Jump to content

Grade 'em


Hotcorner
 Share

Recommended Posts

Use whatever guidelines you want here. Personally I'm grading them based on expectations as well as performance, which is why there's a bunch of C minuses instead of all F's for a historically bad team (for example I didn't expect much from JP and Solano so I don't give them F's... they played about how I figured they would). I'm taking defense and experience into account too (giving rookies a bit of a break). I'll cap this at 100 plate appearances .

 

Hechevarria C-

Stanton B-

Ruggiano C

Polanco D+

Solano C-

Lucas C+

LoMo C-

JP D+

Ozuna B

Yelich A-

Dobbs D+

Mathis C-

Brantly D+

Dietrich C+

Coghlan C-

Marisnick C-

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C

Turner C

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi B

Alvarez B+

Slowey C

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A

Dunn A-

Qualls B+

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Hechevarria C-

Stanton B

Ruggiano D+

Polanco C

Solano D

Lucas C+

LoMo C

JP D+

Ozuna B

Yelich A-

Dobbs D+

Mathis B

Brantly D-

Dietrich C-

Coghlan C

Marisnick C-

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C

Turner C-

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi A-

Alvarez B

Slowey C

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A

Dunn A-

Qualls B

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hechavarria D

Stanton B-

Ruggiano C

Polanco C

Solano C-

Lucas C-

LoMo C

JP C-

Ozuna C

Yelich B+

Dobbs C-

Mathis D

Brantly D-

Dietrich C+

Coghlan C

Marisnick D-

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C

Turner C+

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi B+

Alvarez B+

Slowey C

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A+

Dunn B+

Qualls B

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why are Pierre's grades so good? Shouldn't he get an F or a G.

 

 

He provided some value and for the most part did what he came here to do. He hit .273 as a pinch hitter with 12 hits off the bench and only K'd 3 times in those 44 ab's, that's a big success. Stole 23 bases in part-time duty, that's a success. Overall as a backup 4th/5th OFer he did OK.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hechevarria D

Stanton B

Ruggiano C-

Polanco D+

Solano C+

Lucas B

LoMo C

JP C

Ozuna B+

Yelich A-

Dobbs D+

Mathis C-

Brantly D

Dietrich C+

Coghlan C+

Marisnick C-

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C+

Turner C+

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi B

Alvarez B+

Slowey B-

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A

Dunn A-

Qualls B+

 

 

The difference between our hitting and pitching is night and day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hechevarria D

Stanton B

Ruggiano C-

Polanco D

Solano B-

Lucas B-

LoMo C-

JP D

Ozuna B

Yelich A

Dobbs D+

Mathis C-

Brantly D-

Dietrich C+

Coghlan C

Marisnick D

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C+

Turner C

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi B+

Alvarez B+

Slowey C-

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A+

Dunn B+

Qualls B

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm often reminded that there is no such thing as a C student, they are either A students that underachieve or F students that overachieve, that's what I see while handing out grades. Anyone else not listed is either Incomplete or an F!

Fernandez A+

Cishek A

Yelich A-

Dunn B+

Ramos B

Alvarez B

Lucas C+

Ozuna C+

Webb C+

Qualls C+

Ruggiano C

Solano C

Dietrich C

Eovaldi C

Stanton C-

Morrison C-

Mathis C-

Hechavarria C-

Pierre C-

Marisnick C-

Koehler C-

TurnerC-

Polanco D

Brantly D

Dobbs D

Coghlan D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

don't really want to do whole list, just Hechavarria F worst player in baseball, thought anything better of a grade to the worst player in baseball this year was unfair to all the players who were not the worst player in baseball. Coghlan was better than Hech, even though expectations were higher, coggs hit some, and did not get the distinction of worst player in baseball.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Mathis deserves a good grade in context. The pitching staff really benefited from having him there.

 

As far as the lineup is concerned, only Stanton and Yellich deserve good grades outright, though I think Ozuna did well considering he was at least a year early.

 

The pitching was pretty good all around. I think a full year with Fernandez, Alvarez, Eovaldi and Turner in the rotation will only look better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

don't really want to do whole list, just Hechavarria F worst player in baseball, thought anything better of a grade to the worst player in baseball this year was unfair to all the players who were not the worst player in baseball. Coghlan was better than Hech, even though expectations were higher, coggs hit some, and did not get the distinction of worst player in baseball.

 

 

Hech had the worst WAR for a qualified player since 2009. Good job Adeiny!

 

Looks like Juan Rodriguez has joined the clan of people who think he's actually useful

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Mathis deserves a good grade in context. The pitching staff really benefited from having him there.

 

 

 

 

That could be true, but it could also not be true. It could just be that the pitchers are good.

 

 

Agreed.

 

And if it wasn't for that aspect of his game, he would have easily been an "F" player. The ONLY reason I graded him higher than that was for defense and game calling. Dude couldn't even sniff .200, that's horrible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

don't really want to do whole list, just Hechavarria F worst player in baseball, thought anything better of a grade to the worst player in baseball this year was unfair to all the players who were not the worst player in baseball. Coghlan was better than Hech, even though expectations were higher, coggs hit some, and did not get the distinction of worst player in baseball.

 

 

Hech had the worst WAR for a qualified player since 2009. Good job Adeiny!

 

Looks like Juan Rodriguez has joined the clan of people who think he's actually useful

 

 

Ladies and gentlemen, it seems we have our own Yuniesky Betancourt!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

don't really want to do whole list, just Hechavarria F worst player in baseball, thought anything better of a grade to the worst player in baseball this year was unfair to all the players who were not the worst player in baseball. Coghlan was better than Hech, even though expectations were higher, coggs hit some, and did not get the distinction of worst player in baseball.

 

 

Hech had the worst WAR for a qualified player since 2009. Good job Adeiny!

 

Looks like Juan Rodriguez has joined the clan of people who think he's actually useful

 

 

Ladies and gentlemen, it seems we have our own Yuniesky Betancourt!

 

 

 

 

That's exactly who Adeiny is. I've actually thought of that myself many times before. The comparison is perfect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Use whatever guidelines you want here. Personally I'm grading them based on expectations as well as performance, which is why there's a bunch of C minuses instead of all F's for a historically bad team (for example I didn't expect much from JP and Solano so I don't give them F's... they played about how I figured they would). I'm taking defense and experience into account too (giving rookies a bit of a break). I'll cap this at 100 plate appearances .

 

Hechevarria C-

Stanton B-

Ruggiano C

Polanco D+

Solano C-

Lucas C+

LoMo C-

JP D+

Ozuna B

Yelich A-

Dobbs D+

Mathis C-

Brantly D+

Dietrich C+

Coghlan C-

Marisnick C-

 

 

Fernandez A+

Koehler C

Turner C

Nolasco B+

Eovaldi B

Alvarez B+

Slowey C

Webb B+

Ramos A-

Cishek A

Dunn A-

Qualls B+

 

 

Why even bother grading them individually

We have the makings of a very good starting rotation with an amazing young ace and a solid bullpen with a shutdown closer

We may have a solid young outfield, besides that, well anything else, is not really worth mentioning

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This thread is quite old. Please consider starting a new thread rather than reviving this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share



×
×
  • Create New...