Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The Fire Don Mattingly Thread

Featured Replies

18 hours ago, SonOfJack said:

 

Pathetic if true.  But we know how accurate Mish has been as of late…

47 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Pathetic if true.  But we know how accurate Mish has been as of late…

No, we are definitely playing a double header today.

31 minutes ago, Michael said:

No, we are definitely playing a double header today.

The hot seat -or lack thereof - part

We are 8 games under .500 48 games into the season with a +16 run differential.

This is Don’s fault.

It really is amazing how it just keeps getting worse and worse because the same thing just won’t stop happening. 
 

I have never seen a team with this many 1 run losses. Especially this early in the season. 

9 hours ago, taiwanmarlin said:

Fire Sulser first !!!

Looks like his FB velocity is down 1.5 MPH from last year on a quick look. He probably needs to be relegated to the back of the pen and let Bass/Poteet/Okert get the main innings for now. They really, really, need Bender, Floro, and Bleier to play like last year immediately if they are going to claw out of this. 

13 hours ago, canada-marlin24 said:

It really is amazing how it just keeps getting worse and worse because the same thing just won’t stop happening. 
 

I have never seen a team with this many 1 run losses. Especially this early in the season. 

And yet they do nothing.

  • Author
19 minutes ago, Entendu said:

Just stop watching this shit

I'm also a Jags fan and right now the NFL can't start soon enough for me

7 hours ago, CyggyMarlin said:

I'm also a Jags fan and right now the NFL can't start soon enough for me

Meh I have hope that the Jags can at least be entertaining.  The Marlins haven't given me much hope for anything in a very long time.

Edited by LordMagnus

Statistically, the Marlins have the two best starting pitchers in the National League. Statistically, the Marlins have a top 10 offense in the National League. They are, overall, playing like a last place team. Please tell me how this is not the manager's fault???

7 hours ago, SongInTheAir said:

Statistically, the Marlins have the two best starting pitchers in the National League. Statistically, the Marlins have a top 10 offense in the National League. They are, overall, playing like a last place team. Please tell me how this is not the manager's fault???

You're not wrong, but to respond just for the sake of discussion - because it's everything. I know you know and most others know all of this, but to consolidate frustration:

Because Bruce gave the FO a horrible opening day budget under $80m and it's really hard to put together a complete team for that price. It goes without saying, they'd be a lot better with 2-3 more guys. Even if that's just Rizzo (DFA Aguilar), Tepera, and Kiermaier and not a "star." They could have done that for under $100m with no longterm deals on the books. Also, did Bruce stick them with Don by telling them we're not signing a new Manager to a 4 year deal this offseason so they had the decision of going with Don or an internal interim? That's the question I really want to know. Did Bruce dictate that or Ng? Or both?

Because even with the BS payroll, Ng/FO didn't have the foresight/creativity to get anything at CF and an upgrade somewhere else. The farm is loaded, there is clearly opportunities to get club controlled players from other teams. Likewise, and some hindsight bias here which may not be fair, the prospect hoarding isn't exactly working out as Watson is flat out not good right now, Bleday's AFL has not translated (even if there are some encouraging signs), and they bet right on Luzardo so they could easily afford to move a big name prospect pitcher for something. Also the obvious - what the hell are Garcia and Stallings doing? You can understand why they got them on some level, but performance will out weigh the thought process eventually and they are bad right now. Likewise, the good old Aguilar/Soler/Cooper redundancy. Aguilar should have went and this Ng needs to own big time as that's $7m that could have been used for a CF/pen upgrade. Where is Meyer also May 1st (or is this Bruce not setting payroll expectations so they have to keep him down for Super2 purposes)?

Because it's the players. Floro/Bender/Sulser/Bleier had 5+ WAR last year and are a hard negative right now. Even if the Garcia signing wasn't going to work out, a .547 OPS? No one would expect that. Stallings also. He's bad at framing pitches now when some scouts called him second to Johnny Bench defensively this offseason? Really? What is Rogers doing this year? He's probably the worst one right now. This isn't all the FO fault. These are next level drops in production and the guys on the field do get some major blame here for not adjusting to whatever it is they are facing (that could also be coaching to get back to Don, hence how it is all an intertwined web of sucking).

Because it's luck. Things also have to go wrong to go 6-15 in 1 run games. A lot of them. Injuries can be mentioned here as Luzardo is out, they are having some problems with Wendle/Anderson/Berti/Jazz all being banged up at the same time, Floro has never been right, Meyer is hurt, etc.

So big picture, Don's extremely poor bullpen usage, wacky lineups, and some other moves have certainly cost them some games, but they also gave him a few less players than is reasonable, and some of the players are just playing like assholes. Plus some tough breaks.

Blame gets passed all around, but for me, it starts from the top. Give the FO $100-110m next year and let them pick a reasonably priced manager, and my guess is there is major course correction instantly. That creates depth to deal with player performance/injuries at a minimum. I'd blame Don second because end of the day, a +19 run differential is pretty good (and that's through mismanagement!) and the FO put together this team, so tactical day-to-day decisions are likely causing some of these losses. Then Ng-FO/players/luck kick in all to varying degrees.

It's just everything. They kind of remind me of the Florida Panthers - doing nothing for years with some great young players and all of a sudden, it just clicks. It's likely not happening this year, but they do have the ace-blueprint to make this work quickly if they get those last few pieces in place. Again, starts from the top. Panthers spend money. Marlins don't.

10 hours ago, SongInTheAir said:

Statistically, the Marlins have the two best starting pitchers in the National League. Statistically, the Marlins have a top 10 offense in the National League. They are, overall, playing like a last place team. Please tell me how this is not the manager's fault???

It is for sure partially his fault, hard for anyone to debate that.

Nobody would have seen the Marlins bullpen of mostly unproven guys until last year struggle this year...expect those that know how baseball works and has gone on record saying that bullpens are the most fickle things in baseball, easiest to fix year over year and easiest to have fail as well.

Relievers cant truly be relied upon until they give you a good 2 years of quality production, preferably back to back years.  

Until then its all a lot of outliers and generally a guy that was 28 when he 'first made it as a reliever' was awful until that time, and we are surprised he went back to being awful?  

Weird.  

 

Garcia was also an awful sign, I said so at the time, he went from a positive hitters park to Miami which well, isnt.  

 

But NOOOOOOOOO  Das has no clue what he is talking about.

 

Thrilled the Marlins have guys like Lopez and Sandy.  Less thrilled they are wasting their massively great years.   Cabrera has the potential to do the same, but in the Marlins genius, hasnt ever really been given a chance cause well, GOTTA PROTECT HIM!  (from making money).  

4 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

You're not wrong, but to respond just for the sake of discussion - because it's everything. I know you know and most others know all of this, but to consolidate frustration:

Because Bruce gave the FO a horrible opening day budget under $80m and it's really hard to put together a complete team for that price. It goes without saying, they'd be a lot better with 2-3 more guys. Even if that's just Rizzo (DFA Aguilar), Tepera, and Kiermaier and not a "star." They could have done that for under $100m with no longterm deals on the books. Also, did Bruce stick them with Don by telling them we're not signing a new Manager to a 4 year deal this offseason so they had the decision of going with Don or an internal interim? That's the question I really want to know. Did Bruce dictate that or Ng? Or both?

Because even with the BS payroll, Ng/FO didn't have the foresight/creativity to get anything at CF and an upgrade somewhere else. The farm is loaded, there is clearly opportunities to get club controlled players from other teams. Likewise, and some hindsight bias here which may not be fair, the prospect hoarding isn't exactly working out as Watson is flat out not good right now, Bleday's AFL has not translated (even if there are some encouraging signs), and they bet right on Luzardo so they could easily afford to move a big name prospect pitcher for something. Also the obvious - what the hell are Garcia and Stallings doing? You can understand why they got them on some level, but performance will out weigh the thought process eventually and they are bad right now. Likewise, the good old Aguilar/Soler/Cooper redundancy. Aguilar should have went and this Ng needs to own big time as that's $7m that could have been used for a CF/pen upgrade. Where is Meyer also May 1st (or is this Bruce not setting payroll expectations so they have to keep him down for Super2 purposes)?

Because it's the players. Floro/Bender/Sulser/Bleier had 5+ WAR last year and are a hard negative right now. Even if the Garcia signing wasn't going to work out, a .547 OPS? No one would expect that. Stallings also. He's bad at framing pitches now when some scouts called him second to Johnny Bench defensively this offseason? Really? What is Rogers doing this year? He's probably the worst one right now. This isn't all the FO fault. These are next level drops in production and the guys on the field do get some major blame here for not adjusting to whatever it is they are facing (that could also be coaching to get back to Don, hence how it is all an intertwined web of sucking).

Because it's luck. Things also have to go wrong to go 6-15 in 1 run games. A lot of them. Injuries can be mentioned here as Luzardo is out, they are having some problems with Wendle/Anderson/Berti/Jazz all being banged up at the same time, Floro has never been right, Meyer is hurt, etc.

So big picture, Don's extremely poor bullpen usage, wacky lineups, and some other moves have certainly cost them some games, but they also gave him a few less players than is reasonable, and some of the players are just playing like assholes. Plus some tough breaks.

Blame gets passed all around, but for me, it starts from the top. Give the FO $100-110m next year and let them pick a reasonably priced manager, and my guess is there is major course correction instantly. That creates depth to deal with player performance/injuries at a minimum. I'd blame Don second because end of the day, a +19 run differential is pretty good (and that's through mismanagement!) and the FO put together this team, so tactical day-to-day decisions are likely causing some of these losses. Then Ng-FO/players/luck kick in all to varying degrees.

It's just everything. They kind of remind me of the Florida Panthers - doing nothing for years with some great young players and all of a sudden, it just clicks. It's likely not happening this year, but they do have the ace-blueprint to make this work quickly if they get those last few pieces in place. Again, starts from the top. Panthers spend money. Marlins don't.

The Rays do it every year with under $80M….

54 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

The Rays do it every year with under $80M….

So one team, sort of (where are the rings?), and Oakland perpetually rebuilds as well as all the others? This is not a realistic payroll to contend. You might get lucky here and there and make the playoffs a few times, but you're going to get soul crushed by the $150-200m teams who CAN add the Kenleys and Springers as secondary pieces as they can afford it.

This shouldn't be the model in a top 10 media market (once WPB is added). 

It's Bruce. He's cheap to a fault.

7 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

So one team, sort of (where are the rings?), and Oakland perpetually rebuilds as well as all the others? This is not a realistic payroll to contend. You might get lucky here and there and make the playoffs a few times, but you're going to get soul crushed by the $150-200m teams who CAN add the Kenleys and Springers as secondary pieces as they can afford it.

This shouldn't be the model in a top 10 media market (once WPB is added). 

It's Bruce. He's cheap to a fault.

He is cheap because somehow Jeter conned all these investors into spending $1.2 BILLION on this team. Jeter made his money back and bounced, but Sherman is stuck with this albatross with low revenue.

2 minutes ago, jsprt14 said:

He is cheap because somehow Jeter conned all these investors into spending $1.2 BILLION on this team. Jeter made his money back and bounced, but Sherman is stuck with this albatross with low revenue.

Sherman isn't losing money

4 minutes ago, jsprt14 said:

He is cheap because somehow Jeter conned all these investors into spending $1.2 BILLION on this team. Jeter made his money back and bounced, but Sherman is stuck with this albatross with low revenue.

 

1 minute ago, SonOfJack said:

Sherman isn't losing money

Sherman has never been wealthier!  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...
Background Picker
Customize Layout

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.