December 11, 201411 yr I really want to know if the FO knew about Haren's retirement threats and traded for him anyway.
December 11, 201411 yr Not really. They gave up Heaney, sure, that's not ideal. They gave up Hatcher, who was already replaced by Crow. They gave up Hernandez, which is interesting considering they just got him, but this doesn't raise a red flag with Gordon and Dietrich in Miami. Barnes was a nice utility player to look forward to, but what are the odds he becomes anything? They got back a player whose presence is more powerful than anything else; believe it or not teams see Dee Gordon at the top of the lineup and they see a headache, not an easy out. And what if he gets on base? He's putting pressure on EVERYONE, the pitcher/defense/manager... Dan Haren might never throw a pitch for us, but his cash opens up the funds needed to acquire whomever necessary, and that's basically part of our return. So if they had enough cash to sign Morae and that extra cash gets us Peavy, now those guys got us Gordon AND another core player. And that doesn't take into account if we get a compensation pick for losing Haren to retirement. Lots of balls up in the air still. Let's all chill out. And you were doing so well
December 11, 201411 yr How are you guys defending this trade? This is how: https://twitter.com/JeffPassan/status/542888954882568192 Marlins didn't give up much talent. They gave up Heaney and replaceable players.
December 11, 201411 yr I really want to know if the FO knew about Haren's retirement threats and traded for him anyway. They knew, they worked in contingency aspects of the deal due to it
December 11, 201411 yr Silver Bullet....the Dodgers are sending the Marlins $10 million....if Haren decides to play that money will be used to pay his salary....if he retires the Marlins then have $10 million to do what they please with.
December 11, 201411 yr Side note, a few weeks ago I showed a class the clips of Stantons injury in Milwaukee. The horror on those kids faces. Of course they did! Win win for both teams; Dodgers get rid of Haren and get players in return, Marlins get cash to sign another FA. Easy call.
December 11, 201411 yr That is definitely the part that decides the trade. Hernandez/Barnes/Hatcher are all MLB players but none of them are real game changers at the MLB level. Heaney's the only guy with potential #2 starter stuff. But his stuff at the major league level was incredibly bad, and there's was nothing that showed why he was so good in the minors and why he was such a highly regarded prospect at one point last year (#1 lefty pitching prospect in ALL OF BASEBALL). I'm just frustrated they traded so low on Heaney, but in the Marlins eyes I see the front office thinking they got value for him before he fell off to where he has little value at all. It's the exact same argument we all had here when the Marlins traded Moran for Cosart and Co. That trade so far has worked out great for us, and while I've said Dee's lack of walking ability is a truth the Marlins seem to be ignoring, I said before and I'll say now that he's a very useful player to have at the majors next season and is a real improvement over Solano (improvement over Hernandez is to be determined). The whole "shit in the air" comment was clearly a joke and I see Gordon being a fun player to follow all next season. If his OBP was ever in the .340-350's I'd feel so much better about this trade. I'm cool with wait and see mode. But Heaney was our last real trade asset. Despite what the Marlins think, Nicolino doesn't have the kind of value in the open market that Heaney would've had if they didn't diminish it by making it quite clear just how much they wanted to get rid of him. It's not so much the return. It's not that I see Heaney becoming Clayton Kershaw. It's that we might have one of the worst farm systems in all of baseball now with no real guarantee of a playoff spot or even a winning record next season. It's pretty much the front office, in their own minds, going all in next season. It just feels like it's going about it all wrong, selling everything and the kitchen sink for somebody's who career (and his second half of the season) doesn't match his "All Star" first half.
December 11, 201411 yr The lesson tomorrow is gonna be "Debating the Dee Gordon Trade 101" Every student on the test is given a grade of 'D+", since that's what we got in the trade.
December 11, 201411 yr Joe Frisaro @JoeFrisaro The #Marlins still appear to be in hot pursuit of Justin Morneau #Rockies
December 11, 201411 yr That is definitely the part that decides the trade. Hernandez/Barnes/Hatcher are all MLB players but none of them are real game changers at the MLB level. Heaney's the only guy with potential #2 starter stuff. But his stuff at the major league level was incredibly bad, and there's was nothing that showed why he was so good in the minors and why he was such a highly regarded prospect at one point last year (#1 lefty pitching prospect in ALL OF BASEBALL). I'm just frustrated they traded so low on Heaney, but in the Marlins eyes I see the front office thinking they got value for him before he fell off to where he has little value at all. It's the exact same argument we all had here when the Marlins traded Moran for Cosart and Co. That trade so far has worked out great for us, and while I've said Dee's lack of walking ability is a truth the Marlins seem to be ignoring, I said before and I'll say now that he's a very useful player to have at the majors next season and is a real improvement over Solano (improvement over Hernandez is to be determined). The whole "shit in the air" comment was clearly a joke and I see Gordon being a fun player to follow all next season. If his OBP was ever in the .340-350's I'd feel so much better about this trade. I'm cool with wait and see mode. But Heaney was our last real trade asset. Despite what the Marlins think, Nicolino doesn't have the kind of value in the open market that Heaney would've had if they didn't diminish it by making it quite clear just how much they wanted to get rid of him. It's not so much the return. It's not that I see Heaney becoming Clayton Kershaw. It's that we might have one of the worst farm systems in all of baseball now with no real guarantee of a playoff spot or even a winning record next season. It's pretty much the front office, in their own minds, going all in next season. It just feels like it's going about it all wrong, selling everything and the kitchen sink for somebody's who career (and his second half of the season) doesn't match his "All Star" first half. Keep in mind there was a report that the Dodgers asked for Nicolino over Heaney and Marlins said no... Both of those things should tell us something.
December 11, 201411 yr If Haren retires doesn't he still get paid because he doesn't already have a contract for 2015? Ugh I think I need sleep Ok so if Haren retires we still gotta pay Gordon his 2.5 million ... So again why do we suddenly think Loria has 12.5 million to spend or pocket? If I'm incoherent and annoying feel free to let me know with anything except the Godzilla face palm, I'm pretty sure Wild Card has that copyrighted. Dodgers are paying us 12.5 million essentially. 2.5 for Gordon, and 10 mil which would go to Haren if he plays, or if he retires can be spent on whatever. I guess we're hoping Haren retires at this point so they can afford to go after a 1b... can't believe I'm typing that.
December 11, 201411 yr The Marlins should hope that Haren decides to retire and then use that $10 million to help bolster a contract offer to Peavy.
December 11, 201411 yr The Marlins have a payroll now if you factor in arby of what? 50 mil? If they cant fucking afford a payroll of 80 mil then they are fucking morons and suck at running a baseball team. Its not like MLB is a 9 billion dollar industry or anything, one in which teams get nearly 60 million off the bat due to national media deals. Cant be it. Loria being Loria.
December 11, 201411 yr Dodgers are paying us 12.5 million essentially. 2.5 for Gordon, and 10 mil which would go to Haren if he plays, or if he retires can be spent on whatever. I guess we're hoping Haren retires at this point so they can afford to go after a 1b... can't believe I'm typing that. Haren's money will be used on Jake Peavy (I hope). Hopefully we can acquire Morneau...
December 11, 201411 yr Keep in mind there was a report that the Dodgers asked for Nicolino over Heaney and Marlins said no... Both of those things should tell us something. I'd like to imagine that rumor is BS perpetuated by Marlins personnel to try and bump up the value of Nicolino in a potential Morneau trade.
December 11, 201411 yr lol what the heck do we have left to trade for Mourneau? Solano 1 and Solano 2. Maybe they will even toss in their catcher.
December 11, 201411 yr Yeah I mean I don't particularly want Haren anyway. Rather see if Koehler can repeat 2014. If the money is spent on a 1b or starter I can probably stomach this.
December 11, 201411 yr I'd like to imagine that rumor is BS perpetuated by Marlins personnel to try and bump up the value of Nicolino in a potential Morneau trade. They can't/won't trade Nicolino, he's Heaney's replacement as our next major league ready starter.
December 11, 201411 yr A lot of people here seem to think 5 starts is a large sample size for Heaney, which is dumb. It means nothing. You can't project him out based on that. The Marlins are about the only people who think Nicolino is more valuable than Heaney, btw
December 11, 201411 yr They can't/won't trade Nicolino, he's Heaney's replacement as our next major league ready starter. Don't forget about Adam Conley...I'm still holding out hope that he can amount to something in the majors.
December 11, 201411 yr They can't/won't trade Nicolino, he's Heaney's replacement as our next major league ready starter. Nicolino is an unproven starter. He has to start striking people out to be worth his value, The key to that is he has to do it while at the same time continue to not walk people.
December 11, 201411 yr A lot of people here seem to think 5 starts is a large sample size for Heaney, which is dumb. It means nothing. You can't project him out based on that. Maybe I missed some posts but from what I've seen here people are just saying we don't know what Heaney will be. I haven't seen anyone say he stinks due to his 2014 MLB numbers. Unless you know what he'll be?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.