Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

2 hours ago, hovertical said:

So would rather have just one of Correa or Turner versus both TA and Abreu?

No I would definitely prefer both TA and Abreu. Unlike basketball where you can throw Lebron on a team and they’re pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth, baseball teams need a good depth of “really good” players to be successful. Not just one superstar and a bunch of nobodies.

3 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

No I would definitely prefer both TA and Abreu. Unlike basketball where you can throw Lebron on a team and they’re pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth, baseball teams need a good depth of “really good” players to be successful. Not just one superstar and a bunch of nobodies.

Lakers fans gonna disagree with you there haha

4 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Lakers fans gonna disagree with you there haha

Lmfao literally what came to mind and why I added “pretty much” lol

19 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

No I would definitely prefer both TA and Abreu. Unlike basketball where you can throw Lebron on a team and they’re pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth, baseball teams need a good depth of “really good” players to be successful. Not just one superstar and a bunch of nobodies.

But, TA and Abreu and trading Pablo and Cooper was what was said. Which would be an awful move that increases payroll $20m and maybe nets 2 wins. Correa/Turner and still having Pablo and Cooper and we're light years ahead of that if we are debating the best allocation of $30m/season and what was traded to get there. If we want to ignore you'd have to trade for Tim Anderson, sure the two of them (on lower contract deals) probably arguably better for a year or two.

The Marlins back end of the roster isn't a bunch of nobodies also. They are missing star production like Jazz, not missing some ordinary solid role players. Fortes, Cooper, Berti, Wendle/Rojas (pick 1), Leblanc/Groshans, DLC, and Sanchez produced 8.7 WAR last year. Per their collective PA, this roughly averages into a 2+ WAR player for their playing time over a full season. This is pretty notable if this is your bottom 6/7 position players, and I think most would argue here while Berti/Fortes over achieved, the rest probably under achieved. Of course we have the Stallings/Garcia/Soler disappointments and that is what it is, but they need to hope those guys just had epic down years. So add in Jazz, and then we have 2+ roster spots left, so yes, adding Lebron and Bosh is exactly what they need to fix the offense? Or call it Bennet and Reinhart if we want to go hockey. Or Hill and Armstead if we want to go NFL. And then pray you don't get Cristoballed and Gattis'd?

 

1 hour ago, marlinsmaniac said:

No I would definitely prefer both TA and Abreu. Unlike basketball where you can throw Lebron on a team and they’re pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth, baseball teams need a good depth of “really good” players to be successful. Not just one superstar and a bunch of nobodies.

Eh, when was the last time a singular superstar and a bunch of nobodies won the title? Usually it's superteams now. Superstar goes one place and boom three top 50 players join him.

25 minutes ago, Michael said:

Eh, when was the last time a singular superstar and a bunch of nobodies won the title? Usually it's superteams now. Superstar goes one place and boom three top 50 players join him.

Yeah hence why I said playoff berth and not championship lol. But yeah that original Big 3 in miami really shook all that up and kind of woke players up to how much pull they had in the front office if they are elite enough. 

1 hour ago, MarlinsLou said:

But, TA and Abreu and trading Pablo and Cooper was what was said. Which would be an awful move that increases payroll $20m and maybe nets 2 wins. Correa/Turner and still having Pablo and Cooper and we're light years ahead of that if we are debating the best allocation of $30m/season and what was traded to get there. If we want to ignore you'd have to trade for Tim Anderson, sure the two of them (on lower contract deals) probably arguably better for a year or two.

The Marlins back end of the roster isn't a bunch of nobodies also. They are missing star production like Jazz, not missing some ordinary solid role players. Fortes, Cooper, Berti, Wendle/Rojas (pick 1), Leblanc/Groshans, DLC, and Sanchez produced 8.7 WAR last year. Per their collective PA, this roughly averages into a 2+ WAR player for their playing time over a full season. This is pretty notable if this is your bottom 6/7 position players, and I think most would argue here while Berti/Fortes over achieved, the rest probably under achieved. Of course we have the Stallings/Garcia/Soler disappointments and that is what it is, but they need to hope those guys just had epic down years. So add in Jazz, and then we have 2+ roster spots left, so yes, adding Lebron and Bosh is exactly what they need to fix the offense? Or call it Bennet and Reinhart if we want to go hockey. Or Hill and Armstead if we want to go NFL. And then pray you don't get Cristoballed and Gattis'd?

 

Dude with all due respect, baseball, more than any other sport, is won in the field not on paper. Anyone can see that this team IS NOT Carlos Correa away from being even remotely good. They lost almost 100 games AGAIN. If you told me they finished the year a game out of the playoffs and needed to get over the hump? Ok, I’d give you that. But this team needs a complete overhaul at pretty much every position other than 2B and maybe the corner outfield spots and catcher (if the rest of the team is upgraded enough, I’m fine with Stallings/Forte). With that said, they are (in practice, not in WAR) better adding guys like time Anderson and Abreu who have a shitload of experience playing meaningful games and being in the hunt, and supplementing them with additional proven guys that are actually above replacement level. 

35 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Dude with all due respect, baseball, more than any other sport, is won in the field not on paper. Anyone can see that this team IS NOT Carlos Correa away from being even remotely good. They lost almost 100 games AGAIN. If you told me they finished the year a game out of the playoffs and needed to get over the hump? Ok, I’d give you that. But this team needs a complete overhaul at pretty much every position other than 2B and maybe the corner outfield spots and catcher (if the rest of the team is upgraded enough, I’m fine with Stallings/Forte). With that said, they are (in practice, not in WAR) better adding guys like time Anderson and Abreu who have a shitload of experience playing meaningful games and being in the hunt, and supplementing them with additional proven guys that are actually above replacement level. 

If Jazz stays healthy all year, they add a Correa or Turner type bat and Skip the new skip understands how to actually create lineups, manage a bullpen and not yawn when his team is getting  cheated at the plate by umps....combined with Ng actually paying attention to the roster and not leaving them short, etc.  then yeah? maybe they could sneak into a WC with just a Correa type bat added?  The offense runs through Jazz.  Period.  We all saw what happened to it once he was gone for the season. 

Even if they don't make the playoffs...that sounds like something a lot more fun to watch than a bunch of nearly replacement level guys and a checked out manager and GM ignoring the team for 2/3 of the season.

I want something that's actually watchable at least.  Give me some damn hope here.

53 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Dude with all due respect, baseball, more than any other sport, is won in the field not on paper. Anyone can see that this team IS NOT Carlos Correa away from being even remotely good. They lost almost 100 games AGAIN. If you told me they finished the year a game out of the playoffs and needed to get over the hump? Ok, I’d give you that. But this team needs a complete overhaul at pretty much every position other than 2B and maybe the corner outfield spots and catcher (if the rest of the team is upgraded enough, I’m fine with Stallings/Forte). With that said, they are (in practice, not in WAR) better adding guys like time Anderson and Abreu who have a shitload of experience playing meaningful games and being in the hunt, and supplementing them with additional proven guys that are actually above replacement level. 

Did I say they just need Carlos Correa? No I did not. Not now. Not ever. So not sure what that is about at all. 

Saying they need a complete overhaul is what my, with all due respect, beef with Marlins fans are. It's over-dramatic. Everyone seems to be missing the forest in the trees here. The team has a top 10 SP situation in baseball and that's likely a floor with what is coming quickly. They have one of the best 2B situations in baseball. You can't just ignore the "bottom half" of the position players may collectively produce 7-8 WAR and cost roughly $15m combined. That is a good thing. The lefty relievers are pretty solid also and the 3 of them cost $7m between them which is nothing. Those alone gets them to 18-20 players all pretty good for who they are and contractually.

Do they have a Stallings/Soler/Garcia problem? Yes, but they also can't just cut them with their contracts (well they can with Stallings but no sense as he's cheap and will likely be better). So this overhaul you're talking about is 3-4 players (CF, SS, maybe another bat upgrade, definitely RHP relievers). They need MAJOR IMPACT from those spots if they have any chance with what they have, and the Mets signed the only RHP relievers that could do that so it's getting the absolutely best CF/SS if they will have any chance. The relievers are going to be Bass signings or Nick Anderson hopes and prayers. If anything, it's a Cooper upgrade on top of that.

So yea, if they have $30m to spend in this hypothetical someone posted, they should spend it on Correa. *Not* trade Pablo and Cooper for Tim Anderson and sign Abreu. That's insane. You get way more bang for your buck with the former once you realize Pablo can bring back something major if he has to be moved for payroll. Tim Anderson would be great if the deal is right - but it's not smart with how this was presented. 

33 minutes ago, hovertical said:

If Jazz stays healthy all year, they add a Correa or Turner type bat and Skip the new skip understands how to actually create lineups, manage a bullpen and not yawn when his team is getting  cheated at the plate by umps....combined with Ng actually paying attention to the roster and not leaving them short, etc.  then yeah? maybe they could sneak into a WC with just a Correa type bat added?  The offense runs through Jazz.  Period.  We all saw what happened to it once he was gone for the season. 

Even if they don't make the playoffs...that sounds like something a lot more fun to watch than a bunch of nearly replacement level guys and a checked out manager and GM ignoring the team for 2/3 of the season.

I want something that's actually watchable at least.  Give me some damn hope here.

I'd say add a real CF to this (not Kiermaier, a real everyday good player), and then yes. Maybe they'd have a shot at a last wild card. Assuming also they pull two more Benders and Andersons out of their ass, but they seem to be pretty good at that.

On 11/9/2022 at 3:43 PM, Valid said:

If the Marlins do trade him, I seriously hope it would be for someone better than Gleyber Torres. Torres hasn't been good in three years.

Apparently it was the prospect the Marlins wanted with Torres is what caused that deal to fail. 

Of course team needs to get value, but this is the right time to deal him in my opinion. We have the arms ready to go. Getting a bonafide starting position player and a prospect would be ideal. 

6 minutes ago, QbanCastillo said:

Alek Thomas for Pablo Lopez?

Would that make sense for Arizona right now? Are they on the way up or already right there?

1 hour ago, Michael said:

Would that make sense for Arizona right now? Are they on the way up or already right there?

They might be. Varsho/Carroll could be a devastating 1-2 punch and they have a lot of other useful bats (McCarthy, Walker, Ketel, Rojas, Kelly). Gallen is everything as advertised for them and needs help.

They really could use another SP. They have four left handed center fielders. I think they'd want someone with more control for Thomas (Rogers), but that's also OK. I maintain Soler/Bumgarner is a great dump for everyone here on top of something larger.

12 hours ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Dude with all due respect, baseball, more than any other sport, is won in the field not on paper. Anyone can see that this team IS NOT Carlos Correa away from being even remotely good. They lost almost 100 games AGAIN. If you told me they finished the year a game out of the playoffs and needed to get over the hump? Ok, I’d give you that. But this team needs a complete overhaul at pretty much every position other than 2B and maybe the corner outfield spots and catcher (if the rest of the team is upgraded enough, I’m fine with Stallings/Forte). With that said, they are (in practice, not in WAR) better adding guys like time Anderson and Abreu who have a shitload of experience playing meaningful games and being in the hunt, and supplementing them with additional proven guys that are actually above replacement level. 

But the Marlins led the league in bad luck last year!

3 hours ago, r5812 said:

But the Marlins led the league in bad luck last year!

Yeah their bad luck started when Loria finally sold but did so to another cheap fuck who has no business owning a MLB team lol

  • Author
8 hours ago, r5812 said:

But the Marlins led the league in bad luck last year!

Kim is currently inventing a new "moneyball" type stat for bad luck as we speak.

4 hours ago, SilverBullet said:

ngLCK+ 

And then there's shrmnLCK+ which normalizes franchise cheapassness

Edited by Entendu

28 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

Sandy is a nice guy and isn't gonna complain about payroll publicly. 

I guess we have to extend the same courtesy to Ng then when she talks about how good this team is? 

I get it though, most people don't rip their employers or insinuate their teammates suck and need to be upgraded whereas Ng's function is to actually make changes to the roster.

James Rowson hired by the Tigers as assistant hitting coach. Once again dumbfounded that any team wants the cast offs from our broken coaching staff. 

Also kinda weird that Rowson went from hitting coach to bench coach as a potential future manager and now back down to just assistant hitting coach.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.