Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Who is the one player in franchise history that you look back on and wonder why they never met their potential?

Featured Replies

John Lynch the Marlins 2nd pick ever after CJ

 

I would add Ryan Tucker he looked pretty good when he first arrived also Jason Vargas he came up and was awesome, then they made him cut his hair, it took him 11 years to get it all back together

 

 

Jose Fernandez. I still wonder about it at least 2 or 3 times a month.

 

 

Chris Coghlan for me. That 2009 2nd half sealed his RoY award and I thought he was going to be a solid hitter like Yelich. Great guy too.

 

 

Chris Coghlan for me. That 2009 2nd half sealed his RoY award and I thought he was going to be a solid hitter like Yelich. Great guy too.

 

In 2009 you thought Coghlan could hit like Yelich? That's amazing!

 

 

LoMo. He did really well in 2010 [41/51 BB/K rate in 62 games], really good eye, doubles machine. Loved his hustle.

 

Then Eduardo Perez said, "hey I think you can hit more homers" and ruined him for us.

 

I remember Morrison being able to hit the ball well to all fields and Perez tried to make him a pull hitter.

 

 

Coghlan always stuck with me after his minor league career, being a 1st round pick, winning ROY in 2009 and then ... well...

 

Andrew Miller and Jeremy Hermida come to mind for sure.

 

Surprised no one has mentioned Kyle Skipworth.

 

 

In 2009 you thought Coghlan could hit like Yelich? That's amazing!

 

I was hoping he would turn out like Yelich did.  

 

 

LoMo. He did really well in 2010 [41/51 BB/K rate in 62 games], really good eye, doubles machine. Loved his hustle.

 

Then Eduardo Perez said, "hey I think you can hit more homers" and ruined him for us.

 

I remember Morrison being able to hit the ball well to all fields and Perez tried to make him a pull hitter.

 

I agree.  I thought LOMO was going to be an All Star with us.

 

 

Then Eduardo Perez said, "hey I think you can hit more homers" and ruined him for us.

 

who can understand that blubber mouth ?

 

 

  • Author

Lomo is a good one who was a great pure hitter who looks to have tried to increase his power at the expense of the overall effectiveness of his bat.  His plate discipline coming up was absolutely incredible.

 

 

Lomo is a good one who was a great pure hitter who looks to have tried to increase his power at the expense of the overall effectiveness of his bat.  His plate discipline coming up was absolutely incredible.

 

it was him and G in the minors and there was quite a bit of debate about who would end up being the better player overall because Lomo did have such an advanced approach at the plate for a young dude.  That attempt at the power increase really wrecked his career because he was never the same after he started to swing for the fences. 

 

Hermida will always be the ultimate "AAAA" player though for the Marlins.

 

 

  • Author
it was him and G in the minors and there was quite a bit of debate about who would end up being the better player overall because Lomo did have such an advanced approach at the plate for a young dude.  That attempt at the power increase really wrecked his career because he was never the same after he started to swing for the fences. 

 

Hermida will always be the ultimate "AAAA" player though for the Marlins.

 

I still remember Hermida's second half one year where he was absolutely unbelievable.  Its so weird how a guy can be that good for such a long stretch and then never be anything close to that ever again.  His swing was so nice.

 

 

I still remember Hermida's second half one year where he was absolutely unbelievable.  Its so weird how a guy can be that good for such a long stretch and then never be anything close to that ever again.  His swing was so nice.

 

anyone want to see what the BABIP% was for that one stretch?  I'm wondering if he just had a fluke stretch where hits just fell in at a much higher clip than usual.  Regardless, lots of players just have that one stretch that tantalizes the fanbase and then mostly sucks thereafter.  Lomo shocked me more than Hermida but he wasn't as hyped as Hermida was which is why Hermida will always be my #1 failure in terms of not reaching their potential. 

 

 

anyone want to see what the BABIP% was for that one stretch?  I'm wondering if he just had a fluke stretch where hits just fell in at a much higher clip than usual.  Regardless, lots of players just have that one stretch that tantalizes the fanbase and then mostly sucks thereafter.  Lomo shocked me more than Hermida but he wasn't as hyped as Hermida was which is why Hermida will always be my #1 failure in terms of not reaching their potential. 

 

Looks like you’re referring to the second half of 2007

 

[ATTACH]1795._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

50A1361B-84C9-4A70-965B-A2E528E38A3E.thumb.jpeg.74d7ae102ae0b6855f0dc56f006eaa4e.jpeg

I may be jumping the gun but....

 

Early 1st round Pick:

 

Tyler Kolek

 

 

  • Author
I may be jumping the gun but....

 

Early 1st round Pick:

 

Tyler Kolek

 

I feel like no one ever had much hope for him based on anything he ever did professionally.

 

 

Randy Messenger. Big strike out guy could never figure things out. Another was Ramon Castro. Was suppose to be one of the games best catchers, helped us in 2003, but never did anything after.

 

 

Randy Messenger. Big strike out guy could never figure things out. Another was Ramon Castro. Was suppose to be one of the games best catchers, helped us in 2003, but never did anything after.

 

He had a good career in Asia if I remember right.

 

Speaking of... Rick VandenHurk.

 

 

I remember I was 10 when the Marlins first started playing, and I thought Scott Pose was going to hit .300 and steal 70 bases a year after seeing his stats on some of the first Marlins baseball cards. The stolen bases may have been a stretch, but he hit .342 in AAA.

 

[ATTACH]1801._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

image.png.aa69408360e1466a02f8df557c70ce15.png

I remember I was 10 when the Marlins first started playing, and I thought Scott Pose was going to hit .300 and steal 70 bases a year after seeing his stats on some of the first Marlins baseball cards. The stolen bases may have been a stretch, but he hit .342 in AAA.

 

[ATTACH]1801[/ATTACH]

 

That guy turned out to be such a poser. 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.