Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

You Be The GM: 2012/13 Offseason Edition

Featured Replies

You know what we should do? Trade JJ, Buerhle, Reyes, Buck, and Boni to Toronto for Yunel Escobar.

 

 

I do love that the Marlins have spent the last three or so years talking about how they're trying to create a more professional culture (and that played some part in firing Ozzie Guillen), then trading for a guy who's had multiple instances of immaturity.

I would have a firesale; everyone but Stanton/Reyes is made available. Make the '13 season a tryout for '14 because we're going nowhere in '13.

 

No big moves.

 

If we want to improve the team in '13, I hope they're 1-year, stopgap deals.

 

 

Wow. Excellent job.

If someone told me in April that we can go from this:

C: Buck

1B: Sanchez

2B: Infante

SS: Reyes

3B: Ramirez

LF: Morrison

CF: Bonifacio

RF: Stanton

 

Rotation

1. Johnson

2. Buerhle

3. Nolasco

4. Sanchez

5. Zambrano

 

CL- Bell

 

To this:

C: Mike Napoli / Rob Brantly

1B: Logan Morrison

2B: Marco Scutoro

SS: Stephen Drew

3B: Kevin Youkilis

LF: Josh Hamilton

CF: Justin Upton

RF: Giancarlo Stanton

 

Rotation

1. Greinke

2. Haren

3. Lohse

4. Turner

5. Evoldi

 

CL- Rafael Soriano

Bullpen- Soria, Madsden, Broxton

 

I'd take it!

If someone told me in April that we can go from this:

C: Buck

1B: Sanchez

2B: Infante

SS: Reyes

3B: Ramirez

LF: Morrison

CF: Bonifacio

RF: Stanton

 

Rotation

1. Johnson

2. Buerhle

3. Nolasco

4. Sanchez

5. Zambrano

 

CL- Bell

 

To this:

C: Mike Napoli / Rob Brantly

1B: Logan Morrison

2B: Marco Scutoro

SS: Stephen Drew

3B: Kevin Youkilis

LF: Josh Hamilton

CF: Justin Upton

RF: Giancarlo Stanton

 

Rotation

1. Greinke

2. Haren

3. Lohse

4. Turner

5. Evoldi

 

CL- Rafael Soriano

Bullpen- Soria, Madsden, Broxton

 

I'd take it!

 

 

 

...and then... you woke up...

  • Author

I'm not going to laugh at any trade/FA signing proposal ever again.

 

Dream big, Piazza31. Dream big.

 

This thread has a habit of turning into reality.

Getting Josh Hamilton would be a very Loria-thing to do...and a bad contract just waiting to happen.

Heath Bell we miss you! You represented so much to us! Your contract is soon to be the size of this teams payroll once that sh*thead Nolsaco is gone!

Getting Josh Hamilton would be a very Loria-thing to do...and a bad contract just waiting to happen.

 

2013: $1

2014: $2

2015: $4

2016: $50,000,000

2017: $55,000,000

etc.

 

but he'll be gone by May 2013

LoMo, Nolasco, Escobar to Arizona for Upton.

 

Keep Upton or trade him for whatever Texas offered.

 

I wouldn't mind a team of Uptons and Stanton next year, considering where we are today.

I was thinking about this in the shower earlier. That's where I do my thinking, yes.

 

We desperately need power and pitching at this point. So:

 

Sign Youkilis to play 3B. We would have plenty for say, a 1 or 2 year deal from all the money we saved after this trade.

Sign a mid-level 4th outfielder to be, just that: a fourth outfielder. I do not want Gorkys and Petersen anywhere near the Miami dugout.

Sign/trade for at least two solid SP. Don't break the bank on guys like Greinke/Haren (or if they do, they should only sign one) and get some mid-level guys who can eat innings and throw strikes. Like I said, not necessarily all stars, but we desperately need pitching depth.

Maaaaaybe sign a lefty PH to a minors deal or something. I really don't know how much longer we will see this "PH specialist Dobbs."

 

Those are the only major moves I could decide on. If we did that our roster might look something like this:

 

C- Brantly/Mathis

1B- LoMo

2B- Hechevarria

3B- Youkilis

SS- Escobar

LF- Pierre

CF- Ruggiano

RF- Stanton

 

BN- Mathis/Brantly

BN- Kouzmanoff

BN- Solano

BN- Dobbs

BN- 4th OF (Not Gorkys or Petersen)

 

SP- Someone from trade/FA (Not Nolasco)

SP- Someone from trade/FA (Not Nolasco)

SP- Nolasco

SP- Turner

SP- Eovaldi/Alvarez (maybe Eovaldi to bullpen?)

 

See, if we did that we wouldn't have to force Escobar over to 3rd like we did with Hanley, and Hechevarria has played 2B in the big leagues.

If we took this approach we would have at least a couple bats to protect Stanton, namely Kouz and Youk. If LoMo can stay healthy he could hit 20 HR as well.

I had a weird dream that we traded Stanton for harper + bp arm.

 

You shut your mouth.

 

You shut your f***ing mouth right NOW!

This is the way I envision it as it stands right now. Of course a signing here or there and another trade and everything could change. I'm still hoping that they can trade Nolasco although at this point I doubt it. I'm also hoping that Escobar stays at least for 13' and he can drive up his value. Especially with a friendly contract. Here goes.

 

Starting pitchers:

 

Ricky Nolasco

Jacob Turner

Nathan Eovaldi

Hendrson Alvarez

Wade Leblanc

 

Bullpen:

 

Steven Cishek

A J Ramos

Ryan Webb

Chris Hatcher

Alex Sanabia

Mike Dunn

Dan Jennings

 

OF:

 

Mike Stanton RF

Justin Ruggiano CF

Kyle Jensen LF

 

 

IF:

 

Logan Morrison 1b

Donovan Solano 2b

Eideny Echevarria SS

Yunel Escobar 3b

Robb Brantley C

 

Bench:

 

Chris Coghlan OF

Jeff Mathis C

Juan Pierre OF

Gregg Dobbs IF

Nick Green IF

 

I know that I am probably in the minority on Jensen but I really think that he will hit in the bigs. His power potential is worthing taking a shot on. He had produced at every level in the minors until last season and he still managed to hit 24 home runs. He also had a very solid AFL season.

Mike Stanton RF

 

I know that I am probably in the minority on Jensen

 

You're also in the minority of Marlins fans that don't know it's Giancarlo Stanton now.

 

In all seriousness, not a bad idea for the team, but I don't see Jensen starting the season in the bigs.

Pierre is going to start. They gave him too much money (lol) to not have him start. They already said he would get a lot of playing time in LF and leadoff.

 

Ricky Nolasco really needs to be traded. What a waste of time it is to have him on this roster next year.

 

Also, it's fitting that Anderson Perez and Eideny Echevarria are on the same team.

Pierre is going to start. They gave him too much money (lol) to not have him start. They already said he would get a lot of playing time in LF and leadoff.

 

Ricky Nolasco really needs to be traded. What a waste of time it is to have him on this roster next year.

 

Also, it's fitting that Anderson Perez and Eideny Echevarria are on the same team.

 

 

Why is it fitting?

Because neither one exist.

 

Ha, I c. Like our playoff chances next year.

BA ZING.

 

Also, I very seriously doubt our bullpen will look like that^ next year. We signed a couple pitchers to minor league deals who will probably complete for pen jobs. I imagine A.J. Ramos will probably start the year in NOLA, as will one of either Jennings or Hatcher. We won't make any major deals obviously, but dudes it's still only November. A lot of stuff is going to happen to our team in the next few months.

LoMo, Nolasco, Escobar to Arizona for Upton.

 

Keep Upton or trade him for whatever Texas offered.

 

I wouldn't mind a team of Uptons and Stanton next year, considering where we are today.

 

 

 

:lol

 

that fits zero of that Arizona has stated they want for them to even consider moving him.

  • Author

I've been thinking about this a lot and... I say that Stanton should be traded now. But only to Texas for a deal involving Olt, Profar, Gallo, and probably another decent, young bat (maybe Lewis Brinson - a Coral Springs high guy who I personally played against last year).

 

We have the pitching for the future, no doubt. Our offense is still a big question. Just trade Stanton to a winning team where he will be protected in the lineup. Texas should be ecstatic to get Stanton after presumably losing Hamilton. Plus they already have above average Major Leaguers at the positions Olt, Profar, and Gallo play at in the form of Elvis Andrus and Adrian Beltre.

 

The Rangers have one of the deepest farm systems in the MLB and we could replenish all of our offensive needs in one fell swoop with a deal here. We could possibly field a competitive team by 2014 and then be a force for the following years if all works out.

I've been thinking about this a lot and... I say that Stanton should be traded now. But only to Texas for a deal involving Olt, Profar, Gallo, and probably another decent, young bat (maybe Lewis Brinson - a Coral Springs high guy who I personally played against last year).

 

We have the pitching for the future, no doubt. Our offense is still a big question. Just trade Stanton to a winning team where he will be protected in the lineup. Texas should be ecstatic to get Stanton after presumably losing Hamilton. Plus they already have above average Major Leaguers at the positions Olt, Profar, and Gallo play at in the form of Elvis Andrus and Adrian Beltre.

 

The Rangers have one of the deepest farm systems in the MLB and we could replenish all of our offensive needs in one fell swoop with a deal here. We could possibly field a competitive team by 2014 and then be a force for the following years if all works out.

 

 

Yea, that wouldn't be too bad. We would move Hechavarria to 2B and things would look good for the future. You would think that team would competitive in 2014.

LoMo, Nolasco, Escobar to Arizona for Upton.

 

Keep Upton or trade him for whatever Texas offered.

 

I wouldn't mind a team of Uptons and Stanton next year, considering where we are today.

 

 

 

:lol

 

that fits zero of that Arizona has stated they want for them to even consider moving him.

They want a SS and SP, they in there lol

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.