Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2022-2023 Offseason Thread

Featured Replies

5 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

I don't either, the COVID rules were confusing. I do know some guys got full years of service time for a game or two so maybe this preserved an option. Lewin has been a professional for 9 seasons so I don't think if there are some exemptions he is going to fit into it. This suggests he is OOO but I don't know if it's accurate - https://blogs.fangraphs.com/examining-the-national-leagues-2022-40-man-crunch/. I am assuming it is but would love a hard answer if someone does know.

I can certainly see them trying to ride it out with Lewin unless Rizzo and/or Abreu come here.

I'd love for the "and" to happen and ship off Coop and Soler. Lol.

12 minutes ago, Michael said:

I can certainly see them trying to ride it out with Lewin unless Rizzo and/or Abreu come here.

I'd love for the "and" to happen and ship off Coop and Soler. Lol.

Coop's statcast is "really red" for this front office - https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-player/garrett-cooper-643265?stats=statcast-r-hitting-mlb. And they can say he was hurt July/August (which is true). It's ignoring he is always hurt which is the problem here, but I kind of feel he comes back at a modest arbitration tender in a real contract year. They then "Buxton" him and don't let him play 4/5 days in a row and always take a day off before an off day on top of that to give an extra 2 days here and there. It's not a bad idea assuming they get HUGE upgrades at CF and SS and someone else can play 1B (Anderson? That should satisfy the defensive angle you mentioned earlier with Lewin. Have to imagine he'd be a plus defensive 1B given he's a real solid 3B historically).

I think Cooper goes basically if the payroll goes to $110m to open up for Rizzo.

Or if something weird happens. Since you mentioned Soler....  can't see a situation Soler is moved absent taking back a bad contract - like maybe they swap a really good prospect and Soler for McCarthy and Bumgarner (2/$32 effectively, payable $18 in 2023 then $14 in 2024). Arizona would save minimum $8m if Soler opts into 2024 and he makes sense as a right handed bat with all their lefties (Varsho, Carroll, Thomas). That then opens up moving Pablo for the SS/whoever trade as Bumgarner is unmoveable but he will throw 150+ innings no doubt as the team's # 5 and pray Stallings can frame pitches again. Important to note, this decreases expected payroll $3m shedding $21m with Pablo/Soler for $18m of Bumgarner. You add a little in 2024, but deal with that in a year as hey Bruce, payroll went DOWN and we got a CF my man. Also, Cooper is now at DH which should keep him healthier. You hope?

So if all that happened, they'd be sitting at $72-73m if they further trade Pablo, Rojas/Wendle, and Anderson (and whatever prospects) and they'd only need four guys for MLB roster - 1B/DH, SS, and two right handed relievers. Certainly, trading those 3 guys (and other guys like Burdick who would be expendable) could net 4 roster spots? Rosario and J. Naylor starts becoming VERY interesting for Pablo here, and maybe old Bruce would Werth it with Diaz on top of this. You could do this sub $95m easily with minimal backloading. 

But how cheap and uncreative will they be? That's the real question.

Jazz is the ONLY legitimate mlb player on offense. You're kidding yourself if you think you can talk yourself in to thinking anything different. Gonna be a frustrating offseason of "trying" followed by another 90+ loss season.  I'll buy the first month of MLB TV but that will most likely be it. This franchise is so pathetic and seeing her comments about Garcia and Soler, when everybody and their mother knew they were AWFUL signings AT THE TIME, gives me zero hope. Only a matter of time before Jazz gets frustrated as shit and tries to force his way out 

1 hour ago, Iowa said:

Jazz is the ONLY legitimate mlb player on offense. You're kidding yourself if you think you can talk yourself in to thinking anything different. Gonna be a frustrating offseason of "trying" followed by another 90+ loss season.  I'll buy the first month of MLB TV but that will most likely be it. This franchise is so pathetic and seeing her comments about Garcia and Soler, when everybody and their mother knew they were AWFUL signings AT THE TIME, gives me zero hope. Only a matter of time before Jazz gets frustrated as shit and tries to force his way out 

Jazz may already be doing that, quietly. Lol.

1 hour ago, Iowa said:

Jazz is the ONLY legitimate mlb player on offense. You're kidding yourself if you think you can talk yourself in to thinking anything different. Gonna be a frustrating offseason of "trying" followed by another 90+ loss season.  I'll buy the first month of MLB TV but that will most likely be it. This franchise is so pathetic and seeing her comments about Garcia and Soler, when everybody and their mother knew they were AWFUL signings AT THE TIME, gives me zero hope. Only a matter of time before Jazz gets frustrated as shit and tries to force his way out 

What does legitimate mean here? Genuinely. As at worst, Fortes, Cooper, Berti, Wendle, Rojas, and Anderson are likely low-end starters/positive bench players on good contracts, there are regression to the mean arguments for Soler, Garcia, and Stallings who were all pretty good 19-21, and then we get to DLC, Groshans, Sanchez, Bleday, LeBlanc, and gang who have all had some moments and are effectively 1st year players. If even 1 of them is OK that's a big win to me. They will have to try them out and see if one sticks.

Jazz is certainly the only guy we can consider a well-above average regular, but this gaggle of guys isn't a 0, even if the upside is "average at best." They actually had the 24th "best" position core in baseball last year even with Jazz out half the year and all the injuries/terrible Garcia/Soler/Stallings/Aguilar showings. If they had health, they probably could have clawed to 20th-21st here FWIW.

They need a lot more of course, but it's likely 2-3 major upgrades, likely SS, CF, and TBD based on what else they do. Let's not let frustration cloud the bigger picture here. This isn't a 2018 replay. Their problem is they are missing the top of the roster with OOMPH bats, not that the bottom 2/3rds of the roster sucks.

35 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

What does legitimate mean here? Genuinely. As at worst, Fortes, Cooper, Berti, Wendle, Rojas, and Anderson are likely low-end starters/positive bench players on good contracts, there are regression to the mean arguments for Soler, Garcia, and Stallings who were all pretty good 19-21, and then we get to DLC, Groshans, Sanchez, Bleday, LeBlanc, and gang who have all had some moments and are effectively 1st year players. If even 1 of them is OK that's a big win to me. They will have to try them out and see if one sticks.

Jazz is certainly the only guy we can consider a well-above average regular, but this gaggle of guys isn't a 0, even if the upside is "average at best." They actually had the 24th "best" position core in baseball last year even with Jazz out half the year and all the injuries/terrible Garcia/Soler/Stallings/Aguilar showings. If they had health, they probably could have clawed to 20th-21st here FWIW.

They need a lot more of course, but it's likely 2-3 major upgrades, likely SS, CF, and TBD based on what else they do. Let's not let frustration cloud the bigger picture here. This isn't a 2018 replay. Their problem is they are missing the top of the roster with OOMPH bats, not that the bottom 2/3rds of the roster sucks.

Let me rephrase.. jazz is the only offensive player that should be a starting major league player. Your "at worst" should say "at best".

Also Soler and Garcia have always sucked. Spare me your advanced metrics because if their approach at the plate  didnt make it blatantly obvious to you that theyre garbage, i dont know what to tell you.

Ive seen enough of anderson, dlc, sanchez, lewin, stallings and bleday as well. I'd be okay with never watching them swing a bat agin. I'll give give groshans and leblanc a shot but they better not count on them to start. However i will take berti and wendle on my bench all day, so theres that.

1 hour ago, SonOfJack said:

Who is being non tendered?

Anderson and Stallings seem a little high, so do Floro and Scott but they got a few "saves" to bump that for them, but Pablo seems low which is the most important one here obviously. Seems about right from what I was expecting in the aggregate. Solid team projection here.

Hernandez, Sulser, and Brigham should go but keep the rest of them. They should trade at least one of Rojas/Wendle/Anderson/Cooper/Berti though and maybe two for RP help or throw-ins for a larger trade.

2 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

]Hernandez, Sulser, and Brigham should go but keep the rest of them. They should trade at least one of Rojas/Wendle/Anderson/Cooper/Berti though and maybe two for RP help or throw-ins for a larger trade.

Rojas is curious to me.  He had a 2.5war this year but in watching the games - did he really feel like he was 2 1/2 wins above a replacement level player??  I can't see how as he was absolutely horrid at the plate despite 'leading' the team with a banner .236avg and zero power.  He has his usual great defense aside from that stretch where he seemed to get the yips so I'm guessing that played a large part into his overall replacement metrics?  I also felt he was kinda putrid in the clubhouse this year and just seemed like he 'didn't fit' any longer.  I think he needs to go - but again, i don't see them getting much more than some scrub prospect at best for him. 

I feel like Cooper is one of those guys who would absolutely slay it on a team like the Rays (just a hunch) - but trade with their F.O. at your own risk haha. 

The Marlins have a TON of guys, as listed above, that are 'usable' but yet at the same time - suck when the entire team is filled with them.  Frankly, I'm also pretty sick of seeing some of these retreads fail season over season. They're just so uninspiring and I think some of them need a change of scenery at this point too (Hello, Mr. Anderson). Get some fresh wheels in here, get rid of most of the base cloggers (aguilar was a good start) and let's FINALLY play to what should be the team's strength in the park which should be pitching, speed, contact, and defense.  No, Bruce and Kim, that doesn't mean bring back Hamilton. 

I've said it once I've said it a few times.

 

This is what you have:

 

C - Fortes/Stallings  (you arent going to get much better in the short term, you need your young catching prospects to get going).  Well unless ownership opens their wallets

1b - They dont have a starting type 1b on the roster

2b - Jazz

3b/ss - You have Wendle and Groshans.  You need to upgrade one of these positions.  Ideally you'd get a SS, make Groshans the 3b (unless he falls on his face in the spring) and either trade Wendle or make him into that super utility play all over guy envisioned.  

LF/RF/DH - Soler and Garcia are handling 2 of these spots unless Ng can pull off some magic and find a sucker I mean trade partner for one or both of them.

CF - they dont have a starting level one on the roster (still).

 

You have Cooper - its time to move on from him honestly.

You have Rojas - he either needs to be a bench guy or its time to say adios.

You have Berti - who is probably a guy better suited for a  bench role than Rojas.  

De La Cruz - feel he can be a fifth outfielder on this team if used properly.

Bleday - not really sure what to make of him, he will get at least one more chance at some point just because of his draft pedigree

Lew DIaz - cut bait

Brian Anderson - cut bait

Basically any other player not on the 40 and not mentioned, who cares, keep them, dont keep them, not worth spending much time on any of them honestly.  

 

I'll get into pitching later.

37 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I've said it once I've said it a few times.

 

This is what you have:

 

C - Fortes/Stallings  (you arent going to get much better in the short term, you need your young catching prospects to get going).  Well unless ownership opens their wallets

1b - They dont have a starting type 1b on the roster

2b - Jazz

3b/ss - You have Wendle and Groshans.  You need to upgrade one of these positions.  Ideally you'd get a SS, make Groshans the 3b (unless he falls on his face in the spring) and either trade Wendle or make him into that super utility play all over guy envisioned.  

LF/RF/DH - Soler and Garcia are handling 2 of these spots unless Ng can pull off some magic and find a sucker I mean trade partner for one or both of them.

CF - they dont have a starting level one on the roster (still).

 

You have Cooper - its time to move on from him honestly.

You have Rojas - he either needs to be a bench guy or its time to say adios.

You have Berti - who is probably a guy better suited for a  bench role than Rojas.  

De La Cruz - feel he can be a fifth outfielder on this team if used properly.

Bleday - not really sure what to make of him, he will get at least one more chance at some point just because of his draft pedigree

Lew DIaz - cut bait

Brian Anderson - cut bait

Basically any other player not on the 40 and not mentioned, who cares, keep them, dont keep them, not worth spending much time on any of them honestly.  

 

I'll get into pitching later.

The Cardinals have a better situation, but they’re still watching the playoffs instead of playing in it.

Sad. 

Edited by Erick

7 hours ago, Iowa said:

Jazz is the ONLY legitimate mlb player on offense. You're kidding yourself if you think you can talk yourself in to thinking anything different. Gonna be a frustrating offseason of "trying" followed by another 90+ loss season.  I'll buy the first month of MLB TV but that will most likely be it. This franchise is so pathetic and seeing her comments about Garcia and Soler, when everybody and their mother knew they were AWFUL signings AT THE TIME, gives me zero hope. Only a matter of time before Jazz gets frustrated as shit and tries to force his way out 

Even Jazz is not a true legit mlb player on offense yet..

36 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I've said it once I've said it a few times.

 

This is what you have:

 

C - Fortes/Stallings  (you arent going to get much better in the short term, you need your young catching prospects to get going).  Well unless ownership opens their wallets

1b - They dont have a starting type 1b on the roster

2b - Jazz

3b/ss - You have Wendle and Groshans.  You need to upgrade one of these positions.  Ideally you'd get a SS, make Groshans the 3b (unless he falls on his face in the spring) and either trade Wendle or make him into that super utility play all over guy envisioned.  

LF/RF/DH - Soler and Garcia are handling 2 of these spots unless Ng can pull off some magic and find a sucker I mean trade partner for one or both of them.

CF - they dont have a starting level one on the roster (still).

 

You have Cooper - its time to move on from him honestly.

You have Rojas - he either needs to be a bench guy or its time to say adios.

You have Berti - who is probably a guy better suited for a  bench role than Rojas.  

De La Cruz - feel he can be a fifth outfielder on this team if used properly.

Bleday - not really sure what to make of him, he will get at least one more chance at some point just because of his draft pedigree

Lew DIaz - cut bait

Brian Anderson - cut bait

Basically any other player not on the 40 and not mentioned, who cares, keep them, dont keep them, not worth spending much time on any of them honestly.  

 

I'll get into pitching later.

Well, at least Berti, Wendle, and DLC would make a great bench and provide some great flexibility. Too bad at least 2 of them will be full-time starters next year most likely and if they do indeed move on from Rojas (as they should) then I could see all 3 of those guys being starters unfortunately. 

 

They should still be able to get something 'decent' for Cooper.  Decent is a relative term here but yeah, he should be able to bring something better than a useless Alex Jackson type back. 

I'm done with Lewin, Anderson, and Rojas.  See ya and good luck with whatever club you end up on.  I was NOT impressed with Bleday at all but I'll agree he gets more time (and perhaps a chance to work with a better hitting coach).  I like Fortes over Stallings if I had to choose simply because he has better wheels (and is cheaper).  I feel their offensive skill sets are fairly comparable overall with Fortes holding a power edge.  Fortes could fall off drastically though and Stallings could continue getting better as he did for most of the second half, again, relatively speaking.  There are bigger concerns on the team than catching though at the moment. 

First base is a complete black hole. They 100% need to find a FA to fill this need here.  They still need a closer too with a decent track record - finding someone reliable to close out games would have netted them several more wins this year too than the clown car they ran with.  BP arms are a fickle lot though with a few exceptions. Who knows. 

9 minutes ago, mk613 said:

Even Jazz is not a true legit mlb player on offense yet..

how so?????? because he strikes out?

1 minute ago, SonOfJack said:

This is nonsense

agreed

there is literally no team in all of MLB that wouldn't gladly take him off our hands and put him immediately on their roster.

2 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

And immediately into their everyday starting lineup as well.

well, it depends if they hire Don to be their manager next season or not I suppose

2 hours ago, Das Texan said:

I've said it once I've said it a few times.

 

This is what you have:

 

C - Fortes/Stallings  (you arent going to get much better in the short term, you need your young catching prospects to get going).  Well unless ownership opens their wallets

1b - They dont have a starting type 1b on the roster

2b - Jazz

3b/ss - You have Wendle and Groshans.  You need to upgrade one of these positions.  Ideally you'd get a SS, make Groshans the 3b (unless he falls on his face in the spring) and either trade Wendle or make him into that super utility play all over guy envisioned.  

LF/RF/DH - Soler and Garcia are handling 2 of these spots unless Ng can pull off some magic and find a sucker I mean trade partner for one or both of them.

CF - they dont have a starting level one on the roster (still).

 

You have Cooper - its time to move on from him honestly.

You have Rojas - he either needs to be a bench guy or its time to say adios.

You have Berti - who is probably a guy better suited for a  bench role than Rojas.  

De La Cruz - feel he can be a fifth outfielder on this team if used properly.

Bleday - not really sure what to make of him, he will get at least one more chance at some point just because of his draft pedigree

Lew DIaz - cut bait

Brian Anderson - cut bait

Basically any other player not on the 40 and not mentioned, who cares, keep them, dont keep them, not worth spending much time on any of them honestly.  

 

I'll get into pitching later.

Das Lou.

7 hours ago, SonOfJack said:

Who is being non tendered?

Oh fuck. It says the Marlins first have to deal with Wendle's contract situation. Putting that on Kim Ng's to do list will pretty much take up the entire offseason. 

3 hours ago, hovertical said:

also felt he was kinda putrid in the clubhouse this year and just seemed like he 'didn't fit' any longer.  I think he needs to go - but again, i don't see them getting much more than some scrub prospect at best for him. 

I agree with Rojas losing the clubhouse and no longer fitting in here. It's a shame he seemed to fall down off that pedestal so quickly and so hard.

But at the same time I don't think he leaves the team yet.

I can see his playing time diminishing if we get any upgrade at short and Rojas is still a nice enough guy that he would publicly say he's ok with a utility role for the betterment of the team and because X player is "such a great guy" etc etc. 

But I just think the front office will still value him as a supposed core member of the club. 

"Best" case scenario he's probably a late season DFA next year. 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.