Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2023/24 Off-Season

Featured Replies

5 hours ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

Do you think Jazz would play SS again? If he wanted to play SS again they could put Edwards CF, Arraez 2B, Jazz SS.

I wanted Jazz at SS to begin the season, but after moving him to CF and actually having him become a great defender I don't think it's fair or makes much sense to move him again 

54 minutes ago, LordMagnus said:

You have a wierd obsession with Xavier Edwards.  I'm not willing to be an entire season on him if there are other options.

 

Edwards showed ability to get on base and has some speed. Unlike Mr. Wendle. His only knock is his arm strength and why he didn't play at short.

 

44 minutes ago, EricOwens! said:

I wanted Jazz at SS to begin the season, but after moving him to CF and actually having him become a great defender I don't think it's fair or makes much sense to move him again 

 

Good stuff, Mr. Owens!.

15 minutes ago, Michael said:

 

His only knock is his arm strength and why he didn't play at short.

Send him some nudes from the VIP forum to help bulk that arm up in the offseason.

1 hour ago, LordMagnus said:

You have a wierd obsession with Xavier Edwards.  I'm not willing to be an entire season on him if there are other options.

Every All-Star's fan club started with a few people with a 'weird obsession'. 

  • Author
1 hour ago, Michael said:

Probably not technically til like November.

Yeah I remember the contract seems expired one month after the end of the regular season, but if without the agreement to the new contract (or at least a handshake agreement) then it's impossible for the current GM to do anything in the last month of tenure. 

5 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

not yet extend Ng, means this team have no GM now, right !?

Please don’t panic and overreact.   Nothing “offseason” can even be done until after the WS anyway.  I’m sure they’re working on something 

On 10/6/2023 at 11:24 AM, TaiwanMarlins said:

I would give Castellanos 5/100 and not give Avisail 5/60 in everyday of my life. Cheap Sherman (yeah Marlins makes it to the playoffs but he's still cheap).

I would prefer anyone in baseball over Avisail. Doesn't mean the Marlins should have given Castellanos 5/100. He really hasn't been that great in Philly and I bet that contract ages pretty poorly.

Sherman is definitely cheap but going back and mentioning every single player he could have signed over Avisail is silly at this point.

Edited by Valid

19 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Yeah I remember the contract seems expired one month after the end of the regular season, but if without the agreement to the new contract (or at least a handshake agreement) then it's impossible for the current GM to do anything in the last month of tenure. 

I'd imagine Bruce has already given her an idea on if she's staying or not. They might already be discussing a new deal as we speak. If she was going to be fired Bruce could have easily done that already. The fact that he hasn't says a lot. 

On 10/6/2023 at 12:10 PM, LordMagnus said:

You have a wierd obsession with Xavier Edwards.  I'm not willing to be an entire season on him if there are other options.

No offense, but the guy batted .351 with an .886 OPS at AAA as a 23-year old.  He did everything he needed to do at the plate and deserves a chance.   As to where to play him, that is the problem.

 

Also, I feel like we aren't getting much with a free agent SS, so why not see what we have with Amaya.  He wasn't given a fair shot in the majors and his season was pretty decent at Jacksonville, although a bit up and down at times with a few injuries.  He also walks a lot (as does Edwards)  we need guys in the Arraez mold and good things happen when a team draws a lot of bases on balls.

3 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

No offense, but the guy batted .351 with an .886 OPS at AAA as a 23-year old.  He did everything he needed to do at the plate and deserves a chance.   As to where to play him, that is the problem.

 

Also, I feel like we aren't getting much with a free agent SS, so why not see what we have with Amaya.  He wasn't given a fair shot in the majors and his season was pretty decent at Jacksonville, although a bit up and down at times with a few injuries.  He also walks a lot (as does Edwards)  we need guys in the Arraez mold and good things happen when a team draws a lot of bases on balls.

Yes. unless they completely change the roster, its looking like Arraez might move to 1B (Assuming Bell and/or Soler leaves) and then that opens up Edwards to take over 2B. Not a fan of moving Arraez to 1B but if its necessary its not the worst thing in the world. Then they can find a shortstop unless they go with Berti there a whole year which Im not opposed to as well. If they do in  fact play Berti (or anyone with any speed) then Skip should do some running, it was frustrating watching the station to station play, needing seemingly 3 or 4 hits in an inning or a humerun to score.

9 minutes ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

If they do in  fact play Berti (or anyone with any speed) then Skip should do some running, it was frustrating watching the station to station play, needing seemingly 3 or 4 hits in an inning or a humerun to score.

This was the largest knock all year on Skip. Needed a lot more aggression on the bases.

 

Would def like to upgrade over the revolving door of Wendle, Berti, Hampson at short. Give Amaya a go for a bit and let him try to get settled at hitting big league arms.

19 hours ago, Michael said:

This was the largest knock all year on Skip. Needed a lot more aggression on the bases.

 

Would def like to upgrade over the revolving door of Wendle, Berti, Hampson at short. Give Amaya a go for a bit and let him try to get settled at hitting big league arms.

Yeah, especially with how many DPs we hit into - just starting runners could've eliminated a chunk of those.

 

19 hours ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

Yes. unless they completely change the roster, its looking like Arraez might move to 1B (Assuming Bell and/or Soler leaves) and then that opens up Edwards to take over 2B. Not a fan of moving Arraez to 1B but if its necessary its not the worst thing in the world. Then they can find a shortstop unless they go with Berti there a whole year which Im not opposed to as well. If they do in  fact play Berti (or anyone with any speed) then Skip should do some running, it was frustrating watching the station to station play, needing seemingly 3 or 4 hits in an inning or a humerun to score.

I'd rather keep Berti as a super utility player that winds up playing most days while giving other guys rest, and figure out another permanent SS.

On 10/8/2023 at 7:48 AM, TheMarlinsProject said:

No offense, but the guy batted .351 with an .886 OPS at AAA as a 23-year old.  He did everything he needed to do at the plate and deserves a chance.   As to where to play him, that is the problem.

 

Also, I feel like we aren't getting much with a free agent SS, so why not see what we have with Amaya.  He wasn't given a fair shot in the majors and his season was pretty decent at Jacksonville, although a bit up and down at times with a few injuries.  He also walks a lot (as does Edwards)  we need guys in the Arraez mold and good things happen when a team draws a lot of bases on balls.

He did well at AAA, yes.  I would still rather have a proven hitter if the opportunity presents itself.  Not that I think the team will actually upgrade, so we'll probably see some combination of him and Berti next year.  The main problem with this team is the lack of power hitters and people who can lift the ball.  It's funny that yes, the team cut down on strke outs, but dramatically increased double plays and were nearly last in runs scored.  These contact hitters just aren't going to cut it.

 

2 hours ago, rmc523 said:

Yeah, especially with how many DPs we hit into - just starting runners could've eliminated a chunk of those.

 

I'd rather keep Berti as a super utility player that winds up playing most days while giving other guys rest, and figure out another permanent SS.

I think folks will be pretty disheartened to learn how much of a lift Berti actually gives this team if they make the mistake of not picking up the team option on him (or trading him).  He is an absolutely fantastic utility guy.  The issue has always been we don't have a true starter at SS (and for most of the season - at 3b either) and he has to play too much but even then he puts up very solid offensive numbers, he can obviously steal you a bag as well.  Yeah his defense is middling but I would much prefer to keep Berti a Marlin.

24 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

Berti had a great year. 2.5 WAR! I haven’t looked but prob more valuable than jazz 

yeah he was pretty damn good the last two seasons actually...he had a 2.5war in 2022 and followed that up with 2.6war this season

He likely would have had a 3+ war season this year had Skip let him steal as frequently as Don did

Edited by hovertical

1 hour ago, LordMagnus said:

He did well at AAA, yes.  I would still rather have a proven hitter if the opportunity presents itself.  Not that I think the team will actually upgrade, so we'll probably see some combination of him and Berti next year.  The main problem with this team is the lack of power hitters and people who can lift the ball.  It's funny that yes, the team cut down on strke outs, but dramatically increased double plays and were nearly last in runs scored.  These contact hitters just aren't going to cut it.

 

Yup, I'd like a good doubles hitter that can drive into the gaps in our huge park.

 

1 hour ago, hovertical said:

I think folks will be pretty disheartened to learn how much of a lift Berti actually gives this team if they make the mistake of not picking up the team option on him (or trading him).  He is an absolutely fantastic utility guy.  The issue has always been we don't have a true starter at SS (and for most of the season - at 3b either) and he has to play too much but even then he puts up very solid offensive numbers, he can obviously steal you a bag as well.  Yeah his defense is middling but I would much prefer to keep Berti a Marlin.

I agree that he should stick around.  He's been shoehorned into a starting role (when Wendle wasn't inexplicably left there for way too long), which isn't the ideal role for him.

If Berti isn't the solution at shortstop and more a 'utility guy', maybe Dane Myers can play shortstop perhaps? He played 3B and outfield. He has good hitting, good range, good arm. He's a great all around athlete I remember when Skip started playing him in center during practices when Davis got hurt he said he was impressed how easy it was to go from 3B in the minor leagues to center field. I think the word he called him was a 'freak' alluding to his overall smooth baseball skill and athleticism. I see no reason why he wouldn't be a good shortstop unless he cant field a groundball there. I think Dane Myers is one of the best hitters we had in the minors and proved with his limited time he could hit in MLB, before going in a slump and then never seeing the field again. If not at shortstop I think he earned some playing time in the outfield as well or 3B if Burger gets hurt/needs a day off.

11 hours ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

If Berti isn't the solution at shortstop and more a 'utility guy', maybe Dane Myers can play shortstop perhaps? He played 3B and outfield. He has good hitting, good range, good arm. He's a great all around athlete I remember when Skip started playing him in center during practices when Davis got hurt he said he was impressed how easy it was to go from 3B in the minor leagues to center field. I think the word he called him was a 'freak' alluding to his overall smooth baseball skill and athleticism. I see no reason why he wouldn't be a good shortstop unless he cant field a groundball there. I think Dane Myers is one of the best hitters we had in the minors and proved with his limited time he could hit in MLB, before going in a slump and then never seeing the field again. If not at shortstop I think he earned some playing time in the outfield as well or 3B if Burger gets hurt/needs a day off.

Interesting idea

41 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Not yet extend Ng, panic !?

Can we please not do this daily....

Season 3 GIF by Parks and Recreation

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.