Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. why so quick to blame for Marlins FO? This was in the context of my usual stance which is I respect the decisions the front office makes even though sometimes I don't understand them. This was not a jumping on the FO. More I'm curious the back story.
  2. ...Perry Hill, who they were incredibly sympathetic and thoughtful towards when his wife was dieing, and by all accounts was the architect of the the Marlins 2003 WS defense, just signed as first base coach with Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh? It's hard for me to believe their loyalty to Andy Foxx or their belief in his abilities (which we've all seen the dividends that's paid) as infield coach is so strong they wouldn't make the obvious move. Hill came to the Marlins in the spring of 2002 as Loria was taking over, played a big part in 2003 and even knows most of the new crop of guys from his last full season in 2006 (+part of 2007). If he had stayed near home and signed in Texas I'd understand, and yes I know he is friends with Russell but you would have thought (at least I did) that with 2009 being a playoff push season for the Fish and defense supposedly at the top of the agenda, Hill would have been welcomed home with open arms. And please don't say it was $. I'd love to know the back story here because having Perry Hill back coaching the infield just makes way too much sense.
  3. I wasn't hibernating and nothing is going to save Jeremy Hermida except himself. Why you think Hermida will step up his game and get his arms around what major league players are expected to do just because he changes is positions is beyond me. And if it were that simple the Marlins had plenty of opportunities to try it when Willingham was out for fifty games.
  4. Marlins right fielders hit .243/.311/.407 last year. I think it's more likely than not Hermida hits better than that. You're right, sort of. He hit .247/.318/.401 in '08. Hermida would have contributed a grand total of 1.7 more hits in 2008 based on playing time (against the average). No, that's not a typo. The real question is how many more runs would have scored because of his lackadaisical and error-prone defense had Fredi not seen enough and yanked him. Ross, for what it's worth hit .270/.338/.460 during his time in right field.
  5. Playing hurt is part of the game and can't be a convenient truth a player trots out when he underperforms, but when people speak to Gregg's blown saves last season, it really does (for me anyways) have to be in the context of his knee problems - how many blown saves were because he pitched poorly, and how many were the result of his knee injury causing him to pitch poorly. The mistake in my estimation was to not have it attended to as soon as the season ended instead of waiting until the first week of November. That move will cost the Marlins and himself next year. But if the doctors' reports are good I don't know that Gregg's trade value will necessarily take the hit others think it will.
  6. I'd add one more thing to this discourse. My comments regarding trust or confidence in the the Front Office is meant solely in the context of the Marlins' FO. Were I a Pittsburgh Pirates, Baltimore Orioles or Seattle Mariners fan, I don't believe I'd be anywhere near as comfortable with the decisions made and accepting of them even though I might disagree.
  7. I respect the collective information the FO has at its disposal. It doesn't mean they are infallible nor does it mean we shouldn't debate it, but they are working with the inside dope on 25 active roster guys evaluated from every angle, on the field and off, a ton of minor league and scouting reports from around baseball vs what we have most of which is suspect anyways. And they have a gameplan they have thought out and are trying to execute. So often we're reacting to last night's game. Are they sometimes wrong? Absolutely. And when they are and some guy on a messageboard had it right, more times than not it's a lucky guess on his part, and an unknown (to them) factor. And I'm comfortable with that.
  8. The NO team will be playing in exactly the same PCL division the Isotopes played in last season and against the same teams. I've been trying to explain the PCL's realignment all season but it continues to fall on deaf ears. The good thing is half their games will be played at a lower elevation which is good for pitchers and hitters alike but their road game schedule won't change much at all. They were in the PCL South division last year and they will be again. Take a look http://web.minorleaguebaseball.com/index.jsp?sid=l112
  9. Hermida's problems are of his own making but not necessarily in his control. The fear that if we traded him he might return a player who ultimately failed too is a red herring. The fear that if we traded him and he blossomed into the player everyone expected we would have seller's remorse is something every team has to weigh every time they make a trade. It isn't exclusive to this situation. If the Marlins are going to make a run in 2009 you have to honestly ask yourself are you willing to allow Hermida to flounder again and hold back that effort just so he has one more opportunity? The answer has to be no. If he can produce he should be here, if he can't then the franchise can't wait any longer. Age has nothing to do with it. Nothing at all. Nor at this point does anything he did in the minors matter. The MB website is littered with thousands of posts about minor league players who were touted as having tremendous major league potential and eventually were proven to be AAAA players. To me it's in the hands of the front office. They know what they are doing. I live with whatever their decision is because i know it will be more informed than any I can make. No one here is against Hermida succeeding or hoping he fails. What I think we all share is a desire to be playing in October again and if that means a few of our current players wind up being thrown under bus, regardless of age, pedigree, potential or anything else, so be it.
  10. The team could hold raffles to get to see who's in charge of the radar gun when Penny pitches. The Marlins would have to be out of their minds to commit the kind of money he would be asking even with his bum shoulder although they might get the fast food industry in South Florida to kick in a few mil. It would probably turn out to be a very good investment for them. Ouch! So basically, you would argue all the McDonald's in the Bronx should give a subsidy to the Yankees to sign CC? CC is a dollarmillionaire for sure. Penny's love of fast food used to be legendary here and (I think it's) Broken Arrow OK, hence the comment. Rather than McDonalds (and I bet I'm the only person here who knew the McDonald bros.) I'd guess (and of course this is all silliness) our hometown Burger King Corp. would jump at the chance to sign Brad Penny as their spokesman for the Super Loaded Steakhouse Burger or maybe pitching (yeah, the pun was intended) a Triple Bacon Cheese Whopper ! Can't you just see Brad and the King together on the same stage... :brigginbounce
  11. The team could hold raffles to get to see who's in charge of the radar gun when Penny pitches. The Marlins would have to be out of their minds to commit the kind of money he would be asking even with his bum shoulder although they might get the fast food industry in South Florida to kick in a few mil. It would probably turn out to be a very good investment for them.
  12. If Pavano's side was amenable, there isn't a question (for me) that Loria wouldn't give the guy a chance to reclaim his career.
  13. I may be completely off base but if the Marlins "push to the playoffs in 2009" is the modus operandi, then I would think that if they acquire a catcher it's going to be a guy who can help them in 2009, and I don't mean some end of his career guy like Ramon Hernandez from the Orioles. So I kind of doubt they trade Olsen for Ramirez unless there is someone else in the pipeline (another trade) to split time with Baker this upcoming season. And perhaps it's too outlandish to think about Laird and Ramirez for Olsen and Gregg and perhaps fillintheblank, but if payroll flexibility is part of the decision-making, the team would save more than $3 million (+3.5 - 3 - 4) if something along those lines came to fruition. Maybe Treanor recovers and can contribute by spring training alongside Baker, I like them as a tandem (and yes I know it's not very popular here), and who knows perhaps a healthy Mike Rabelo brings more to the table than we saw last season, so a Ramirez/Olsen trade makes some sense then but I'm not sure the former is ready for prime time in 2009.
  14. You're talking about a below average defensive catcher (with a really good bat) for... oh nevermind it can't be true. I am not putting down Martin because overall he's a guy an awful lot of teams would want *and conceivably the Marlins* , but let's face it defense is not his strong suit
  15. Loria and Pavano have mutual respect for one another. Loria advised Pavano throughout his free agent tour before signing in NYC.
  16. Because I see things the way I do (right or wrong) I read this and say to myself "this is an extension of Beinfest's strategy of diminishing the perceived need the Marlins may have in any particular area whether it's true or not is irrelevant". This time of the year Admin and the guys have only one constituency, their peers, not the fans, not the press. It would be nice if these guys can step up and fill a void but if someone wants to hand the Fish a quality reliever in a trade for fillintheblank, you gotta know they're jumping on the opportunity.
  17. This would be AMAZING if true. Developing an average 1B bat like Gaby is still very valuable, and when it comes down to it, who do we like better? G. Sanchez, or Raynor/Cousins/Petersen/Carroll/De Aza. That is an easy choice. If Hermida pans out this year, we could be looking at a Baker/Max Ramirez (I'm hoping hard on that one), Gaby, Coghlan, Hanley, X-3B, Morrison, Maybin, Hermida core, with Dominguez, Stanton, and Skipworth directly below them. And an insane pitching staff and bullpen full of arms, with Gregg, Cantu, Ross, Willingham and Uggla still left to trade off the team. Talk about insane. If Morrison can play LF, the baseball gods are shining upon us. I want every player to flourish but doesn't Coghlan have to learn to actually catch a baseball before he is spoken about as major league talent? He was no better at the end of the season than he was at the beginning when it comes to defense right up to and including the last game of the post-season series where he committed two more errors. To me he's another outfield transition candidate like the guy about whom this thread exists. He has the speed, he's a smart ballplayer, I'm not going to diminish hit bat in any way. I listened to a lot of Mudcats games this summer and he just seems to have so much trouble around the bag. And clearly the Marlins are trying to position themselves to contend and make a run at the playoffs, I don't see where he helps you get there, at least in 2009. I still think his bat, his speed and overall skillset gets him traded to the AL before he ever dons a Marlins uniform. He's high value, just not with this team and certainly not next season. But then again I've been wrong before. As for Morrison, would love to see it. He's young enough to actually get to learn the position rather a Willingham thrown to the wolves out there or even Miggy. It really is amazing what the front office has done in stocking the minors position players after the bad rap all they could do was draft pitchers.
  18. And didn't Cantu beg off a move to 2nd at one point in the season as well. I don't think it's his favorite position.
  19. I'm surprised. I would have thought, not quite Green Monsterish, they would have used in at least part of the outfield, high outfield walls to decrease the overall dimensions and thus the building's footprint as a cost-savings measure.
  20. When you're talking about signing Griffey a team really has to dot the i's and cross the t's regarding the deferred portion of his existing contract (cots: "57.5M in salary deferred at 4% interest, to be paid 2009-2024, reducing contract's present-day value at time of signing to between $9.2M and $9.3M annually, according to Reds management sources" plus $16 million for 2009 (which after all would be the year we're talking about or absent that a $4 million buyout which defeats the purpose. You probably need three teams of lawyers and twice as many CPAs to figure who owes what under what is one of the strangest contracts in the history of the game. Who knows what language is in there.
  21. Fredi isn't going anywhere. Girardi has a better chance of losing his job in the next couple of years than Fredi does. At least once, the front office will be willing to change up the team to fit the manager. Maybe next time not so much but I suspect throughout the off-season Fredi is going to have huge input the reshaping of the 2009 Fish.
  22. Erick, your contempt for the game and so many of the people playing it is actually very sad. This obsession of yours, it's almost borderline hatred for anyone who's an adult makes me question...nevermind I won't go there. Over and over this "veteran presence" thing is the mainstay of your hollow argument EXCEPT you're the only one talking about it, certainly not me. I can't remember the last time I used the phrase or even anything "veteran". Everyday like a broken record "veteran presence" this and "veteran presence" that and always in a disparaging way. It's all in your head. Suffice it to say once again as you stoop to bashing a player with a storied career because he's taking playing time (in your mind) from the kid you so adore and idolize, who has done nothing in three years but prove he is a chronic underachiever, it just reinforces the notion you really don't know very much about "the game" at all. You are all talk and no substance. All stats and no passion. All absolutism and no saavy. Since you like to question everyone, tell me when was the last time you played baseball? You're a kid I would imagine at your age if I really loved baseball so much I'd be out everyday finding a game. Like a nine inning game. When? It couldn't have been this summer because you were here virtually every minute from the time school was out. My guess is you never have, because even kids in Little League learn the meaning of being part of a "team" which was the point and the reason "we won" was exactly the right answer.
  23. I haven't heard anything about that curveball problem since May. I'm pretty sure he's adjusted to that. Since their ASG, and post his time on the DL Maybin has played exceptionally good baseball as I suspect we'll soon see. As for McPherson I'm not sure he doesn't just get a curtain call. I was listening to game the other night and again the broadcast guys remarked (several times now) that he's out of gas, he proved he was healthy and can play everyday but he's running on fumes these days.
  24. The Marlins aren't the real losers tonight, it the so-called fans here who have proclaimed they have given up on this team in August, August for god sakes. Did the Mets fall teach you nothing from last season? Did the Rockies absolutely unbelievable come from behind run to the playoffs not sink in? No one can say where we'll finish but those of you who didn't get what you wanted for Christmas and wanna go pout or feel sorry for yourselves, be my guest. There's a whole month of baseball left. Anything can happen. Anything. Neither the Mets nor the Phillies are significantly better teams than ours. We are all flawed in our own ways and after 130 games or so only six games separates the three of us. If you feel compelled to voice your confidence the season is over, I'm not sure why, but that's your right. I only hope to have the opportunity to watch you eat your words. Tonight three feet was the difference between a potentially different outcome and what resulted. McCann goes to right, Hanley goes to left (please tell me you didn't think like everyone at Turner Field that ball wasn't long gone when Hanley connected). But that's the beauty and tragedy of baseball. And I'll say it again, this season is far from over. The Dodgers in '51, the Phillies losing ten in a row or the Red Sox and Bucky F'ing Dent or of course the Mets in 2007. The Cubs have collapsed so many times in so many ways there is a reason they have the reputation they do. I'm not going to stand here and proclaim the Fish ultimate National League East winners at the end of September, that would be foolish. I can do the math. And by the of Sunday night it could be much worse or it could be a whole new beginning. Tonight is not the night to give up on 2008.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.