Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

Just now, SonOfJack said:

What if the new manager doesn't want Mel? Seems unlikely but plausible. 

It is possible, and of course a chance Mel doesn't want to stay without Don, too.

The good news is the new manager will choose their group to work with.

1 minute ago, Michael said:

It is possible, and of course a chance Mel doesn't want to stay without Don, too.

The good news is the new manager will choose their group to work with.

Whoever the new manager is will automatically get a -1 and a "Fire _______" thread started if they don't want Mel around.

13 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Whoever the new manager is will automatically get a -1 and a "Fire _______" thread started if they don't want Mel around.

Now that you mention that, it's only a matter of time before we want the next manager fired. Should we just start the thread now and get a jump on it already?

22 minutes ago, Michael said:

 

 

Yes keep Mel. Only former Yankee to keep.

Pretty obvious "scoop" here but this is also a smooth way for Kim to basically fire all the coaches without having to fire them. "It's not that we want you out but we're gonna allow the next manager to choose his own staff."

1 minute ago, SilverBullet said:

Pretty obvious "scoop" here but this is also a smooth way for Kim to basically fire all the coaches without having to fire them. "It's not that we want you out but we're gonna allow the next manager to choose his own staff."

That's the way to do it.

20 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

What if the new manager doesn't want Mel? Seems unlikely but plausible. 

Fair question but now I wonder what is more important for Kim... keeping Mel or letting the new manager have their choice?

Because there's a difference between "Welcome aboard, choose whatever coaches you want" and "Welcome aboard, choose the rest of your staff but Mel is our pitching coach if that's cool with you."

1 minute ago, Michael said:

That's the way to do it.

And not that it matters but it's the right move and I would imagine every one of those coaches would understand why a shakeup is needed on the staff.

Is Mel being interviewed for manager, and if not why not? They are going to live and die on the mound and things clearly are working there across the organization, so wouldn't you take a leap of faith with Mel who understands all of these pitchers *now* and get an ex-Manager bench coach who can primarily run with the hitters? At minimum, at least an interview assuming Mel has ambitions to be a manager.

This is a bad example because he sucked but relevant for Miami purposes, but how Al Golden is # 2 at Notre Dame somehow with a rookie head coach who is a defensive genius. Al does bring some value to them with experience at minimum.

Why not do that, except you know, do better than Al Golden. Charlie Montoyo? He coached multiple years for the Rays and didn't do a bad job in Toronto (.500 over 4 seasons in that division with them not having the players when he arrived). And he's Puerto Rican which is a bonus for Miami. 

It's worth a meeting IMO. I'm not sure why this hasn't been floated but maybe I missed that?

 

34 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

I'm not sure why this hasn't been floated but maybe I missed that?

I hadn't seen it said until 7 minutes ago when @Entendu said it here in another thread. At least I think that is what he meant.

It does seem like they something they should explore, if Mel has interest.

Ehh, if he's that good of a pitching coach I feel like that's his best role. Making him manager puts him a role less suited for him and probably puts a lesser pitching coach in that role. Seems like a downgrade to do it that way. 

53 minutes ago, SilverBullet said:

Ehh, if he's that good of a pitching coach I feel like that's his best role. Making him manager puts him a role less suited for him and probably puts a lesser pitching coach in that role. Seems like a downgrade to do it that way. 

I'd honestly rather have him focused entirely on working with the pitching staff. I also feel that if did interview and didn't get the job then it would be an awkward situation for him and he may want to go elsewhere then. For me, anything but Mel staying on as pitching coach only will likely end up in a losing situation for the Marlins. 

  • Author
21 hours ago, SirFishFan said:

What’s the deal with Baseball teams having a “captain?”

Isn’t the manager technically the “captain?”

I can understand on a NFL team or what not. But the Marlins don’t deserve to have a “captain”, they’re not the Yankees and Rojas is no Derek Jeter.

Let them get like maybe two winning seasons in a row, and then someone can be Captain Marlin, until then they need to accept that besides Sandy, Pablo and sometimes Jazz, they are just mediocre players and forget about that “captain” nonsense.

😂

I don't think it's as much of an actually designated thing anymore, it's more just someone assuming the unofficial role.

And, no, why would the manager be the captain?  He's the manager.  The captain is always a player.....it's not ship lol

2 hours ago, Michael said:

 

 

Yes keep Mel. Only former Yankee to keep.

 

This is good news to me.

 

2 hours ago, SonOfJack said:

What if the new manager doesn't want Mel? Seems unlikely but plausible. 

I'd prefer to keep him.  It's also not unprecedented for organizations to keep the pitching coach while a new manager and other staff comes in.

1 hour ago, SilverBullet said:

Pretty obvious "scoop" here but this is also a smooth way for Kim to basically fire all the coaches without having to fire them. "It's not that we want you out but we're gonna allow the next manager to choose his own staff."

Water off a duck's back.

Her clock starts after the new manager is in.

 

1 hour ago, MarlinsLou said:

Is Mel being interviewed for manager, and if not why not? They are going to live and die on the mound and things clearly are working there across the organization, so wouldn't you take a leap of faith with Mel who understands all of these pitchers *now* and get an ex-Manager bench coach who can primarily run with the hitters? At minimum, at least an interview assuming Mel has ambitions to be a manager.

This is a bad example because he sucked but relevant for Miami purposes, but how Al Golden is # 2 at Notre Dame somehow with a rookie head coach who is a defensive genius. Al does bring some value to them with experience at minimum.

Why not do that, except you know, do better than Al Golden. Charlie Montoyo? He coached multiple years for the Rays and didn't do a bad job in Toronto (.500 over 4 seasons in that division with them not having the players when he arrived). And he's Puerto Rican which is a bonus for Miami. 

It's worth a meeting IMO. I'm not sure why this hasn't been floated but maybe I missed that?

 

Have we heard he has any aspirations for that?

I'd rather him stay where he's had the most success and focus on that only, not adding overall hitting+pitching responsibilities.  If it's something he wants to potentially do, that's one thing, but I don't think I'd voluntarily offer, unless he's hinted that he wants a crack at it.

2 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

Is Mel being interviewed for manager, and if not why not? They are going to live and die on the mound and things clearly are working there across the organization, so wouldn't you take a leap of faith with Mel who understands all of these pitchers *now* and get an ex-Manager bench coach who can primarily run with the hitters? At minimum, at least an interview assuming Mel has ambitions to be a manager.

This is a bad example because he sucked but relevant for Miami purposes, but how Al Golden is # 2 at Notre Dame somehow with a rookie head coach who is a defensive genius. Al does bring some value to them with experience at minimum.

Why not do that, except you know, do better than Al Golden. Charlie Montoyo? He coached multiple years for the Rays and didn't do a bad job in Toronto (.500 over 4 seasons in that division with them not having the players when he arrived). And he's Puerto Rican which is a bonus for Miami. 

It's worth a meeting IMO. I'm not sure why this hasn't been floated but maybe I missed that?

 

So few of the pitching coach 'gurus' have excelled at managers.  

I think its best to just put Mel in charge of pitching in the entire organization and just be done with it honestly.

 

I'd rather them just let the manager do his own thing and let Mel focus on the pitching all in all.  

  • Author
1 hour ago, SonOfJack said:

how could you be so sure joe pesci GIF

Oh, that's today's projected clock reset.

It'll change another 5 times this week.

30 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Oh, that's today's projected clock reset.

It'll change another 5 times this week.

When the High-A manager's bat dog gets fired, THEN Kim will finally have full control.

5 hours ago, Michael said:

Nobody has asked the big question though.

Will the new manager also hire their own fans?

Absolutely! The beat writers need someone to blame after all.

48 minutes ago, Michael said:

When the High-A manager's bat dog gets fired, THEN Kim will finally have full control.

not if she loses her phone and thus nobody can call her.  she could have some nice job security going that route. hmmmm

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.