they perform up to their career averages we are looking at 45 W's between those 3.

2) Agree with you but something inside me wants to give him a last chance.

4) Brad Hand has been better this year control wise. Also, he's only 22, I'm all for giving him a chance, in 122 innings he's only allowed 109 base hits this season.

The Tigers were scouting Anibal at the game yesterday.

 

Anibal + Infante for Castellanos?

 

I don't think that nets us Castellanos...

The Tigers were scouting Anibal at the game yesterday.

 

Anibal + Infante for Castellanos?

 

I don't think that nets us Castellanos...

 

I could see it netting us more than Castellanos. Think about it like us giving Adrian Gonzalez and 2 prospects in 2003, we won it all because of that trade. At the end of the day the tigers see this as there year to win it all, they have a few holes to fill, and if they can fill them with a single trade they will more likely do it.

everyone should keep in mind that Detroit from second base has hit .201 with 74 strikouts, and 2 home runs. Omar infante would be absolutely huge for them. He is really a bigger piece for the tigers, with anibal as an extra bonus.

Just looking at Jacob Turner's stats [Minor Leagues] - I'm not entirely sure what's to be seen here. Does he have potentially lights out stuff that could be developed? Personally I don't see it just in the stats.

I could see it netting us more than Castellanos. Think about it like us giving Adrian Gonzalez and 2 prospects in 2003, we won it all because of that trade. At the end of the day the tigers see this as there year to win it all, they have a few holes to fill, and if they can fill them with a single trade they will more likely do it.

 

You might be right but they really value Castellanos...

Just looking at Jacob Turner's stats [Minor Leagues] - I'm not entirely sure what's to be seen here. Does he have potentially lights out stuff that could be developed? Personally I don't see it just in the stats.

 

 

He has a 3:1 - K:BB ratio

Just looking at Jacob Turner's stats [Minor Leagues] - I'm not entirely sure what's to be seen here. Does he have potentially lights out stuff that could be developed? Personally I don't see it just in the stats.

 

 

He has a 3:1 - K:BB ratio

Other than that, though ...

And in his short time in the Majors [i know, very small sample size], hasn't been good at all.

Just looking at Jacob Turner's stats [Minor Leagues] - I'm not entirely sure what's to be seen here. Does he have potentially lights out stuff that could be developed? Personally I don't see it just in the stats.

 

 

He has a 3:1 - K:BB ratio

 

yep, and I agree with Erick on Castellanos - he doesn't take walks at all.

 

 

 

such a great history with big Tigers prospects, how can this go wrong? :)

New idea, Screw Detroit(for anibal at least). Trade Sanchez to Boston for Lavarnway a Catching prospect. Then trade infante to Detroit for who ever they are willing to give, detroit has had zero production from second base, and has defensively been poor as well. Ideally they give us Castellanos, but i'll take Oliver, Crosby, and Fields.

Just looking at Jacob Turner's stats [Minor Leagues] - I'm not entirely sure what's to be seen here. Does he have potentially lights out stuff that could be developed? Personally I don't see it just in the stats.

 

Lights out stuff, 18-20 years old in all those years playing against much older competition. Top end projections are a 1/2, reasonable projections a good 3. He would be awesome to match with Fernandez longterm. The Marlins would be extremely lucky to pry him (Detroit knows this and loves him).

 

But they are contending and need to win, and the Marlins could be a one stop shop with Anibal/Nolasco, Infante, and maybe some of C. Lee, Choate, and the tradeable competitive balance draft pick the Marlins received. There might be enough to get them to include Turner as a centerpiece. Castellanos would be great, but Turner and their young other pitching (Crosby, etc), is more than enough and would be an immediate turn around into the current team.

New idea, Screw Detroit(for anibal at least). Trade Sanchez to Boston for Lavarnway a Catching prospect. Then trade infante to Detroit for who ever they are willing to give, detroit has had zero production from second base, and has defensively been poor as well. Ideally they give us Castellanos, but i'll take Oliver, Crosby, and Fields.

 

The Marlins have two position players in the system who might be future starters, Yelich and Realmuto. The later is a catcher. Not that Lavarnway isn't awesome, but Realmuto does provide hope for the future, and catchers can always be found on 1 year deals who are acceptable. The catcher situation isn't as bad as some of you guys want to make it. Not saying that is you, but Buck is going nowhere, Hayes is serviceable, and there is hope with Realmuto and future vagabond FA. They can deal with this problem later basically.

 

Pitching, pitching and more pitching. That is the theme of the deadline.

New idea, Screw Detroit(for anibal at least). Trade Sanchez to Boston for Lavarnway a Catching prospect. Then trade infante to Detroit for who ever they are willing to give, detroit has had zero production from second base, and has defensively been poor as well. Ideally they give us Castellanos, but i'll take Oliver, Crosby, and Fields.

 

The Marlins have two position players in the system who might be future starters, Yelich and Realmuto. The later is a catcher. Not that Lavarnway isn't awesome, but Realmuto does provide hope for the future, and catchers can always be found on 1 year deals who are acceptable. The catcher situation isn't as bad as some of you guys want to make it. Not saying that is you, but Buck is going nowhere, Hayes is serviceable, and there is hope with Realmuto and future vagabond FA. They can deal with this problem later basically.

 

Pitching, pitching and more pitching. That is the theme of the deadline.

 

Realmutto is 3 years from the majors, where as lavarnway is ready now. You cannot have too many catching prospects, it also gives us a chance to take our time with realmutto. just do me the favor and look at his stats

http://www.baseball-reference.com/minors/player.cgi?id=lavarn001rya

 

.300 avg 32% caught stealing, personally I would like to get him, and I think the sox would give him to us.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.