Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

3 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

As expected, Wendle's option was declined, but he can be retained via arbitration.

Cody Poteet, Jordan Holloway, and Bryan Hoeing have been outrighted.

Luke Williams was claimed off waivers by the Dodgers.

 

Not sure I agree with Williams and Poteet here. They have room.

Lewin, Devers, all 5 of Anderson/Berti/Wendle/Rojas/Cooper where they all can't possibly be coming back, all 5 of DLC/Sanchez/Bleday/Burdick/Jerar where someone likely gets added to a trade.

I'd keep Williams and Poteet for now at least..... but maybe they have something brewing and need immediate space (laugh track)

23 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

Not sure I agree with Williams and Poteet here. They have room.

Lewin, Devers, all 5 of Anderson/Berti/Wendle/Rojas/Cooper where they all can't possibly be coming back, all 5 of DLC/Sanchez/Bleday/Burdick/Jerar where someone likely gets added to a trade.

I'd keep Williams and Poteet for now at least..... but maybe they have something brewing and need immediate space (laugh track)

I liked that Puke Williams busted his ass out there consistently and even came through on some occasions but ultimately, he should be a "eh" type player that a good team SHOULD be able to replace pretty easily.  The Marlins have just set the bar really freaking low.  Williams just seems like a guy who will bounce around from club to club for his career.  Honestly, not calling him a bad ballplayer either but I still won't lose any sleep over him leaving along with the rest.  I will miss the name Poteet though. It always made me giggle.

3 hours ago, hovertical said:

I liked that Puke Williams busted his ass out there consistently and even came through on some occasions but ultimately, he should be a "eh" type player that a good team SHOULD be able to replace pretty easily.  The Marlins have just set the bar really freaking low.  Williams just seems like a guy who will bounce around from club to club for his career.  Honestly, not calling him a bad ballplayer either but I still won't lose any sleep over him leaving along with the rest.  I will miss the name Poteet though. It always made me giggle.

Well that's the thing, the best team just claimed him. Makes you wonder.

I don't disagree with you if the 40 man strategy is "shoot for upside, find the next Luke Williams for free in a $1 Cody Ross kind of deal midseason," i.e. why they are keeping Lewin and Devers who clearly have more upside even if Williams may end up being more of a bounce around player longterm. But as you said, the bar is low and he's a top 20 MLB bat they have today. Of course, future moves may dictate needing space but it's curious with their depth chart. 

Poteet still with organization. He's just off the 40 man. You can see him latching back on like Neidert if rehab goes well.

12 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

Well that's the thing, the best team just claimed him. Makes you wonder.

I don't disagree with you if the 40 man strategy is "shoot for upside, find the next Luke Williams for free in a $1 Cody Ross kind of deal midseason," i.e. why they are keeping Lewin and Devers who clearly have more upside even if Williams may end up being more of a bounce around player longterm. But as you said, the bar is low and he's a top 20 MLB bat they have today. Of course, future moves may dictate needing space but it's curious with their depth chart. 

Poteet still with organization. He's just off the 40 man. You can see him latching back on like Neidert if rehab goes well.

Correa, Turner, and Judge will all sign with Miami by Xmas. No worries!

3 hours ago, hovertical said:

Correa, Turner, and Judge will all sign with Miami by Xmas. No worries!

And be traded by New Years! 

23 hours ago, WSE said:

Very expected. I think a deal gets done this off-season. 

If the Marlins do trade him, I seriously hope it would be for someone better than Gleyber Torres. Torres hasn't been good in three years.

Abreu makes a lot of sense on this team. Could use a leader and wont be super expensive 

Talk in chicago of trading anderson for SP and signing correa. Maaaan TA and Jazz would be entertaining 

3 minutes ago, Iowa said:

Talk in chicago of trading anderson for SP and signing correa. Maaaan TA and Jazz would be entertaining 

Yes please

22 minutes ago, Iowa said:

Abreu makes a lot of sense on this team. Could use a leader and wont be super expensive 

This is the guy I want.

1 hour ago, Valid said:

If the Marlins do trade him, I seriously hope it would be for someone better than Gleyber Torres. Torres hasn't been good in three years.

Torres was pretty good this year. 2.7 WAR (Pablo 2.8). He hit the ball really hard and there is some big power potential there. If there is confidence Torres (or Jazz) can play suitable SS defense for 4+ years, he's a pretty good trade target if Gleyber would sign a 5 year extension (age 26-30 seasons) for a reasonable price. That being said, I'm not sure those guys can do it so it's a lack of a position fit for me. 2B depth sucks in baseball so someone else likely can offer more.

I'd pass and look at Rosario for a veteran option. Who was better than Tim Anderson last year and is 3 years younger/will be cheaper to extend more than likely.

39 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Yes please

Pablo and coop and whatever for TA. Then sign abreu. Great freakin start

6 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

Torres was pretty good this year. 2.7 WAR (Pablo 2.8). He hit the ball really hard and there is some big power potential there. If there is confidence Torres (or Jazz) can play suitable SS defense for 4+ years, he's a pretty good trade target if Gleyber would sign a 5 year extension (age 26-30 seasons) for a reasonable price. That being said, I'm not sure those guys can do it so it's a lack of a position fit for me. 2B depth sucks in baseball so someone else likely can offer more.

I'd pass and look at Rosario for a veteran option. Who was better than Tim Anderson last year and is 3 years younger/will be cheaper to extend more than likely.

Torres only looked okay because of how bad he was in 2020 and 2021 by comparison. He slashed .257/.310/.451 with a .295 BABIP in an incredibly hitter-friendly park (for reference, 17 of his 24 homers came at home). That's not great.

He wasn't great with the bat, and he is a disaster at SS. The only reason why his WAR was halfway decent this year was because he was okay at 2B, but we have Jazz there. Not that Jazz is great defensively, but he is certainly better off at 2B than SS.

Torres certainly looked like he had big power potential back in 2019, but since then, he has slugged .368, .366 and .451, respectively (and again that's in a very hitter-friendly stadium). Seems like the pitchers just learned him and he hasn't adjusted. His K rate has increased and his walk rate has plummeted.

I'm not saying Torres is the worst thing ever, but I would expect (or at least want) a much better return for Pablo.

Edited by Valid

8 hours ago, Valid said:

Torres only looked okay because of how bad he was in 2020 and 2021 by comparison. He slashed .257/.310/.451 with a .295 BABIP in an incredibly hitter-friendly park (for reference, 17 of his 24 homers came at home). That's not great.

He wasn't great with the bat, and he is a disaster at SS. The only reason why his WAR was halfway decent this year was because he was okay at 2B, but we have Jazz there. Not that Jazz is great defensively, but he is certainly better off at 2B than SS.

Torres certainly looked like he had big power potential back in 2019, but since then, he has slugged .368, .366 and .451, respectively (and again that's in a very hitter-friendly stadium). Seems like the pitchers just learned him and he hasn't adjusted. His K rate has increased and his walk rate has plummeted.

I'm not saying Torres is the worst thing ever, but I would expect (or at least want) a much better return for Pablo.

I mean, we agree he (and Jazz) are 2B, he is not a good fit because of same as already stated with Jazz, and they should do something else, but not to split hairs Torres 2022 performance was objectively pretty good and whatever he did 20/21 doesn't impact that by comparison. We can footnote that this may be the case because 2B depth in baseball was very weak last year so "average" guys are getting propped up (for instance, Berti was statistically a middle of the pack starter at 2B and 3B last year with a .662 OPS which is just nuts), but he still did it and it counts. There aren't many club-controlled 26 year old infielders with his statcast profile (75th percentile hard hit rates roughly), advanced stats are park adjusted so the park factors aren't that damning, and they are thinking a 3.2-3.3 WAR is coming next year (which sadly would be 3rd best on the Marlins). Just saying, I think this is a bit harsh and falls into over-scrutinizing Yankees as that market expects everyone to be an allstar. If the Marlins didn't have Jazz, he'd be kind of perfect (assuming reasonable extension) to try and "buy low" on a guy that has a profile to do much more age 26-30.

Maybe he never does it, but the point here is, a poor-ass ownership franchise is going to have to identify guys with roughly this exact profile at positions of need and try and get lucky with them they over-perform past performance. I think we agree here that we should expect most player acquisitions to be semi-risky in this vein because until Bruce wants to spend, nothing perfectly shiny is being acquired and penned into the lineup. We're going to get some warts.

Being said, I keep getting back in my mind to Rosario to fill "this" hole as the K/contact rates are elite, he has good maximum EVs, so if he can just barrel a few more balls (comically low), he may just explode. Combine that with arguably a high floor with said contact rates and he is OK enough defensively, that's the kind of guy I think the Marlins need to try and find. A not to expensive high floor player, with some chances for a step forward if everything goes right. He too is projected for a 3.2-3.4 WAR next year. 3rd best player on the team immediately on paper.

We'll see. Not sure what they can get for Pablo, but I would imagine if they did go for Gleyber/Rosario type, that's a different player trade and Pablo is used for a "Peraza" or "A. Thomas" type of 1st year player.

15 hours ago, Iowa said:

Pablo and coop and whatever for TA. Then sign abreu. Great freakin start

TA (avg. $13m next 2 years) and Abreu (expected $17-18m free agency) cost the same as Correa/Turner.

If they have that money to spend, don't you just go for Correa/Turner, and you can still make multiple trades to solve CF/bullpen?

59 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

TA (avg. $13m next 2 years) and Abreu (expected $17-18m free agency) cost the same as Correa/Turner.

If they have that money to spend, don't you just go for Correa/Turner, and you can still make multiple trades to solve CF/bullpen?

You think adding both Correa and Turner would be only an extra 30mil a year?

1 hour ago, hovertical said:

You think adding both Correa and Turner would be only an extra 30mil a year?

I think he meant Correa OR Turner lol

15 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

I think he meant Correa OR Turner lol

So would rather have just one of Correa or Turner versus both TA and Abreu?

5 minutes ago, hovertical said:

So would rather have just one of Correa or Turner versus both TA and Abreu?

Yes. Is this really a question? You really need me to explain why a 27 year old Correa for $30m/year + keeping Pablo and Cooper or trading them for something else as that was floated is a significantly better idea than trading Pablo/Cooper for a 30 year old Tim Anderson (who you'd need to extend) and signing a 36 year old Jose Abreu, who combined make $30m/year? If they have that kind of budget (doubtful), they need to go get a star. If they did those transactions, it would just become another.... Garica/Soler/Aguilar made the same as Correa so why the hell are they not just consolidating this into the OOMPH production they need and dipping into pitcher/farm trades for CC options to build out the rest. 

19 hours ago, Iowa said:

Abreu makes a lot of sense on this team. Could use a leader and wont be super expensive 

Plus "Cuban"

image.png.b772c76c8fc4472fb8031ececce7858f.png

19 hours ago, Erick said:

This is the guy I want.

Dude seems like a good guy too. I remember the second year he was w the White Sox and I sent him a ball asking for his autograph. The plan was to get a bunch of cubans on it... he signed it w my full name and a beautiful signature for his own. Got a nice note back too.


Rare and far between any players do that.

49 minutes ago, hovertical said:

So would rather have just one of Correa or Turner versus both TA and Abreu?

Long term, Turner.... short term TA and Abreu.
We have no business short term. This team isn't built well enough. Turner and try your hardest to clear payroll for Abreu or Trade for Anderson for two years. You can't afford TA and Turner in 4 years.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.